AQ78 694 96 The mmgraton Judge speccally noted the deh of documenty evdnc of th resodent's tes to the Unted States J at 1, th ac of afdavts om famy or ends (J at 12-13, he lack of proof t
at he mantaned any renta unts or had any propry oneshp n the Unted Stats .J a � 1, 12. h hs moton, the respondent· has submed evdence of hs nted tates busness tes Moton, Exhs. B C6), adavts om hs Untd States ctzen amly membrs (Moto, Exh.
2, documntato of th
accout h mantand n th ntd States (Exh A12, as w as vdence he says dcates that, durng h years n quston, he pad rnt to mant a resence here Moton, Exh A2 ad ownd, rgstred and pd xes on h car whch h kpt n the Unted States (Moton, Exh. A, 5-8 The resondet hs aso submd medca evdece regardng hs ther's nss and deah whch he sad caued hm to rman n Chna n 2 as wl as evdence of hs on medcal probem hat h sad deayd hs r n 21 (Moto, Exhs D d E Athough the vdence proerd by the rspondnt was prevousy valabe, he assers a cam of nectve sstce of counse aganst hs er aoey r fang to advs he respodnt to produc such evdence Moton, at 142 He also cams hat hs aoey ed to advse hm of the consequences o a rmoval order, namely t yar ba om retng to he Unted tates, ad dd not gve hm the oton of whdrang or renouncng s L staus (Moton, at 23 Tr at 1-8) The respondent has comled th the requrments set rh n n
Mate of Loada
9 &N Dec. 637 BA 1988, r nectve assstance of counse cams Moton, Exh , 25 W w remand r the mmgraton Judge to evauate th neectve assstace cam ad to detern whether th respondent h estabshed the rqust prudce
627 .3d 36, 373
Cr. 21 prjudce mens that the outcome of h proceedng may hav ben aected by th alleged volaton).
Accordngy, th owng ordrs shal be enterd RDE e respondnts moton to rmd s granted TE ORDE: Th record w be remandd to the mmgaton Judge r her rocdngs consstnt h te regong onon nd r th ntry of a new decson
Gv our dsosto o th moton, we need not adjudcate th respondnt's appa at ts tme 2
Cite as: Xingchen Ye, A078 694 496 (BIA Nov. 8, 2013)