Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
8Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
The Problem of Delay in Hamlet

The Problem of Delay in Hamlet

Ratings: (0)|Views: 2,083 |Likes:
Published by AbdulRehman
Hamlet-a great play by Shakespeare.The critical essay is written for M.A. English students and generally for literature lovers.
Hamlet-a great play by Shakespeare.The critical essay is written for M.A. English students and generally for literature lovers.

More info:

Published by: AbdulRehman on Sep 11, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

10/23/2013

pdf

text

original

 
 1
THE PROBLEM OF DELAY IN HAMLET:
Hamlet’s delays in carrying out the command of the ghost by killing his uncle and itscauses have been the subject of endless controversy among critics. Some modern critics likeT.S Eliot refused to take notice of it. According to them it is certainly an artistic flaw.Others like German critic Hanner and American critic Stoil explain this matter in a verysimple way by saying that if Hamlet had killed the king, the story would have endedsomewhere in Act-II. Shakespeare was therefore forced to delay his revenge. Suppose hehad done so, there would have been no tragedy of Hamlet. Some critics argue that there isno delay at all, every thing that hero does is calculated and deliberate. German criticWerder remarks that Hamlet is intelligent and passive. Passive in the sense that heunderstands the difficulty of his task, he goes to the mark straight in the heart of crime andby no mean slowly.These are, no doubt, two extreme views. When we study the plays we feel that there hasbeen delay on the part of Hamlet. When we say that there is delay, the question arises whatwere the causes? To answer this question, a number of theories have been advanced. Thesetheories can be divided into two groups: External Causes; Internal Causes. Those whobelieve in external causes hold the circumstances responsible for the delay of Hamlet.While those who believe in internal causes are in majority and hold Hamlet responsible forthis delay:
External Causes:
This theory of Hamlet’s delay due to external difficulties was expounded by the Germancritic Werder. The main arguments advanced in favour of this theory are, what wasHamlet to do when ghost had left him with its command of vengeance? The king wassurrounded not merely by courtiers but also by Swiss body guards. How was Hamlet to getat him? Was he able to accuse him for murder publicly? If he did what would happen?How would he prove the charge? All that he had to offer in proof was a ghost story. Others,to be sure, had seen the ghost but no one else had heard its revelations.
 
If the court ishonest it would vote for Hamlet’s madness or would punish him.It is true that immediately after “The Mouse Trap”, he got a chance. He found the kingdefenseless. But what Hamlet wanted was not a private revenge He wanted a public justicewith the king, so he spared the king. But, on the voyage, he discovered the king’scommandment to the king of England to put him immediately to death. He with this letterin his pocket comes back to Denmark. He had now a solid proof that the king attempted tokill him. This would also provide him a proof for his father’s death but his enemy wasquick enough. This public indictment of his enemy can also go with his own death.Though this story was rejected by the late critics on the plea that no where in the play doesHamlet make the slightest reference to any external difficulty. On the contrary, he hasasserted many times that he can obey the ghost as he says in his mothers closet: “I shall lugthe guts into the neighbour room.”But this theory we can not ignore. Firstly, it is quite probable that when Hamlet wasthinking quite precisely on the event, he was considering other things, the question, howcould he avenge his father without sacrificing his own life. Secondly, he was anxious thathis act of vengeance should not be misconstructed. In the end, he requests his friendHoratio to explain his act .Hamlet says:“Horatio, I am dead,Thou livest, report me and my cause arightTo the unsatisfied.”
Internal Causes:
When we take internal causes of Hamlet’s delay, we see four important theories.(i) Sentimental theory presented by Goethe.(ii) Weakness of will theory presented by Coleridge.
 
 2
(iii) Conscience theory presented by Ulrich(iv) Melancholic theory presented by Bradley.
Sentimental Theory:
Sentimental theory is outdated It presents the picture of Hamlet as agraceful youth, sensitive, full of delicate sympathies and aspirations, shrinking from thetouch of every thing gross and earthly. He is frail and weak. This picture of Hamlet thoughnot rootless, yet is certainly untrue. This picture of Hamlet is not fit to be the hero of thetragedy.
The Weakness of the Will:
“The weakness of will theory” is widely accepted. Accordingto this theory, the cause of Hamlet’s delay is irresolution, that is, excess of reflective orspeculative habit of mind. Hamlet is an intellectual and prefers to live in the world of idealism and thus he is unfit to perform the duties of the world. He cannot concentrate hisattention on the work in hand. He is never satisfied, never resolute and always remains in
 
state of “to be or not to be.”“Thus conscience does make coward of us all,And thus the native hue of resolutionIs sicklied over with the pale cast of thought.”Though this theory is supported by Hamlet’s own words in his soliloquies, yet it is a partialtheory and leaves much unexplained. This theory does not take into view the element of fate, which instead of helping him, conspires to paralyse him.
Conscience Theory:
According to conscience theory, it is not the will that renders him acoward. The king, after all, is his uncle, brother of his father and husband of his mother.He cannot kill him without thinking over the matter from all sides. He is scrupulous. Theghost also seems to him doubtful.“The spirit that I have seenMay be a devil, and the devil hath power,T’ assume a pleasing shape.”This is the main reason for his designing the play scene. He wanted to trap the king’sconscience. He cannot kill Claudius while he is praying because his conscience is notsatisfied. Conscience theory explains the cause of Hamlet’s delay to a certain extent. Butobviously, we cannot say that conscience is the chief hindrance in his action.
The melancholy theory:
The melancholy theory of Hamlet’s delay was advanced byBradley. In his book “Shakespearean Tragedy”, he says: “Melancholy accounts forHamlet’s inaction.”The immediate cause of this is simply his feelings and ideas full of disgust with life, andevery thing in it. Such a state of feeling is inevitably adverse to any kind of decided action.His body is inert; the mind is averse to response. His killing of the king is a violent,dangerous and a difficult task. But It sinks into the sea of his diseased feelings.None of the above theories explains completely the cause of Hamlet’s delay. As Hamlet is acomplex character, his delay may also be due to several causes. Every critic has given hisown interpretation of character and causes. But however, in the end of the wholediscussion, we may come to the conclusion that Hamlet hesitates not because he is devouredby nervous reflexes and apathy but because he is afraid of taking a false step. Hence “theweakness of the will theory” is the most widely accepted theory.
Written&Composed By:Prof.A.R.SomrooM.A.English&Education.
0661-610063

Activity (8)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
Mirza Fahad Iqbal added this note
Very Reasonable And Logical Assignment On Problems Of Delay In Hamlet
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
milancomputers liked this
tanusreeghosh liked this
arminsafe liked this
Rosarioval liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->