Decsio f te Board o ma Appeals . Executive Oce r Imgraon Reew Flls Chch; Vig
le A03 944 0 -Ne York, NY ate
N J 2013
In re GBEL OCTVIO ARELLN aka Garieo rellan ak.a Gabr relan REMOVAL PROCEEINGS APPEAL ON BEHA OF SPONDENT Ge H. Bank, Esqure CHRGE: Notce Sec 212(a )(2)(A)()(I), I& N Act [8 .S.C § 182(a )(2)()()()] Crme involvng oral tide Se 2(a )(2)(A)((I), I& N Act 8 S.C §
82(a )(2)()()(I) Contoled subsance voaton Lodged: Sec 212(a )()(C)(i), I& N Act 8 SC § 182(a )(6)(C)(i) rad or ll msrepresentaton of a atea ct The respodent has apealed om the Immaton Jdge's erry 26, 203, decson ordering the espondent removed to Per The Dement of Homeand Secrty (DHS) dd ot epy to the espondent's contetons on apea The espondents apeal is ited o haengng the mmiatio Jdges ndings th respec to he lodged charge of aud o wll msreesenaton of a material fact de secton 22(a )(6)(C)(i) of e Immaton and Natonaty Act, 8 SC. § 1182(a )()(C)().
We reve e ndgs of t, ncluding he Igraton dge's deteination of redbty, nder a "clery erroneous sdd 8 CR § 1003(d)(3)(i) We evie al other isses, dng whether he artes have met the elev bden of proof, and sses of discreton, ude a de novo standd 8 C.R 100.(d)();
24 I& N Dec 93 (I 2008) We aee wth the responent hat e HS did not meet is urden o proof conceg the lodged chge st, there as inscent evdence sstantating that chage, as he douments marked r denticato as Exht 3 -d proedy oered to cooborate the ad charge were no amed o evece eo, we are ersae ta te H esase at e esodent's re o dsose hs Novebe 5, 9 convicon on is mmgrt vsa d alen registraton appliaton amoted to ad Fraud reqies an ntentonal, deberate, d vot msepesetaton t may not be based on a mistake, mee negigece, or vertene.
23 3d 10, 117 (2d C. 2008) s the respondent observes, he
Ahough n e aaent o e notice of appea he espondent ia chaenge he chge hat he was covcted o a rme involving mora ttde uder seion (a )()()()(I) of the At, he naroed he sses n hs apelate ref o adress the aud charge exsvey
Cite as: Gabriel Octavio Arellan, A043 944 603 (BIA Nov. 22, 2013)