Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword or section
Like this
1Activity

Table Of Contents

0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
VDS v. Arizona - Harboring Decision

VDS v. Arizona - Harboring Decision

Ratings: (0)|Views: 299|Likes:
Published by J Cox
Striking down harboring provision of SB1070.
Striking down harboring provision of SB1070.

More info:

Categories:Business/Law
Published by: J Cox on Oct 08, 2013
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/17/2013

pdf

text

original

 
FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALSFOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
V
ALLE DEL
S
OL
I
 NCORPORATED
;C
OALICION
D
E
D
ERECHOS
H
UMANOS
;
 
U
 NITED
F
OOD AND
C
OMMERCIAL
W
ORKERS
I
 NTERNATIONAL
U
 NION
;
 
B
ORDER 
A
CTION
 N
ETWORK 
;
 
J
IM
S
HEE
;U
 NKNOWN
P
ARTY
, Named as JaneDoe #3 in Amended Complaint;J
OHN
D
OE
#1, proceeding under  pseudonym; L
UZ
S
ANTIAGO
;A
RIZONA
S
OUTH
A
SIANS FOR 
S
AFE
F
AMILIES
;
 
J
APANESE
A
MERICAN
C
ITIZENS
L
EAGUE
;
 
L
OCAL
5
 
S
ERVICE
E
MPLOYEES
I
 NTERNATIONAL
U
 NION
;S
OUTHSIDE
P
RESBYTERIAN
C
HURCH
;T
ONATIERRA
C
OMMUNITY
D
EVELOPMENT
I
 NSTITUTE
;
 
C.M., aminor; A
SIAN
C
HAMBER OF
C
OMMERCE OF
A
RIZONA
;
 
S
ERVICE
E
MPLOYEES
I
 NTERNATIONAL
U
 NION
;A
RIZONA
H
ISPANIC
C
HAMBER OF
C
OMMERCE
;
 
P
EDRO
E
SPINOZA
;M
AURA
C
ASTILLO
;
 
J
OSE
A
 NGEL
V
ARGAS
,
 Plaintiffs-Appellees
,v. No. 12-17152D.C. No.2:10-cv-01061-SRBOPINION
Case: 12-17152 10/08/2013 ID: 8812749 DktEntry: 115-1 Page: 1 of 46
 
V
ALLE DEL
S
OL V
.
 
W
HITING
2M
ICHAEL
B.
 
W
HITING
;
 
E
DWARD
G.
HEINHEIMER 
;
 
D
AISY
F
LORES
, GilaCounty Attorney, in her officialcapacity; R 
ICHARD
M.
 
OMLEY
,Maricopa County Attorney, in hisofficial capacity; M
ATTHEW
J.S
MITH
, Mohave County Attorney, inhis official capacity; B
RADLEY
C
ARLYON
, Navajo County Attorney,in his official capacity; S
AM
V
EDERMAN
, La Paz CountyAttorney, in his official capacity;
ENNY
A
 NGLE
, Graham CountyAttorney, in his official capacity;D
EREK 
D.
 
APIER 
, Greenlee CountyAttorney, in his official capacity;D
AVID
W.
 
OZEMA
, Esq., CoconinoCounty Attorney, in his officialcapacity; B
ARBARA
L
A
W
ALL
, PimaCounty Attorney, in her officialcapacity; J
AMES
P.
 
W
ALSH
, PinalCounty Attorney, in his officialcapacity; G
EORGE
S
ILVA
, Santa CruzCounty Attorney, in his officialcapacity; S
HEILA
S.
 
P
OLK 
, YavapaiCounty Attorney, in her officialcapacity; J
ON
R.
 
S
MITH
, YumaCounty Attorney in his officialcapacity; J
OSEPH
D
EDMAN
,
 
J
.,Apache County Sheriff, in hisofficial capacity; B
ILL
P
RIBIL
,Coconino County Sheriff, in hisofficial capacity; R 
OD
OTHROCK 
,
Case: 12-17152 10/08/2013 ID: 8812749 DktEntry: 115-1 Page: 2 of 46
 
V
ALLE DEL
S
OL V
.
 
W
HITING
3Chief Deputy; J
OHN
R.
 
A
RMER 
, GilaCounty Sheriff, in his officialCapacity; P
RESTON
J.
 
A
LLRED
,Graham County Sheriff, in hisofficial capacity; S
TEVEN
 N.T
UCKER 
, Greenlee County Sheriff, inhis official capacity; D
ONALD
L
OWERY
, La Paz County Sheriff, inhis official capacity; J
OSEPH
M.A
RPAIO
, Maricopa County Sheriff,in his official capacity; T
OM
S
HEAHAN
, Mohave County Sheriff,in his official capacity; K 
ELLY
C
LARK 
, Navajo County Sheriff, inhis official capacity; C
LARENCE
W.D
UPNIK 
, Pima County Sheriff, in hisofficial capacity; P
AUL
R.
 
B
ABEU
,Pinal County Sheriff, in his officialcapacity; T
ONY
E
STRADA
, SantaCruz County Sheriff, in his officialcapacity; S
TEVE
W
AUGH
, YavapaiCounty Sheriff, in his officialcapacity; R 
ALPH
O
GDEN
, YumaCounty Sheriff, in his officialcapacity,
 Defendants
,andS
TATE OF
A
RIZONA
;
 
J
ANICE
K.B
REWER 
,
 Intervenor-Defendants – Appellants
.
Case: 12-17152 10/08/2013 ID: 8812749 DktEntry: 115-1 Page: 3 of 46

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->