• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
 
Complaints recei v ed by the nursing home
The Commission has been notified of many complaints made to the nursing home bythe families of former residents. However, whereas the Commission understands thatit has been provided with details of all complaints made to the Health Board / HSE, inthe case of complaints to the nursing home the Commission has information onlyfrom those families who came forward voluntarily to give evidence. Less than one infive families of former Leas Cross residents provided the Commission withinformation, so any statistics derived from this information are of limited value.
30
See chapter 15.
113
 
The complaints of which the Commission is aware were made in a variety of formats.In a minority of cases, written complaints were made to the matron or the proprietor.However, most of the complaints were made orally. In some cases, the complainantssought out the matron to lodge their complaints at managerial level. In other cases,complaints were made to nurses or care workers and it is impossible to know for certain whether those complaints were passed on to the matron or the proprietor. For all these reasons, and in the absence of a comprehensive written record of complaintsto the home, it is impossible to state with any accuracy how many complaints weremade during the seven years Leas Cross was in operation.
Complaints in writing
The documents disclosed to the Commission by the owners of Leas Cross NursingHome contain two letters of complaint written by the families of residents in 2004.The first, dated the 8
th
January 2004, is addressed to the matron, Grainne Conway andconcerns the removal of sweets and biscuits from a resident’s locker, and the apparentdisappearance of clothes belonging to the resident. It is not clear whether this letter received a response.The second letter, dated the 11
th
 November 2004, is addressed to Mr John Aherne,and contains a complaint about the designated smoking room for residents at thehome, which the author of the letter considered to be poorly situated and badlyventilated. A handwritten note on the face of the letter indicates that Mr Ahernetelephoned the author of the letter on the 17
th
 November and informed him that LeasCross was
“looking into the situation”
.From information provided by the families of residents, the Commission is aware of afurther five written complaints to Leas Cross made while the residents in questionwere in the home and prior to the Prime Time documentary. Only one of those lettersyielded a substantive written response, while another resulted in a meeting with the proprietor at which the complaint was resolved. The letters are not amongst thedocuments disclosed to the Commission by the owners of Leas Cross Nursing Home.The substance of these letters is summarised below, according to the resident to whomthey relate.Kathleen R e illyMs Reilly, who suffered from Alzheimer’s disease, was admitted to Leas Cross inJuly 1999. In September 2000, members of her family found her wandering aroundthe area in Swords where she used to live. On the 6
th
September her niece wrote aletter of complaint to the owner of Leas Cross in relation to the incident.The letter of complaint was replied to by the matron Grainne Conway on the 11
th
September. The matron expressed regret on behalf of the nursing home for theincident and explained that that the transport section of the Eastern Health Board hadsent a taxi instead of an ambulance to take Ms Reilly to Beaumont, and asked the taxidriver to bring her to the x-ray department. They informed him that her details were inan envelope in the resident’s pocket. When Ms Reilly left Beaumont, she was brought114
 
to the taxi by a porter, but on hearing the price of the taxi, she told the porter that shewould take the bus. The letter concluded:
“It seems to me that it was unfortunate that the taxi driver did not inform Beaumont staff that [the resident] was an Eastern Health Board Transport  patient. I accept that we are responsible for [her] care and safety and I am not retracting from that………….I apologise for the distress caused and by thisincident and I have assured your mother that [she] will attend her futureappointments in a taxi booked privately by us and with an escort.”
The matter was also investigated and reported on by the Northern Area Health Board,to whom the family had also complained.
31
Catheri n e M ullinsMs Mullins was admitted to Leas Cross in June 2003. According to a statement provided to the Commission by her daughter, Ms Mullins and her family wereinitially happy with the nursing home but found that care standards
“deteriorated  significantly”
as the number of patients in the home increased. The family state thatthey made several verbal complaints to the matron, but their concerns about the care being received by their mother at the nursing home remained unresolved.By a letter dated the 13
th
January 2004 the family informed the matron that they haddecided to remove their mother from Leas Cross as they were
“…very unhappy withthe nursing care and management of our mother’s welfare at Leas Cross in recent times…”
On the 15
th
January 2004 the family wrote again to the matron setting outdetailed complaints regarding Ms Mullins’s care. Copies of this letter were also sentto the owner of the nursing home, the Northern Area Health Board and a consultant physician at Beaumont Hospital. The matter was subsequently taken up by the Northern Area Health Board.
32
Elizabeth FlemingIn February 2004 Ms Fleming, a resident of Leas Cross Nursing Home, discoveredthat a wallet containing €900 had been taken from her handbag. She reported this tostaff in the morning and her family was informed when they visited that evening. Thefamily subsequently wrote to Mr John Aherne seeking a meeting to discuss the issue.A meeting was held and the family accepted an offer by the management of LeasCross to replace the missing €900. Ms Fleming was happy to accept the offer and thematter was considered closed by the family.Resident P.S.
31
See chapter 15.
32
See chapter 15.
115
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...