High Quality
Open the downloaded document, and select print from the file menu (PDF reader required).
11 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT2CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA34HONORABLE ANDREW J. WISTRICH, MAGISTRATE JUDGE PRESIDING56
UMG RECORDING, INC., )ET AL., )
7 )PLAINTIFF, )8 ) CASE NO. CV-07-6835-AHM(AJWX)VS. )9 )
DIVX, INC., ET AL., ) (10:04 A.M.)
10 )DEFENDANTS. )11_________________________)1213DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES14TO DISCOVERY FROM UMG15 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA16 DECEMBER 8, 2008171819
COURT DEPUTY/RECORDER:YSELA BENAVIDES
20
TRANSCRIBED BY:HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS& TRANSCRIPTION INC.
21
1450 W. COLORADO BOULEVARD
SUITE 100
22
PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 91105
(626) 792-7250
232425
PROCEEDINGS RECORDED BY ELECTRONIC SOUND RECORDING;
TRANSCRIPT PRODUCED BY TRANSCRIPTION SERVICE.
HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS & TRANSCRIPTION, INC.Court Reporting (626)792-6777 Transcription (626)792-7250
Case 2:07-cv-06835-AHM-AJW Document 96 Filed 12/29/2008 Page 1 of 37
21APPEARANCES:2ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANT:3LAW OFFICES OF WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH & ROSATIBY: COLLEEN BAL, ATTORNEY AT LAW4 650 PAGE MILL ROADPALO ALTO, CA 94304-1050567
ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF:
8LAW OFFICES OF ARNOLD & PORTER LLP
BY: SEAN O. MORRIS, ATTORNEY AT LAW
9 RYAN M. NISHIMOTO, ATTORNEY AT LAW
777 SOUTH FIGUEROA STREET, 44TH FLOOR
10
LOS ANGELES, CA 90017-5844
111213141516171819202122232425HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS & TRANSCRIPTION, INC.Court Reporting (626)792-6777 Transcription (626)792-7250
Case 2:07-cv-06835-AHM-AJW Document 96 Filed 12/29/2008 Page 2 of 37
31LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA, MONDAY, DECEMBER 8, 200823THE CLERK: CALLING CV076835AHM(AJWX). UMG4RECORDINGS, INCORPORATED, ET AL., VERSUS DIVX,5INCORPORATED. COUNSEL, PLEASE MAKE YOUR APPEARANCES.6MR. MORRIS: GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. SEAN7MORRIS ON BEHALF OF UMG.8THE COURT: MM-HMM.9MR. NISHIMOTO: GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR.10RYAN NISHIMOTO ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFFS UMG.11MS. BAL: GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. COLLEEN12BAL ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT, DIVX, INC.13THE COURT: GOOD MORNING. ALL RIGHT. I'M14INCLINED TO GRANT THIS AS WELL BECAUSE I THINK THE15PRESUMPTION HAS TO BE REBUTTABLE SOMEHOW, AND I DON'T16KNOW HOW IT COULD POSSIBLY BE REBUTTED IF SOME17INFORMATION WEREN'T REQUIRED TO BE TURNED OVER.18YOU KNOW, I AM OPEN TO PERSUASION ON THE ISSUE19OF, CAN THIS BE LIMITED IN SOME WAY? I THINK IN THE20MYSPACE CASE I LIMITED COMMUNICATIONS TO CHALLENGES TO21OWNERSHIP BY AN ARTIST, BY SOMEONE ELSE THAT ROSE TO A22LEVEL WHERE A LAWYER BECAME INVOLVED EITHER INSIDE OR23OUTSIDE OF UMG. SO THAT -- THAT'S A LIMITATION I WOULD24BE INCLINED TO IMPOSE IN THIS INSTANCE, AND -- AND MAYBE25SOME OTHERS ARE APPROPRIATE.HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS & TRANSCRIPTION, INC.Court Reporting (626)792-6777 Transcription (626)792-7250
Case 2:07-cv-06835-AHM-AJW Document 96 Filed 12/29/2008 Page 3 of 37
Add a Comment