Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Evaluating Learner Strengths

Evaluating Learner Strengths

Ratings: (0)|Views: 95|Likes:
Published by Edward G. Rozycki
Legal and moral contexts, not just the technical ones, provide us criteria for identifying strengths and weaknesses.
Legal and moral contexts, not just the technical ones, provide us criteria for identifying strengths and weaknesses.

More info:

Published by: Edward G. Rozycki on Aug 28, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/28/2009

pdf

text

original

 
8/28/09 10:35 AMEvaluating Learner Strengths and WeaknessesPage 1 of 4http://www.newfoundations.com/EGR/Strengths.html
An earlier form of this essay appears inthe Spring 2005 issue of 
educational Horizons
Evaluating Learner Strengths and Weaknesses:the Impediments of Formalism
 © 2005 Edward G. Rozycki, Ed. D.
RETURN 
edited11/13/08… occult causes: the very absurdity which Moliere so happily ridiculedwhen he made one of his pedantic physicians account for the fact thatopium produces sleep by the maxim, Because it has a soporific virtue. --- John Stuart Mill
1
Pseudo-Explanations
"Occult " causes are frequently offered as explanations. They may be difficult to distinguish fromexplanations that have some scientific basis. Indeed, it is often lack of knowledge on the part of theexplainer that turns a useable concept into semantic puffery. Easy availability of such explanations -- youcan concoct them on the spur of the moment -- overrides any concern for their inaccuracy.
2
"Why can't Johnny read this book?" "Because it's beyond his readiness level!""How can you tell that?" "Because, as you say, he can't read the book!"Another common one is this:"How can I get Sammy to behave?" "Reinforce his desirable behavior!""How will I know if I havereinforced that behavior?" " If you see it occur more frequently!"Then, of course, there is that good ol' fashioned distinction between between the "good kids" and the "badkids." The Good Kids you can expect to be good, even when they aren't because they have merely made amistake, or have had a misunderstanding, or have suffered a momentary, uncharacteristic slip. Good kidsareworth the investment of a teacher's time and trouble.The Bad Kids you can rely on to be bad even when they appear otherwise because they're really trying totrick you and lull you into being off your guard and who knows what mischief they're up to when your eyesare off them? Such kids just waste a teacher's time and don't deserve the opportunities so lavishly affordedthem.
3
Weaknesses and Formalism
We tend to overlook the fact that we judge performances in context. That is why people who are generallycompetent outside of the classroom can appear so inept inside it. "Can you read this text?" is not merely ademand to make some sense of it, but often, in school, to identify plot, and character, author intent, and or,at a minimum, to be ready to recast the story in one's own words. (I teach philosophical analysis at the
 
8/28/09 10:35 AMEvaluating Learner Strengths and WeaknessesPage 2 of 4http://www.newfoundations.com/EGR/Strengths.html
university. Educated adults who have long believed themselves to be quite competent readers have, initially,rough going in my classes when I ask them to analyze a text in the methods of my tradition.)Any individual competence can be recast as a display of weakness if we restrict the manner in which it isperformed. Formalisms are the, usually social, restrictions in terms of which we judge individualachievements. Some formalisms are necessary. Many are controversial. Others are pernicious.For example, anyone might traverse a 100-mile stretch of highway in an hour by just exercising a heavyfoot on the accelerator pedal. The formalism we call "speed limit" makes this feat difficult, if not impossibleto do. Do we, nonetheless, complain of a "weakness" in our driving? The recognition of the idea of plagiarism places restrictions on many a student's ability to hand in an impressive essay. Concepts of theftmight interfere with an individual's otherwise quick accumulation of wealth. Yet behavior constrained bysuch rules and regulations is not judged to be a weakness.Pernicious formalisms are ones which have been, often unconsciously, introduced as schooling customsfrom a particular social class or cultural group and which cannot be reasonably expected to be same forevery child. Pernicious formalisms might be the particularly idiosyncratic expectations of an individualteacher, not necessarily intentionally perverse but stultifying all the same. Basically, our schools tend to judge a child's strengths and weaknesses within a framework of expectations that the following constraintsare in place and have been adapted to: "Children, even though it is only 8AM (or even earlier), behave asthough you have had a good breakfast, enough sleep, warm clothing, time to prepare your lessons,supportive parents, emotional calm, high energy despite the long bus trip to school, impeccable manners andhyper-trained sphincters!"
Academic Formalisms
And then there are the Formalisms of the school and classroom "subject matter ." Whether these arenecessary or pernicious is often a controversial issue that must be decided on a case-by-case basis.
4
Whether or not they even matter is debatable : there is no end of delight in our society to recounting themany, many examples of successful, wealthy people who are weak in academics.No one is weak or strong in a school subject except with respect to a task we might consider for them.Johnny is never just "too weak" or "strong enough" without provoking the inquiry, "For what?" Studentswho study foreign language via a reading translation method usually end up weak in communication skillsin that language. Phonics advocates fuss that whole language approaches to reading make for inadequatereaders. Whole language advocates fume to the contrary. Modern approaches to math, some argue, leavestudents with weak computation skills. Mere computation is not really mathematics, rebut others.There is a legitimate concern about student strengths and weaknesses. It comes from the recognition thatwhat the curriculum is determines what we count as strength and or weakness in a student. The curriculum,in turn, is much determined by the organizational needs of the school, or even, merely, by administrativeconvenience; consider, for example, the debates over whether block scheduling is appropriate, and for whichsubjects.So far as concerns for schooling equity are concerned, it is worrisome, indeed, that the administrativeconvenience of the school district or of different levels of government might ultimately determine whopasses and who fails in the classroom. The practice of standardized testing, for example, is not rooted inpedagogical concern.
5
 
8/28/09 10:35 AMEvaluating Learner Strengths and WeaknessesPage 3 of 4http://www.newfoundations.com/EGR/Strengths.html
Computers
 , et alia
A strength is the ability to provide consistent, near-perfectperformance in a given activity --- Clifton & Anderson
6
What about the effects of technology on our judgments of personal competence? Is being a poor speller aweakness, especially since word processors have spell-checkers? Don't calculators make the memorizationof "math facts" obsolete? Few people can use a slide rule any more. Even engineers, relying heavily oncomputers, can let their skills at solving differential equations decline .We have generally given up that notion that everyone must be prepared to grow and hunt her own food . Wecan and have to depend upon farmers, and food processors and retailers. Must we rebaptize every suchdependency a weakness?Harry can enter almost any secure building undetected. Is this ability one of his strengths? It depends. Is hea government investigator? Or a burglar? Louise doesn't know where the Islets of Langerhans are. Is thisinability a weakness? It depends. Is she a doctor? Or a travel agent?The moral: Abilities do not necessarily indicate strengths. Inabilities do not necessarily indicate weaknesses.
Pursuing Educational Equity: a dilemma
The notion of formalism gives us a handle on something that many educators complain about in the presentnational atmosphere of coercive achievement testing for public schools . The strong test emphasis, theycomplain, interferes with their attempts to reach each child. Their complaints are dismissed as merely self-serving. But, in fact, "No Child Left Behind," or anything vaguely similar which imposes a standardizedtesting program on schools, may be a mechanism by which many children are stultified in their learning.Purportedly in pursuit of educational equity, standardized tests are being used -- indeed, overused -- inpublic schools as an organizationally convenient means of comparing student abilities. But standardizedtesting imposes severe and often new levels of formalism in terms of which the academically relevantbehavior of the students is evaluated . Unless prior preparation has been done with the students, one oughtto expect vast discrepancies in achievement as measured by the tests. And every educator knows thatspending the majority of class time preparing for testing is bad curriculum, any way you look at it. It isboring to student and teacher; and, it provokes rebellion and sabotage from both the "good" and the "bad"students, as well as their parents. The uncircumspect pursuit of equality makes dependency a weakness. Itmake school related abilities a strength. Change of context might well reverse these judgments, or makethem pointless.
REFERENCES
[1] 
 A System of Logic
 http://www.la.utexas.edu/research/poltheory/mill/sol/sol.b01.c03.html[2]See related essays on teaching and learning athttp://www.newfoundations.com/TeLeHTML/TLPallette.html[3]The modern version of 
 Malleus Maleficarum
. Seehttp://www.malleusmaleficarum.org/. Suspected

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->