Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COMMUNITY COLLEGES
A Call to Progress
munity colleges. They educate 4 percent of the entire U.S. population13 million studentseach year. Most of the countrys college freshmen and sophomores are in community colleges, whose relatively inexpensive tuition makes them a boon for Americans seeking a brighter future on constricted budgets. More than any other set of institutions, the nations nearly twelve hundred community colleges are well positioned to meet the increasing demand for skilled workers in manufacturing, technology, health care, and other high-growth elds. They are a necessity for a nation trying, in an age of austerity, to reverse a steady decline in higher education attainment relative to the rest of the world. But they dont always deliver on that promise. While access has expanded over the years, outcomes for students have not necessarily improved. So a new reform movement is taking hold, and community colleges are being pushed to achieve better results. Following repeated calls for improved graduation rates from national foundations, the Obama administration, and state governments, in 2012 the sectors own champion, the American
1
IN TR OD UCT ION
Association of Community Colleges, called student success rates unacceptably low and career training inadequately connected to job market needs.1 Simultaneous recognition of community colleges importance and poor student outcomes translates into enormous pressure. State funding is increasingly being tied to graduation rates (rather than to the number of students enrolled, the traditional method).2 Federal and state agencies are requiring more public reporting on completion and employment outcomes. And for-prot competitorsinvesting in technology-based instructional delivery and using private-sector marketing techniquesare enrolling more and more students, including the low-income and minority populations long served by community colleges. To attract students and public dollars in an era of accountability, transparency, and competition, community colleges must deliver signicantly more degrees of higher quality at a lower per-pupil cost to an increasingly diverse student populationan equation that adds up to an immense challenge. In the balance is not just the colleges survival but also continued opportunity for Americansparticularly the less advantagedto access the knowledge and skills they need to have a secure future and to fuel our nations economic growth. But improvement is not coming easily, or quickly. Almost a decade into a new reform movement, there is not yet complete agreement about what community colleges should aim for, let alone good systems for measuring whether those goals are being attained. And there is not yet even universal acceptance of what, to most reformers, is a vital premise: it doesnt matter how many students enter community colleges doors unless they exit with a meaningful credential in hand.
2
We are moving in that direction, however. With few exceptions, improving the rates at which students earn degrees and certicates lies at the center of recent change strategies, from state policy reform to nancial aid redesign to eorts by state systems and nonprot organizations to improve institutional practice. Completion matters to students; holding a degree or certicate is strongly correlated with having a good job with decent wages. Any signicant attention to completion, then, is a dramatic improvement over the days when community colleges responded to ever-increasing enrollment numbers by developing more and more programs and courses, paying too little attention to whether students were succeeding in them. As institutions and policy makers aim to improve community college completion rates, though, they must not do so at the expense of access. Its easy to increase the graduation rate if you just stop admitting the students least likely to succeed, if you invent policies and practices that eectively close doors to the rapidly growing numbers of minority and low-income young people who want to enrollgroups that historically have more trouble nishing college. And while nobodys recommending that as a remedy, it must be guarded against as a possible unintended consequence of the drive to improve completion rates. But even maintaining access and improving graduation are not sucient. After all, students dont go to community college to graduate; most go to acquire skills relevant to the careers they will pursue either directly out of community college or by way of a four-year school. Just as institutions work to increase the numbers of students who complete, they must put equal eort into ensuring the quality of their oerings and their instruction so that students leave well equipped to succeed in whatever comes next.
3
IN TR OD UCT ION
Facing a steady drumbeat to improve student outcomes, community colleges across the country are seeking more guidance on how to meet higher expectations. Already, a group of talented community college researchers, practitioners, and advocates has emerged. Some devote themselves to devising and testing the eectiveness of specic practices to increase success: learning communities that connect small groups of students across several classes, early warning systems to give struggling students the help they need, additional nancial aid for students who achieve certain milestones, mandatory courses in study skills and career planning. Others are taking a more systemic approach, seeking to change state and federal policy or improve community college practice at multiple institutions at the same time. Nearly all of these strategies aim primarily to increase the number of students who complete, and evidence suggests that they work only some of the time.3 Indeed, community college graduation rates have not signicantly increased over the past decade.4 This book seeks to contribute to the growing body of knowledge regarding how to increase community college student success, and thus help institutional leaders and policy makers understand important strategies for improving degree completion, equity, learning, and post-graduation outcomes. It draws on examples of what is happening at exceptional community colleges that were named nalists for the Aspen Prize for Community College Excellence over its rst two years, as well as on understanding gained through the extensive data-gathering and selection process that begins with consideration of over one thousand community colleges each year. Proles of the seven colleges that received the Aspen Prizes highest recognition and are highlighted in this book can be found in appendix A.
4
The Aspen Prize is built on a four-part denition of critical community college outcomes: Completion. Do students earn associates degrees and other meaningful credentials while in community college, and bachelors degrees if they transfer? Equity. Do colleges work to ensure equitable outcomes for minority and low-income students, and others often underserved? Learning. Do colleges set expectations for what students should learn, measure whether they are doing so, and use that information to improve? Labor market. Do graduates get well-paying jobs? Pursuing and making signicant progress on all of these goals is how exceptional community colleges ensure that diverse populations of students get what they came for: the knowledge and skills that will aord them a better life than they would have had otherwise. Achieving any one of these goals is better than improving access alone. Achieving all of them means a high-quality education for students, and a much brighter future for our country (see gure 1). By starting with a holistic denition of excellence, measuring success against that denition, and then identifying practices and policies that align to high levels of student success, the Aspen Prize aims to help college leaders, educators, and policy makers better understand practices and policies that improve student outcomes across entire institutions as well as ones that may impede those eorts. This book sets forth whats been learned about exceptional community colleges, especially from the schools recognized during the
5
IN TR OD UCT ION
FIGURE 1
Aspen Prize for Community College Excellence, indicators of community college excellence
WHY THIS MATTERS
Completion
Do students earn associates degrees and other meaningful credentials, and bachelors degrees after they transfer?