The old “saw” about thecamel being a horse designed by acommittee is a repudiation of thedemocraticprocess.PresidentObama hascalled for abi-partisanapproach to the criti-cal issuesconfronting our nation.This necessitates consulting with the opposition in the process of formulating legislation. There areof course negative consequences;you do not attain all the elementsyou think essential to the nation’swell being. But you do unite all but the lunatic fringe of the society be-hind the process.There was a time, our tradi- tion teaches, when individuals(designated prophets) could clearlydiscern the teaching of God. Peo-ple at that time were well advised to heed the prophet’s admonition.But prophecy ceased with Malachi.To determine the word of God thereafter, rabbis met in counciland hammered out their differ-ences. One group thought the me-zuzah should be vertical on thedoor post, the other, horizontal.Their compromise was the slanting position with which we are familiar.The Bible, which most of us believeis the word of God, was similarly acompromise document. The moreOrthodox insisted on including thebooks of the Pentateuch which, inaddition to eternal moral standards,demand a plethora of minute in-scrutable ritual obligations. The“liberals” introduced highly skepti-cal works like Job and Ecclesiastes,plus the Book of Ruth, which de-picts a non-Jewish woman as theancestress of both King David and the messiah.Rabbi Jay Brickman
As the month of Sivan comes in, wewelcome it with the singing of
torah Sivanlanu Moshe
– in Sivan Moses brought us the torah from the top of Sinai. While somechoose to understand ‘torah’ in this contextas the “Ten Commandments,” others under-stand ‘Torah’ to mean the firstfive books of the bible, whileothers believe ‘torah’ is thecollected wisdom of our peoplefrom Sinai until tomorrow…Regardless of how you choose to understand it, as Shavuotcomes it is certainly the “time of the giving of our torah” and wehave much to celebrate.In the wintertime,when we are in the midst of thestory of the miracles our peopleexperienced on the shores of the sea, and the subsequent gift of the Law amidst clapsof thunder on Mount Sinai, we may begin toenter the discussion of what was really givenat Sinai – what is Torah, or torah to each of us?On Shavuot, we read the famous“Ten Commandments” in our synagogues –a list, not really of the “big ten,” but perhapsa representative sampling of what the wis-dom and law of the torah contains. In thesecommandments we read about how to re-gard God and how to regard one another –what we should and should not do. Whilewe may never be able to remove the imageof Charlton Heston from our minds, we muststop at Shavuot to ask ourselves – whatdoes this mean,
z’man matan torateinu
– the season of our receiving of our torah?Perhaps there is something to be learnedfrom the cantillation of the
asseret dibrot
– the ten commandments.
Page 3
May 2009
In studying the ten command-ments, you will see two sets of trope, or can- tillation marks instructing in how the pas-sage is to be read in synagogue. These setsof markings are referred to as
ta’amei ha-elyon
, the upper trope, and
ta’amei hatach-ton
, the lower trope. In syna-gogue (or any public reading venue), we read the upper trope.The upper trope divides eachcommandment (no matter itslength) into one distinct unit, orsentence. For study, however,we read from the lower trope. In the lower trope, the
p’sukim
, orsentences, are divided into aver-age length.I cannot help at this time of year, as we begin to pre-pare for Shavuot, to wonder if the double
ta’amim
, trope marks, are teaching us asmall lesson. Perhaps we read publicly insuccinct and specific sentences to make agrand statement to elicit the feelings of di-rection and guidance our ancestors musthave experienced at Sinai. And then, whenwe are studying alone or with friends, we relyon our innate ability to make meaning andsense from the text – for our feelings now, in this present time of the giving of the Torah, to shape our understanding of the sen- tences. And for our own knowledge to de-fine for ourselves, year after year, what is torah.Best wishes to you and your familyfor a
Chag Sameach
– a Shavuot of joy andgratitude.Cantor Rebecca Robins
Compromise
Cantor’s Notes Reflections
Save the date & your extra stuff!
Start saving your electronics, bikesand home goods for Sinai'sRummage Sale, which will take place July 26, 2009.For more information, contact Jennifer Moglowsky at jlmog@wi.rr.com.More details to follow.
Something Interesting About Those Commandments…
Add a Comment