• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
 
The street vending community scored a historicvictory on September 28th, when Supreme Court
Justice Carol Edmead overturned the City’s 2003
fine increase against vendors, finding the increase
“unreasonable, unfair, and clearly undemocratic”.
She reduced the fines, just days before many li-censes were about to expire, from a maximum of $1,000 to a maximum of $250, and ordered thecity not to deny licenses based on failure to paythe illegal fines. Vendors packed the courtroomand cheered as the judge delivered her verdict.The Street Vendor Project filed the lawsuit in
August, after learning that the city’s fourfold fine
increase was done without publishing it in theCity Record or holding a public hearing, whichare required by law.The stars of the hearing were the vendors,including the named plaintiffs, who all testified.Moussa Ousmane, a watch vendor downtown,testified about how the $1,000 fines were devas-tating his ability to support his wife and eightchildren. Antonia Delgado, who used to vend onLiberty Street, spoke of how the fear of fines waskeeping her from working. Hot dog vendor Mo-hammed Ali spoke of how he received a $1,000fine for having his license in his pocket instead of around his neck.After so many years of losing, some vendors
were not sure we had won. Said Cheikh Cisse, “Ithought we’d never have the power to beat thecity like that.”
Within days of the dramatic victory, everyvendor with a $1,000 fine on his record had itreduced to $250. Lower fines were also reducedaccordingly; the total reduction has been esti-mated at $1 million.While bills were reduced, the city is refus-ing to send refunds to vendors who already paid.The matter is still in the courts. Hopefully, eve-ryone who paid their fines will get refunds soon.In the meantime, thanks to everyone forcoming to the courthouse. It was an unforgetta-ble experience, and a few eyes must have gotten
teary when the judge said that “what the city did
does not facilitate access to what is sold everyday and on every commercial as the American
dream. You can’t put it out there in the air andnot live behind it.” Truer words were never spo-
ken. Vendor power.
 VendorsFight$1,000Fines
VENDORNEWSLETTER
INSIDE:
• Profile: Cesar Abreu….2• Goods Recovered……2Legislative Reform ….2• Membership Info…….3• Planter Campaign...….3Central Park …..……...4
BoardofAdvisorsMustaphaCisseProkashDasGuptaMd.AnwarHussainMohammadEl-Madaawy SophiaLaskaris AngeloVegaMichaelWells JieanWeychu JanisColladoProjectOrganizer  JudiMukarhindaProjectDirector SeanBasinski VolunteersDavidChang MattFurshong SaraSluszkaMaxineSpencer  AnnaTkacheva
 
Street Vendor Project Fall 2004666 Broadway, 5th Floor (646) 602-5679New York, NY 10012 or (646) 602-5681
What Next? Fine Update
Despite the court victory, the battle over the$1,000 vending fines continues. On November18, the ECB held a hearing to gather publicinput on the whether $1,000 fines should stillbe imposed. More than 130 vendors filled theauditorium on Worth Street, and dozens of ven-dors spoke into the night about how the in-creased fines were unreasonable. As AmadouLam, a general vendor, reminded the panel,
“we don’t only have fines to pay; we have kids to feed.”
Not one person spoke in favor of raising thefines. The great turnout was covered by NY One, Channel 4, the Post, and the Daily News.After the hearing, the ECB voted to post-pone its decision until February, when it willhold another hearing on the matter. Please call to help prepare for this hearing and spread theword to other vendors. Despite our victory, wemust continue this fight.
 Judge Edmead “They seem pretty powerful today”
 
My name is Cesar, and I sellcellular accessories in Wash-ington Heights. I came to theUS in 1969, when I was 18and the political situation inthe Dominican Republicstarted to get worse. In mycountry, I was involved infarming. My father had hisown farm, and I often helpedhim with his business. At thesame time, I had developedan interest in political activ-ism.I enrolled at the NewYork Technical College toreceive a degree in Environ-mental Nursery, and I waslooking for a way to pay formy education. As a result Ibecame a cab driver. For
MemberProfile:CesarAbreu
Page2
is when I became a street ven-dor.I still remember my firstday as a vendor, three yearsago. I knew a Peruvian guywho sold elec-tric drills inthe neighbor-hood. Heseemed to bedoing ratherwell, so I de-cided to fol-low his exam-ple. I got twoboxes odrills, set up atable on thesidewalk, andwas waitingfor a first cus-thirteen years I drove aroundNew York, which allowed meto learn a lot about the city.After being a driver, Iworked at a tree nursery inLong Island forseven years.That job I par-ticularly enjoyed:I felt as if I wasgoing back to myroots, especiallysince I was onceagain doing whatmy father haddevoted himself to. However, at acertain point Irealized that Iwanted to havemore independence. Thattomer. Before I had anythingsold, police came over and ar-rested me for vending illegallyin the streets. After fourteenhours in Criminal Court andone day of community service,I was finally able to go bachome.I like being a vendor. Itgives me a certain freedom andindependence that other jobsfailed to provide me with. I canwork for as many hours as Iwant; my schedule is alwaysflexible. Most importantly, Ihave more time to spend withmy family, especially with mygranddaughter. I have been amember of the Project since the
 beginning, and I’m very proud
of what we are doing.
LegislativeReform:Update
Vendor Arrested at Wendy’s
Photo: PaulMargoli
When handbag vendorMohamend Ali ordered a spicy
chicken sandwich from Wendy’s
one afternoon in November, hedid not expect to be arrested forunlicensed vending and insultedwith racist slurs by two policeofficers. He expected to get achicken sandwich.He had just turned awayfrom the counter when he sawcourt, and Ali has filed a CCRBcomplaint against the officers. Inthe meantime, with help fromSVP, and after three days of run-ning from precinct to precinct(and being told he could nothave it back), Ali and his mer-chandise were happily reunitedoutside the police warehouse in
Queens. “Vendor power,” said
Mohamend Ali.through the window the officersrummaging through his merchan-dise, which he had left neatly bun-dled on the sidewalk outside. WhenAli went to investigate, the policearrested him, seized his goods, andused racist (to say the least) lan-guage, telling him he looked like a
monkey. “They don’t have the rightto say that,” says Ali, correctly.
The charges were dismissed at
 Alirecovers his handbagsFrom one of oursponsors:
Despite a busy 2004, theSVP continues to seek thelegal reforms that are neces-sary to improve the lives of all street vendors.Our proposal, recentlyintroduced as the Street Ven-dor Opportunity Bill, will dofour things to benefit all seg-ments of the vending com-munity.First, it will remove thelicensing cap to give foodand general vendors an op-portunity to work legally.Vendors want licenses, andrather than arresting vendorslike criminals, the city shouldbring people into the system.Want to solve the problem of unlicensed vending? Give peo-ple licenses.Second, the bill will abolishthe Vendor Review Panel andopen up more streets by creat-ing an objective standard, as iscurrently used for newsstands,for determining which streetswill be closed to vending.Third, the bill will changethe oppressive 20 foot rule to10 feet when regular store-fronts are involved, openingup many more spaces forvending.Fourth, the bill will lowerthe maximum fines and takethe power to set fines awayfrom ECB, which has abusedthat power.We are currently in talkswith City Council membersabout this bill. Call to getinvolved with this process.
 
Bea Member oftheStreetVendor Project!
Page3
You may have noticed that thesidewalks are more congestedthese days. It is not just yourimagination. They actually are.And it is not the fault of streetvendors.The Street Vendor Projecthas kicked off a campaignagainst the proliferation of illegal planters, which seemto have taken over the side-walks of midtown and down-town Manhattan.Many buildings place theplanters there, without therequired permits, for the pur-pose of displacing vendors.
“What kind of a city dowe live in,” said vendor A.
Davis, who is leading thecharge among a coalition of 
vendors. “So many streets
have already been closed tovending that, with these planters,
we have no where to go.”
While vendors bear no illwill toward the shrubs them-selves, the same cannot be said of many building owners, who in-variably claim that the planters
are there for “beautification” or “security.” They complain that
the sidewalks are too congestedto allow vending, while at thesame time illegally placing 4 x 4foot concrete barriers on the pub-lic thoroughfare.The SVP is collecting illegalplanter locations to present themto the Department of Trans-portation, which has jurisdic-tion over these sidewalk ob-structions, and demand en-forcement. We will also beattending Community Boardhearings to speak out againstthese public nuisances.On Thursday, Jan 13th, wewill be attending Community
Board Five’s meeting, where
they will be discussing theplacement of planters at 641Fifth Avenue. Please come to227 W. 27th Street at 5 p.m.to help us with this fight.
Peddlersvs.PottedPlants
 
Sign upforMembership!
Benefits
ECB TicketsECB AppealsSales Tax HelpCriminal Court (some cases)ID Badge (see sample, right)Vote in Annual ElectionsForfeiture & License RevocationsLicense Applications & RenewalsNewsletter (four times a year)Free Disposable Camera and 30 foot tape measureHelp with filing Police Complaint (CCRB) Forms, and more !
DUES = $100 per year
 
New Longer Hours
Office now open until 9pmon Mondays
Call for details: 646-602-5681
MONTHLY MEETING
2nd Tuesday of the month @ 7 pm

January 11, 2005

February 8, 2005

March 8, 2005
StreetVendor ProjectMembership Card
Expiration date: 9/15/05
Ramirez,Odulio
ID No 00-119
666 Broadway, NY, NY10012
Jointhe230memberswhohavealreadysignedup
Congrats to SVP mem-ber Godwin Ojofeitimion his new website:
check out
 justamazing.net
 The culprits
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...