11UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT2CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA34HONORABLE ANDREW J. WISTRICH, U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE5PRESIDING67

UMG RECORDINGS, INC., )

et al., )8 )Plaintiffs, )9 ) CASE NO. CV 07-6835-AHM(AJWx)VS. )10 )

DIVX, INC., et al., ) (10:22 A.M.)

11 )Defendants. )12_________________________)1314DIVX'S MOTION TO COMPEL THE PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS AND15PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO DISCOVERY FROM16DIVX, INC.17LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA18JANUARY 26, 20091920COURT DEPUTY/RECORDER:YSELA BENAVIDES21

TRANSCRIBED BY:HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS& TRANSCRIPTION INC.

1450 W. COLORADO BOULEVARD

SUITE 100

PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 91105

(626) 792-7250

2425PROCEEDINGS RECORDED BY ELECTRONIC SOUND RECORDING;

TRANSCRIPT PRODUCED BY TRANSCRIPTION SERVICE.

HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS & TRANSCRIPTION, INC.Court Reporting (626) 792-6777 Transcription (626) 792-7250

Case 2:07-cv-06835-AHM-AJW Document 133 Filed 02/09/2009 Page 1 of 64

21APPEARANCES:2ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF UMG RECORDINGS, INC.:3ARNOLD AND PORTER LLP

BY: SEAN O. MORRIS, ATTORNEY AT LAW

4 - AND -RONALD L. JOHNSTON, ATTORNEY AT LAW5 - AND -RYAN M. NISHIMOTO, ATTORNEY AT LAW6777 SOUTH FIGUEROA STREET, 44TH FLOORLOS ANGELES, CA 90017789ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT DIVX, INC.:10 WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH & ROSATIBY: COLLEEN BAL, ATTORNEY AT LAW11650 PAGE MILL ROADPALO ALTO, CA 943041213141516171819202122232425HUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS & TRANSCRIPTION, INC.Court Reporting (626) 792-6777 Transcription (626) 792-7250

Case 2:07-cv-06835-AHM-AJW Document 133 Filed 02/09/2009 Page 2 of 64

31LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA, MONDAY, JANUARY 26, 20092-oOo-3THE CLERK: CALLING CV 07-6835-AHM(AJWx), UMG4RECORDINGS, INC., ET AL. V. DIVX, INC. COUNSEL PLEASE MAKE5YOUR APPEARANCES FOR THE RECORD.6MR. MORRIS: GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. SEAN7MORRIS FROM ARNOLD AND PORTER, AND WITH ME IS RONALD8JOHNSTON AND RYAN NISHIMOTO, ON BEHALF OF UMG.9THE COURT: OKAY.10MS. BAL: GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. COLLEEN BAL11FROM WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH AND ROSATI ON BEHALF OF THE12DEFENDANT DIVX, INC.13THE COURT: OKAY. THE FIRST THING I WANT TO TAKE14UP IS THE PROTECTIVE ORDER ISSUE ABOUT PARAGRAPH 20, AND15HERE'S WHAT I'D LIKE YOU TO EMBODY IN THE ORDER. SO I TAKE16IT THE WAY THIS IS SUPPOSED TO WORK IS WHEN PRIVILEGED17DOCUMENTS ARE DETERMINED TO BE INADVERTENTLY PRODUCED,18NOTICE WILL BE GIVEN AND THEN THE RECEIVING PARTY WILL HAVE19FIVE DAYS TO RETURN OR DESTROY. AND I THINK IT'S -- IT IS20CONTEMPLATED THAT KEEPING A COPY SEQUESTERED FOR PURPOSES OF21LITIGATING WHETHER THE PRIVILEGE HAS BEEN WAIVED IS22CONTEMPLATED BY THE RULE, BUT I WANT TO PUT A TIME LIMIT ON23THAT. SO WHAT I WILL SAY IS THAT TACKED ON TO THE END OF24THAT FIVE-DAY PERIOD IS A PERIOD OF 11 DAYS DURING WHICH THE25RECEIVING PARTY MUST FILE A MOTION SEEKING A DETERMINATIONHUNTINGTON COURT REPORTERS & TRANSCRIPTION, INC.Court Reporting (626) 792-6777 Transcription (626) 792-7250