MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

Page1of4

J .P. Morgan v Sherry Kaplan Roberts

GROUNDLESS EFFORT TO DISQUALIFY CANDIDATE DISMISSED
Insubstantial lawsuit filed by famed lawyer for blogger falls flat
5 November 2013 (Updated 7 November)
Filed by David Arthur Walters
MIAMI MIRROR
MIAMI BEACHJ .P. Morgan's petition for a declaratory judgment to disqualify Sherry Kaplan
Roberts candidacy for a City of Miami Beach Commission seat was tossed out of court
yesterday.
Morgan, who sits on the citys Transportation and Parking Committee, and is the editor and
owner of the online publication, City Debate, had already filed a "Confidential" Complaint with
the Elections Commission, and published it on the Internet, making the allegation that Ms.
Roberts was actually a resident of Ohio, not Miami Beach, suggesting that she may have
committed the crimes of perjury and real estate tax fraud in Florida or Ohio, since she had
claimed residency in both states.
Morgan declined to respond in writing to my letter to him after he filed his complaint with the
Elections Commission. I had pointed out that what Roberts may have said in Ohio did not
disprove that she was a resident of the City of Miami Beach, that the definitions of residency
could be complex, and that he had presented no proof of non-residency in Florida.
On 3 November, I sent an email to his legendary attorney, Benedict Kuehne, as follows:
MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

Page2of4

"Sir. Mr. Morgan raises good questions and his motives for doing so are irrelevant; but what Ms.
Roberts may have said in Ohio would NOT be relevant to the facts here even though suspicious.
Do you have absolute proof that she is not a resident according to Florida and local law therefore
lied here? If not would some federal law obtain? I am curious about the legal principles to which
the particulars are incidental. Thanks if you can help educate the lay public."
He did not reply. He obviously did not have the proof required. His 48-page suit fell flat as
expected the next day.
Rumors were afloat that Robert's opponent Mickey Steinberg was paying the fees for Morgan.
Morgan said that if Steinberg had picked up on his exposure of Roberts, it was not his problem.
He denied that he contributed to the mass mailing depicting Roberts as a resident of Ohio, the
glossy mailer virtually quoting his allegations, with Roberts wearing a T-shirt I Love Ohio.
Steinberg denied that she had anything to do with getting Roberts off the ballot. Nonetheless,
retired lawyer and political activist Frank Del Vechhio, who said the lawsuit was bogus,
revealed that her politician husband Richard Steinberg had fingered the exact location where
Roberts was sitting on the beach to the process server.
The process server was surprised that I was waiting for him, Roberts said. He said people
usually run.
"Wow!" I said to Morgan when I initially saw he had filed suit after filing a complaint with the
election commission, and that Benedict Kuehne, Al Gores attorney in the 2000 Florida elections
fiasco, was his lawyer. He said the complaint to the commission would take too much time, so he
had to file suit to stop Roberts before the election.
"You sure cooked Sherry's goose! It will be tossed but serves the purpose. How can you afford
high-priced Ben? I didn't realize you were that loaded!"
"There is no price we should put on the First Amendment," he answered, but refused to answer
my question as to the retainer he paid, after I estimated it to be $5,000, citing attorney-client
privilege. However, he later admitted that the fee exceeded $4,000, and insisted that he paid out
of his own pocket.
Morgan has told me in the past that political campaign seasons are lucrative for his business.
However, according to the 18 October report of Miami Herald reporter Christina Veiga, he
denied that any candidate had paid him to run his blogs, and he insisted to me that his sole
interest was in getting at the truth as an editor, journalist, and citizen.
I told Morgan that I was looking forward to his report on the upcoming 4 November hearing,
how the judge would decline to give him the declaration he wanted. He promised to immediately
let me know the disposition:
MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

Page3of4

"I will send you a text the moment I leave the court house tomorrow morning."
I did not hear from him by late afternoon. However, I was alerted that his petition had failed, and
was told that not only was Roberts declared a resident, but the judge had said, in effect, that she
was a good resident.
I happened to be on the lanai of a Decoplage condo on the floor below Robert's former penthouse
residence, where she had lived recently for years and had served the condominium association as
its president.
I forwarded the news to Morgan.
"No that's not what the judge said although the judge did rule in her favor," he responded.
I opined that the transcripts would be out the next day, and the matter would be aired on
television.
"I doubt it very much considering that the only court reporter there was on my payroll and I have
no intention of having it transcribed."
"Oh, really? I don't blame you for keeping it secret. It's getting her a lot of votes."
"My only interest in filing the suit was to finally settle which way it was or was she not a
resident of the City of Miami Beach under the city charter. I might even wind up voting for her,"
he said.
I contacted him again, on 5 November, and said that he had made Roberts Florida residency
look fishy, but looks are insufficient in court.
Let voters see the transcript of the hearing for balance, okay?
Do you want to pay $600 for this transcript to be transcribed for an election that will be over in
three hours?
Your motive may be political, I responded. I was surprised that you, as an editor and journalist,
filed any complaint at all. My training is to write a report and have it published, send a copy to
the relevant authority, ask them later what they did with it, and report on that. My purpose is
educative and expositive. I am hoping you will sponsor transcription and publication to that
end.
He later informed me that Roberts had confessed during the hearing that she had mistakenly
misstated Ohio as her residence on forms filed in Ohio, and said she would take steps in Ohio to
correct the errors. He would not press criminal charges against her anywhere, he said, as his only
interest was in getting at the truth in respect to the elections.
MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

Page4of4

The judge said he would revisit the issue if there was a runoff, was his final word on the
subject.
That reticence was not in the ruling, I responded, and it should have been in the ruling if true.
We must see the testimony to bring out the truth. You should pay for the transcript, and post it
and all the other documents onto the Internet as an example of a challenge to candidacy based on
residency. Everyone interested in the subject would be grateful.
##
11-04-13JOB2785MORGANRULING
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
11TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND
FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CIVIL DIVISION
CASE NO. 2013-34364-CA-01(09)
JOHN P. MORGAN,
Plaintiff,
vs.
SHERRY KAPLAN ROBERTS,
PENELOPE TOWNSLEY in her
capacity as Miami-Dade Supervisor
of Elections and RAFAEL E. GRANADO,
in his capacity as City Clerk,
City of Miami Beach,
Defendants.
_________________________________________/
Dade County Courthouse
73 West Flagler Street
Miami, Florida 33130
Monday, November 4, 2013
PLAINTIFF'S VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR EMERGENCY
DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF (EXCERPT OF RULING)
The above-entitled cause came on for hearing before
the Honorable Jerald Bagley, Circuit Court Judge.

APPEARANCES
Page 1
11-04-13JOB2785MORGANRULING
For the Plaintiff: GENOVESE, JOBLOW, ET AL.
By: Jesus M. Suarez, Esquire
Theresa Van Vlict, Esq.
44th Floor
100 Southeast Second Street
Miami, Florida 33131
For the Defendant: LAW OFFICE BENEDICT P. KUEHNE
By: Benedict P. Kuehne, Esq.
Michael T. Davis, Esq.
Suite 1200
100 S.E. 2nd Avenue
Miami, Florida 33131
Also Present: Jeanie Olin, Esquire
Michael Valdes, Esquire
Jose Smith, Esquire
Debra Turner, Esquire
REPORTER: CATHY J. RUNDELL MURPHY

3
1 (Thereupon, the following proceedings were had:)
2 THE COURT: Thank you. The Court having
3 conduct an evidentiary hearing on the Plaintiff's
4 Complaint for Emergency and Declaratory Relief, and
5 that's what I'm addressing first and foremost at
6 this time. Having listened to the evidence
7 presented, your arguments, at this time the Court
Page 2
11-04-13JOB2785MORGANRULING
8 makes the follow findings; I find that the clear
9 and convincing evidence demonstrates that Ms.
10 Sherry Kaplan Roberts is a resident of the City of
11 Miami Beach. All testimony presented thus far to
12 this Court, by that standard, shows that she
13 possesses a Miami Dade County voters registration
14 card, which she has possessed since October 10,
15 2001. She has a valid Florida driver's license
16 which we all know that any time you move from one
17 state to the next, you have thirty days to change
18 your driver's license, which makes you a resident
19 of the State of Florida. She testified that she
20 has been a resident of Miami Beach since, I believe
21 she left Ohio in 2000, the year 2000. In 2004, she
22 achieved or obtained her real estate, her Florida
23 relate estate license. She has presented evidence
24 of Florida Power & Light electric bills. She's
25 fulfilled a great deal of civic commitment to the

4
1 City of Miami Beach having served six years on the
2 City Board of Adjustments. So all the evidence
3 presented shows this Court that she is a bonafide
4 resident of the City of Miami Beach.
5 Therefore, the Plaintiff's Emergency Motion
6 for Injunctive Relief to strike her name from
7 November 5, 2013 Miami Beach election ballot is
8 denied, because it is now moot, based on my
9 declaratory findings. Folks have a great day.
10 (Thereupon, the hearing was concluded.)
11
Page 3
11-04-13JOB2785MORGANRULING
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

5
1 COURT CERTIFICATE
2
3 STATE OF FLORIDA )
4 ) SS:
5 COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE )
6
7 I, CATHY J. RUNDELL MURPHY, Reporter and
8 Notary Public for the State of Florida at Large,
9 certify that I was authorized to and did
10 stenographically report the foregoing proceedings
11 and that the transcript is a true and complete
12 record of my stenographic notes.
13 DATED this 3rd day of November, 2013.
14
15
Page 4
11-04-13JOB2785MORGANRULING
16 _______________________________
CATHY J. RUNDELL MURPHY
17 Notary Public, Florida
Commission #FF034363
18 Expires: October 31, 2017
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

Page 5
STATE OF FLORIDA
FLORIDA ELECTIONS COMMISSION
107 West Gaines Street, Suite 224, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1050
Telephone Number: (850) 922-4539
www.fcc.stale.fI.us
CONFIDENTIAL COMPLAINT FORM
The Commission's records and proceedings in a case are confidential until the Commission rules on probable
cause. A copy of the complaint will be provided to the person against whom the complaint is brought.
t. PERSON BRINGING COMPLAINT:
Name: John P. Morgan
Address: 6538 Collins Avenue, Suite 113
City: Miami Beach County: Miami-Dade
Work Phone: (305 )868-1161
Home Phone: <-.) _
State: Florida Zip Code: 33141
------
2. PERSON AGAINST WHOM COMPLAINT IS BROUGHT:
A person can be an individual, political committee, committee of continuous existence, political party,
electioneering communication organization, club, corporation, partnership, company, association, or any
other type of organization. }fboth an individual and a committee or organization are involved, name both.
Name of individual: Sherry Kaplan Roberts (alleged Florida address used here)
Address: 6801 Collins Avenue C1411 Phone: (419) 777-LAKE
City: Miami Beach County: Miami-Dade State: FL Zip Code: 33141
------
If individual is a candidate, list the office or position sought: Miami Beach Commission, Group J
Name of committee or organization:
Address: _
City: _ County: _ State: _
Phone: <-) _
Zip Code: _
Have you filed this complaint with the State Attorney's Office? (check one) D Yes III No
3. ALLEGED VIOLATION(S):
Please list the provisions of The Florida Election Code that you believe the person named above may have
violated. The Commission has jurisdiction only to investigation the following provisions: Chapter 104,
Chapter 106, Section 98.122, and Section 105.071, Florida Statutes. Also, please include:
./' The facts and actions that you believe support the violations you allege,
./' The names and telephone numbers of persons you believe may be witnesses to the facts,
./' A copy or picture of the political advertisements you mention in your statement,
./' A copy of the documents you mention in your statement, and
./' Other evidence that supports your allegations.
See attached for facts & evidence supporting same.
FEe 002 (Rev 4-24-05)
October
Additional materials attached (check one)? [ljYes DNo
4. OATH
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF _M_ia_rn_i._Da_d_e _
I swear or affirm, that the above information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
)riginal .igtlature of Person Bringing Complaint
/'
to and subscribed before me this _ ..... I_b_'_'{'_\")_day of
20 13
--------------,
Authori7.cd to Administer Oaths or NOlary public.
Notary Public State of Florida
; \8 r;. Silvio Ortega
i: My CommiSSion EE115658
Expires 0712612015

(Print, Type. or Stamp Commissioned Name ofNotary Public)
Personally known Or Produced Identification
Type ofldentification Produced B... Or\\i(..,'J-
Any person who files a complaint while knowing that the allegations are false or without merit commits a
misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082 and 775.083. Florida Statutes.
FEC 002 (Rev 424-05)
ALLEGATIONS
As supported by the facts outline below, Miami Beach Commission Candidate Sherry Kaplan
Roberts has:
a. Made false statements of facts to the public in her campaign literature by claiming: III
came to Miami Beach in 1996 on vacation fell in love with this city and never left.
1I
(Exhibit A).
b. Made false statements under oath to the Miami Beach City Clerk in her qualifying
documents stating that IIher legal residence is 6801 Collins Avenue C1411, Miami Beach,
Miami-Dade County, Florida
ll
and that she has been "residing within the City at least
one year before qualifying for City of Miami Beach elected office.
1I
(Exhibit B).
c. Made false statements to The Miami Herald alleging that it is only "[her partner, Alice
Randolph] lives there [in Ohio].11 (Exhibit C).
d. Made false statements to The Miami Herald that she was unaware ofthe requirement
that positions she maintained in Ohio required her to be a resident of Ohio. (Exhibit C).
e. Unlawfully received homestead exemption for real estate she owned in Florida until
earlier this year. The Miami Herald has report that she "c1aimed a homestead
exemption [in Miami Beach, FL] since at least 2005." (Exhibit C). Yet, the records in
Ohio, as outline below, indicate that she has repeatedly told the State of Ohio that she is
a resident of Ohio.
Essentially, the common question that shows that each ofthe above allegations are accurate, is
the overwhelming amount of evidence that shows that Ms. Roberts is a resident of Ohio, not
Florida. Thereby not only making her ineligible to quality to run for office in Miami Beach,
Florida, but also supporting the allegations above in their entirety.
FACTS
1. The City of Miami Beach's Charter requires a candidate to be a IIqualified elector of the
City residing within the City at least one year prior qualifying." (Exhibit D). liThe rule is
well settled that the terms 'residence,' 'residing,' or equivalent terms, when used in
statutes, or actions, or suits relating to taxation, right of suffrage, divorce, limitations of
actions, and the like, are used in the sense of 'Iegal residence'; that is to say, the place of
domicile or permanent abode, as distinguished from temporary residence./I Herron v.
Passailaigue, 110 50.539,543 (Fla. 1926). The residency requirement, therefore, means
more than just having a residence in Miami Beach.
2. Ms. Roberts is currently and has been receiving a property tax reduction in Ohio since
2001 that is only available to Ohioans who "own the home, occupy the home as your
principal place of residence." As a result, Ms. Roberts receives a "2.5% Homesite
Rollback." The application requires the applicant to "declare under penalty of perjury
that I have examined this application and, to the best of my knowledge and belief, it is
true, correct, and complete." (Exhibit Eshows the current exemption while a telephone
call to the Ottawa County Auditor at 1-800-788-8803 Ext. 6740 indicated it has been
received every since at least 2001.)
3. At the time Ms. Roberts qualified to run for office, Ms. Roberts was serving as the
Statutory Agent (equivalent to Registered Agent in Florida) of three different Ohio
corporations with the first appointment being made in 1993 and most recent in 2012.
(Exhibit F). In order for one to serve as an Ohio Statutory Agent, one must be "a
resident of [Ohio]" and companies are obligated to notify the Secretary of State if "any
agent ... removes from the state [of OhiO]." Ohio Rev. Code 1701.07 (A) & (D) (Exhibit
G).
a. When this was first reported online in a blog (Exhibit H), Ms. Roberts quickly had
an attorney assume the role of statutory agent for these three entities. The
Miami Herald reported "Roberts said she was unaware ofthe requirement and
has since made her lawyer the statutory agents for her Ohio businesses. The
blog, Roberts said, 'gave me an opportunity to correct an error.'" (Exhibit C).
However, the face of the official document Ms. Roberts signed to become a
statutory agent of Psychological Transitions Inc. clearly states the requirement of
"a natural person who is a resident of Ohio." (Exhibit F). Thus, Ms. Roberts was
fully aware. Further, it is unrealistic to believe that a person would sign
documents for three different entities identifying them as the individual "upon
whom any process, notice or demand required or permitted by statute to be
served upon the corporation may be served" at a specific address in Ohio, if they
lived in Florida. After all, how would they expect a process server to locate them
to accept service if they were not only not at the address they registered with
the State of Ohio, but not even in the State of Ohio. Thus, as I would hope that
Ms. Roberts would not have been committing fraud for all these years in Ohio, I
can only assume she was in Ohio to accept service as a resident of Ohio as
required by the laws of Ohio and indicated on the documentation she signed.
4. Since 2012, Ms. Roberts has repeatedly filed documents with the State of Ohio's
Department of Commerce, Ohio Division of Real Estate certifying subject to criminal
prosecution that her "home address" was in "Marblehead, OH." (Exhibit I) In fact, the
most recent such document was filed in 2013, clearly within one year of qualifying
indicating she is not eligible to run for office.
5. Ms. Roberts has held herself out to the public in Ohio as being a resident of Ohio when
doing business as a Realtor there.
a. Ms. Roberts and her partner, Alice Randolph, have an Ohio Realty company
named Lake Erie Boutique Realty, Inc. Ms. Roberts and Ms. Randolph are the
only individuals licensed to work for this entity. (Exhibit J).
b. Ms. Roberts is the one who is featured on the company's website. The website
(www.lakeerieboutiguerealty.com) has her photograph, not Ms. Randolph's, and
her information as the contact person. Further, the website proudly declares
"We are experienced REALTORS, living in Marblehead[, Ohio] and enjoy this
IIperpetual vacation" lifestyle. (Exhibit K).
c. Ms. Roberts has acknowledged that she posted this information to The Miami
Herald. /11All of that stuff, they found on my website. So if I had something to
hide, I wouldn't have posted it,' Roberts said." (Exhibit C).
d. As Ms. Roberts has acknowledged posting this information, with her name,
photo and contact information, it is clear that the "we" includes her. Further,
the fact that only two people (as documented above) are licensed as Realtors
with the company, the "well can only be read to include Ms. Roberts.
e. Beyond the main page ofthis company, on the Blog Page (Exhibit L), Ms. Roberts
in 2012 was thanking her "neighbors" in Ohio for coming to the grand opening of
her Ohio entity. Of course, referring to people in Ohio as her IIneighbors" further
supports her claim on this website that she lives in Ohio.
6. Ms. Roberts has held herself out to the public in Ohio as being a resident of Ohio as part
of a company that offers handy-man services in Marblehead, Ohio
(www.islandhelpers.com).
a. On the website ofthe company, Ms. Roberts states she only "spends her winters
in Miami Beach." (Exhibit M).
b. Not only is this likely her own words as she is also identified as the company's
"webmaster," but Ms. Roberts has acknowledged that she posted this
information when questioned by a reporter from The Miami Herald. 111All of that
stuff, they found on my website. So if I had something to hide, I wouldn't have
posted it,' Roberts said." (Exhibit C).
c. Thus, she has clearly held herself out to her neighbors in Ohio as spending most
of her time in Ohio and only a minimal amount oftime in Miami Beach.
7. While Ms. Roberts claims to the Miami Herald that she lives in Miami Beach, while her
partner, Alice Randolph, lives in Ohio, Ms. Roberts has filed documentation with the
Miami Beach City Clerk under penalties of perjury stating that they share a primary
residence.
a. Pursuant to City of Miami Beach Ordinance 2004-3451 (Exhibit N), in order to
gain certain benefits Ms. Roberts filed an official notarized government
document under penalties of perjury stating they "share a primary residence"
and that "each partner agrees to immediately notify the City Clerk's Office, in
writing" if that changed (Exhibit 0).
b. There is no record with the City of Miami Beach that indicates that Ms. Roberts,
or anyone else, has ever notified the City Clerk's Office, in writing, that they no
longer share a primary residence.
c. Publicly available information clearly confirms that Ms. Randolph does in fact live
in Ohio - as Ms. Roberts has told The Miami Herald.
i. Ms. Randolph Clearly lives in Ohio. In fact, she cannot even vote for Ms.
Roberts in this election because she is registered to vote in Ohio. (Exhibit
P).
ii. Ms. Randolph is on the board of her "Boatominium"/condominium in
Ohio. (Exhibit Q).
iii. Ms. Randolph identifies her residency on Facebook as being in
Marblehead, Ohio. (Exhibit R).
d. Thus, as Ms. Randolph lives in Marblehead, Ohio, and Ms. Roberts stated under
penalties of perjury they share a primary residence and would immediately
notify the City Clerk's Office, in writing, should that change, then by the
transitive theory dictates that Ms. Roberts' primary residence is in Marblehead,
Ohio too.
e. Further, this documentation creates a presumption that she lives with Ms.
Randolph in Ohio. Since the eighteen hundreds, Florida Courts have held that
the place where a married person's family resides is generally deemed to be his
or her legal residence. Smith v. Croom, 7 Fla. 81 (Fla. 1857). In today's society,
over a hundred fifty years later, where equality should exits the same
presumption would apply to a couple of 30+ years who have taken affirmative
acts to register as domestic partners in which they indicate they share a common
primary residence to obtain benefits.
8. When comparing her Ohio address to her Miami Beach address, it would lead a person
to believe that the Ohio address is her home and Miami Beach merely a vacation spot.
a. The Jake front home Ms. Roberts owns in Ohio appears to be a lovely spacious
residence - as indicated on Google Earth. (Exhibit S).
b. In contrast, Ms. Roberts' Miami Beach address is a 870 sq. ft. rental unit at the
Canyon Ranch resort in Miami Beach that was being offered for a "Yearly or
seasonal rental with spa membership." (Exhibit T).
9. While Ms. Roberts claims to have ties to Miami Beach based on her business it seems to
be based in Ohio, not here as outlined below.
a. According to documents filed by Ms. Roberts this year with the Florida
Department of State, the mailing address of South Beach Boutique Realty, Inc.,
that she is the President and Secretary of, is in Port Clinton, Ohio (at the offices
of Lake Erie Boutique Realty, Inc.). (Exhibit U).
b. Unlike the Ms. Robert's Ohio realty company where it is just her and her partner,
Ms. Roberts actually has employed an additional sales associate in the Miami
Beach Office. (Exhibit V). Thus, their realty businesses has coverage when they
are both in Ohio for extended periods of time, but not if they are both in Miami
Beach. Obviously, this is yet another indication of where Ms. Roberts spend the
bulk of her time - in Ohio.
10. Ms. Randolph even maintains an Ohio cellular phone number. If one calls 417-777-5253
Ms. Roberts answers it herself or a voicemail identifying her as the recipient does.
(Although, I suspect that might change once she learns of this complaint.)
11. I have been advised by others familiar with Ms. Roberts' service on Miami Beach boards
that she often flew back to Ohio after the meetings forcing her to turn down lunch
invitations from others in attendance at those meetings.
CONCLUSION
While Ms. Roberts' prior statements on these issues would lead one to believe that she
will point to the fact that she has been registered to vote in Miami Beach since 2001, that self-
serving fact alone does not establish Miami Beach as her residence. She has also pointed to her
Miami-Dade homestead exemption to support this claim; however, that is negated (and likely
made unlawful) by the fact that she has received a similar benefit in Ohio every year from 2001
to 2013. Consequently, the overwhelming facts establish that her residence is in fact in Ohio.
Accordingly:
a. Ms. Roberts lied to the voters when she published campaign literature by
claiming: "I came to Miami Beach in 1996 on vacation fell in love with this city
and never left."
b. Ms. Roberts is not legally qualified to run for office in Miami Beach and
committed perjury when under oath to the Miami Beach City Clerk in her
qualifying documents stating that "her legal residence is 6801 Collins Avenue
C1411, Miami Beach, Miami-Dade County, Florida" and that she has been
"residing within the City at least one year before qualifying for City of Miami
Beach elected office."
c. Ms. Roberts lied to The Miami Herald when she stated that only "[her partner,
Alice Randolph] lives there [in Ohio]."
d. Ms. Roberts lied to The Miami Herald when she stated she was unaware of the
requirement that positions she maintained in Ohio required her to be a resident
of Ohio as same was on documentation she signed.
e. Ms. Roberts has defrauded Miami-Dade County and Miami Beach out of taxes
since at least 2005 by unlawfully received homestead exemption for real estate
she owned in Florida until earlier this year as she was a resident of Ohio and
already receiving a similar benefit there.
EXHIBIT A
The story of Sherry Kaplan Robcrts'
adult life is a blend of successful
business development, community
activism, social advocacy, parenting and
strong family involvement.
At age 29, divorced after working to
put her husband through college, and
with a three-year-old son to support,
she started Sherry Roberts and
Associates, and S & R Temps, two
prominent Clcveland personnel service
firms. Ayoung woman starting a
business in the 1970s was such a rarity
that she was featured in the Cleveland
Plain Dealer in a full-page article wCan
A Woman Be A Boss?" In her 30 years
in business she has proven that the
answer certainly is YES and she has
paved the way for other women.
HR consulting prepared her for the
difficult work facing the City in st'!fI
acqumtiOll and retention, hen':fit (lnd
pensIon Issues, and HR compliance.
During those years shc also cared for
her infinn parents and three other
elders in her family who had
Alzheimer's Disease. Continuing her
ethic of community service she served on
the board of the regional Alzheimcr's
Association. Throughout hcr life she
has been in civic and professional
organizations. She was President of the
Clcveland Personnel Association and
Vice President of the Ohio Personnel
Association. She is a successful and
sought after leader, a "straight shooter."
One of her colleagues said, "She says
what she means and you can count on
her to follow through."
In 1993 Sherry and her partner opened
a hcalth carc practice and she serves as
chief operations officer with
rcsponsibility for budgeting, complying
with federal regulations, and
advocating for healthcare justice.
Al'(omplishmcnts in Ohio ar('
grt'at and what about Miami
B('ach? READ MORE ON PAGE 2.
JOB DESCRIPTION H)R A MIAMI 8liACH COMMISSIO:'l:liR
Skills and expericnce directing, managing, staffing, budgcting, understanding laws, ordinances
and government relations, communicating effective!)', building consensus, dealing \\ith
diversc people with respect and integrit). A quick wit and infectious sense of humor.
She has what it takes.
Commission.
quasi-judicial board that works to
prevent hardship for residents and
business. She was elected chair in
2011 and is touted for her respeciful
and deliberate leadershIp of this
committee and has repeatedly
demonstrated the abiliry to difuse a
COnlenrJous Situation andJoster
compromlse and consensus. These
skills arc important on the
seem to know how to turn down a
things, she is everywhere. Her energy
seems boundless and she does not
request for help or support.
Sherry generously contributes her
time and resources to many civic
organizations and according to
some of those who watch these
There is no doubt that as a
commissioner she will give the job
~ ._----..-.---.--.---.----..
.\ I L \1)fR P\ \\L\\lI Bf,\C'I I
True to her value of community
service, Sherry was president of her
condo association for 6 years and
In 2008 she was appointed to the
Board of Adjustmcnt, a powerful
during that time she brought a
neglected building into compliance
learning first hand about the process
IfpermltJ and building codes. She
became a licensed Community
Association Manager (CAM). When
asked why, she said, "I never
intended to work as a manager, just
be a better informed director."
She was on the Beach Preservation
Committee and chaired it in 2007,
working closely with city and
county officials on homc1essoess. beach
ecolo8J. and stren8thenJll8 the CJry
counry alliance, working to ensurc
that the county docs its fair sharc.
Sherry, with the Police Color
Guard, Dona Zemo and the
Conference Committee at the
opening of the futh annual Miami
Beam Women's Conference,
March 22,2013 sponsored by
Mayor Matti Bower and Womens'
Exhibit. She is a director and
chaired the Program Committee of
this organization established to
empower women.
':'ind Bennie, Shana and Cammie came too. "
"[ came to Miami Beach in 1996 on vacation
fell III love with this cit)' and nerer l ~ t . ..
"Even thouah [ didn't ",in in my bidJar
commissioner in 2009 JstaIed mvobed."
110%.
\ IHIS1\:1.SS C)\\' rR P\ .\ II. \.\ 1I B1.. \ <- .f I
South Beach
Boutique Realty
----
Sherry is Brok.er and owner of South Beach Bouti<juc Realty with her office on
Lincoln Road. She specializes in condominium sales with the boutique concept of
exceptional personalized servicc. She knOH's the real estate, tOUTlsm and economIC
market of Miami Beach and believes that the IS scrongest when resIdents and
busJnesses work toaether in harmony.
FAMILY
nl' {'ldO: In,>ulJ rI1III"! />c.'ch,w 11Irh III} I hul,' I>,','n nuh llta f," 1(1
Sherry's Parents and Inspiration
rO\\ing up in a traditional jcwi h famil)',
herry a quir dh r mcredible work ethic
from fath r who owncd a h c tor on
the W t idc of Clevcland and who
walk d c"eral milc dail\' to sa\'C th hus
fare and th n worked hi typical 10 hour
dOl\" herT)" s In nds and supporter oftcn
comm nt on her ener8)' lere! and business
me and her r pon e could he "You
should ha\' known my father, Ben." E"cn
il 'CIT l.eF [JM.Urlt r ti.r{!d lh \,\,U i1 '"c
in Beth In )'nagogu and when their
health fail d, 'herry tepped in with long
hours of upport to nable h r par n to
continuc their fundrai ing cti,'itic \\i
tbc Templc. h learned the importancc of
bac and paj"inaJorward"at a young
age and thi comm,cm nc co communit)' sen'ice
ontinuc today.

Board of Adjustment 2008 - Present, Vice Chair 2010, Chair 2011 . present.
Beach Preservation Committec 2006-2007, Chair 2007.
Miami Beach Chambcr of Commerce - Board of Govcrnors and Advocacy Committce.
Graduate of Miami Beach Leadership Acadcmy and Citizens' Police Academy.
Temple Beth Shalom - Member.
Miami Association of Realtors Broker.
SAVE Dadc - Guardian Mcmber 2007 - present.
Miami Dade Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce.
Women's Exhibit Director 2008 - Present.
A Woman Worth Knowing' Awarded 2012 by Miami Beach Commission on Women.
Presenting Life Time Achievement
Award to Senator Gwen Margolis
who has endorsed Sherry Roberts for
commissioner.
November 5, 2013 is Election Day.
SIILRHY KAPLAN HOBJ:H1S
ONI.Y TO(;ITIfER CAN WI-: J\tAKt A DlrrFRENtT
Tune into channel 77 on the first Friday of each
month for the Board of Adjustment Meeting chaired by
Sherry Kaplan Roherts.
"1'he best predictor (?f how a perso/J will a('l is how
she currently d ~ She has what it take.,; to lead. ..
Follow our campaign at
II II II ,11, ITI roh. rb (' .111
EXHIBIT B
MIAMI BEACH ''- 'f
h l..r ,;- f \. r- D
City of Miami Beech, 1700 Convention Center Drive, Miami Beach, Florida 3313'9,
www.miamibeochfl.gov 20/3 SEP -4 PM 2: 50
CITY CLERK'S OFFICE
Tel: 305-673-7411, Fax: 305-6737254
Email: RafaeIGranado@miamibeachfl.gov
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMIDADE
CITY CLtl{H'S on ICE
Before me, an officer authorized to administer oaths, personally appeared to me well
known who, being sworn, says that he/she is a candidate for the office of City
Commissioner (Group No. r (or Mayor) for the City of Miami Beach, Florida;
that he/she is a qualified elector of said City residing within the City at least one year
before qualifying for City of Miami Beach elected office; that hislher legal residence is:
(;j,t &/lI't'tA K. C/.I/II , Miami Beach, Miami-Dade County,
Florida; that he/she is qualified under the ordinances (including Miami Beach City Code
Chapter 38 governing "Elections") and Charter of said City to hold such office; and that
he/she has paid the required qualification fee. /
_ I n./ n Sherry Kaplan Roberts
A,Lt Candidate
Signature of Candidate
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 1!!J- day of
' .. " .
NOTARY SEAL

Igna re Notary
Date
F:\CLER\CLER\OOO ElECTrON\OOOO 2013 General Election\MISCElLANEOS WORD
DOCS\CANDIDATE'S OA /.
EXHIBIT C
Miami Beach candidates rebut challenges to residency - 10/ I0/20 13 i... http://www.miamiherald.com!2013/1 011 0/v-print/3681914/miami-bea...
BiamiHeralb
Posted on Thu, Oct. 10, 2013
Miami Beach candidates rebut challenges to residency
By Christina Veiga
The Miami Herald
Two candidates running for office in Miami Beach face questions over whether they actually
live in the city.
Sherry Kaplan Roberts and Steve Berke both say they are residents, despite claims to the
contrary. Both candidates willingly provided the Miami Herald with leases, bills and property
records to prove their case.
Such residency questions are actually common in local elections. Courts recently tossed out
a complaint that North Miami Mayor Lucie Tondreau didn't live in the city for a full year before
qualifying for office there. In 2011, Hialeah candidate Alex Morales insisted he lived away
from his wife and children in a small apartment in the city, despite owning three homes
outside the municipality's boundaries. A longshot mayoral candidate in that race also
claimed he lived in his Hialeah warehouse.
Miami Beach rules, like many city's, require candidates to be a "qualified elector" of the city
and to have lived in the city "at least one year prior to qualifying."
Roberts has been slammed on CityDebate.Wordpress.com, a local political blog, for
supposedly not meeting those requirements.
"No one can do what I've done and not be a resident of Miami Beach. Period," Roberts
counters.
She is running for commission Group I. Her opponents are Micky Steinberg, a real estate
agent and wife of former state Rep. Richard Steinberg; retiree Elsa Urquiza; and political
newcomer Mohammed Islam.
According to the documents she filed to run for office, Roberts' address is 6801 Collins Ave.
- the Canyon Ranch Hotel. The building includes hotel rooms and condos, Roberts said.
She provided the Miami Herald with her lease for a unit in the building. The date of the lease
is May 2013.
"I am renting a condo unit," Roberts said. "It is a residential condominium."
Property records show that Roberts recently sold her Lincoln Road penthouse, where she
claimed a homestead exemption since at least 2005. Roberts has been registered to vote in
Miami Beach since 2001, according to the county elections department.
Her critics, however, point to Roberts' businesses in Ohio as proof that she lives there. On a
website for a business that connects people with handymen and help with household
100 10/16/20136:43 PM
Miami Beach candidates rebut challenges to residency - 10/10/2013 I ... http://www.miamiherald.conl''2013/1 0/1 Oiv-prinI/3681914/miami-bea...
chores, Roberts' bio says she "spends her winters in Miami Beach." She is also described as
a "neighbor" in Marblehead, Ohio.
"All of that stuff, they found on my website. So if I had something to hide, I wouldn't have
posted it," Roberts said.
She said her partner, Alice Randolph, travels back-and-forth to work at Psychological
Transitions, which is described on its website as a company that provides long-term mental
health care for people in assisted living facilities and congregate-living homes in Ohio,
Nevada, West Virginia and Florida.
"She lives there. She's there, and back ...City Debate acts like people don't travel the world,"
Roberts said. "They're kind of selling the voters short and think they're stupid."
The blog claims that Roberts was listed as a statutory agent for the Psychological
Transitions company and two others. Under state law, a statutory agent for an Ohio business
must be a resident of that state, according to a spokeswoman for the Ohio Secretary of
State.
Roberts said she was unaware of the requirement and has since made her lawyer the
statutory agents for her Ohio businesses.
The blog, Roberts said, "gave me an opportunity to correct an error."
Berke has faced similar questions about his residency. Berke is an entertainer who is
running for mayor against Michael Gongora and Philip Levine. Fringe candidate Raphael
Herman is also running.
County records show that Berke has been registered to vote at his current address, on
Washington Avenue, since May.
Berke provided the Miami Herald with a lease for his current apartment. It is dated April 2012.
The lease shows Berke's previous address as being in North Beach.
Berke also allowed a Miami Herald reporter over to his apartment without notice late in the
evening. Campaign paraphernalia hangs on his walls. The fridge was stocked with food. His
girlfriend lay on his bed, surrounded by (dirty) laundry.
He shared a light bill that stretches back to July 2012 and shows his current Washington
Avenue address.
"I don't understand why you're even doing the story, when I've invited you into my home and
provided you with hard proof that I live here, have roommates who you can talk to, have
building valets, security and neighbors who you can talk to as well. ... Why bother moving
forward with a story if there isn't any truth to it? What kind of journalism is this?" Berke wrote
in an email.
Property records show Berke owns a condo outside the city limits, but he has not claimed a
homestead exemption there. Berke, who makes a living from his YouTube channel, where he
posts parodies in support of decriminalizing marijuana, says he uses the condo as a work
studio.
2 on 10/16/2013 6:43 PM
Miami Beach candidates rebut challenges to residency - 10110/2013 I... http://www.miamiherald.com/2013/10110/v-printl36In 914/miami-bea...
Berke points out that Gongora is part of a trust with his mother that, according to court
records, owns a condo at the Charter Club in Miami. Levine and his companies own many
properties outside of the city, too, Berke noted.
Follow @Cveiga on Twitter.
2013 Miami Herald Media Company. All Rights Reserved.
http://www.miamiherald.com
30f3 1011612013 6:43 PM
EXHIBIT D
Municode http://library.municode.conl'print.aspx?h=&cl ientID=13097&HlMReq...
Sec. 6.03. Qualifying.
The City Commission shall cause to be placed on the ballot to be used in the general election
the name of any qualified elector of the City residing within the City at least one year prior qualifying
and who, within the four (4) consecutive days immediately following the first Monday of September
prior to said general election, shall have paid to the City Clerk of the City of Miami Beach the sum
equal to seven and one-half percent (7%%) of the annual salary of the office to which he/she seeks
election as a qualifying fee and shall have been photographed and fingerprinted by the identification
bureau of the Police Department of the City, unless such person shall file with the City Clerk no later
than noon of the 14th day prior to the first day of qualifying as a candidate for such office, a petition
approving his candidacy signed by sufficient qualified and registered voters to constitute not less than
two percent (2%) of this number of such voters as the same shall be on the date sixty (60) days prior
to the first day of qualifying as a candidate for office, in the event the Miami-Dade County Elections
Department has not issued its certificate verifying the required number of valid signatures on the
subject qualifying petition by 5:00 p.rn. on the second day of the City's four-day qualifying period, the
City's 7%% qualifying fee shall be waived by the City in the event the subject candidate should
otherwise qualify for office pursuant to this Charter section. All candidates qualifying for office shall
have taken, signed and subscribed to an oath or affirmation in writing in which he/she shall state (1)
the title of the office for which he/she is a candidate; (2) that he/she is a qualified elector of the City of
Miami Beach, Florida, and has resided in the City at least one year prior to qualifying; (3) his/her legal
residence, by street and number; (4) that he/she is qualified under the ordinances (including Miami
Beach City Code Chapter 38 governing "Elections") and Charter of the City of Miami Beach, Florida,
to hold the office for which he/she is a candidate.
Such oath or affirmation shall be substantially in the following form:
Ion
~ T T E
IoF
FLORIDA
~ S
k:OUNTY
OF
DADE
Before me, an officer authorized to administer oaths, personally appeared to me well known who,
being sworn, says that he/she is a candidate for the office of City Commissioner (Group No.
_____(or Mayor) for the City of Miami Beach, Florida; that he/she is a qualified elector of
said City residing within the City at least one year before qualifying for City of Miami Beach elected
office; that his/her legal residence is: , Miami Beach, Dade County, Florida; that he/she
is qualified under the ordinances (including Miami Beach City Code Chaptsr 38 governing "Elections")
and Charter of said City to hold such office; and that he/she has paid the required qualification fee.
Signature of Candidate
Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of A.D., 19
I01l6/2013 3:19 PM
Municode
2of2
http://1i brary.municode.comtprint. aspx?h=&c1ientID=13097&HTMReq...
Authorized Officer
The City Commission shall, by ordinance. prescribe the manner of holding general and special
elections not inconsistent with the provisions hereof, and shall, by ordinance or resolution, prescribe
polling places in the various voting precincts in the City.
(Res. No. 2003-25290, 7-30-03; Res. No. 2003-25391, 7-30-03; Res. No. 2012-27964, 718-12, passed by voters
11-6-12; Res. No. 2012-27965, 7-18-12, passed by voters 11-6-12)
10116/2013 3:19 PM
EXHIBIT E
Ottawa COWlty. Ohio: Online Auditor - Property Data http://www.oltawacoWltyauditor.orlY'Data.aspx'!ParcelID=O1402374
Data For Parcel 01402374
Base Data
Feature not found.
Parcel: . 01402374
Owner: : R-oBER:rssHERRY
- ----- ----
Address: : 5465 CONSlTIUTION.8:IID _ _ -----2.
[+] Map this property.
Geographic
Mailing Address
Legal

! M14 I Legal Acres: I --=--==="'11

I 0_ _ __i
Legal i 656 I [- (570) R MFGHOME---:.
i Description: I Land Use: TAXED UKE REAL __ -J
iWEST HARBOR LANDING- E ----II
iBOATAMINIUM UNIT 393 Property Class: RESIDENTIAL 'I'
lLCA 1393 _J
I GI_S_P_I_N_:__ J
Tax Year 2012 Valuation
I
, Land Value:
Appraised Assessed (35%)
$0.00 jj $0.00

Building Value: <-I $100,300.00 - $35,110,00
i-===-----=====-==-:-:- .==0==- --
Total Value: $100,300.00 .1 $35,110.00
ICAUV Value: L $0.00
ITaxable Value: $35,110.00
Tax Credits
----------- ===================;1 2.5% Homesite iYES I
Rollback: !

Notes
1-----
i Notes:
:--=R=EA----.,. _=_============;'11
lof2 10116/2013 6:48 PM
Ottawa County. Ohio: Online Auditor - Property Data
1
l-__
Report Discrepancy
GISparcel shapefile last updated 10/16/2013 3:31:00 AM.
C4MA database last updated 10/15/2013 7:10:20 PM.
20f2
http://www.ottawacoWltyauditor.orgfData.aspx?ParceIID=O1402374
---------J
10116/2013 6:48 PM
Ottawa COWlty. Ohio: Online Auditor - Home http://www,ottawacoWltyauditor,org!
lof2
.. - ----- -_._------_._- -
Ottawa County, Ohio
2%0/0Tax Reduction
i
I Population 41,000
Parcels 37,000 Forms
Property Search
2 Y2% Tax Reduction Application
....._--- ..
----~
I_~ B E ~ READER-
,
r I
Home
...._-
--
---_... -
-- I
1
Search
To receive the 2 Y2% tax reduction you must:
Map
own the home, occupy the home as your
I :
----
principal place of residence, and apply with
, I Reports
the County Auditor between January 1
st
and I ,
-_.
I I
the first Monday in June.
I
I I
Forms
I ,
i ' ..__.
--
I
The reduction applies to the homesite and
Links
the home itself. It does not apply to: rental
I
2 Y2% Tax Reduction
homes or apartments, homes occupied by
someone other than the owner, homes owned
I
- --
Agricultural District
by corporations, partnerships, associations or
,
groups, units within a building primarily for
I
,--
I'
Ask the Auditor
retail, commercial or other non-residential
i
purposes, manufactured or mobile homes
Board of Revision
:
taxed under the depreciation method (see
;
Manufactured Homes) and excess acreage
CAUV
over one acre.
--- ---- _._------
Cigarette Dealer's License
Please check your tax bilt to see if you are
_._- . __ ._-
---
Dog License
already receiving the reduction.
-_._- ---_._._--_._---
:
Estate Tax GISparrel shapefile last updated 10/16/2013 3:31:00 AM.
:
-----
C4MA database last updated 10/15/20137:10:20 PM.
GIS
Homestead Exemption
Legal Description Reviews
Levy Information
:
Links
I
Lodging Tax
I
Manufactured Homes
I
I
Personal Property
I
I
Property Tax Facts
Property Transfer
I
Public Information
I
I
I
10116/2013 6:48 PM
Ottawa County, Ohio: Online Auditor - Home
Tax Estimator
Tax Rates
: Vendor's License
!----;eights & M-e-a-s-u-r-e-s---
I
1
1
_._ ..._. _. J
20f2
hltp:llwww.ottawaCOlmtyauditor.org!
10116/20136:48 PM
Auditor's no. _
DTE10SC
Rev. 11/08
Parcel number _
Tax district _
Application for 2lh.% Tax Reduction on Owner-Occupied Home
File with the county auditor no later than the first Monday In June.
Please read the back ofthis form before you complete it See the instructions County------ _
for a Late Application on the back of this form.
oApplication for this year 20__ 0 Late application for prior year
Name ofowner(s}ofhome _
Address ofhome _
Date home acquired _
Type of home: 0 Single family dwelling 0 Unit within a multi-unit dwelling 0 Condominium
Is the land surrounding the home more than one acre? 0 Yes 0 No
Do you occupy all of the home as your principal place of residence? 0 Yes 0 No
If answer is no, give details _
If the applicant or the applicant's spouse owns a second or vacation home, please provide the address and county below.
Address City State ZIP code County
I declare under penalty of ~ u r y that I have examined this application and, to the best of my knowledge and belief, it is
true, correct, and complete.
Signature ofapplicant _
Applicant's address _
Phone number Oate _
For CountyAuditor's Use Only o Granted o Denied
Tax Year Parcel number Total Acres Land Building(s) Total
$ $
Taxable value eligible for deductions $ _
Land Building Total
Name on taxduplicate _ Date filed _
Please read this before you complete the front of this application.
General Instructions and Information
Qualifications: To receive the 2lh% homestead tax reduction,
you must own and occupy your home as your principal place
of residence (domicile) on Jan. 1 of the year you file for the
reduction. A homeowner and spouse are entitled to this
homestead tax reduction on only one home in Ohio, unless
they can establish that they are domiciled separately. Aperson
only has one principal place of residence. Your principal place
of residence determines, among other things, where you are
registered to vote and where you dedare residency for income
tax purposes.
Current Application: If you are applying for the 2
1
1.1%
homestead tax reduction for the first time this year, check the
box for Application for This Year.
Late Application: If you also qualified for the 2
1
,6% homestead
tax reduction for last year, but did not file an application last
year, you may file a Late Application by checking the late
application box on the front of this form.
Instructions: The line after Auditor's Numberis for the auditor
only; do not write on it. The lines following Parcel Number
and Tax District are for the parcel number of your home and
for the taxing district in which it is located. If these lines are
not already completed, both ofthese can be found on your tax
bill. If you cannot locate them, contact your county auditor. In
the line following Name of Owner(s) of the Home, list the
names of all the owners. If all the names are not on your tax
bill, list the names as they appear on the deed to your home.
EXHIBIT F
Doc 10 -->

9302_1164
PteIIcrQled by
Bob Tat. 5ecnItaty ot Stu
3D IiAIlBftlMsn.. ,. Floo,.:
COlumbus. 0bI0 4Sl!'/leo0418'
Form AGO 162)
P-"'3
.',
.:.


?
...
.1
J.
6
Q
.....
ORIGINAL APPOINTMENT OF STATUTORY AGENT
The under8Jg1uKt being at 'eut. m&PitY at the UlCOlpalaten of _
psvdBoxoorcu "tHy
_____ II) bog 8taIUtI)fy Igent upon Whom any
, ,,,.,. ClfliIIlIV
procea. nQtIce id8mand or permltIBd ItIIUt8 tD be 88Md upon the COI'J)OnIISon may
be S8MId. T'hI COfnPI* 8CIdI'8a of the ....11:
L!D4'erhav.n J)rj.v.e
ACCEP'TANC8 011 APfIODma!NT
T1Ie undI,, Sh.ny RobuU ,.. hnIn .,. *"""'.... lDr
pSYCPQWGTcir "'DUxnms mc:. " __ IJld __lie
/)
.;0'''_"' __''
,_.,
1) PJ'GIlIftd cdda ot i11C1l11'J1018l1O_ FI"':- ......... oJ
. 17O'1mtB). 1702_11). .: ' '.'
2)
lIIlrrar. forelgn:prcftt: COtPCI... \ft:OIilo whlch- In .....
bf iRs.,1eIa ot II..,..." staa=rv JGIfIt,:
...
'"-......fIMt... .......Oft_...
. . ! . . .
N otOCClDre. ,.RoC. f1D'I -..';'.".,..,10", WD_uMlrIftdI:: s;iA1I..... .. ItIlaIt
-'..., -.., ;$
.
Page 5
Doc 10 -->
201205201682
ICGlnDIIIflt ftIe InfanJJetlonln thbJ MdIan If /IQl' ttl 121 or m ,. I
ORIGINAL APPOINTMENT OF STATUTORY AGENT
The undersigned, being at Ieaat a majority of the IrlcorporalotB of Lake Erie Boutique Realtv l--#.f..
haruby appoint the following III be stalutoty agent upon whom eny process, notice or demand required lit permltled by
Il1atule 10 be aerwd upon the corporvtion may be seN8d. The oomplete BddTllllS of lhe agenll8
Sherry Roberts
(Name)
5465 E. Constitution Blvd
(!lIrortJ
NOTE: ,..o. __...
Marblehead
,OhIo
43440
(Cityj fZ*' Cl>doJ
Musl be authenticated by an

I
I 'd.. euthartzed rep8t4lnlallv8
Dale
I I
I
AuthorWtd RepresenlBtive Date
I I
I
AutIlOl1zed Represenla1ive Date
ACCEPTANCE OF APPOINTMENT
The S), etOt. t( 'Ko" (. tl-t; .s , lIIII1llld h&nlln 88 the
I
S1Btutofy agentlol'. Lake Erie Boutique Realty J;: f\i <'-
, hereby acknowledges and ac:ceptB lhe said enti1Y.
Signlllure: ). v t..J
(St&lutory J(genl)
Page 4
Doc 10 -->
199932200516
Pn:oatbcdbJ J. Kenneth Blackwell
Pl_oblain ftie llDoant and Il1IIiliag iDslrudiaas frW1lbc Fonm
IDVeDfo" Lin( v.siog tIu: 3digit form' Iocatl!d at the bottamofthis
farm). To oblliu!be FOI"IDIlImntory Lmor for lISSislaDu. p/ase
call Cus!olDe:' Savice:
CalnI Ohio: 1-877-SOS-FlLE (1-877-767-3453)
ORIGINAL APPOINTMENT OF STATUTORYAGENT
Tht lI/Iden:igued, being III least IL oC1IIe IDcarparIItcn of
Corporate Transitions, Inc.
hcrUy sppo!Dl:
__Shs_rry......;._Ro_berts 10 be mdDImy IgaII upcm whmD lIII)'proccas, llOlb: or
dcu1l11ld or permitted by st:at=to be served upcm Ibc mil)' be 5Crftd. The ccmplcte Bddmss ofllle is:
9394 Westwood Drive
(rbot _Illd1IIIIlIIa) 44056
Hade:ionia
_______________,Ohio
(cII)'.m. (zip code)
By: 'i n tJ::
-------
By: _
NIIIIIt: _
ACCEPTANCE OF APPOINTMENT
The IIIIdcnigw:d. Sherry Roberts IIllmCd Ju:n:iq u 1110 SlmUtlIrY agem for
_...,....
appointment oflltlItUlory agent for said lXU]lOl'lltion.

Sherry Roberts Sllltutmy Agcnt
Page 4
EXHIBIT G
Ulwriter - ORC - 1701.07 Statutory agent - cancellation and reinstatem.. http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/1701.07
100
1701.07 Statutory agent - cancellation and reinstatement of
articles.
(A) Every corporation shall have and maintain an agent, sometimes referred to as the "statutory agent,"
upon whom any process, notice, or demand required or permitted by statute to be served upon a
corporation may be served. The agent may be a natural person who is a resident of this state or may be
a domestic corporation or a foreign corporation holding a license as such under the laws of this state,
that is authorized by its articles of incorporation to act as such agent and that has a business address in
this state.
(B) The secretary of state shall not accept original articles for filing unless there is filed with the articles
a written appointment of an agent that is signed by the incorporators of the corporation or a majority of
them and a written acceptance of the appointment that is signed by the agent. In all other cases, the
corporation shall appoint the agent and shall file in the office of the secretary of state a written
appointment of the agent that is signed by any authorized officer of the corporation and a written
acceptance of the appointment that is either the original acceptance signed by the agent or a photocopy,
facsimile, or similar reproduction of the original acceptance signed by the agent.
(C) The written appointment of an agent shall set forth the name and address in this state of the agent,
including the street and number or other particular description, and shall otherwise be in such form as
the secretary of state prescribes. The secretary of state shall keep a record of the names of corporations,
and the names and addresses of their respective agents.
(D) If any agent dies, removes from the state, or resigns, the corporation forthwith apPoi':"!t another
.witb secretary of state, on a form prescribed by the secretary of state, a written
appointment of the agent.
(E) If the agent changes the agent's address from that appearing upon the record in the office of the
secretary of state, the corporation or the agent shall forthwith file with the secretary of state, on a form
prescribed by the secretary of state, a written statement setting forth the new address.
(F) An agent may resign by filing with the secretary of state, on a form prescribed by the secretary of
state, a written notice to that effect that is signed by the agent and by sending a copy of the notice to
the corporation at the current or last known address of its principal office on or prior to the date the
notice is filed with the secretary of state. The notice shall set forth the name of the corporation, the
name and current address of the agent, the current or last known address, including the street and
number or other particular description, of the corporation's principal office, the resignation of the agent,
and a statement that a copy of the notice has been sent to the corporation within the time and in the
manner prescribed by this division. Upon the expiration of thirty days after the filing, the authority of the
agent shall terminate.
(G) A corporation may revoke the appointment of an agent by filing with the secretary of state, on a
form prescribed by the secretary of state, a written appointment of another agent and a statement that
the appointment of the former agent is revoked.
(H) Any process, notice, or demand required or permitted by statute to be served upon a corporation
may be served upon the corporation by delivering a copy of it to its agent, if a natural person, or by
delivering a copy of it at the address of its agent in this state, as the address appears upon the record in
the office of the secretary of state. If (1) the agent cannot be found, or (2) the agent no longer has that
address, or (3) the corporation has failed to maintain an agent as required by this section, and if in any
10116/2013 2:35 PM
EXHIBIT H
Can you believe Sherry Robert" is living a double life? ICity Debate http://citydebate. wordpress.conv2013/10/071can-you-believe-sherry-r...
'1up,''Jr -EO : .. r"SEc, . cI, E:RE".' C:O[.-,O, LC::'-.',l '1'[_11[:' .>:. o:oE Jr" ,
;JPS;:;" .[! :t_: ;fEW5 W.PEr' "EI'5" ": C:CECCU'; 'L[<SEF .w:,: - .''!:;:f.JP,5C Jr ';';'C8J
'.DON E lC 2[e;.T 'w r C;:'8.'E J'I('"' .OM C[E, cr .. :J,' 'm ' CEB:'TE . 'Cr"':SSCJM [JM"'[N. r[EO r;v'
_-Ill"'. E,,0 G.'l [S'., "-0 G -' .,," B - -r -,'tEvpc'x - ,Rf
C
" C' . 9R 0' ',' cr s:>r: -p , ,r or '.[ P:1'" -r
0 ... r"JI ... r J. l.LBfBA' - . C 'I. I Le'
Can you believe Sherry Roberts is living adouble life?
Can you believe Sherry Roberts is living adouble life?
by: J PMorgan
We hawaII heard the stories of the cliche traveling salesman who has two families in two places that are
clueless as to the existence of the others. 1M. to think that someone would actually lead adouble life in this
digital age and run for office in one of them is simply astonishing. She not only proudly tells Ohioans that she lives
there to get themto do business with her, but continues to represent to the Ohio Secretary of State that she is a
resident of Ohio.
Last week, Ireported that Miami Beach Commission candidate Sherry Roberts is aRealtor in Ohio that boasts
on her website that she is "living in Marblehead: Ohio, While that claim in itself would seemto disqualify someone
fromrunning for office in Miami Beach. I decided to dig alittle deeper to see if these was an isolated incident or
perhaps amistake, or whether Ms. Roberts - excuse me, Ms. Kaplan Roberts - actually does live in Ohio. I did not
have to look very far to find more.
PHOTOS
On the blDg section of the very same website shows that just last year she was thanking her "neighbors' in Ohio
for coming to the opening of her newreal estate office there. She even said theywere bringing their "skills [from]
South Beach to Ohio." Maybe she's trying to counter Lebron James' taking his "talents [fromOhio) to South
Beach?'

But, it turns out she this isn't the only place online that Sherry has made it clear that she lives in Ohio'
lof4 1011612013 6:54 PM
Can you believe Sherry Roberts is living a double life? ICity Debate hltp://citydebate.wordpress.coml2013/ 10107/can-you-believe-sherry-r...
SHERRY ROBERTS
IT GETS EVEN BETTERI
On another company's website,
where she is the webmaster - so
these are presumably her own words-
Sherry proudly states she only:
spends her winters ;n Miami Beach.'
20f4
Cherry F<:otJerts Ili1S experience in personnel services ancl operations. She Is our
"nil over:oees I'll! staffing. management and information fune1ions. She spends her in
Ivliami Beaeh where is a
Conleol COlJYl1llh1201o.2013 l$IanclHeJpers com Al1llllhlS reselVell
Even more alarming, according to the Ohio Department of State, Sherry Roberts has repeatedly - and as recently
as last year -filed documents declaring that she is aresident of Ohio. In fact not only has she dedared this
recently, but she has continues to maintain that she is an Ohio resident to the Ohio Department of State to thIS
day - eVlln though she is running for Miami Beach Comnission.
According to the Ohio Department of State, Ms. Roberts is the "Statutory Agent" of tI1ree active Ohio entities (see
links below). And Ohlo's Statutes makes it clear that in order to be aStatutory agent. one lTlJst be "a resident of
this state [. Ohio]" and are obligated to notifythe Secretary of State if "any agent ... removes from the state [of
Ohio)."
Essentially, Sherry Roberts is Jiving adouble life Telling those of us in Miami Beach that she "came to Miami
Beach in 1996fell in love with this city and never left" and filing documents with our City Clerk attestingthat she
has is and has been aresident of Miami Beach in order to have her newname placed on the ballot Yet at the
same, she is declaring herself to the Department of State of Ohio as aresident of Ohio and telling people there that
she is "living in Marblehead[, Ohio]" and only "spends her winters in Miami Beach: Not to mention the disparity
between her lovely waterfront home in Ohio. c0rl1lared to her staying at Canyon Ranch when she is kind enough to
grace us with her presence in Miami Beach.
Can it be that Ms. Robert, excuse me, Ms. Kaplan Roberts (forgot she wants us to think she's IOOre Jewish), thinks
that the people of Miami Beach are so naive that theywould fail to even Google her to discover her other life? Does
she think we should have to find her in Ohio when we have aproblem in Miami Beach? Does she think she will be
ahle to have the city pay for her to fly from Ohio to attend Corrrnission meetings if she miraculously was elected?
If she does, why hasn't she been honest with us instead of claiming she came [here] in 1996 ... and neVllr left?"
Sherry sirl1l1y reminds me of the tired story of the traVllling salesman who is discovered to have two families tI1at
have no idea that tI1ey aren't his only family. The good news is we have found out about tI1e otl1er family before
we'Vll walked down the aisle and been asked to say "I do. For one. Ican tell "I don't."
PSYCHOLOGiCAl TRANSITlONS,INC. (http://\N\,1\\I2sos.state oh l!s/pls/bsqry
If'p==lOO:7:0::NO:7:P7_CHARTER_NUM.856546)
CORPORATE TRANSITIONS. INC. (http://WWN2.sosstate.oh.us/pls/bsqry
/f:'p",l00:7:0.N07 P7_CHARTER_NUM:1116998)
lAKE ERIE BOUTIQUE REALTY. INC. (http://www2.sos.state.oh.us/pls/bsqry
10/16/2013 6:54 PM
Can you believe Sherry Roberts is living a double life? ICity Debate
/f?p=100:7:0 NO. 7P7_CHARTER_NUM 2083790)
http://citydebate.wordpress.com/2013/1 0/07!can-you-believe-sherry-r...
The fmal entity, Lake Erie Boutique Realty, filed just last year and is relatively new.
*Here is the form in which she acknowledges she accepts the appointment (http /Jwww2.sos state Oh.us/reports
/rwsel"tAet?lmgcIIDm=201205201682)
To read aprior story click link below:
http://cltydebate.WIlrdpress.com/2013/lO/Q4/where' does'sherry' roberts-Iive/
Name (required)
Email (required)
Website
Comment (required)
hUp: i t ~ ISpOyPr
Rattthls:
Sh.tthl.:
LIk.IIII.:
ukt 0
-- ,
two 3
30f4
l!<llhe GtSlIO lil<elhlf
PllS1EC ~ MIAMI or"" MIAMIOEM)- MIAMI DADE muNT' UNrAlEGORII['
PREVIOUS
Leave a Reply
NEXT
10116/20136:54 PM
Can you believe Sherry Robert" is living a double life? I City Debate http://citydebate.wordpress.com'2013/ I0107/can-you-believe-sherry-r...
:. .'. fo,_' t ~
40f4
I'" ,- ~ ~ . 0"1' ....
10/16/20136:54 PM
EXHIBIT I
LICENSE EXAMINATION APPLICATION
SALESPERSON
RECEIVED
FEB 24 2012
OHIO DIVISION OF
RiAl5S+ATE
Plule vl&U 0IIl' Wlblltl al
www.com.ohlo.gol//real
14118""00
FBI 514 1544-0584
TlYfTDD: 800 I 750.Q750
r
APPLICANT INFORMATION
ETHICAl. CONOUCT AND LE!GAl HISTORY
o PLEASE! AmC" ACOMPlete EXPLANADQN FOB ANy gUESJlQNS ANSWERED B!lOW,
o QUESTIONS CONCERNING PROFESSIONAL LICENSES APPlY TO ALb PROFESSIONAL liCENses REGARDlESS OF PROFESSION.
FI E
o Incomplete upplltlltiolls and appllclllions lb:ll lire nlled out Incorrectly \\111 bc FEE: 560.00
relurlU.od for corrtloa,
Allach a copy of Ihe officiAl Irnnscripl or ceniticale of complelion of Ihe four
required pre-licensure c1asscs,
A chcck or money order fOf S60.UO In:lde pnyable 10: Division of Real Estoh: &.
Professional Licen5ing, must be rcn,illed with torm. Carh will not be: accepted.
Note: The nume and duce orblrlh on this I1ppllcatioD must malch tile name und date ofbirlh un Ihr gu\'ernlllent issued phutu
IdcnllRclllloD \'011 will use to Idrnlify YOlusdf III the eJumlnlltion site,
OYES!8INO

DYES laNO
DYES
DYES &(NO
DYES IXNo I'hlve you ever bern disciplined in ony manner by lIny public entilY Dr professional or Irude i15SO:iUlioll for IIny
violation ofllny prvfl:sionallicensing law. n:gUllllion orclhicDI rule?
Hal/l: you ever been rolUsed or denied lIny professionallicensl! or regtslT1llion by Dny public cnlil)'?
Hove you evcr h:td any professionallic:cnse revo,"cd. suspooded or limilcd in lIny \YI\)' for nny rellson?
lill\'e you ever b.xn ROlilied by :lny public cnlily or professiollal or Irnde llSllocialion Ihul yOIl wrre undu
,investigation for My violation of I1ny professioMllicellsinlllllw. rcgulalion or clhic:l1 rule?
l'lavc: you ever be.:n Ihe subjeci ofnny unsDlisfiedjudgmenls"
Hllve you ever been of, plead guilty to or betn granled illlervcnliun in lieu of conviction for Dny
unlawful conduct c:xc!u<lillil minor trOme Yiolntions'l EXPLAIN:
THE APPLICANT MUST COMPLETE THE FOUOWING CERTIFICATION
I c.:nilY 111111 uH orlh&: SIulcmenlS on Ihis "pplicillion and all oflhc attnchl:d millcrials are c0l\1llle1e nnd lIecu"'lc. I ullLlcrstllod lhulony
r:llsr SIRlrmenl on Ihi! form or Ihe nUllerilll, muy SUbject me 10 cri innl prose . n "lid the loss of my Ohio e51:11c

THE SPONSORING BROKER MUST COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING CERTIFICATION
I hereby cenity lhol, ITOOllhe invCSlillntion5 nmdr by Ole, [ find the :lbove listed npplil:lInt for a fC:lIl CSl:llc license is hOllesl, tnllhful
lind of GOod repuliltion. IUllderslQnd lh:u Dny fllise 51DlCInenc 01\ this 10m, or the nllnched Innlerio!s lhol is known 10 me at the lime or
my may 5ubjecl 10 criminal proseculion nnd!lle loss or my
J11\J c9}@()Id-..
N"ME OF BROKEIrI"'."Olyp.ct elll't! FILE NUMBER SIGNATURE Of BROKeR DArE ;
NOTICE; Per Sllctlon 149.43,lhls application amllhe information contained lnerllln, except for the social secunly number. is public record.
NOTICE; Pel R.C. Sedlan 4735.0918), " an II$lpliCallon i. denied prior III lhe applicant's being IIdmIUed 10 lha 8llsmlnalJon. IIlI dlvlsion 10 cover lite
expenses 01 precessing the applicallon. shall reulll one-llatf of Ihe let. anclille olheronehall shall be I8Iurned 10 Ihe applicant
NQTICE: Relusal 01 check paymenl by the drawer'lI bank my rSlIullln I 5100 lee 10 lhe superlnllndeJII sncIIOt Ih' rejeclion Of wilhdr_1II 01 Ihis
d5Pl;eaIiOf\,
Please ylsll our webslle 8\
www.com.ohl.o.gov/real
1114 1466-4100

TTYITDD: BOO.' 750-07.!lO
SALESPERSON
TRANSFER I REACTIVATION APPLI.CATION
HOME PHONE
87 734-'2030
FOR DIVISION USE OMIlY
&.ASTNAME
Robert.s
10" to be willi In ItnJ secIi'On below,
DOING BUSINESS AS (U.s.A., NAME
MIDDlE NNole. OR
Inc
FIRST NAME

MAIN BUSINESS 1IIl0000SS
205 SE' Catawba' Rd. Suite A
FILE NUMBER
2012000435
This form is Yuu "",)'. before prinUag, Iype your ri:spOnscs direclly onto 'the form.
lacomplcte l!Pplitlltions and those Ihnlon: filled out incorrectly will be: for com:clion.
Acheck or moncy. order fur any fees, mDde payoble 10 the Division of Real Estliic & Proressional L.- -I
Licensing, lhis llPplication. ClIsh will no' be accepled.
Indh'ldual fees afl! listed lK!low or In Ihc,reacth'DUoD fet: schedule un puge 1.
APPUCANTtNF.ORMATION
em' llUSlNESS PHONE
Port Clinton (4UJ 117-5253
REASON FOR COMPLETINGTHIS FORM (Chec:kall.lhat epply. Remlt onll BppncatJon 1&11 IMI!:Tarm checll muI\Ipk! boln.1
,r ;eLu of II llce'nse:1j Ie 1fW: lridilde'lIlll ORlG"tNAl.lItell&e.1I II Inal i1eerisci Is rii51. lease riwnlu C" '.' Ic:aIlan -IiuiMdUat with. US roo.
TRANSFER TO A NEW BROKERACE-.US fee
If two or mon: people arc.lrllnsfemll&, Ddvisc broker 10 complcte.tllt: Mulliplc l:.icC1lsc Tr.ul5fer Affidal/it.
C REACTIVAToE liCENSE FRO/HINACfIVE STATUS ... 51S fee Iii;ensee is 70 yelllS ohgc or older i1nd'renctivating
from inactive also include "roof of completion orall outst:mding continuing eduClltion.)
D PLACE LICENSE IN IN,\cnVE STATUS - no fee (skip Broker Infonnorion and
InliCttvc licensees are required Iu submit n:neWllI'IUl"d cuntinuing education by due dote every ye:trs,
a REACTIVATE LICENSE TO ACTIVE STATUS FROM RENEWAL -,see le'c sChedule 'an :1
(i nelude Bruker Infonn:llion llIld re'urn orlginalllccnsc)
IJ REACT'"ATE LICENSE TO INACTIVE STATUS FROM RENEWAL SUSPENSION - see fee sdlcdulc IUI!:e 1.
(skip Broker Infonnllion and l"clurn origlnollkense)
IJ RE,\cnV,\TE TO ACTIVE STA1'US FROM IO-HOUR POST liCENSE EDl!CATION'Sl,JSPENSrON
- SZS fu (;m:!udc Braker Information Bnd retum orlglnul Uel:nsc)
C REACTivATE LICENSE TO INACTIVE STATUS FROM IOHOUR POST LICENSE EDUCATION SUSPENSION
- 515 fcc (skip Broker Inrotm:llion)
D REAqlvATE. LICENSE TO ACTIVESTt\TUS F"ItOM SUSPENSION DUE TO SOLE BROKER SUSPENSION - no fee
(include. Broker Information llI1d retl!rn originnlllceo5e. Iftrnnsrcrrinllto II new brokcr,lnclulk or1sinal licenSe.
If two or more licensees nre advi!ic your broker to completcthe Multiple License: Tronsrcr Afiidllvit.)
E:I TE.LIENSE TO INAcrrVESTATUS' FROM SUSPENSION DUE TO SOLE BROKER
110 (skip Brdccr InrOrnt:l.hOn lUId relurn origlnnlliccnsc)
C REACTIYATE'UCEN.S.E TO ACTIVE STATUS ENFORCEMENT ACTION-S2.S fee
DREACTI\'ATE LICENSE TO INACTIVE; STATUS FROM ENFORCEMENT ACTION.- S25 reo
I '!1IlEASE COPLETE PAGES 1AND 2 OF THIS FORM'" 1
This appllca1jon end !tit Information conlalnlMf lhllr&ln, elCell\ for Ills sa:laI S:\lrlly "umber. Is publicrec:ord pUl$lIan1111.0hlo RlIVlsed COde 149.43.
af by !he dl1lWll(s maY l1IIUllln I fe!llo \he'superlnlendent Or 0( wlltldrawai of of

COM3572 (Rev: .6120101 "AI1 EquGI OppoflrmllJ amI Pr,...iilcr' Page 1 01 2
licensees reaclivBUng'flOm Renewal/Contlnulng Education Suspension owe the following fees:
Rlfnewal'Fee Late,Renewal Penal Reactivation Fee Total who havo plIld tho 5135 rvnll"'!'lll,feo
$
'25.00 $227 shDuld remit ....e Late Renewal Penalty end the
$135.00 .50 Reactivation Felt,
jEnlICALCONDUCTAND-LeCJALHISTO'RY' ,- - - .
,;.., _
SINCE your most recef't filing of an application for Ohio real estate lIc:en5ure. renewal or transfer/reactivation
a licat!on. have ou;
NO bm1,disciplintd in an)' manner by lilly p,ublic enlilY or profeSsional UT I""k QssotioliDn for any \:iohstion or'any
rorcssion:d liccnsin IIlW, To: ulolion orelhiclll rule?
C YES NO been n:ruscd or.dcnil.'d lUIy prvrl:S5ioriollice:nsc or n.:sislmrion by ony pUblic cnlity'l
c' YES h"d DR)' professionn/liccnsc n:vokcd. suspended'or limited in IIny way for My n:osori?
If license is currentlY5us[lCndcd, check "yes," SUSPENSION REASON:
eYES - bec\l noriliCli by 1I0y public cntity or prvrc:ssionlll.or tnJdl: llSSocialion chllt you wen: under inve5tigati",n an)'
6r'NO .violation,oran rorc:ssional lew. n: 'ullliDn or'eLhii:.al rule?
NO been the sub'eel oran unsolislic:d 'ud
NO Conviclc:d or, plcnd guilty to or.bel:lt pnled inlctVenlioD in lieu ofronvjclion fOT IIny conduct
excluding,minor trilfJic violations? LIST:
'lHEAPPUCAN'T MUST COMPlETE ntE FOLLOWING CERTIFICATlON
I cenifr that all orlhe on this ,lIppliCllliollllnd'all orlhe Dllschcd mnterials'PTe ,complerc lind :U:cUIllIC:. I understand thai
any r:*e S1IIIc:mcnl on Ihi, form may subjcci me to criminDI n the or . Ohio rolll estlle lic:al5e.
A4h
A I T
COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING AfftRMATlON IF TRANSFERRING TO A OIFFERENT BROKER;
I hove loforml!d m)' present brvker, In wrillDg, Iball oin trullsferr!"g 0 dlrrerc: roker,

:THE SPONSORING BROKERMUST COMPLETE lltEFOllOWlNG;CERTlFICAll0N
Mar .;10 I
DAlE
2012000432
FIl.ENLJrJIlEA
I hcreby certify Ihill. from the invcslignlionl\ msot I lind lhe: aoovc"/islcd ullplicont fora real eslate IkC:l1Se is hancst, lruthful
l1Ild ofgacKfn:J1Ulation. I 'hnl any Sllllc:me:nl on thi! fonn that is knowlllo me ot du: lirl\ll Dfmy signinG JUbjec:,1
me Iii criminal prOscculioll and the IOSli lJr.my Ohio redl CSlllle liecnsc.
Alice Randolph
HMlI! OF BROKER ...
RECEIVED
MAR 21 lOIZ
QHiO DIVISION OF
REAL ESTATE
Psgil2012
'TEN-HOURPOST LICENSURE l!'.i>UCATION'FORM
REAL ESTATE
RECEIVED
JAN 09
OHIO DIVISION OF
REAL ESTATE
Plea" villi our Mb* III
www.com.ohlolloYlreal

Fu
TlYITOD: loa 1750-0750
tills form Is JntUlCtivc. You may, before printing II, type yow
rcsponsu direclly onto tbe form. OtherwIse, Ihls rQrm muse be
typewrl,lCen or printed leslbly in blade Ink.
Submillhls original, completed ram" along with I copy ordlt
Ilrtend8ncc certificale, to the above address. Do Not FllIl.
Remember to si nand date Ibii Conn, '
COURSE INFORMATION
COURSE PROVIDER, ,
A BETTER WAY INSTITUTE
THE APPLICANT MUST COMPLETE,THE FOLLOWING eeRnFlCAOON
POST LICENSURE EDUCATiON REqUIREMENTS
No later than 12 months after the date of Issue of areat
estate salespeuon or broker license. the licensee shall
submll to 1M otvtslon proof of completion of a len' hour
posilicensure course.
PlEASE INDICATS UClNSE T1PE(S1
HiLDAHO fILE fNUlIER
I certify that all ofthe stillements on Ibis applica,ion and 1111 or the at,tathed mlltCfials l:olllph:le and KcurBte. I undersland lhal
81ly false, stBlemenl on lhis form !nay subject me 10 crimlnlll FOSCtU:2he loss of my Ohio ,rca,' estate license.

n __ - __ "
..
,
'
11J1.4L 1Ell'I'ROI'6SSIUNAL LIt'f.NSIM;
(OHI'I.IAIK'/i
UCUlllun'
UIJOII 11'()1l1:I;1I.'iAI'EJl'
STArE FIM
1,1()IIOII/'/ltlTllIH,
C 1:1111":;
COM 3689 (Rev, 02.20101
Pogll011
EXHIBIT J
Print Lookup Details https://elicense3-secure.com.ohio.gov/Lookup/PrinllicenseDetails.asp...
Please note that an entry indicating a suspension or revocation MAY merely reflect
that a licensee has elected not to renew the license. If you are concerned about the
meaning of a particular entry or the reason why a licensee is in suspended or
revoked status please contact the Division at WebReal@com.state.oh.us.
WARNING:
-
Prior to March 1, 2007, not all course providers submitted their rosters electronically and
therefore those courses may not be on this list.
Courses listed may have been used to fulfill a previous CE Reporting Cycle. Credit for CE
Courses may be used ONLY Once) Please be sure you have not already used any listed
course In a previous reporting cycle.
The Division will accept certificates for approved courses not on the list that were not
previously submitted for CE credit. When submitting continuing education to the Division,
please include the certificates totaling the 30 hours that you want applied to your current
deadline.
By law, CE providers have 15 days to complete the Course Rosters Entry. If more than 15
days have passed since taking your CE course, contact the provider directly. Only the
Provider may post the roster.
Distance Education Courses are assigned a generic date of either 1/1 or 12/31-
Please be aware that the Sales or Broker lO-Hour Post-Licensure Courses CANNOT be used
to fulfill ANY OF YOUR THREE-YEAR Continuing Education Requirements. Proof of attendance
of the post-licensure course must be submitted to the division within 12 months of initial
licensure to avoid suspension.
A license status of revoked does not necessarily mean that the license
was revoked due to disciplinary action. Please call the Division for further
details if needed.
bookuD pelaiI View
Name and Address
Name and Address
Name DBA MallAddress PublicAddress
Lake Erie Boutique Realty, Inc. Port Clinton, OH 43452-2666 Ottawa Port Clinton, OH 43452-2666 Ottawa
Ucense Information
License Information
xUSPAP Due pertains to Appraiser licenses only.
db' ""Post Licensure Due and Post Licensure Received pertains to Rea Estate sales an IOKC' licenses only.
Ucense First
Last
Effective Expiration CE USPAP
Post
Post
Ucense Ucense Status Ucensure Ucensure
Type Issuance
Issued
Date Date Due DUE
Due Received
REC. 2012000720 Real 03/27/2012 03/27/2012 03/27/2012 06/30/2014 ACTIVE
Estate
Company
tity(s) Supervised
Ucense Number Contact Name Other Name Effective Date Expiration Date
SAL,2012000435 Sherry Roberts 03/13/2013 03/12/2015
Supervisee Information
En
pervised Bv
Employer File Employer Employer Employer Doing Business Effective Expiration
Number Status Name As Date Date
BRK.2012000432 ACTIVE Alice H 08/25/2012 08/24/2015
Randolph
Supervisor Information
Su
Generated on: 10/16/201311:30:06 AM
1 of 1 10/1612013 3:30 PM
EXHIBIT K
www.lakeerieboutiguerealty.com
EXHIBIT L
EXHIBIT M
SHERRY ROBERTS
Sherry Roberts has experience in personnel services and operations. She is our webmaster
and oversees the staffing. management and information functions. She spends her winters !D..
Miami Beach where she Is a Realtor.
Content cOpyright 20102013.lslandHelpers.com. All rights reserved.
EXHIBIT N
ORDINANCE NO. 2004-3451
AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING
CHAPTER 62 OF THE MlAMI BEACH CITY CODE, ENTITLED
"HUMAN RELATIONS", BY ADDING AN ARTICLE IV THERETO
ENTITLED "REGISTERED DOMESTIC PARTNERSHIPS" WHICH
PROVIDES FOR REGISTERED DOMESTIC PARTNERSHIPS AND
SETS FORTH THE RIGHTS AND LEGAL EFFECTS OF SUCH
PARTNERSHIPS; PROVIDING FOR REPEALER, SEVERABILITY,
CODIFICATION, AND AN EFFECfIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, it is in the best interest of the City to be responsible to the changing
needs of society and to treat all persons fairly and equitably; and
WHEREAS, the City recognizes that long-term committed relationships foster
economic stability and emotional and psychological bonds; and
WHEREAS, the City has adopted a human rights ordinance and seeks to comply with
the full spirit of it; and
WHEREAS, the City, independent of the rights and benefits provided by Article In
of Chapter 62 for City employees, wishes to afford persons the ability to become a
Registered Domestic Partner with certain legal rights.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, FLORIDA:
SECTION 1. That Chapter 62 of the Miami Beach City Code is hereby amended by adding
an Article IV thereto, as follows:
ARTICLE IV. REGISTERED DOMESTIC PARTNERSHIPS
Sec. 62-130. DefinitioDs.
"Committed relationship" means a family relationship. intended to be of indefinite duration.
between two individuals characterized. by mutual caring and the sharing of a mutual
residence.
"Mutual residence" means that the Registered Domestic Partners share the same place to live.
It is not necessary that the legal right to possess the place of residence be in both of their
names. Two peo.ple may share a mutual residence even if one or both have additional places
to live. Registered Domestic Partners do not cease to share a mutual residence if one leaves
the shared place but intends to return.
"Declaration of Registered Domestic Partnership" means the document that is filed with the
City Clerk's office according to the procedures established in section 62-131 !
A "dependent" is a person who resides within the househQld of a Registered Domestic
Partnership and is:
1. a biological. adopted. or foster child of a Registered Domestic Partner; or
2. a dependent as defined under IRS regulations: or
3. a ward of a Registered Domestic Partner as detennined in a guardianship
or other legal proceeding.
'Registered Domestic Partnership" means committed relationship between two persons who
consider themselves to be a member of each others immediate family and have registered
their partnership in accordance with section 62-131.
Sec. 62-131. Registration. amendment. terminatioD and administration procedures.
(a) Registration.
(1) Declaration of Registered Domestic Partnership. A declaration of Registered
Domestic Partnership shall be filed with the City Clerk's office and shall contain the
names and addresses of the applicants who shall swear or affirm under penalty of
perjury that each partner:
a. Is at least 18 years old and competent to contract;
h, Is not married to Of a member of another Registered Domestic Partnership or
civil union with anyone other than the co-p!)plicant:
c. Agrees to share the common necessities of life and to be remonsible for each
other's welfare:
d. Shares his or her primaIy residence with the other:
e. Considers himself or herself to be a member of the immediate family of the
other partner; and
2
,
f. Agrees to immediately notify the City Clerk's office. in writing. of any change
in the status of the Registered Domestic Partnership.
g. Agrees to mutually support the other by contributing in some fashion. not
necessarily equally. to maintain and support the Registered Domestic
Partnership.
(2) Each partner agrees to immediately notify the City Clerk's office, in writing.
ifthe terms of the Registered Domestic Partnership are no longer applicable or one of
the domestic partners wishes to tenninate the domestic partnership.
(b) Amendment
A Registered Domestic Partner may amend a Registered Domestic Partnership
previously filed with the City Clerk to show a change in his or her household address
or to add or delete demmdents. Amendments shall be signed by both members ofthe
Registered Domestic Partnership under penalty of perjury.
(e) Tennination.
(1) Termination statement. A Registered Domestic Partner may terminate the
Registered Domestic Partnership by filing a tennination statement with the City
Clerk's office. The person filing the termination statement shall swear or affinn under
penalty ofpeIjmy that:
a. The Registered Domestic Partnership is to be tenninated: and
b. If the termination statement is not signed by both Registered Domestic
Partners.. a copy of the termination statement shall be served. by certified or
registered mail. on the other Registered Domestic Partner. and proof of
service shall be filed with the City Clerk's office.
(2) Effectiye date. The termination shall become effective on the date of filing of
the tennination statement signed by both Registered Domestic Partners or if the
termination statement is not signed by both parties. on the date proof of service is
filed with the City Clerk's office pursuant to subsection (c)(l)b.. above.
(3) Automatic termination. A Registered Domestic Partnership shall
automatically terminate in the event that one of the Domestic Partners dies. marries.
or enters into a civil union with someone other than his or her Registered Domestic
Partner.
(d) Administration.
en Founs. The City Clerk's office shall provide forms for the establishment.
amendment. and termination ofRegistered Domestic Partnerships.
(2) Certificate of Registered Domestic Partnership. The City Clerk's office shall
issue to the Registered Domestic Partners acertificate of Registered Domestic
Partnership no later than ten business days after the declaration of Registered
Domestic Partnership is filed.
(3) Maintain records. The City Clerk's office shall maintain copies of the
declaration of Registered Domestic Partnerships. any and all amendments thereto.
certificates of Registered Domestic Partnership. and termination statements filed by
Registered Domestic Partners.
3
(4) Fees. The fee for registering the declaration of Registered Domestic
Partnership shall be $50.00. which shall cover all costs of registration. The fee for
amending or tenninating the declaration of Registered Domestic Partnership shall be
$25.00 which shall cover all costs of amendment or termination of the Registered
Domestic Partnership.
Sec. 62-132. Rights and Legal Effect or Registered Domestic Partnenhip
To the extent not superseded by federal, state, or county law or ordinance. Registered
Domestic Partners shall have the following rights:
Cal Health care facility visitation.
The tenn "health care facilitv" includes. but is not limited to. hospitals. convalescent
facilities. clinics. doctor's offices. mental health care facilities. and other short and
long teon facilities located within. or under the jurisdiction of. the City ofMiami Beach. All
health care facilities operating within the City of Miami Beach shall allow a Registered
Domestic Partner the same visitation rights as a spouse (or Parent if the patient is a
de.oendent of the Registered Domestic Partnership) of the patient. A of a
Registered Domestic Partner shall have the same visitation rights as a patient's child.
(b) Correctional facility visitation rights.
The tenn Hcorrectional facility" includes. but is not limited to. holding cells. jails, and
juvenile correction centers of any kind. located within or under the jurisdiction of the City of
Miami Beach. A Registered Domestic Partner shall have the same visitation rights at all
correctional facilities operating within the City of Miami Beach as a spouse (or parent. if the
person in custody is a dependent of the Registered Domestic PBrtnership) of a person in
custody. A dependent shall have the same visitation rights afforded to the child of a person
in custody,
(c) Health care decisions.
This section pertains to decisions concerning both physical and mental health. If a patient
lacks the capacity to make a health care decision. the patient's Registered Domestic Partner
shall have the same authority as a spouse to make a health care decision for the inc81Jacitated
party. If the patient is a de,pcndent of the Registered Domestic Partnership. the Registered
Domestic Partneg shall have the same authority to make health care decisions as a parent:
however. if a biological parent of a minor dependent whose parental rights have not been
tenninated. is available. willing. and competent to make the health care decision the
biological parents' authority to make health care decisions on behalf of the minor shall
supersede that ofaRegistered Domestic Partner who is not the biological parent ofthe minor
de.oendent,
(d) Participation in Education.
A Registered Domestic Partner shall have the same rights to participate in the education of a
dqlendent of the Registered Domestic Partnership as a Parent to participate in the education
of their child. in all educational facilities located within or under the jurisdiction of the City
4
of Miami Beach. This includes the right of a Registered Domestic Partner to participate in
the home schooling of a dependent in accordance with Florida law.
(e) FunerallBurial decisions.
Following the death of a Registered Domestic Partner. the surviving partner shall have the
same rights to make decisions with regard to funeralJburia) decisions and diPOsition of the
decedent's body as a surviving spouse.
(n Notification of family members.
In any situation providing for mandatory or pennissible notification of family members,
including but not limited to notification of family members in an emergency. or when
permission is granted to inmates to contact family members. "notification of family" shall
include Registered Domestic Partners.
(g) Preneed guardian designation.
Any person who is registered as a Registered Domestic Partner PUIBuant to this Chapter shall
have the same right as any other individual to be designated as a preneed guardian pursuant
to section 744.3045. Florida Statutes, and to serve in such capacity in the event of his or her
declarant Registered Domestic Partner's incapacity. A Registered Domestic Partner shall not
be denied or otherwise be defeated in serving the plenary guardian of his or her Registered
Domestic Partner or the partner's property. under the provisions of Chapter 744. Florida
Statutes. to the extent that the incapacitated partner has not executed a valid preneed guardian
designation. based solely upon his or her status as the domestic partner of the incapacitated
partner.
Sec. 62-133. Limited effect.
(a) Nothing in this article shall be inter,preted to alter. affect. or contravene county, state
or federal law.
(b) Nothing in this article shall be construed as recognizing or treating a Registered
Domestic Partnership as a maniage.
(c) All rights. privileges. and benefits extended to Registered Domestic Partnerships
registered pursuant to this Cltapter shall also be extended to all persons legally partnered in
another jurisdiction.
liD Nsthiltg iIt this Chapter "'till +e eMfflet! If tI'fI* Bthlitit!l!tIl ",. liBlJilitie:f
greater thall titHe tII"sstlt elsWlI11t1er Is" twHI eretlle IISf' BriwIte HIISeI S(lIetitJ",
Cd} A Registered Domestic Partner mav enforce the "ghu under Sec. 61-132 bv min, a
private 'action agaiflSt II person or en,i" in any court of competent jurisdiction fOr
declaratory relief injunctive relief. or both.
Bolded/ltaliciz.ed language reflects llInendments mtUle betweenfirst and second reading.
5
(e) This Article is inde;pendent of Article ill of Chapter 62 and does not affect any rights
or benefits of City employees.
SECTION 2. REPEALER.
All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are hereby repealed.
SECTION 3. SEVERABILITY.
If any subsection, clause or provision ofthis Ordinance is held invalid, the remainder
shall not be affected by such invalidity.
SECTION 4. CODIFICATION.
It is the intention of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of Miami and it is
hereby ordained that the provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made a part of the
Code of the City of Miami Beach, Florida. The sections of this ordinance may be
renwnbered or relettered to accomplish such intention, and the word "ordinance" may be
changed to "sectionI', "article," or other appropriate word.
SECTION 5. EFFECTIVE DATE.
lbis Ordinance shall take effect on the day of Augus t
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 28th day of--=.:=r'--\--'
ATTEST:
6
,2004.
APPROVED ItS10
FORM&lANGUAGE
& FOR EXECUTION
EXHIBIT 0

EXHIBIT P
hltp:ff"otcrlookup.SOs.Slalc.oh.us"'olerlookup.aspx'?hUp:/lwww.sos.sla...
Voter ProfIle Page
Name:
Address:
Polling Location:
Precinct:
US Congressional District:
Senate District:
State Rep. District:
ALlCE H RANDOLPH
5465 E CONSTITUTION BLVD
MARBLEHEAD OH 43440
Grace Baptist Church
4650 E Port Clinton Eastern Rd
Port Clinton OH 43452
(Get Directions)
031 DANBURY 5
9
2
89
lofl
1III /"/ WI rhi, 1'1I}!C i.\ rlmel wnl /0 ,hI' Ohm Scac!m:r O{S!CI!l'\ 0llin' fmnl thl' lo( ell nlllnrr /till/HI.. of
d .. .'(,UI .. JI lILll tI/lIHI' I jllInl o{,'letJioll.\ lUI.' Iw!ith'J nllIil of II pr"u"lu'! dlllng", 111' i(rlJu l",n'll (Jlll'.,titJll "hem(
,ml o( flu'lfll J ' wi m II(,I''',l'le".\t' ccmtllct youI' ('ount\' /tOlll'cl oll'lt'ction\ ,Ur('err,.. Click IIt'l"(' lor (11/ Ohio count\
how'" pf ctN"rifJl/\' diNe'lIll'I'.
Crmglt' A/"l'S is till intt'l'Ilt,/-lllI.\t',1 nlllpl'mg I('n'h,'. rill' Ohio S"('I"('(IWY of S!lI(I'" Ollin' mllke.1 II(} gUl/rlllllt'(' 1I.\ III tilL'
tln'ure,,'" "trh.' dlredirJII.\ 1'1'tll'idl'd hI' Gemgh-
10/912013 2:41 PM
EXHIBIT Q
Direclors http://weslharborboawminiwn.comDircctors. hIm)
West Harbor Boataminiums
HOMEfWiE NElGKIIOIUolOOO NEWSI EVEHTS RESOURCES FORUM REPORlS DfRClORS CONTACT us
lor:!
DIRECTORS
WEST HARBOR LANDING BOATAMINlUM DIRECTORS



Carolyn AdaITS
419-235-5961
carottnada[!'@w!!sthartxllbolllamnh.mcom
I ]
Mary AmBehlke
.19-734-9561
ltqJl)'itonbehllte@weslhalbofboalsailjllD.com
10/912013 2:44 PM
EXHIBIT R
(51) Alice Randolph hltps:/lwww.facebook.comlsherr).I.oberlS.rniami beach?fref=ts&re f=br_t.f
Alice Randolph
2
41 _
Home 5 Richard
Sponsored
GROW YOU

))..
Alice Randolph
Photos 61

qu1ckbooksor.
Palm Beach
palmbeachpo

Message Give Gift

More
Friends
Friends 30 MLtuaI
Photo Post
About Timellne
About
OWner and Psychologist at Psychological
Transitions
Past: Ohio Ps-;chologlcal Assodatlon
studied Counseling Psychology at West Virginia
UnivenJity
Past: Nova Southeastern Uriverslty and Villa Maria
Lives in Marblehead, Ohio
Write something..
Alice Randolph
OCtober 5 via lOS
A great day at ORGULLO
I Recent
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
Born
In a relationship with Sheny Kaplan Roberts
Chat (Off)
J of6 10/9/2013 2:43 PM
EXHIBIT 5
EXHIBIT T
Print Page 1 of 1
RNT RESIDENTIAL RENTAL Southeast Florida MLS
ML: M1326552 Be: PWRE01 1PUig Werner Real Estate Svcs.
AD: 6801 COLLINS AVE U#: 1'111
CT: DADE F#:
MC: 0 TN: 0 SE: 0 SD: 0 PN: 0
LG:
AREA:
CITY:
ZIP:
MAP:
32
MIAMIBCH RENT:t $3,600
33141
ST: Fl IN11.VLS: 1
STATUS;
PER:
GEOAR:
FURN:F ZN:
PS
M
RESIDENT
MN:
FURN ANNUAL RENT:
UNFU ANNUAL RENT:
JAN: FEB:
JIll' AUG
$3,600
MAR:
SEP:
DV: Canyon Ranch
FURN SEA RENT: $4,500
UNFU SEA RENT:
APR: MAY:
OCT: NOV:
SN;canyon Ranch
FURN OFF RENT: $4,000
UNFU OFF RENT:
JUN: #1: 11
DEC:
STYLE: R60
#STOR: 0 FL: 14 TYPE: SINGLE
DATE AVL: 04/01/13 SAtE: N
o HBTH:
BAL&P:
ES:
MS:
HS:
FBlli: BED; 1
FACE: NE
DINE:
OCEAN
EFF: CONV:
WF:
PARKING RESTRICT:
LOTOS:
VIEW:
DESGN:
WNDW: BLINDS
ROOF:
SF/FF:O
YR:
CPT: 0
ASSIGNED
870
11 A'IT
VALET
LA:
GARAG:
PARK:
LOT:
RESTR:
WATRFR: Y1OCNFRONT
WTRAC: BEACHACC
CONST:
FLOOR: OTHER
ROOMS:
POOL: Y1HEATED HOnuB Pl: 50X95 SPA: Y PElS: N1 RES
REM:Llght, bright one bedroom Pled-a-terre with full access to the fabulous Canyon Ranch Living. Top of the line kitchen with Sub-Zero, Miele appliances. Master
bath wIth soak tub and glass enclosure shower. Gorgeous beach vIews from every room. Full membership to all spa activities, classes, servIces, well ness
lectures, medical evaluations and healthy hfesly1e restaurants. Gorgeous beach front WIth access to boardwalk. Also available seasonally min 6 months @

DIR:
BRK-REM:Yearly or seasonal rental WIth spa membershIp. Available MarcM,2013. seasonal $4000 month. Perfect way to enJoy Miami and be fit and healthyl
INTER:
SECUR:
EQUIP:
BAR CLUBHSE COMPOOL ELEVATOR EXERCISRM MAINTAND
HOPA: N
#LSE YR: 0
APPFEE: $150
ADDL$:
MOVE IN$: $10,800
RENEWABLE: Y
1STMO lASTMO SECDEP
ASSOCFE CABLETV HOTWTR POOLMNT WTR/5WR
WTR:
SWR:
EXTER:
AMENS: ACTVRM
MISC:
MIN LS #DAY:
APPRV:
LSE TERMS:
RENTAL DEP INCL:
RENTAL PMT INCl:
HEAT:
COOL:
LPID: 0509667/ Judith Werner APH: 305-720-6862 OPH: 305-8&l-(1060
2PID: 2AG: FAX: 305-864-0068
LTY: ER ON: ON#: 2PH: 3057206862
URL: BRD: A
EMAILA: jwerner@pujgwerner.com WD:
COMM: R COBA: 5.0% COTB: 5.0% CONR: VAR: Y JA: lOX: Y
OCCUP: VACANT SHOW: CALL-LA OK ADV: N LD: XD:
PREV STATUS: A STATUS CHNG: 04/10/13 Ll:
PREV$: $3,200 PRICE CHNG: 02/26/13 ORIG$: $2,600 L2:
INET Y/ World famous Canyon Ranch Living Miami Beach-Spa included. Halfway between Bal Harbour Shops &So Beach restaurants; 15 min to
Intematlonal Airport.
VT: http://lnstatour.propertypanorama.coml,nstav1ewfmiafM1326552
OM: RP:
55:
RD:
51:
*(c) 2013 MIa..,. S88R - INFORMAnON IS 8l:UEVEP ACCURATl: BUT IS NOT WAAAANlBl'
CB: RPID:
10/16/13 9:39AM
EXHIBIT U
2013 FLORIPA PROFIT CORPORATION ANNUAL REPORT
DOCUMENT# P07000046831
Entity Name: SOUTH BEACH BOUTIQUE REALTY, INC.
Current Principal Place of Business:
407 LINCOLN ROAD
SUITE 2E
MIAMI BEACH, FL 33139
Current Mailing Address:
205 S.E. CATAWBA ROAD
SUITE A
PORT CLINTON, OH 43452 US
FEI Number: 35-2296171
Name and Address of Current Registered Agent:
ROBERTS, SHERRY
407 LINCOLN ROAD
SUITE 2E
MIAMI BEACH, FL 33139 US
FILED
Mar 24,2013
Secretary of State
Certificate of Status Desired: Yes
The above nal7l8d entity submits this statement for the purpose of changing its registered offICe or registered agent, or both, in the State of Florida.
SIGNATURE:
Electronic Signature of Registered Agent
Dale
Officer/Director Detail Detail :
Tille PS
Name ROBERTS. SHERRY
Address 407 LINCOLN ROAD SUITE 2E
City-5lale-Zip: MIAMI BEACH FL 33139
TiUe VT
Name RANDOLPH, ALICE H
Address 407 LINCOLN ROAD, SUITE 2E
City-State-Zip: MIAMI BEACH FL 33139
lnereby certify the' Ihe itlformtl/ioll indicBltHl on /his report or supplemental report is 111m end eCCUtlJJe and thaI my eIeI:IlDtIiC&iQnallJra shaUhave /he sams legel orrect BS If m8do under
DlIfh; that lemen otIicerO( director or /he corpomlion or the receIver or trustee ampowemd 10 execute this reporl as mquimdby Chapter 607. Ftoride Slelutes; Bnd /her myJ1Ilms eptXlBI$
ebow. CJ(' on an etlacllment with all oIher like empowemd.
SIGNATURE: SHERRY ROBERTS
Electronic Signature of Signing Officer/Director Delail
PRESIDENT
03/24/2013
Dale
EXHIBIT V
Related Information
Licensee
https: _cnt=3&Lic...
Print all related licenses.
Name:
Rank:
Primary Status:
SOUTH BEACH BOUTIQUE
REALTY INC
Real Estate Corporation
Current
License Number:
License Expiration
Date:
Original License Date:
1029230
03/31/2015
06/04/2007
3199459 Current, RIVERA, GLADYS
Active
Secondary Status: Active
Related License Information
. . Relation
N
Licenbse Status Related Party Relationship Effective Rank
urn er Type Date
3194686 Current, RANDOLPH, ALICE HARRINGTON Qualifying 05/05/2008 Real
Active Broker Estate
Broker
Employed By 07/24/2012 Real
Estate
Sales
Associate
Expiration
Date
03/31/2014
03/31/2015
1of 1
3194840 Current, ROBERTS, SHERRY
Active
Qualifying
Broker
02/13/2012 Real 09/30/2015
Estate
Broker
1011612013 5:04 PM