Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Rodrigo Vasquez-Lopez, A048 138 084 (BIA Jan. 24, 2014)

Rodrigo Vasquez-Lopez, A048 138 084 (BIA Jan. 24, 2014)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 345 |Likes:
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) held that recklessly endangering another person under 18 Pa. Cons. Stat. 2705 is a categorical crime involving moral turpitude because defendants must consciously disregard that their actions could result in a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death or serious bodily injury. The decision was written by Member Ellen Liebowitz and joined by Member John Guendelsberger and Member Molly Kendall-Clark.
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) held that recklessly endangering another person under 18 Pa. Cons. Stat. 2705 is a categorical crime involving moral turpitude because defendants must consciously disregard that their actions could result in a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death or serious bodily injury. The decision was written by Member Ellen Liebowitz and joined by Member John Guendelsberger and Member Molly Kendall-Clark.

More info:

Published by: Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLC on Feb 03, 2014
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

03/17/2014

pdf

text

original

 
Grn, Thomas
M.
Esq. Surin
&
rin P C
Chestnut Street Sute
1
hladelpha PA
96 U Dptmt o Justic
Executive Oce r Imigraton Revew
Board of Immigration peals Oce othe Clerk
507 leburg Pike, Sut 000 Fas Church Vrgna 0530
HS/ICE Oce f Cef Counsel P

Maket Steet, uite
46
Phlaelphia PA
1917
Name: VASQUEZ-LOPEZ, RODRIGO A
48-18-84
Date of ths notce
1//14
nlosd s a copy of th Board's dso and odr n t above-renced as. nosure
P b: Gg h KdCk y Lz  C
Sncy,
D
c
l
Dona Car Chef Cek
Tn  
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Rodrigo Vasquez-Lopez, A048 138 084 (BIA Jan. 24, 2014)
 
U epet o Justce
Exve Of     Rew
Din
 e B
  mign A
Fl
CV
2053
Fie: A0 3 0Phiadelpha, PA
 re: RODO V
AUEZ-LO EZ
I
MVL PROCGS  E  Date: ON BELF OF SODT homas M
f 
 Esquire O BF OF S: CGE: eey T. Bubier Senior toey
JAN 2 4 01
otie: S 237 (a)( 2 )(  )( i)   I&  At [S § 227 (a)( 2  (A)(i) ] Conv of cme nvolvng moral trpitde  PLICATIO: Tention  cae i preenty before u prt o  or f the nited Ste Cou of pes r  the Thrd Ciruit an the oveens unoppo oon to reman e cae to e od r a dision concg hher the respondt s removabe
an len ne of a ime involving mora ttde We concude at e reponent is removable as chge The proedura hio of thi case is a low. On Febary  2007 e Imition Jue deened hat te respondens 2006 Peyvan convction r Recklesly Endangerng  nther Peron was no r ce involvin oral trpitude8 a. Cons St § 2705. The Bod wthout opnon on rh 7, 2008. The Depeof Homeland Sety  ( "HS ) ed a motion to rensider on p
S
2008 On Fe 20 2009 he Bod  he DHS' s moo pplyng the Bod's dion n
Maer of Sia-Trevno,
24  & N ec. 68 (A 2008 ) d detnng th here as no reis problty tat te satte of onvcion would e pped to reach conduct a does not involve mor rpide. On h
I
20 he Trd Crt t the v 
ents noppo moon to reman he e to the Bod t er onid wheher the respndent nvcon was r a me nvolg mra ptude in lht of he o's decion n
JeLouis v.
S
A' Ge
52 F3d 462  ( 3d Cr. 2009 )n s 18, 200, e od ed is Febry 20, 2009 deson in h e nuded  e respondent s removble s
en onvcted of  ce novng morl  tpitde d reand e rerd to he Imion Judge r he en of  order of remova
1
he  on de' decion i eoneosy ded Feby 7, 2006
Cite as: Rodrigo Vasquez-Lopez, A048 138 084 (BIA Jan. 24, 2014)
 
A08 13 084 n ob 3, 20, the mmiaion Judge ord he responden remov. The responden apealed, d he Bod  ed the iation Jue decision tho opinion on  3, 212 On Septeber 5, 212, e rd Crit ed he Gveens unopposd motion o r 
 
d the a to the Bod to aess wheer th respode's onviion w r a cme invoving moral ide despie he asence in th Pennylvia eckless endngermen e o the avaing fos in he N York ste ide by he o in
Kik v Ah
384 F.3d 84
9
(3d Cr 2004). The paes he smitd splemen bef We ai conclde that te resodt's conion r Rkessly ndaging oth Person in violaon of seon 2705 of he Plvani criin de was r a me inlvin mor de Mora tide reers generally to ndu which is ierenly base ve, o depravd, d or to he ep les of moaiy ad he des o bween persons or iy in gal.
See M er f Frlin
20 &N De 867, 6 I 1994);
 ee al meh v US A'
G.
666 F3d 109, 14 (3d Cir. 2012). To nsitute a me involving moral itde  oense mu hve two essential elemes:  culpabe men se d reprehensile ndu
See aer f Ce Medi
26 &N ec 7 I 213);
Mar  Oegapez
26 N D 99  A 23) For e poses o ries involving moral ide rklessness c be a pable mal te
See Mt er f uin
24 &N D 4, 7567 A 20) (nng t r he pos of ries involvig morl iud, a lpable mental stae may be speci int deliberess, willlness, or recesness)
the hird Ciri noed n
ik v Ar ra
the Bod nsisly h iere moal titde to incde recklessness rimes
ceran stto agvaing os e r suh as he a dend nsciosly dids a sstial risk o serious h or deh to other pn
Kikv Acr pra
90;
 ee e Maer  eal
26 N . 20, 25 I 212) (one who onscioly disregds a kno sk of
exhbits a ase ontet r the wellbeing of e mmniy wch is the essence of mora itude)�
Maer f e
5 & D. 611 61 BI 97) (h iminally reckess ond rre a ocio disregd of a bstantial d njuiale risk of sious injy or e
ote, he e involves or itde
.
ik  v Ahcr
e Thid Ciri held ha the Bod did n a sonaly n onldin tht  Yor rs d recess endgermen stte was a e involving oral turpide ecuse he Boa old reonably conclude t te elemens of depravity, reklessness d ve sk of det when conside togh, iplice aee les of morality and the duties o o iey
Kik v

A ' Gen ra
0 To dee wehe the oense r whih he responent as ovi nttes  ce involving mor tiude we mst look
the spi tat nder whih ·e respond was coni d aen e lst lpable cond nessa o
a
 oniion der he e
See S v ur
3 F.3d 25 214 {d Cir 2012) (qon
Jei v US A' Gen
ra, 
6; 
 v

A'
Ge
41F408 411 (3d C 205) Alho te responden was covied unde a diere e om he one aressed by the Third Cui i
ik v A
the co's disio i th
suppos  iil rel he The respond was coied of Recklessly Endangeing Aot Pern in violion o sion 2705 of the Pnnsylvaa imnl ode whih provides h "[a] n commits a 2
Cite as: Rodrigo Vasquez-Lopez, A048 138 084 (BIA Jan. 24, 2014)

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->