Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WOK_ WLd b U
UN rU
uKOH dBM* _ sdA dN s dA wU UB* U u dN w
dO_ u v tId r d b U
Ub_ 5u*
s WzU s dI U
wb
w UD s WdI vK
UUG r dO_ I
t jO% dO_ tK w wC1 u tO X iC vK
d u bI
WN' s bb U UK WKU u u s tUL s tMO1 s
WOU_
nB
c q
fUwd dU UN rU
114
WOK_ WLd b UN
U dOB WD oD uJ r dH bI
tUF vK u tO XO s
wK U U tFu w tM s d UNO rKJ tH b
b U b VK
w
UD uO
Wd& s dF t _ wMOQ
vIK
ru tzUb qd c U c
WUN UEKU d J rJ uI ue%
w dOu
XM UL w uL UIU d J UO(U d J UU rJdUA w r %
WUNM v rJ rQ
WOu
tA U w tM vK vIK* t b UNML{
w UI WLK 5M U
Ubu sLC
WLKJ c uDI* bu d*
uKO U c u
d* UI survie UI WQ b u
bI d UCH cU s d Ud `H WLK
tIU vK lI U wUL u WU bF
tUL w d* UI J w WOR s c
WLKJ b a
U*U td tULd w tu1 tU qO bF tH qLF UI q
UO vK WuGK WzU u UNO w dI UUJ V b survie u vK
W) UUF* bN' w ad
d
UC w rOI d UO v b
U bI wUO
ULK
oU WUJ uKO WHKH dU tUL
cM U cJ UFH
UJ
p JH
bb VOd w UNKUO n bOF WOM
WHKH Q
u*U dOJH U UFu tKO q v t{u wI c UL*
Ud
115
WHO tF td c uD*
u( w b bI p l u* rKF U U w
d* bI U u u*
b UF c w s dA sU w t dA buu
WuNO q 9 bF r UN U qOzd UNF w WU WUOU b
tH u( w tLKF
5*U( bU 5OO
uN rC
UA
ZUd WbI*
d W
_ v uFU
vK UNO Z
WU UNH WHOBK V dO_ tU w t{d dd vK s
VUK dB t ru ru
dI
w c w d UG w ULK tKLF WOdF
c UIeOUO* tOK fQ
b' pOJUb wd s b uLI*
c wJOJ
UC*
UI* WOuNH*
_ s b vK b fQ
WOKLF
WbC
WKUI* q UMOI WDO VK
UOI wMF WUF* wd b_ UB
b{
WUJK b dBM r tM UMd U U dJ U c UF* dUM
WOK
WU s u s nA
q WIOI( v d UIeOUO* bF
J
c wUHA
dH
UE o UF nd UM U 5LKJ VJ sM J WUJ s
lL&
5LEM 5du W WOCH ULKJ 5 U/ UM U UOzuA sJ 5F
uLF* qL c td%
U WF s rdU dJH WUO UO( dF w
116
WOK_ WLd b UN
bO_ U U
uKL tF uUF s lOL b c b UD UNKUJ
j/ s WbB oKF d_
vK rUH vK WLzU UN U
w wD sJ1 c
WFd tML{
WbB UUO tuM U L{ U U U c w b l{ UO
u uB
t sdUF sd JH tAO v uD cM WbB UHKH u WIO
wbB
bIFK
tH
dGU WU)
UOuuO* UNO b w UIeOUO* f_ tO u c wUI
wHKH
kdI s
w b d Uu du d_ tUUI dR tUUNO nMJ
WOUOJ
WO_
WdJH
rNUUb fR
b
iOH c qL s
d
dO b c tOM U sdUF* s b bb
s b U C qLA U uN wU u U ! fOd d s qC u
WOU*
dG w dOJ UNO ru
WE( w fU* U
vK qL WLd
UM
eK UL
bOF nO s d q 9 bF r
U dbU s l WK WUuD
dbU
UbK WOU Vd uM s bOF d J U tM td Q tQ
dF uH
eOOL UO w VB
s lM b uN WOU*_
uI
UM* wdF
S U U
Ub dJ d sd gOLN vK uI U OUu
U O U UD Q
dO wUd'
d
dOU u wdH
dUA WOC
u du v qLA sdAF dI
oOLF wzd
bUM uA fu WObB s qOMK u_ iF XUF UbM
s UA uM w td W
s qOM uI b u uu vK dOQ
tObB
uH w uA tU c wKFH
UAMU tO d
wMO1
U U b l{ dD
UO
u WOdH
wU
b bM b n u
WUI*
117
wU*_
qOBH XF WUI* dUM s U Wd WU
U bUB eF* tA
WH tU b uM u c uA UNOL
w WEK c U v
VFBuA*dIsWHOMwwC9d_sC%XUwWbBc
bF WbB XILF
tUC U tH s dONA uKO UU t
r
5OU
WUzd v tu bU d
uM q qdJ WK UNdA W w XH
5OMODKH l tH wA
u o
s uNO
dJHK WUM dO w b tN
w WuNO
Ub w UN fOU u q_
UNO U dBM* dI s UOMO
W WR
b q UNH b& sJ1 rzb Ud
sd pOuAO dM s U HOM bI tH vK d
WUA u{u qUJ c qF
rdE w WOuONB
w b c aU s UNd XU du v WuNO
qu uLN
b% d U
vM uN dUA u{u uNO Wd s rKJ U b
uF UUF0 WuNO
UUF* d vK d( rz U cJ WE( q
w v sU w
q
Wd& q
VK w U UJ dx U U tU u cF UJ U C d
UO dJ UI v UMOHO U U tU w t b U u c UD
WOd
UUL* d dd WKF UNO b U* tK VF dJ
ed
WOUu
118
WOK_ WLd b UN
dOJH UF c edM
b UI w UN WU UJS U
s UMFM9 tUHR
d
vK
bK 5F
qQ WUOU UD* W9U w tb tK c
b dJH hB
Europe U WOdH
WK* s b w dA u w
v s 5 U J 5Ld* 5U dI
s be* bF cN dJ c
oKF d_
dO WHzU s Uub b WHzU
WIOI v tU w b dOA WOHzU
5L UI
V dOB WOu tKLF 5Dd 5Od
dO UdG r_
VUG w
d JH VUG w r WOUO
q UMJ vK WOBF
WIKGM*U Ud w XFM uBM 5uH rNO d uKU
WUF
WUJ s rKJ UbM v bOBIU
rN U s dOJH bB
cN uJ d U sJ1 UL UUI* UUL bM
tUNOu tzUB
119
u qO U Ud c U c l s bB w tFC wGM U
U qCH b q
WbF
VN tKL l UuB q pc uKOH
s UNL
UIQ d_ UE wBA
t vK WU dJH aU w UN qO
U id iO w q W UNO W d s uJ U bF w WbF
qL WKU Wb s iL
w c U l s U CF q JA tK c dJH
vMF*U wUO
bF
U d hOB UM
WIOI( eU tH b tOL
U JOJH tu s UO_ uI
bF U dJH w YU
nAJO c ULF
WOdG
UIeOUOLK dJ u* pOJH v U WIdD pOJH aOd d= b
u
WU dOJH UNKO
WOuNH*
UNUI
WOU_
w VFA
wU{
d OJH uN
U WUOU U US eO9
b d u uJ
bI
qzU
WGU Uu{u s UNO U bU rJ( dHG WbB sbU
= WOU
WBs
uKcNWLbNA* bvUNldBF l sJ
wUdOJHw
UU
WU_ b d
`O 5OdA
b d
dc V uHF o(
WbF uB)
w o(
VK sJ
120
WOK_ WLd b UN
tNu
WUO UD wUO
QA wUO
q_U s D w UIeOUO* d w
UOML{
W d
F wUO
Udd%
wHKH
dBK dUG WU2 u d U O WOUM*
qLF oOLF U c w w dH
c
UD) s UD) w dJ WOR*
u b sJ
WOUD) UUL* nK
WIOI( eU UNK c 5 pc WOKLF
U dB(
UUMF0 WLd s bzU dOJH VKI U c uKOH v_ WbU
UFU bF
b dOF U Ou
b bI w uO) c lOL rE wJ
Wb
U&
UKDB U
UuNH q JA w `OUH* b dH wU
la traduction originaireWOK_
WLd tOL
b
UL
UM rKJQ WOzd
qO% w UUM u U c wL
WUJ `O WLd q U2 WLd
v UNCF bA
lU d
qFH iF
WMJL* WOKFH
tULd v U B
b U
dB(
UUMF0 WLdU
dO WOUD)
UUL* nK
d1
tK c U U* WOUD)
WLd dJ b VK
UN w WKUA bM b w n uQ
u
wdUE
UbF vK bU WLdK rNH WHKH bI
uOMF*
dE
WIKF* WOId
Yu U U UMF{ s U S tH qFHU dDO R
121
WOu
dUG s dCU bB sJ WLd v lb w tKUA U wMN*
gOF*U
nO WOu'
u
WLd v d U lb c UL wb
dUG* c uI rO
cK oOI% q
uFA v duE c q qO
wK t v bd Vc c rGU
U
U uFA oKF d_
WDd cKU UN U Dd qEO
WOOQ
b rd*U
U d
WO) dH uD u
lOOC ULK c bI bIH UH WOub*
UO( w u* uC q
s u_ uC( UO q
s d UL* UOG uF
sJ uI
uUM UU U
bJ
] WDK wzd
u
dO t ULO
lMB s
d* uJ s u) lOMB qLJ U UFU uFA
UL
dO
uJ s
b qLF ULKJ d
dH uFA p UUO pc tLK b tM
tM wUF U BI U O bO dUG* c U U/ t Q d{
t Q rd* lU0 cQ
tKO% WOU
VI( iF sJ
UNO dL uJ b UI hI _
tG tUI
WUI WG XU u WOHJ UN U WG W
WUI W r
WKU UNH bF
UuLK U F
hM
rN
uJ UbF WLd v rd* lb c U o U0 jd R d UL
U t
tQ s c VdG dBMF 5buN 5GO v UM l dF U rN
122
WOK_ WLd b UN
c w UM wuB)
dBMF uN vK eH Wb
lOM u
U& qFH
uGK
bF
WLd s dONA tU w u
bb VOd v Uu WU(
]
WAF s bb j/ s Y s dMU u b
uu*
AfterBabelqU bF
dOFK uAOM
vMF*U uIK
e'
WbI*
s pc U Ud dOF WOc
cU WN uI
_ vK UJF w w ULKJ u
WNu v rd* lb
lb UN bOIF d w U/ WQ*
UMd 5UOM dU dOJH bB cN uD
c dEM*
WLd UOuuuMO uK w u s bF
v_ mU dc
5LK
5H s bOu
UO
5Uu
u dF
UUI*
pc wOQ
U_ dOF WOUuO
WGK w b b YL rKF oDM* u
WdF
WOUd
v WOUuO
s UNKzb WLd UUO bI F dB w ULd
UQ* qU dE w hK
bF
c s_ sU uGK
vK uKU wIKO WOdFU
qUJ WOdF
VOB s oDM* sJ r r
Wd0 uM
U UNCUF WF WOdF
XK XUJ UCU
5IUM uI w dL Uu q UJ_ U u t bR
WOM
U/ uGK
bF
c uKOH U$ dN U1 bF
vK bF s bR
bO
w U UNF U UUI WL
uKF WFO w WFOD wH WON
WOA0 rzU u
r UF w tuJ U
wDdI
wdF
uKOH nu s U WR*
= c UI dJ bM tH u
UOU WOzU
bF
WEK bM dOJH
UGK UH WE( WOKU
WE( wM_
bd WUF
dO b uD tBIM XU
uB hIM c d cU wQ WLd
Xd U w c WOOQ
qU uD v udU Wd v bF
WMF u%
kOGU dOGU dF
b UMd UGKU UM dA UuF qGA
b tK
UL
tUH w UD YO UA bd uU c d c dA lOM s dd*
uI _ r tL uJ Q dQ
UGK s WbF
w ULd
bb WOuLA
WGK pOJH d pOJH tK d e cN b V
w UNFM
WGK UO tFM0 UF
w
b
W b rB
WLdU e
WG
c Wbb
dI c vCI0 tK uJ WOuLA
dA 5OdF
s WUF
w cF
Wd{
WLd `B cJ r UFK u uGK
ULF wuLA
qIF
bndictionbO
v ub
v u
u Wd
WBB
uKOH cN W d b U bI mMKO wU*_
u d uKO UN
rd rd WLd
rU wN
du' qu v sUO* c lOL eM c rLF*
WLd lOMB
ULK WdF* UM s b q
WdF* c w
UNO dA w b w w WOK_
124
WOK_ WLd b UN
uJ s tb UI uJ w
p WAFM WO
WOK
UC s uC q qFH
dL*
bF*
tKLF hIM s uF
U LJ tK wK&
UI dO ub
WLdU vb U w Wd{
Ue c
WOKU
WEK s UNH Wb wH UF WOUJU c UI UI dJ XO
WuD) qK; h vK dJ W;
UUMF0 WKu
dUA UI wHM wKOK
Ue
W w b t UH vK WLd bI bQ b lL Ud U M UM
]
s Wb*
dJHK bB
UNuM WLd s bz
b 5UOM dU U rd* WLN
UB UUU WLd
jO ubLK qI w U0 WLd hM
s tUB sJ1 U*
UMJ2 UNzUI UL o ZCM WU dE w u tU9S U Mb uJ U t hM
eK U
s hM
rd* s J1 c UIU UUB v c UI UC dJH lbO b wQ
nR* u bF uu WKu b*
UMF0 UIU t W tuK
s d gOFO t q V u U M UO qLF vI fO b V
sb* wK_
hMsqFU
2 tu
wK1euUMdAdHLK
uIvMF*U
gOF tLd wJ rd
UL tOK b
rd* S UMb _
dO h
q
dJ s Ze wbu
iUM s u d UMN qu% UB U W qF q
w
WOM tNu
d
VUJ h S W;
S q rd*
tK c tG tH hM
d U O t _ w dOB tH WLd w qE h
d
5G 5 U
UNO w WGK tG tH rd* d U C u
WLd tO uJ d rd
U{ WLd vI K UF U ILF
5UOM U zU b WU w cJ e -U WU0
125
WOU_
b UO wMF Uu sLC
wULd
qFH UOuuuMO Q
UI
wb
pM
dCU WId* WF* Q s dOuK UJUJ
qJ
s d
tUL WLd WUF
WLdU oKF WK vK U O
b rKJ WU
L u d k
rd* k
w
s WLd w qLA r
UF* UIK
uKD* qJAvMF* s dOF w Uu UNOUC w dH* UI k( eF* WE(
fO UI UF uF U1 s Q
UI dU rd*
p UOU UOI WE(
5 UFH
_ WUM* WLKJ UM u wA UM W U C UN WO WGK q u
u B
UMFb w uF w WOOQ
v A UNK 9 U v U I sH
5LOI 5OK
UM VK W w tLd wK_
hM
cJ
b q
UI tuM h
d uK
b 5Dd w uJ tH b h
Larrt de mort u* WH
uKF
jdA UNKI U WLd qI UL
U u d_ UMuB
UKI UL wKH
UNO eH
WLd qI p l qE
tLd cF U f
U2 WLd vK vQ
uGK uN p l qIM rNH vK dO b wKH
d JH V
U cF WLd WOKU
WeM0 dOJH v bb b
hM
5 `Q u WUF
126
WOK_ WLd b UN
hM
gOF uI
UI
s izU UOK UO u U0 UIK uc* vMF*U hM
U t _ w sJ r vI u UIU uu sJ r
W LdK qU dO
qI U2 bOd
jdA
uJ wKH
cN UNUI Q WLdK qU dO hM
U hM
v uN tOK
5UOM dOF U*
uJ UbM b t U IU qE
w WLdK
U
U FM2 U U uG
b WUJ h
WLd vK WOKJU
u U0 b dE w
U
tG wK_
tU q JA t bIF U b w v
lb cN d dI* qLF d
dI
UHM b w bN d q w 5bIM
tu
b
be w_
wdF*
d
s b UNOK iI VKD wUF* s We U& w Y
U hM
WU WUb UOK U F d vMFLK WUF
q qI
WK u u
Uu WKU _ vMF* w U d WO
dUF* bb WuO(
WGU UM b w UF c oK b U WLd
d WG vK WG XK
d_ W GK nM F WG rOC
U
UNOK XK
w UFH
bF
w UH sJ2 dO qE nMF c q UNOK jK UNd&
uGK
UNO U qC uI UGK lb tKCH WdF0 t D{ t wu V WLd
tH u qE
c bOBI dI U U b d c nMF cN tO u
dU wK_
UNU nM F UNG vK U HM b w U9 bOBIU u B
bF
127
tO tM Ubu d UUJ d b q vK tU d
bIM U1 wK_
nMF c d vK dUA UdE w u U WdBO
WOKL
sL u
vK U Lz d( l bOBIK
w qE
Ud
vK wzUNM
s UIM bOBI nAJ
dI vKF b J UbI
pN Q t s tK s hM
d&
d lOL
nMF s jLM cN tuB uI UHMU rOIF U
w jI
UH sJ1 fO t vMF
U d uO bOBI 5UN
u d VU dJ U w b WKU vK U FU
s q
WUL{ w lL' w O U WOU*_U
wU
d
5 b WuO
dUA UM
WbIM
dI dI b b WUF
UIK 5 uNH WLd WbIM
dI
UIK WOd
ub U* u
U_ mU bN1
uKOH UNF{ b U w O
dOU wU*_
d UDI WEK
U tc c bN' s b
O bOBI U Hu tH b b dOU U
WU vK iIK bOBI
U b U U( UUUD vK WCIM WM A b b
d_
lM L lM9 Wd uJ
c uN* c
b Wuu Wd
Wd vb p bF o
q d dOF
q
Wd
vK iIK dUA tc
du v b dE w dOAO WOBF* d*
sL
lOL uI cJ qO* sJL* UHu lOL vK qQ WLd w bN
q
tu
U v WFM L* bOU bOBI UNHB w WF v dI c w b U
128
WOK_ WLd b UN
5OUM dO u UH s
UU&
w `M c b U qU VDI bOBI WOI
s eFM dO U O
w pc O dOU s q dJ
d w b WU w dHC
b u
qQ rK UIODuMdN WdFA
s q
dFA dI UNLd w uNF* b( We
uI jO XO u WHKH wHM
qOK
] bF
s UMLd U wU*_
qO vK
XO b rd UI 5O
V
UL dI UL bF
tO 5 MLC*
5UF 5 WCUG WF UC
pKL wKF
bF r UF 5MJ2 ULUK E 5KU vK tUO US
v ld aU VOG bF r UF pKL wK
uJ ULO bF rUF
w U uI c U wK
q VOG
u d 5OF
UNO wK
wGM w WOF WEK c w VOG aU bF r UF pc
qL rd d sLC
wK
dOF S
pKL wGM ULO VOG rUF
]
qLF cN tCdF s tUN te s tUO w dN vK d
d*
tu
UQ eeF qd
v wJ WUM b( U w tUL WKU bd UMd c
qL vK Wu
WPJ s tUH WU w iL
c tLN wM e v
tO w c UO( bO vK e U d
uJ 5 v tO b c c dJH qFH
129
tOe U uB u* tu t _ w U C tu
d u
s tF Vu
c sL w WUO q JA u bd dE w `UM b(
qL tO c rzb v_ p d
U k
q
sLD
= UO
n tM qC qE
aU VOG
rUF bF ULO d qL vK cU uI
dI WLd vK oD
UMOI K b lu
wHJ
s s JL v c b h
c w q L
UNLd bOF O bOB tM U D b dI c dx qL (
U0 bOKI
bIM
d* WOHMW
OKOK
dI w b* U iF UMdO UbI
Wb( bOKI
tO
bM tOK c wU_
fK c O XO c q* tH bIU 5MJ2
VJ
l{u* p
b t _ w W
bOBI q JA UNM; WLd U W
UOIK ub
WLd UM wUU W Ld b b
WGK Wd bOu rz*
UK
R U cJ VO
U MJ2 qO* WU qO*U
UdF
W GK qUF
U UFH
130
WOK_ WLd b UN
WEI w d_ u cJ WOK
bF
UNNu
WLd uGK
uB w U uB
b
fuqsULK
wU( fOUNuMWw fufLO'UGOMO
UNO dH WeOK$
WGK u bLF
UUMF wahr WOU*_
dJ
fu
wIOI
d u U0 U OIOI
U d u U0 U
WOdH
WLd c ub qN WeOK$
tM bOKI
WGK tI pK1 U UM wb WU v tu
r
qLF q wBA
V qOb w U0 w
UNN w UM uQ ULKJ dJ v
WLd w UL dI w U
nKK dCU cM*
tH b XOJO fu
tU dOJ U s 5b WU bI
UF*
vMF* s rzb UNUe ULKJK WOU'
U{ wUF* bF
UF UM
131
c tOK
u
U c s WOBF* Vu' iF U bN' Q
= WOL ud tM rKF
dFA
U uJ UJ
UO
iF Q
dI
s sJ ULN
5Ld* vK ULC* c w U$ iF WOL
w U rNULd
se* U U {d XFM UL WMe uB UNO dEM U wGM U
p l wGM dC
v WUI q JAO c Ub v uI
l{u c
WORLK
U bF c uJO WIKD* WUU uI
sJ1 UL WU uN
c b WLd sJ1 suc* U J Q tQ
d dd WdFA
UNU vB w ULKJ qUF WU ub UNO w WUJ WU2
u
bF c WLdU c WUJ UGA rd v UOML{
u uU
U*d c UC b wQ q WOK_
WLdU u U UL WUJU WLdK
uB U U dF
UL tUHO wU tOK U uJ rd* U tOL
*
WU uU UN r J XL
UHO w wHM
qOK w ld
n u U*U b
bF
v dJH cN wUO
vM v dO dOA wGM
UF
dK iFK b WOUO
bUA 5 b WOK_
WLd s u U bM
UL WODK
U_ dO_ tUHR s b w UI WMJ2 dO W{UF
U WOd
UJF U 5OUO
UD) bNALK WILF*
OK s WKK
132
WOK_ WLd b UN
U
d WN s t b W
U9 w WU
s dJF sdJF*
rNH bF
q Xu b UUD WMOF
UU tUF tK tU
Ub XU
*UF
WUIWb
WOKOKCUUL*b
UOUwzUNMDb`UB
b1
UNK s iL
w
U2 sdJF*
U rJ
s WL{ WOUU
UFA
w
WLd WOKU
U c
s b nAJ bN b U
wd
5 c
U( q JA q R vKF WOHKH
b(
WH uuO w w*UF U ed
q
U t Q dI
U b uJ bK dbU ndF V Ub
VFB
sL p
vK vQ
U UD UMd vK UMOK dH qF
tF u tUU qI d WIKD b
b q
o
UFA q
Xd
UOKL
XU UI l u s U OzU dA U( U qN
b WU; u w WOU
u{u v u%
UL 5d
b Ud
U bb ULN UA u
s qOM
U 5d
P* Wd* WOF
u c w uHM U dO U nd UNO
q UNFOM XU w WuUJb
WLE_ lA l WOzd L*
WUO ULNOK td
WOJd_
e U vK c WOR*
s dN b dE w dH
w w Ud bB q JA
U( tU u d rU b( WOL s eF
iO_ XO WUO wK1
s U U UU duB rN VOD qF U dN c s q s dFO uK s dA
133
fJOKO u qO UuKOH dc
WHKH w U dA* ULNU w
WOdFU
_u(
wdUNVUUdJbW1bIUuOwWHKH
QUu
d
UF b b w qdJ w dA c uD c VU tF d c
qUJU U O
tuJ dFA r t rKF uN w c w b
uIU b
wM Q f
b UL tU9 Xd
U c U l s b U C w WUFH
b c
fU
1- Jacques Derrida, Je suis en guerre contre moi-mme , entretien ralis par Jean
Birnbaum, Le Monde, Paris, 18 aot, 2004.
2- Jacques Derrida, Politiques de lamiti, d. Galile, Paris, 1994.
3- Jacques Derrida, Pour Paul Celan, d. Galile, Paris, 1986.
4- Jacques Derrida, Adieu Emmanuel Lvinas, d. Galile, Paris, 1997.
5- Jacques Derrida, La vrit blessante , entretien ralis par ?velyne Grossman,
Europe, n 901, Paris, mai, 2004.
6- Jacques Derrida, Tours de Babel , Psych Inventions de lautre, d. Galile, 1987,
pp. 203-204.
7- Jacques Derrida, Les langages et les institutions de la philosophie , Texte, n 4,
Toronto, 1985.
134
WOK_ WLd b UN
8- Op. cit., p. 39.
135