Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Examples of Fatawa Conflicts

Examples of Fatawa Conflicts

Ratings:
(0)
|Views: 80|Likes:
Published by shianews
Conflicts in the Rulings of Mujtahids
Conflicts in the Rulings of Mujtahids

More info:

Published by: shianews on Sep 17, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/25/2015

pdf

text

original

 
Conflicts in the Rulings of Mujtahids
Conflicts in the Rulings of Mujtahids
Acknowledgements:We gratefully acknowledge Syed Baqir Nisar Zaidi’s invaluable compilations ‘Kashaf-ul-Tazaad’ and Kashaf-ul-Hijab, which were frequently used in citing various rulings of Mujtahids.
 
Conflicts in the Rulings of Mujtahids
Statements of Fallibles will always be Inconsistent 
) ا ري ث ك  ف ل ت خا هي ف اود ج   ه لا  ر ي غ د ن ع  م  ك    و  آ ر ق ا و ر بد ت   ل فأ4:82(
Do they not then meditate on the Quran? And if it were from any other than Allah,they would have found in it many a discrepancy.
 ض ف     و    ن م ه  ط  ن ت س  ذ ا ه  ل      ن م  ر م ا  وأ ى إ و   را ى إ و;     و ه ب ا عاأ    ا  وأ  م ا  م A ر مأ   ء ج اإ و )  لي ل   إ  ط ي شا   ت     ه ت  ح  و    ي ل ع ه لا4:83(
 And when there comes to them news of security or fear they spread it abroad;
 
and if they had referred it to the Messenger and to those in authority among them,those among them who can search out the knowledge of it would have known it,and were it not for the grace of Allah upon you and His mercy, you would havecertainly followed the Shaitan save a few.
In Tafseer-e-Safi it is written about the Word
ا ري ث ك  ف ل ت خا
, that if Quran would be other thanAllah
azwj
’s Words then there will be many defects in it, few of its parts would not beconsistent and fall short of eloquence and would not describe past incidents and containseveral contradictions.It is referred to Imam Mohammed Baqir 
asws
in Tafseer-e-Safi that ‘Istambat’
ه  ط  ن ت س 
(theprocess of deriving religious orders) can only be practised by the Masoom Imams
asws
.And it is in Tafseer-e-Aiashi that Imam Ali Raza
asws
says, Allah
azwj
in this Verse refers tous
asws
, we are the ones
asws
who are worthy of practising
ه  ط  ن ت س 
in Quran and are fullyaware of Allah
azwj
’s Halal and Harram. And we
asws
are His
azwj
‘Hujjat’ on His
azwj
creation.In Akmal-u-Deen, Sheikh Sadduq reports from Imam Mohammed Baqir 
asws
: Whoever tried to seek ‘Wilayat’ and derivation of Divine Knowledge from other than the Ahlul Baitof Prophet
saww
, has acted against the Commands of Allah
asws
. Those are away from thereligion of Allah
azwj
and attributed lies to Him
azwj
, who considered ‘Ulul Amr’ other thanthose who are guided by Allah
azwj
and have assumed that anyone other than Masoom
asws
is worthy of deriving Allah
azwj
’s orders. These are the ones who did not turn to Allah
azwj
’s‘Fazal’
1
where it was meant to be (with Masomeen
asws
) and, as a result, not only theywent astray but also have misguided those who followed them. Thus, no excuse will beaccepted from them on the Day of Judgement.
2
A blind leading the Blinds!
There are several such claims made by Mujtahids of today, but for the brevity of thisarticle we just give one example:Agha Seestani says: InShaAllah you will not be blamed (in the Hereafter) if you act asper this book (Touse-ul-Masail). See, Appendix 1.
1
Divine Blessing, Amir-ul-Momaneen
asws
as per several traditions of Masomeen
asws
.
2
See, for example, Quran by Imdad Hussain, pg. 117.
 
Conflicts in the Rulings of Mujtahids
Anyone with little knowledge of Islam would realise, this claim is totally against the Quranand traditions of Masomeen
asws
, see for example the following two verses:
ا= لو@ سرث ع ب نى ت حيO ذ ع@ ما @ كا م خ@أرزO\ةرOز@رO ا لا ه ي  O ض ا  نOإ ف  مO O   O لOد ت ه ا  نOإ فد ت O م17:15(
Whoever goes aright, for his own soul does he go aright; and whoever goes astray, to itsdetriment only does he go astray: nor can the bearer of a burden bear the burden of another,nor do We chastise until We raise a messenger.
  ب    ئL  ن ي ف     ج ر م   L ب  ى إ     ر خأ   ز و Aة  زا و       و   ي ل ع  إ R   ; ك  س     و Rء  L ك ;     و X ب    بأ ه لا  ر ي غأ   )   ل ت   هي ف   ت ن ك6:164(
 Say: What! shall I seek a Lord other than Allah? And He is the Lord of all things; and no soul earns (evil) but against itself, and no bearer of burden shall bear the burden of another; thento your Lord is your return, so He will inform you of that in which you differed.
Is Hallal and Harram a matter of Point of View? 
As per several traditions of Masomeen
asws
Allah
azwj
’s ‘Halal’ is Halal until the day of Judgement and Harram will also remain Harram until the Dooms Day.
)  لد   ه لا  ن س  د     و     م  ل خ د   ت ا ه لا  ن 2348(:
Such has been the course of Allah that has indeed run before, and you shall not find a change in Allah's course.
وهييبحدبادحاقاطلاكزىيدحأادحاقحرجعليهلدمدحأادحاموقيلومتعيشفدفعلفتفعكتسمودباأعساقحةحاسدميأتذلعكتلانيكتئلأيلافكصلبلهملىومدعفتعيشفاهنوبمووتايندلاطحفاعولطبيلمديغ
It is narrated from Imam Jafar-e-Sadiq
asws
: Whoever would try to divert to his ownadvantage in the Divine knowledge (as revealed by Ahlul Bait
asws
), would loose his worth.…… nly those would strive on this path, who without any guidance and nominationfrom Allah
azwj
, want to corrupt the Just, for the sake of worldly gains by issueing Fatawa.
3
We present, below, some examples of Mujtahid’s decrees ‘Fatawa’ from their Articles‘Touzi-ul-Masail’. The selected Mujtahids are quite well known and are followed by mostof Usooli Shia but an unbiased reader will soon find out that these Mujtahids do not onlycontradict themselves but also go against the traditions of Masomeen
asws
.However, prior to presenting traditions of Masomeen
asws
after quoting the contradictionsof Fatawa of Mujtahids, it is important to note there cannot be any contradictions in thetraditions of Masomeen
asws
, if one finds any then he has to look into more details thecontext and background to that traditions, as a hadith may have been reported from that
3
 
Muani Al-Akhbar, pg. 226, tradition 1.
 
(رابخ181ناعمعلاائتسىعما)

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->