A Note to William,If you examine your arguments presented in the videos overall, there is only one that isabsolute, a few that are suggestive, and the rest are lacking in citation or basis.The unfortunate fact is that during your refutation of the Siri Thesis, as your videos aretitled, you did not actually target the Siri Thesis directly in full, as to debate all its particular claims. What you have done instead is deviated to alternate sources wherein theclaim of the Siri Thesis was neither completely disputed, but points challenged andmerely touched upon.The Siri Thesis is not just about Cardinal Siri, but contains so many more points thatwere totally neglected. At multiple times, you attempted to refute the Popeinred.com,which contrary to the name of videos, may have seemed somewhat relevant, however this brought into the debate aspects that were simply not relevant to this refutation, such asyour interpretation of Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich’s vision. The videos wereriddled which much logical fallacies, with generalizations, with insincere remarks(concerning Fr. Khoat and Cardinal Siri – regarding his pains & sufferings in particular),and other undesirables not suited in the context of a formal debate (refutation).I’m not sure what to make of your videos on an academic level, nevertheless I do acceptit as an honest attempt to challenge the Siri Thesis. But, if someone asked me if thesevideos were indeed a “refutation” of the Siri Thesis, I would have to say ‘No’.Why? Because the Siri Thesis was not actually deconstructed point by point – reducing itto its fundamental arguments – then refuting it, in these videos. What seems rather to bethe case was that you may have read it, then read other alternate sources, then assumed anentirely independent thought of what the Siri Thesis actually was, then from this refutedthat particular creation. What I had originally hoped was that you would have refuted theSiri Thesis as it presented itself, understood for what the Siri Thesis holds, and not for what others hold or don’t hold for it. Nonetheless, nothing lost, however, by the grace of God may our understanding of this be brought to that perfect clarity, who is Christ.God bless.