Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more ➡
Standard view
Full view
of .
Add note
Save to My Library
Sync to mobile
Look up keyword
Like this
2Activity
×
P. 1
Concurring opinion on SC decision re: constitutionality of Cybercrime Law (Justice Brion)

Concurring opinion on SC decision re: constitutionality of Cybercrime Law (Justice Brion)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 5,207|Likes:
Published by Rappler Philippines
data from the Supreme Court
data from the Supreme Court

More info:

Published by: Rappler Philippines on Feb 24, 2014
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See More
See less

02/25/2014

 
J.\. Ia. <67773
-
DAWC DCWSW K. @NWNIN, D\., CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v.
PBC WCG\CP H\^ AE DSWPNGC, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. J.\. Ia. <67<>>
-
OSNW LH\AM G. LN\HAJA,
Vctntnaicr
v.
IHPNAIHO LS\CHS AE NIUCWPNJHPNAI, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <67765
-
HOHL
IJ
KHKHKHBH ^HJ (HOHK), CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. AEENGC AE PBC V\CWN@CIP, CP HO,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <6773>
-
WCIHPA\ PCAENWPA @O JSNIJAIH NNN,
Vctntnaicr
v. PBC CRCGSPNUC WCG\CPH\^, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <677:2
-
HOCRHI@C\ H@AINW, CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. PBC CRCGSPNUC WCG\CPH\^, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <677>8
-
BAI. \H^KAI@ U. VHOHPNIA,
Vctntnaicrs
v. BAI. VHXSNPA I. AGBAH,
D\.
CP
HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <6706:
-
LHJAIJ HO^HIWHIJ KHMHLH^HI WCG\CPH\^ JCIC\HO \CIHPA K. \C^CW, D\., CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. LCINJIA WNKCAI G. HXSNIA NNN,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <67006
-
KCOCIGNA
W.
WPH. KH\NH, CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. BAI.
V
XSNPA AGBAH,
CP
HO.,
\cspai`cits.
J.\. Ia. <67037
-
IHPNAIHO SINAI AE DAS\IHONWPW AE PBC VBNNONVVNICW, CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. PBC CRCGSPNUC WCG\CPH\^,
CP
HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <67030
-
VHSO GA\ICONSW P. GHWPNOOA, CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. PBC BAI. WCG\CPH\^ AE DSWPNGC, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <6705>
-
HIPBAI^ NHI K. G\ST, CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v.
BNW CRGCOOCIG^ LCINJIA
W.
HXSNIA NNN, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <67368
-
VBNONVVNIC
L \
HWWAGNHPNAI, NIG.,
Vctntnaicr
v.
BNW CRGCOOCIG^ LCINJIA
W.
HXSNIA NNN, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <6736>
-
LH^ HI KSIH \CV\CWCIPHPNUC IC\N
D
GAOKCIH\CW,
Vctntnaicr
v. PBC CRCGSPNUC WCG\CPH\^ VHXSNPA AGBAH, D\.,
\cspai`cit=
J.\. Ia. <67383
-
IHPNAIHO V\CWW GOSL AE PBC VBNONVVNICW, NIG.,
CP
HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v. AEENGC AE PBC V\CWN@CIP, V\CWN@CIP LCINJIA WNKCAI HXSNIA NNN, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits=
J.\. Ia. <67382
-
VBNONVVNIC NIPC\ICP E\CC@AK HOONHIGC, CP HO.,
Vctntnaicrs
v.
PBC CRCGSPNUC WCG\CP H\^, CP HO.,
\cspai`cits.
Vrakuojhtc`4
ECL\SH\^
82
<680
r
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 x
WCVH\HPC GAIGS\\NIJ AVNINAI
L\NAI
D 4
H. Gaigurrcigcs @nsscits
Pcgbiaoajy hi` nts gaitniuc` rhpn` `cvcoapkcit ni tbc
<8st
gcitury bhvc lcci pusbnij autwhr` tbc laui`hrncs
ae
tbc ohw, gakpcoonij icw rcspaiscs hi` tbc rc`cenintnai
ae
eui`hkcitho rnjbts erak tbcnr arnjniho
 
Wcphrhtc Gaigurrnij Apninai < J.\. Ia. <67<>>
earkuohtnai= ciohrjnij tbc icc` ear, hi` tbc kchis ae, javcrikcitho rcjuohtnai= hi` karc nkparthitoy, sbhrpcinij tbc gaoonsnai lctwcci tbc ni`nvn`uho„s cxcrgnsc ae eui`hkcitho rnjbts hi` javcrikcitho icc` ear nitcrvcitnai. Ni tbns mni` ae gaoonsnai, tbc Gaurt ‗ hs gaistntutnaihooy `csnjic` ‗ eni`s ntscoe ni tbc kn``oc, lhohignij nts `uty ta
 pratcgt ni`nvn`uhos
„ cxcrgnsc ae eui`hkcitho rnjbts, wntb tbc
Wthtc„s nitcrvcitnai
 (tbraujb rcjuohtnai hi` nkpockcithtnai) ni tbc pcrearkhigc ae nts `uty
 ta pratcgt sagncty
. Nt ns erak tbns vhithjc panit tbht tbc Gaurt, tbraujb tbc
 paicignh
, goascoy cxhknic` tbc Gylcrgrnkc prcvcitnai Hgt (
Gylcrgrnkc Ohw
) hi` tbc vhon`nty ae tbc vhrnaus  pravnsnais tbc pctntnaicrs gbhoocijc`. N wrntc tbns Wcphrhtc Gaigurrnij Apninai
 ta jcicrhooy suppart tbc  paicignh,
 hotbaujb ky vatc khy lc
quhonenc` ni sakc pravnsnais
 ar
ni  `nsscit wntb rcspcgt ta atbcrs
. Ni onic wntb tbc Gaurt„s ‟pcr pravnsnai‛ hpprahgb hi` ear chsc ae rcecrcigc, N bhvc thluohtc` ky vatcs hi` bhvc htthgbc` tbc thluohtnai hi` cxpohihtnai hs Hiicx ‟H‛ ae tbns Wcphrhtc Apninai. Pbns Apninai onmcwnsc euooy cxpohnis ky vatc wntb h euoo `nsgussnai ae
ky awi rchsais hi` quhonenghtnais
 ni tbc hrchs wbcrc N ecco h euoo `nsgussnai ns ghooc` ear. N hk thmnij tbns hpprahgb ni
Wcgtnai 8<
ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw ni ky vatc ear nts uigaistntutnaihonty. Ky quhonenghtnais gakc, hkaij atbcrs, ni tcrks ae ky hotcrihtnvc vncw tbht wauo` lhohigc gylcrgrnkc ohw cieargckcit wntb tbc pratcgtnai ae aur gntnzciry„s rnjbt ta prnvhgy. N gaigur wntb tbc
 paicignh„s
 eni`nij tbht
 gylcr-onlco 
 hs `cenic` ni Wcgtnai 0(g)(0) ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw `acs iat aeeci` tbc Gaistntutnai. N `a iat hjrcc, bawcvcr, wntb tbc
 paicignh„s
 uotnkhtc gaigousnai tbht tbc vhon`nty ns
‟aioy wntb rcspcgt ta tbc arnjniho hutbar ae tbc past‛
 hi` tbht gylcr-onlco ns uigaistntutnaiho
‟wntb rcspcgt ta atbcrs wba snkpoy rcgcnvc tbc  past hi` rchgt ta nt.‛
 N lconcvc tbht tbc gaistntutnaiho sthtus ae gylcr-onlco bnijcs, iat ai Wcgtnai 0(g)(0), lut ai tbc pravnsnais tbht h`` ta hi` quhoney onlco ni nts hpponghtnai ta Nitcrict gakkuinghtnais. Ear cxhkpoc, hs tbc
 paicignh
 `acs, N eni` tbht
Wcgtnai 3
8
 ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw
 (wbngb pcihonzcs hn`nij, hlcttnij ar httckptnij ta gakknt h gylcrgrnkc) ns uigaistntutnaiho ear tbc rchsais euooy cxpohnic` lcoaw, hi` sbauo` iat hppoy ta gylcr-onlco. N onmcwnsc hjrcc wntb Gbnce Dustngc Wcrcia„s panit ai tbc uigaistntutnaihonty ae hppoynij
Wcgtnai 5 ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw
 (wbngb
8
 Wcgtnai 3. Atbcr Aeeciscs. Pbc eaooawnij hgts sbhoo hosa gaistntutc hi aeecisc4 (h) Hn`nij ar Hlcttnij ni tbc Gakknssnai ae Gylcrgrnkc. ‗ Hiy pcrsai wba wnoeuooy hlcts ar hn`s ni tbc gakknssnai ae hiy ae tbc aeeciscs ciukcrhtc` ni tbns Hgt sbhoo lc bco` onhloc. (l) Httckpt ni tbc Gakknssnai ae Gylcrgrnkc. ‐ Hiy pcrsai wba wnoeuooy httckpts ta gakknt hiy ae tbc aeeciscs ciukcrhtc` ni tbns Hgt sbhoo lc bco` onhloc.
 
Wcphrhtc Gaigurrnij Apninai 7 J.\. Ia. <67<>>
 pcihonzcs grnkcs gakknttc` tbraujb niearkhtnai gakkuinghtnais tcgbiaoajy) hi` nkpasc ai onlco h pcihoty aic `cjrcc bnjbcr. Eurtbcr, N dani Dustngc Ghrpna„s ghoo ta `cgohrc
Hrtngoc 730 ae tbc \cvnsc` Vciho Ga`c
 uigaistntutnaiho wbci hpponc` ta onlcooaus sthtckcits gakknttc` hjhnist pulong aeengcrs hi` enjurcs, hi` ta iuooney tbc hpponghtnai ae
Wcgtnai : ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw
 ta gylcr-onlco. Ai tbc atbcr gaitcit-rcohtc` aeeciscs ni tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw, N gaigur wntb tbc
 paicignh
 ni upbao`nij tbc gaistntutnaihonty ae
Wcgtnai 0(g)(8)
 ai gylcrscx hi` Wcgtnai
0(g)(<)
 ai gbno` pariajrhpby gakknttc` tbraujb gakputcr systcks, hi` ni strnmnij `awi hs uigaistntutnaiho
Wcgtnai 0(g)(7)
 ear vnaohtnij tbc ercc`ak ae spccgb. N hosa hjrcc tbht
Wcgtnai 3
<
 ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw
, ni sa ehr hs nt  puinsbcs hn`nij, hlcttnij ar httckptnij ta gakknt aionic gakkcrgnho saongnthtnai, gylcr-onlco hi` aionic gbno` pariajrhpby, vnaohtcs tbc Gaistntutnai. Ohstoy, N phrtnhooy suppart tbc
 paicignh
„s pasntnai tbht
Wcgtnai 8>
7
 ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw (wbngb ckpawcrs tbc Wcgrcthry ae tbc @cphrtkcit ae Dustngc ta rcstrngt ar loagm hggcss ta gakputcr `hth eaui` ta lc ni vnaohtnai ae nts pravnsnais) ns uigaistntutnaiho ear vnaohtnij tbc rnjbt ta ercc`ak ae cxprcssnai.
L.
 
Ky Vasntnais ai Gylcr-onlco L.8. Pbc Garc Kchinij hi` Gaistntutnaihonty ae Wcgtnai 0(g)(0)
Lhsc` ai h
 ehgnho cxhknihtnai
 ae Wcgtnai 0(g)(0) ae tbc Gylcrgrnkc Ohw, N eni` ia rchsai ta `cgohrc gylcr-onlco ar tbc hpponghtnai ae Wcgtnai 733 ae tbc \cvnsc` Vciho Ga`c (tbht pcihonzcs onlco kh`c ni prnit hi` atbcr earks ae kc`nh, ta Nitcrict gakkuinghtnais) uigaistntutnaiho. Ohws pcihonznij onlco iarkhooy pnt twa gakpctnij vhoucs hjhnist chgb atbcr ‗ tbc eui`hkcitho rnjbt ta ercc`ak ae spccgb ai aic bhi`, hi` tbc sthtc nitcrcst„s ta pratcgt pcrsais hjhnist tbc bhrkeuo gai`ugt ae atbcrs. Pbc ohttcr gai`ugt pcrthnis ta sgurrnoaus spccgb tbht `hkhjcs tbc rcputhtnai ae tbc pcrsai nt h``rcsscs. Durnspru`cigc bhs oaij scttoc` tbns hpphrcit gaieongt
<
 Wcgtnai 3. Atbcr Aeeciscs. Pbc eaooawnij hgts sbhoo hosa gaistntutc hi aeecisc4 (h) Hn`nij ar Hlcttnij ni tbc Gakknssnai ae Gylcrgrnkc. ‗ Hiy pcrsai wba wnoeuooy hlcts ar hn`s ni tbc gakknssnai ae hiy ae tbc aeeciscs ciukcrhtc` ni tbns Hgt sbhoo lc bco` onhloc. (l) Httckpt ni tbc Gakknssnai ae Gylcrgrnkc. ‐ Hiy pcrsai wba wnoeuooy httckpts ta gakknt hiy ae tbc aeeciscs ciukcrhtc` ni tbns Hgt sbhoo lc bco` onhloc.
7
 Wcgtnai 8>. \cstrngtnij ar Loagmnij Hggcss ta Gakputcr @hth. Zbci h gakputcr `hth ns prnkh ehgnc eaui` ta lc ni vnaohtnai ae tbc pravnsnais ae tbns Hgt, tbc @AD sbhoo nssuc hi ar`cr ta rcstrngt ar loagm hggcss ta sugb gakputcr `hth.

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->