Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Maria Leticia Garcia-Aguilar, A098 237 255 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)

Maria Leticia Garcia-Aguilar, A098 237 255 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 20 |Likes:
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) upheld the denial of a motion to suppress filed by a respondent who was arrested during a workplace raid. The decision was written by Member Roger Pauley.
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) upheld the denial of a motion to suppress filed by a respondent who was arrested during a workplace raid. The decision was written by Member Roger Pauley.

More info:

Published by: Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLC on Jan 24, 2014
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/30/2014

pdf

text

original

 
Shuyer Pisa Esqure

mn  Ji
Executve Oce r Imigraion Review
Board of mmigraton ppeals Oce of he Clerk
5 /07 Leburg Pike Suite 000 Fls Crch Vrgini 0530
Cathoi Soal Seies o Fal Rver I 1600 Bay Street HSICE Oie of Cie Counse OS P

ox 878 Bosto, MA 02114 a River, MA 02724 Name: GARCAAGUILAR, MARIA LET ... A 098-237-255 Date o tis notice 115204
ncosed s a copy of he Boad's decsio

orde n the above-rereced cae. closue
 Mb: Py g
Siceey,
D
c
t
Doa Cr Ce Clek
c U k
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Maria Leticia Garcia-Aguilar, A098 237 255 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)
 
US
e1armn of Jse
Deciso of he Bod of Iiaio Appeals Executive Oce
r
Imiation Revew Fa Cc, Virga
5
Fle:  A098 237 25 Boton, MA
In r e: M AR A LET ICIA G  ARCIA- AG UL AR 
IN RMOVAL PROCEEDINGS  APPEAL Date ON BALF OF RSPONDET: Schuyer Pisha, Esquie CHA
JAN 1 4
 Noce Sec 212(a)(6)(A)(i), &N Act 8 SC. §  182(a)(6)(A)()] Preent whout eng adied or paroled  APPLCAON Tenation The resonent s a natve an czen of Mexico. e resondent's cae was previouly ere s Board when on Octoer 17, 2011, we reande he cae so hat he iaon udge could lly consier te responden alegation in her oion to spres sppleent the record wi tetony o one o ore of the agent nvolved in er aes, and ases whether uppresion is an appropriate reedy in hi cae On rean, the igration ude held a ean d consdered e evdence esene On erury
I
203, the iraon ude isued a eciion denyin the reonden otio to suppres an otion to termnae an granting the responent's requet  volunty eparuehe respondent now appeal tat decision. We revew the maton Juges cual ning r clea eo and all oher isses
de novo See
8 CF.R § 1003(d)(3) The apel will be dsmeOn appeal, te esponent agues hat te Iiation Jude eed y denyn the responden Motion to Suppes e Record of Deporabe/naisbe Alen (Fo -23)  e epondent' tteen conined therein.
See
Respondent's Brie at 7-12; xh. 3 at 2  Accorn to the reponent, her ason at he enere the ne State th the hep of a sugler on April 5 2005, houd e uprese because her aet at the chael anco ctory violated her conttutonal and regulatory rght
ee
Repondent's Brie at 711 In
NS v ope-Mendoa
468 US. 1032, 1050-51 (984) te Supree Co he hat the Fourh Aendent eclusionary rule i inapplicale to deoration proceedings ut le open he  ossy of pplyin h e f tere  rgous Four endn voations wch  rsress h Aendent noions of ndamenta faies nd udeine te proave value of he evdence
See Maer oBarcena
19 &N ec 609, 611(BIA1988);
Maer oSandova
7 &N Dec. 70 (BA 1979);
Maer oGarca
17 &N ec 319, 321 (BA 190) (repondent ae pria ce showng ha adsons were gven nvolnariy and te goveent  resented no conary evidence; proceeding teinated);
Maer o oro
17 &N ec 340 343 BA 180). her h nited Staes ou of As
r
 t Frst t  dicad at supeson o cer evence may e wrned in he case of egregious volations
See eover v Reno
202 3 475, 79 (s Cir),
 cerdened
53 .S. 83 (2000)
Cite as: Maria Leticia Garcia-Aguilar, A098 237 255 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)
 
98 3 

INSv Delado 66
U
 1 6-1 (198)
 determ whethe  le ecoe wh  lw ecemet ae wa csesu the peme ou stated  w ]he most ctzes wl rspod o  pce equest the ct that peple  so  o s wthut ben tod the e ee ot t respd, hd elmtes te csesual atue o e esse. . ess the ccmstces  the ecouer e s mdat as to demsate hat a easable peso wold ve  beleved he was t ee t eave  he had t espded, oe ca a at the queston reslte  a detet under the Fou mee. t  e  pes reses t swe d th ce take ddtal steps . to ob a swe, the he Fo medm mpes some mnm evel o ojecte stcat t valdate he detet  sezure.
ale seek te excuso  evece bsed  the Foth medmet bes e e o establsh a
prma ace
cse that evece soud be supresed
See aer oang 13
&N Dec.
 691

19)
Ol whe  le has cme wrd wth dequte evdece  supo o suppesso wl the bude sh t e Depmet o omeld ecut H to  just e me  wch t btaed the evdece.
See Maer oBarcena ura

 61
e hve aso he tt
1
s eetl trustwot d mssble to pe eae bet  dcat at t cotas mt at s coect or w btaed b cerc or dues
See Maer oGome-Gome 3
&N Dec
 
B
 ); NS

PonceHernande  
&N Dec
 8 8
B
999) Maer oBarcena ura
at
 61
O appe, e respodet ares,
 ner aa
 that he rest ws ncstt bce  ws e esut  acal pl ad te aes h o prculaze suspco t se wa vl e aw whe th aeste he a the chae aco cto.
See
Respodet e at
8-9.
Deste ths cteto, however, as e mrato Jde u, te UC aets   ths case we ct o a tp e receved that severa mplees t the cor were ndocmeted ales J 
1) See
xh
 
at
 
Ths was he ss o e  whc ead t he respdets rest
See ope-Mendoa 68
. t

Fuhe othe h alle hat e aes mprperl  ested he, te espdet s presete  evdece tt e e wa  the result o rcal po. The espoet also es  pea that the Fom
-3
 he cse d te statemets cte thee shd be suppessed because e ccmstaces surr he aes conttted res vlats  he Fh dmet hs.
See
espdet Be t
9
he clms t se wtessed eats drected at the detaees d, uer th ole amsphere" she ws terred wth be ve he hts.
See
Repodets ie t

The esodet tested coce e hoste atmshee"  he deeo he ese  t te U es wee ed d t she el mde

she od t ee
I

 
T 
 6666-6)
he als este, wee ht e ces d o d ei eos Ja
1
T. 
 66366-6)
1
o te extet that the espodet seeks o hve us ppl the law   deral cct te th  te Frst Crcut  whch ths cse arses, we dce to do so
See aer onemo 
I Dec
 31

989)
the ad hsocll lows a cou precede  cses s  ta ccut)
See
Repdets Be at
8-9
U
M
_.&l
 
Cite as: Maria Leticia Garcia-Aguilar, A098 237 255 (BIA Jan. 15, 2014)

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->