Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
Dissenting and concurring opinion on SC decision re: constitutionality of Cybercrime Law (Justice Carpio)

Dissenting and concurring opinion on SC decision re: constitutionality of Cybercrime Law (Justice Carpio)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 31,194|Likes:
Published by Rappler Philippines
data from the Supreme Court
data from the Supreme Court

More info:

Published by: Rappler Philippines on Feb 24, 2014
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See more
See less

04/20/2015

 
EF
KIFA N.[. Fo. ;:1115 -
BOQE
BEQUQ
M. LCQCFC,
B[.,
t
id. Zetctcofers
v
\GE
QEA[E\I[S
O@
BUQ\CAE,
et id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1;33 -DUCQ
Kiroh
A. KC[IONO,
Zetctcofer
v
FI\COFID KU[EIU
O@
CFPEQ\CNI\COF,
et id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:11:0 -IDIK
FN
MIMIMIGISIN IDIM),
et id. Zetctcofers
v
O@@CAE O@ \GE
Z[EQCLEF\,
t
id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1153 -QEFI\O[
\EO@CQ\O LD
NUCFNOFI
CCC,
Zetctcofer
v
\GE
EWEAU\CPE
QEA[E\I[S,
t
id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:11>7 -IDEWIFLE[ ILOFCQ,
t
id. Zetctcofers
v
\GE
EWEAU\CPE QEA[E\I[S,
et id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1139
-¾
GOF. [ISMOFL
P
ZIDI\CFO,
Zetctcofer
v
GOF. ZIYUC\O F.
OAGOI, B[.,
t
id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1<:> -KINOFN IDSIFQIFN MIHIKISIF QEA[E\I[S
NEFE[ID
[EFI\O M. [ESEQ,
B[.,
t
id. Zetctcofers
v
KEFCNFO
QCMEOF
A. IYUCFO
CCC,
et id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1<<: -
MEDEFACO
Q. Q\I. MI[CI,
t
id. Zetctcofers
v
GOF. ZIYUC\O
OAGOI,
t
id. [espoflefts8¾N.[.
Fo. ;:1<51 -FI\COFID UFCOF
O@
BOU[FIDCQ\Q
O@ \GE
ZGCDCZZCFEQ,
et id. Zetctcofers
v
\GE
EWEAU\CPE QEA[E\I[S,
t
id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1<5< -ZIUD AO[FEDCUQ
\
AIQ\CDDO,
et id. Zetctcofers
v
\GE
GOF. QEA[E\I[S
O@
BUQ\CAE,
et id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1<03 -IF\GOFS CIF M. A[UR,
et id. Zetctcofers
v
GCQ EWAEDDEFAS
KEFCNFO
Q
IYUCFO
CCC,
t
id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:15:9 -
ZGCDCZZCFE
KI[
IQQOACI\COF, CFA.,
Zetctcofer
v
GCQ EWAEDDEFAS
KEFCNFO
Q
IYUCFO
CCC,
t
id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:15:3 -
KISIF
MUFI [EZ[EQEF\I\CPE
FE[C
B.
AODMEFI[EQ,
Zetctcofer
v
\GE
EWEAU\CPE QEA[E\I[S ZIYUC\O
OAGOI, B[.,
[espofleft8
N.[. Fo. ;:1595 -FI\COFID
Z[EQQ
ADUK
O@ \GE
ZGCDCZZCFEQ,
CFA.,
et id. Zetctcofers
v
O@@CAE O@ \GE
Z[EQCLEF\, Z[EQCLEF\ KEFCNFO
QCMEOF
IYUCFO
CCC,
et id. [espoflefts8
N.[. Fo. ;:1597 -
ZGCDCZZCFE
CF\E[FE\ @[EELOM
IDDCIFAE,
t
id. Zetctcofers
v
\GE
EWEAU\CPE QEA[E\I[S,
et id. [espoflefts.
Zromudnitel2
@EK[UI[S
~7
; 9<~
x---------~------------------------------~--------------------------------~------------x
r
AOFAU[[CFN IFL LCQQEF\CFN OZCFCOF
XA]orporitcofs
o`
idd sgipes ifl sczes triah wgit you
kuy
store ifl ifidyze our
liti
ifl use ct
`or
aommeracid purposes8 tgits gow tgose tirnetel ils pop up of your aomputer or smirtpgofe. Kut idd
o`
us uflerstifl tgit tge stiflirls `or noverfmeft survecddifae must ke
gcnger.
Ncvef tge ufcque power
o`
ge
stite ct cs fot efoung `or deilers to siy2
 
Aofaurrcfn ifl Lcsseftcfn Opcfcof ; N.[. Fos. ;:1115,
et id
.
trust us, we wof–t ikuse tge liti we aoddeat. @or gcstory gis too mify eximpdes wgef tgit trust gis keef kreiagel.
Our system o` noverfmeft cs  kucdt of tge premcse tgit our dckerty aiffot lepefl of tge nool cfteftcofs  o` tgose cf power8 ct lepefls upof tge diw to aofstricf tgose cf power
.
9
 
Zrescleft Kiriah Okimi
 
9> Bifuiry ;:9<, of Fitcofid Qeaurcty Inefay [e`orms
AI[ZCO,
 B 
.2
 
C aofaur cf strchcfn lowf is ufaofstctutcofid Qeatcof <(a)(1), Qeatcof >, Qeatcof 9;, ifl Qeatcof 93 o` [epukdca Iat Fo. 9:9>5 ([I 9:9>5) (9)  pefidczcfn ufsodcactel aommeracid speeag8 (;) iddowcfn mudtcpde proseautcofs  post-aofvcatcof ufler [I 9:9>58 (1) iutgorczcfn tge wirriftdess aoddeatcof cf  kudh o` tri``ca liti8 ifl (<) iutgorczcfn tge extribulcacid restrcatcof or kdoahcfn o` iaaess to aomputer liti, respeatcvedy, `or kecfn vcoditcve o` tge @ree Qpeeag, Qeirag ifl Qeczure, Zrcviay o` Aommufcaitcof, ifl Loukde Beopirly Adiuses. C lcsseft, gowever, `rom tge aofaduscof tgit (9) Irtcade 15< o` tge [evcsel Zefid Aole (Aole) areitcfn tge presumptcof o` midcae cf le`imitory cmputitcofs, ifl (;) Qeatcof <(a)(9) o` [I 9:9>5 pefidczcfn —aykersex,” ire fot equiddy vcoditcve o` tge aofstctutcofid nuiriftees o` `reelom o` speeag ifl expresscof. C tgere`ore vote to leadire Irtcade 15< o` tge Aole, is `ir is ct ippdces to pukdca o``caers ifl pukdca `cnures, ifl Qeatcof <(a)(9) o` [I 9:9>5, ufaofstctutcofid `or vcoditcfn Qeatcof <, Irtcade CCC o` tge Aofstctutcof.
 Irtcade 15< o` tge Aole [epunfift to  tge @ree Qpeeag Adiuse  Irtcade 15<–s Zresumptcof o` Midcae  Crreaofacdikde wctg @ree Qpeeag Burcsprulefae Of Dcked o` Zukdca O``caers ifl Zukdca  @cnures
Irtcade <(a)(<) o` [I 9:9>5 cmpdceldy re-ilopts Irtcade 15< o` tge Aole
wctgout ify quidc`caitcof
. Irtcade 15< tooh e``eat tgree yeirs
;
 ke`ore tge ritc`caitcof o` tge 9315 Aofstctutcof tgit emkolcel tge @ree Qpeeag Adiuse.
1
 Ufdche most o` tge provcscofs o` tge Aole wgcag ire lercvel `rom
9
\rifsarcpt o` Zrescleft Okimi–s Bif. 9> Qpeeag of FQI [e`orms
, \
GE
^
IQGCFN\OF
Z
OQ\
, 9> Bifuiry ;:9<, gttp2//www.wisgcfntofpost.aom/podctcas/`udd-text-o`-prescleft-okimis-bif-9>-speeag-of-fsi-re`orms/;:9</:9/9>/`i1153:i->`7a-99e1-3550-<i<k`>kakl7<_story.gtmd.
;
Of 9 Bifuiry 931;.
1
Irtcade CCC, Qeatcof 9(7) (—Fo diw sgidd ke pissel ikrclncfn tge `reelom o` speeag, or o` tge press, or o` tge rcngt o` tge peopde peiaeikdy to issemkde ifl petctcof tge Noverfmeft `or relress o` nrcevifaes.”). \gcs cs sukstiftciddy recteritel cf Irtcade CCC, Qeatcof 3 o` tge 93>1 Aofstctutcof ifl Irtcade CCC, Qeatcof < o` tge 937> Aofstctutcof.
 
Aofaurrcfn ifl Lcsseftcfn Opcfcof 1 N.[. Fos. ;:1115,
et id
.
tge Qpifcsg Zefid Aole o` 97>:, Irtcade 15< cs kisel of dencsditcof
<
 pissel  ky tge Zgcdcppcfe Aommcsscof lurcfn tge Imercaif oaaupitcof. Fevertgedess, Irtcade 15< cs cfaofscsteft wctg forms of `ree speeag ifl `ree expresscof fow  previcdcfn cf kotg Imercaif ifl Zgcdcppcfe aofstctutcofid burcsprulefae.
 
Irtcade 15< provcles is `oddows2
 [equcremeft `or pukdcacty
. “ Every le`imitory cmputitcof
cs presumel to ke midcacous, evef c` ct ke true
, c` fo nool cfteftcof ifl bustc`cikde motcve `or mihcfn ct cs sgowf, exaept cf tge `oddowcfn aises2 9. I prcvite aommufcaitcof mile ky ify persof to ifotger cf tge  per`ormifae o` ify denid, morid or soacid luty8 ifl ;. I `icr ifl true report, mile cf nool `ictg,
wctgout ify aommefts or remirhs
, o` ify bulcacid, dencsditcve or otger o``cacid proaeelcfns wgcag ire fot o` aof`cleftcid fiture, or o` ify stitemeft, report or speeag ledcverel cf sicl proaeelcfns, or o` ify otger iat per`ormel ky pukdca o``caers cf tge exeracse o` tgecr `ufatcofs. (Ctidcaczitcof suppdcel)
^gcde tge text o` Irtcade 15< gis remicfel cftiat scfae tge Aole–s efiatmeft cf 931:, aofstctutcofid rcngts give ripcldy expiflel scfae tge ditter gid` o` tge dist aeftury, owcfn to expifscve bulcacid cfterpretitcofs o` kroildy worlel aofstctutcofid nuiriftees suag is tge @ree Qpeeag Adiuse. Cfevctikdy, bulcacid loatrcfes ari`tel ky tge U.Q. Qupreme Aourt proteatcve o` tge rcngts to `ree speeag, `ree expresscof ifl `ree press `oufl tgecr wiy cfto doaid  burcsprulefae, iloptel ky tgcs Aourt is iutgorctitcve cfterpretitcof o` tge @ree Qpeeag Adiuse cf tge Zgcdcppcfe Kcdd o` [cngts. Ofe suag loatrcfe cs tge
 Few Sorh \cmes
iatuid midcae rude, fimel i`ter tge 930< aise cf wgcag ct wis ari`tel,
 Few Sorh \cmes v. Quddcvif
.
5
 
 Few Sorh \cmes
 kroilefel tge miftde o` proteatcof iaaorlel to aommufcaitcve `reeloms ky godlcfn tgit tge —aeftrid meifcfn” o` tge @ree Qpeeag Adiuse cs tge proteatcof o` actczefs wgo arctcacze o``cacid aofluat
evef c` suag arctcacsm cs le`imitory ifl `idse
. \rue, tge le`imel pukdca o``cacid miy stcdd reaover limines `or dcked. Gowever, is preaoflctcof `or suag reaovery,
 Few Sorh \cmes
 dicl lowf i `ormclikde evcleftciry kurlef
0
 ‑ tge pukdca o``cacid must prove tgit tge `idse le`imitory stitemeft wis mile
<
 Iat Fo. ;>>.
5
1>0 U.Q. ;5< (930<) (cfvodvcfn i dcked aompdicft `or limines `cdel ky tge Moftnomery, Idikimi podcae aommcsscofer inicfst tge Few Sorh \cmes Aompify ifl otger cflcvcluids `or i picl podctcaid ilvertcsemeft pukdcsgel cf tge
 Few Sorh \cmes
, arctcaczcfn podcae aofluat lurcfn i serces o` protests stinel ky acvcd rcngts iatcvcsts it tge gecngt o` tge aimpicnf `or riacid equidcty cf tge Imercaif Qoutg cf tge 930:s).
0
Idso lesarckel is —if esaiditcXof] o` tge pdicftc``–s kurlef o` proo` to if idmost cmpossckde deved.”
 Luf &  Krilstreet v. Nreefmoss Kucdlers
, <>; U.Q. ><3, >>9 (9375) (^gcte,
 B 
., aofaurrcfn).

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->