Virus.GR Comparative AV test 082009

File Windows Macro Malware ScriptTrojans &BackdoorsFile Windows Macro Malware ScriptTrojans &BackdoorsBootdisk/cdRight-clickmenu scanOnlineupdateBackgroundscanningFolder-onlyscanFreewareversionFile Windows Macro Malware ScriptTrojans &BackdoorsAntivirus/Antispyware270 4146 6243 43098 30814 477515TotalDetection% TotalDetection270 4146 6243 43098 30814 477515Total ScanTime (mins)270 4146 6243 43098 30814 477515G DATA 2009 20.0.2.1

246 4119 6177 40606 30712 473985

555845 98,89%

1 1 1 25 18 353 399 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,11% 99,35% 98,94% 94,22% 99,67% 99,26%F-Secure 2009 9.00.148

248 4021 6229 41186 30539 472696

554919 98,72%

1 10 4 155 124 815 1109 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,85% 96,99% 99,78% 95,56% 99,11% 98,99%Kaspersky 2010 9.0.0.463

248 4074 6211 42418 30141 471526

554618 98,67%

1 2 4 29 23 458 517 YES YES YES YES YES NO

91,85% 98,26% 99,49% 98,42% 97,82% 98,75%AntiVir 9.0.0.381 Premium

246 4090 6138 41972 30329 471654

554429 98,64%

1 1 1 11 9 195 218 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,11% 98,65% 98,32% 97,39% 98,43% 98,77%ZoneAlarm Antivirus 8.0.400.020

248 4007 6210 42405 30018 471427

554315 98,62%

1 1 2 39 24 419 486 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,85% 96,65% 99,47% 98,39% 97,42% 98,73%AntiVir 9.0.0.407 Personal

246 4048 6136 41572 30329 471654

553985 98,56%

1 1 1 12 8 204 227 NO YES YES YES YES

YES91,11% 97,64% 98,29% 96,46% 98,43% 98,77%Ashampoo 1.61

246 4048 6136 41447 30277 471380

553534 98,48%

1 1 1 7 5 106 161 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,11% 97,64% 98,29% 96,17% 98,26% 98,72%MultiCore 2.001.00036

233 4072 6190 40444 30046 471909

552894 98,36%

1 9 3 289 114 693 1109 NO YES YES YES YES NO

86,30% 98,22% 99,15% 93,84% 97,51% 98,83%Paretologic 6.1.1

248 4005 6039 40005 30316 470865

551478 98,11%

1 3 2 34 22 382 444 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,85% 96,60% 96,73% 92,82% 98,38% 98,61%TrustPort 2.8.0.2255

187 4085 6212 41034 30467 469022

551007 98,03%

1 7 4 389 84 2812 3297 NO YES YES YES YES NO

69,26% 98,53% 99,50% 95,21% 98,87% 98,22%eScan 10.0.977.4091

208 4047 6062 38591 30459 470484

549851 97,82%

1 9 13 90 65 411 589 NO YES YES YES YES NO

77,04% 97,61% 97,10% 89,54% 98,85% 98,53%The Shield 2009 12.0.12

209 4051 6058 39156 30481 469301

549256 97,72%

1 1 1 38 25 467 533 NO YES YES YES YES

YES77,41% 97,71% 97,04% 90,85% 98,92% 98,28%BitDefender 2010 11.0.15.297

209 4048 6062 39037 30462 468809

548627 97,61%

1 1 1 35 28 476 542 NO YES YES YES YES NO

77,41% 97,64% 97,10% 90,58% 98,86% 98,18%Ikarus 1.0.97

248 3991 6167 42259 30373 463046

546084 97,15%

1 2 1 32 28 1014 1078 NO YES YES YES YES NO

91,85% 96,26% 98,78% 98,05% 98,57% 96,97%AVG 8.5.392 Free

106 3940 5978 39539 28942 466713

545218 97,00%

1 4 4 214 67 1070 1360 YES YES YES YES YES

YES39,26% 95,03% 95,76% 91,74% 93,92% 97,74%BitDefender 2009 12.0.12.0 Free

198 4018 6031 38739 30345 462370

541701 96,37%

1 1 1 36 24 447 510 NO YES YES YES YES

YES73,33% 96,91% 96,60% 89,89% 98,48% 96,83%Nod32 4.0.437.0

215 3889 6102 37301 29041 462904

539452 95,97%

1 2 1 153 122 3970 4249 YES YES YES YES YES NO

79,63% 93,80% 97,74% 86,55% 94,25% 96,94%Avast 4.8.1335 Free

236 4003 6018 37893 29953 460745

538848 95,87%

1 1 1 12 5 135 155 NO YES YES YES YES

YES87,41% 96,55% 96,40% 87,92% 97,21% 96,49%Comodo 3.9.95478.509

172 3913 5965 40715 28358 458037

537160 95,57%

1 1 1 8 4 97 122 NO YES YES YES YES

YES63,70% 94,38% 95,55% 94,47% 92,03% 95,92%Trend Micro Antivirus 17.1.1250

229 3965 6158 41037 29674 454950

536013 95,36%

1 3 5 62 40 848 959 YES YES YES YES YES NO

84,81% 95,63% 98,64% 95,22% 96,30% 95,27%F-Prot 6.0.9.1

181 3498 6132 33667 27546 451900

522924 93,03%

1 14 22 270 167 2596 3070 NO YES YES YES YES NO

67,04% 84,37% 98,22% 78,12% 89,39% 94,64%McAfee Enterpise 8.7.0i

259 4060 6227 26365 29506 452660

519077 92,35%

1 5 4 106 102 1128 1346 NO YES YES YES YES NO

95,93% 97,93% 99,74% 61,17% 95,76% 94,79%McAfee 13.11.102

259 4085 6191 39295 29925 439156

518911 92,32%

1 3 11 80 165 858 1118 YES YES YES YES YES NO

95,93% 98,53% 99,17% 91,18% 97,11% 91,97%Norman Security Suite 7.10.0.1

137 3394 5916 31195 28109 441404

510155 90,76%

1 9 1 273 76 1458 1818 NO YES YES YES YES NO

50,74% 81,86% 94,76% 72,38% 91,22% 92,44%Blink Personal 4.3.2

137 3394 5916 31191 28100 438106

506844 90,17%

1 5 1 72 52 647 778 NO YES YES YES YES NO

50,74% 81,86% 94,76% 72,37% 91,19% 91,75%Vba32 3.12.10.9

97 2959 5997 32916 26437 436941

505347 89,91%

1 27 5 531 351 8329 9244 NO YES YES YES YES NO

35,93% 71,37% 96,06% 76,37% 85,80% 91,50%K7 Antivirus 7.7.0568

17 1208 5292 35062 25158 433605

500342 89,02%

1 2 1 6 4 115 129 NO YES YES YES YES NO

6,30% 29,14% 84,77% 81,35% 81,64% 90,80%Norton 16.5.0.134

217 3667 5255 26826 25111 430021

491097 87,37%

1 3 4 42 27 549 626 NO YES YES YES YES NO

80,37% 88,45% 84,17% 62,24% 81,49% 90,05%ArcaVir 2009

65 3290 5804 36002 27315 405789

478265 85,09%

1 2 1 36 19 346 405 NO YES YES YES YES NO

24,07% 79,35% 92,97% 83,54% 88,64% 84,98%Outpost 6.7.2957.446.0711

154 3345 5959 31216 26744 402421

469839 83,59%

1 2 1 35 35 894 968 NO YES YES YES YES

YES57,04% 80,68% 95,45% 72,43% 86,79% 84,27%Dr. Web 5.00.4.06300

154 3429 6142 26781 27141 402268

465915 82,89%

1 4 2 176 89 2336 2608 NO YES YES YES YES NO

57,04% 82,71% 98,38% 62,14% 88,08% 84,24%Rising AV 21.51

110 2976 5064 30240 24974 391490

454854 80,92%

1 9 13 132 96 2135 2386 NO YES YES YES YES

YES40,74% 71,78% 81,11% 70,17% 81,05% 81,98%Vipre 3.1.2775

8 2542 2864 31943 22976 387571

447904 79,69%

1 13 1 176 153 2837 3181 NO YES YES YES YES NO

2,96% 61,31% 45,88% 74,12% 74,56% 81,16%Kingsoft 2009.08.05.16

57 2092 5673 34451 23447 381647

447367 79,59%

1 1 1 20 12 263 298 YES YES YES YES YES NO

21,11% 50,46% 90,87% 79,94% 76,09% 79,92%V3 Internet Security 2009.08.10.02

27 1631 5180 24825 22511 391224

445398 79,24%

1 4 8 35 28 519 595 YES YES YES YES YES NO

10,00% 39,34% 82,97% 57,60% 73,05% 81,93%ViRobot Desktop 5.5

17 3459 5593 27052 23103 385079

444303 79,05%

1 12 14 98 79 1485 1689 NO YES YES YES YES NO

6,30% 83,43% 89,59% 62,77% 74,98% 80,64%Antiy Ghostbusters 6.1.6

210 2357 72 37204 22678 371099

433620 77,14%

1 3 4 167 80 1140 1395 NO YES YES YES YES NO

77,78% 56,85% 1,15% 86,32% 73,60% 77,71%Panda 2009 9.00.00

177 2505 6097 24079 20567 344555

397980 70,80%

1 3 1 85 87 1851 2028 YES YES YES YES YES NO

65,56% 60,42% 97,66% 55,87% 66,75% 72,16%Twister 7.3.3.9983

53 2019 208 23399 19176 332524

377379 67,14%

1 3 2 131 102 998 1237 NO YES YES YES YES NO

19,63% 48,70% 3,33% 54,29% 62,23% 69,64%Virus Chaser 5.0a

154 3108 5845 21204 22914 320783

374008 66,54%

1 2 1 30 25 417 476 NO YES YES YES YES NO

57,04% 74,96% 93,62% 49,20% 74,36% 67,18%Quick Heal 10.00

69 1893 5262 21764 20933 320911

370832 65,97%

1 1 1 12 9 207 231 YES YES YES YES YES NO

25,56% 45,66% 84,29% 50,50% 67,93% 67,20%PC Tools 6.0.0.19

167 3076 5954 10443 16813 299532

335985 59,77%

1 5 5 97 21 289 418 NO YES YES YES YES NO

61,85% 74,19% 95,37% 24,23% 54,56% 62,73%ClamWin 0.95.2

126 2146 5234 17318 15912 254231

294967 52,48%

1 2 3 53 24 564 647 NO YES YES NO YES

YES46,67% 51,76% 83,84% 40,18% 51,64% 53,24%Sophos Sweep 7.6.8

212 3104 6028 12115 14797 204519

240775 42,84%

1 60 1 1595 365 8757 10779 NO YES YES YES YES NO

78,52% 74,87% 96,56% 28,11% 48,02% 42,83%Iolo 1.5.3

176 3246 6092 11305 18059 186747

225625 40,14%

1 5 5 141 120 2406 2678 NO NO YES YES YES NO

65,19% 78,29% 97,58% 26,23% 58,61% 39,11%Net Protector 2009

0 563 7 12135 9786 170529

193020 34,34%

1 3 1 31 20 353 409 NO YES YES YES YES NO

0,00% 13,58% 0,11% 28,16% 31,76% 35,71%The Cleaner 2010 Free 6.1.0.2007

1 1025 0 9862 11006 169819

191713 34,11%

1 1 1 25 13 46 87 NO NO YES NO YES

YES0,37% 24,72% 0,00% 22,88% 35,72% 35,56%Digital Patrol 5.10.102

137 1892 226 29979 21484 99694

153412 27,29%

1 5 5 51 30 168 260 NO NO YES YES YES NO

50,74% 45,63% 3,62% 69,56% 69,72% 20,88%Trojan Hunter 5.1.875

0 254 0 9638 5272 119719

134883 24,00%

1 3 1 60 44 845 954 NO YES YES YES YES NO

0,00% 6,13% 0,00% 22,36% 17,11% 25,07%Protector Plus 8.0.E02

46 841 3704 6938 10930 99003

121462 21,61%

1 1 3 27 19 342 393 YES YES YES YES YES NO

17,04% 20,28% 59,33% 16,10% 35,47% 20,73%Solo 8.0

98 1401 5255 3994 5597 47192

63537 11,30%

1 2 3 29 12 134 181 YES NO YES YES YES NO

36,30% 33,79% 84,17% 9,27% 18,16% 9,88%Trojan Remover 6.8.1

1 135 0 5084 4086 53442

62748 11,16%

1 22 1 132 92 1589 1837 NO YES YES YES YES NO

0,37% 3,26% 0,00% 11,80% 13,26% 11,19%VirIT 6.4.71

0 325 770 4723 2380 42454

50652 9,01%

1 1 1 10 8 122 143 NO YES YES YES YES NO

0,00% 7,84% 12,33% 10,96% 7,72% 8,89%IOBit Security 360 beta 3.1

17 114 19 3590 1942 44482

50164 8,92%

1 1 1 6 5 159 173 NO YES YES YES YES NO

6,30% 2,75% 0,30% 8,33% 6,30% 9,32%PCClear 1.0.8.6

1 25 10 2309 6282 36802

45429 8,08%

1 1 1 3 3 109 118 NO NO YES YES YES NO

0,37% 0,60% 0,16% 5,36% 20,39% 7,71%* Antivirus software are listed with darkblue color * Antispyware/antitrojan software are listedwith dark grey color % Detection per Virus categoryVirus category Scan Time (mins) Features

Virus.GR Comparative AV test 082009

2700%41461%62431%430988%308145%47751585%

Samples tested per virus category

FileWindowsMacroMalwareScriptTrojans & Backdoors

Virus.GR Comparative AV test 082009

98,89%98,72%98,67%98,64%98,62%98,56%98,48%98,36%98,11%98,03%97,82%97,72%97,61%97,15%97,00%96,37%95,97%95,87%95,57%95,36%93,03%92,35%92,32%90,76%90,17%89,91%89,02%87,37%85,09%83,59%82,89%80,92%79,69%79,59%79,24%79,05%77,14%70,80%67,14%66,54%65,97%59,77%52,48%42,84%40,14%34,34%34,11%27,29%24,00%21,61%11,30%11,16%9,01%8,92%8,08%0,00%20,00%40,00%60,00%80,00%100,00%G DATA 2009 20.0.2.1F-Secure 2009 9.00.148Kaspersky 2010 9.0.0.463AntiVir 9.0.0.381 PremiumZoneAlarm Antivirus 8.0.400.020AntiVir 9.0.0.407 PersonalAshampoo 1.61MultiCore 2.001.00036Paretologic 6.1.1TrustPort 2.8.0.2255eScan 10.0.977.4091The Shield 2009 12.0.12BitDefender 2010 11.0.15.297Ikarus 1.0.97AVG 8.5.392 FreeBitDefender 2009 12.0.12.0 FreeNod32 4.0.437.0Avast 4.8.1335 FreeComodo 3.9.95478.509Trend Micro Antivirus 17.1.1250F-Prot 6.0.9.1McAfee Enterpise 8.7.0iMcAfee 13.11.102Norman Security Suite 7.10.0.1Blink Personal 4.3.2Vba32 3.12.10.9K7 Antivirus 7.7.0568Norton 16.5.0.134ArcaVir 2009Outpost 6.7.2957.446.0711Dr. Web 5.00.4.06300Rising AV 21.51Vipre 3.1.2775Kingsoft 2009.08.05.16V3 Internet Security 2009.08.10.02ViRobot Desktop 5.5Antiy Ghostbusters 6.1.6Panda 2009 9.00.00Twister 7.3.3.9983Virus Chaser 5.0aQuick Heal 10.00PC Tools 6.0.0.19ClamWin 0.95.2Sophos Sweep 7.6.8Iolo 1.5.3Net Protector 2009The Cleaner 2010 Free 6.1.0.2007Digital Patrol 5.10.102Trojan Hunter 5.1.875Protector Plus 8.0.E02Solo 8.0Trojan Remover 6.8.1VirIT 6.4.71IOBit Security 360 beta 3.1PCClear 1.0.8.6

Total Detection % per software (Best-to-worst detection rate)

Total Detection