• Embed Doc
  • Copy Link
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
 
111!
1
7
*
3
45
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
1516
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
VI 11
VI
EDMUND
G.
BROWN
JR.
Attorney
General
of
California
Yf\M
A TLT A
XT
"V \t
t7XIXTI7D
(
JLMNA
1
irAIN
^..
lxEINjNl^i\
Supervising
Deputy Attorney General
PETER
A.
KRAUSE
Deputy
Attorney General
i ~
State Bar No.
1850981300
1
Street, Suite
125
P.O.
Box
944255
Sacramento, CA
94244-2550
Telephone:
(916)324-5328
Fax:
(916)324-8835
(~
E-mail:
Peter.Krause@doj.ca.gov
a, ^
Attorneys for
Defendant
[
Secretary
of
State
Debra
Bowen
mini.
^^^^^^^^^^t^^^^^^^^fm
I i • ^ 4 [ j •" 1
AN^^^Hl
1
1
UAH
9 0
2009
1 '"
FILED
V
g^jB
J
X.
J/ffil
X^___-^affy
MAR
2 3
2009
W
•
, - _ .
-|L
d fi
•~\\
ML/
—
 ^
^
Deputy Clerk
SUPERIOR
COURT
OF THE
STATE
OF
CALIFORNIA
COUNTY
AMBASSADOR
DR.
ALAN KEYES;
DI
WILEY
S.
DRAKE,
SR.;
and
MARKKAROBINSON,
Petitioi
V.
CALIFORNIA SECRETARY
OF
STATDEBRA BOWEN
et
al.,
Respond
///
///
//////
/////////
///
OF
SACRAMENTO
I.
Case
No:
34-200880000096-CUWM-GDS
M
[PROPOSES]
ORDER
SUSTAINING
THE SECRETARY
OF STATE'Siers,
DEMURRER
TO THE
FIRST
AMENDED
PETITION FOR
WRIT
OF
MANDATE
WITHOUT
LEAVE
TO
AMENDDate: March
13,
2009
E
Time: 9:00 a.m.Dept:
31
JudgeThe
Honorable Michael
P.ents.
Kenny
1
[PROPOSED]
ORDER SUSTAINING
THE
SECRETARY
OF
STATE'S
(34-200880000096-CUWM-GDS)
DEMURRER
TO THE
FIRST AMENDED PETITION
FOR
WRIT
OF
MANDATE
 
to
11
1213
14
15
ORDER SUSTAINING SECRETARY
OF
STATE'S
DEMURREROn March
13,2009,
at
9:00 a.m.,
the
demurrer
of
respondent
Secretary
of
StateDebra Bowen
to the
First Amended Petition
for
Writ
of
Mandate came
on
regularly
for
hearing in department 31 of this Court, the Honorable Michael P. Kenny, judgeresiding. Peter A. Krause appeared on behalf of respondent Secretary of State DebraBowen, Gary G. Kreep appeared on behalf of peltioners Ambassador Dr. Alan Keyes,
Dr.
Wiley8,Drake,
Sr.,
andMarkham Robinson,andMichaelJ.Strumwasserand
Aimee
Dudovitz appeared on behalf of respondents President Barack Obama, VicePresident Joe Biden, and the California
Electors.
For all the reasons explained in the tentative ruling of this Court, a copy of
which
is attached as Exhibit "A" and is incorporated herein by reference, the Court
hereby
sustains
the
Secretary
of
State's Demurrer without leave
to
amend.
IT IS SO
ORDERED.Dated March
,
2009
MICHAEL P.KENNY
Judge
of the
Superior Court
APPROVED
AS TO
FORM:
Fredric
0.
Woocher
Michael
J.
Strumwasser
Aimee
Dad
OOCHER
LLP
16
17
18
19
20
21
2223
24
THE LAW
OFFICES
OF
GARY
G.
KREEP
25
By.
26
By
Attorneys
for
Atapondents
President
Barack
Obama, Vice
President
Joe
Biden,
and the
California
Electors
t
Gary
G. Kreep
Attorney
for
Petitioners
AmbassadorDr.
Alan
Keyes, Dr.
Wiley
S.
Drake.
Sr.,
and
Markham Robinson
ORDER
SUSTAININGSECRETARY
OF STATE'S
DEMURRER
(34-2008-80000096-CU-WM-GDS)
1
 
3
ORDER
SUSTAINING
SECRETARY
OF
STATE'S
DEMURRER
On
March 13,2009,
at
9:00
a.m.,
the
demurrer
of
respondent Secretary
of
StateDebra Bowento theFirst Amended PetitionforWritofMandate cameonregularlyforhearing in department 31 of this Court, the Honorable Michael P. Kenny, judgepresiding. Peter
A.
Krause appeared
on
behalf
of
respondent Secretary
of
State DebraBowen, Gary
G.
Kreep appeared
on
behalf
of
peitioners Ambassador
Dr.
Alan Keyes,Dr.Wiley
S.
Drake,
Sr.,
and
Markham Robinson,
and
Michael
J.
Strumwasser
and
Aimee Dudovitz appeared
on
behalf
of
respondents President Barack Obama, VicePresident Joe Biden, and the California Electors.
101!
For all the reasons explained in the tentative ruling of this Court, a copy of
11
which
is
attached
as
Exhibit
"A" and is
incorporated herein
by
reference,
the
Court
12
herebysustainsthe
Secretary
of
State's
Demurrer
without
leave to amend.
13
1415
16
19
20
21
22
23
IT IS SO ORDERED.Dated March
2*,
2009
1CHAEL
P.
KENNY
Judge
of the
Superior Court
17
APPROVED
AS TO FORM:
18
Fredrlc
D.
Woodier
Michael
J.
Strumwasser
Aimee
Dudovitz
STRUMWASSER
&
WOOCHER
LLP
By.
Attorneys
for
Respondents
President
Barack Obama,
Vice
President
Joe
Biden,
and the
California
ElectorsG.
KREEP
26Attorney
Dr.
Alan
Keyes,
Dr.
Wiley
S.
Drake,
Sr.,
7
andMarkham Robinson
28
ORDER SUSTAINING SECRETARY
OF
STATE'S
DEMURRER
(34-2008-8000009&-CU-WM-GDS)
1
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...