2Internet News Record
H1N1: Who Do You Trust? - FOXNews
(Most Popular - Google News)
Submitted at 10/9/2009 9:10:02 AM
Have you decided what you'regoing to do about the swine fluvaccine yet? Have you heardanybody yet talk about it that youtrust? Will you take your chanceswith the swine flu or the vaccine?Will you take the vaccine andgive it to your children? Howmuch do you trust yourgovernment?I think that's the main question.Do you trust your government in acouple of things: A, that this crisisis even real, and B, that they havecompetently worked with the bestmedicine to develop, distributeand administer a potentiallylifesaving vaccine? Do youbelieve that?Are you even troubled by thefact that we have to ask thesequestions of ourselves? I am,quite honestly. I can't believe thatwe live in a world that we donow, where there is such a lack of trust.Unfortunately, there is thatcredibility issue in Washington,with science — with the sciencethat comes from the worldorganizations like the WHO, orreally it's the U.N. that bothers meso much. We have been lied tobefore. We have been lied to bythe media. We have been lied toby both sides of the aisle, andpoliticians — with politician anddoctors are wrong. I'm not alonein asking these questions.There is a recent poll out byConsumer Reports that found thattwo-thirds of parents planned todelay or skip giving their childrenthe H1N1 shots altogether. Ithought about how to do thisshow, and I thought about it longand hard. I have made mydecision about the swine fluvaccine, but because of theenormity of the ramificationshere, we are facing a potentialpandemic. I believe in pandemicsand I believe we're due for one.Trying to decide what is best toprotect my family is what I havedone, but that's now in yourhands, finding out how you'regoing to protect your family.Therefore, I'll keep my decisionprivate.I'm trying to give you the factswith no opinion. So, what I wantto do is arm you with as muchinformation as possible, so youcan make the best choice for yourfamily. We have worked hard tocompile the best information fromthe best doctors and expertsavailable. I've personally spokento a couple of the best doctors inthe world and some of the expertson both sides in order to help youmake an informed decision. So,let's start with some facts that wealready know.Flu pandemics have struck before, and with deadly results.The biggest one was 1918 to1919. It was the Spanish flupandemic. It swept the planet,killing at least 40 million peopleworldwide. This was the nastyone here in America. More than500,000 people died in the UnitedStates. Forty years later, there wasanother one — in 1957-1958,Asian flu hit the world, causingabout 70,000 deaths in the UnitedStates. We also had the HongKong flu from 1968 to 1969 thatcaused about 34,000 deaths in theUnited States. Earlier this year,there were hundreds of reporteddeaths from H1N1, but it paled incomparison to the death rate of even the annual garden varietyflu, about 36,000 people each yeardie just from the seasonal flu herein the U.S.Right now, according to theexperts I have talked to, H1N1may actually be less virulent thanits predecessor earlier this year,although it still has proven attimes to be capable of taking life.The fear, of course, is that a moredeadly strain of H1N1 willcirculate. That's what happened in1918-1919. First, I think it startedin about 1916 and it was fine;1917, fine; and then 1918, itswept through and killed a lot of people. The World HealthOrganization recently warned thatH1N1 could kill millions andcause anarchy in third worldcountries unless $1.5 billion israised to help poor countries payfor the vaccine.OK. We also know that here inNew York, it has been mandatedthat 500,000 health care workersmust be vaccinated. Well, as youcan imagine, that's not going wellwith some workers here inAmerica. These people wereprotesting, I think it was lastweek. Americans generally bristleat the mere thought of beingforced to have something injectedinto their bodies, whether that'ssome bureaucrat saying that it'sgood for us or a doctor or not, itdoesn't matter. Some of thesepeople may have actually believedit was for the best. But oncefreedom of choice is removedfrom the equation, to many, therest of the argument is moot.However, one physician withwhom we spoke, Dr. Marc Siegelput it this way, "The decisionwhether to make the vaccine forthe novel H1N1 flu mandatory forhealth care workers is not a moralor ethical problem. It is simply aquestion of health mathematics. Inthis case, the math is on the sideof the vaccine."By the way, Dr. Siegel will beappearing later on this program,but I was bothered by the "simplemath" part of that. I mean, I'm nota number. These people were notnumbers. Those who are beingforced to take the injection, it'snot numbers. If they don't taketheir injections, they lose their jobs. It may or may not be a moralor ethical problem, but it certainlyraises questions of freedom andliberty. Were their rightstrampled?I don't think I can go that far,because you do have the option of not receiving the vaccine. You just have to go and find otheremployment. Again, asAmericans, something, though,seems inherently wrong in thatscenario, and the off repeatedrefrain from Ben Franklin jumpsto mind, "Those who are willingto sacrifice their freedom forsafety deserve neither and willlose both." We can debate BenFranklin some other day.I want to focus on helping youmake the best decision for thisvaccine for your family. So, let'sstart here: Why should you get thevaccine?Well, according to the Centersfor Disease Control, swine flu,"can be life threatening in somepeople with underlying healthconditions. The H1N1 vaccinecan help prevent infection andalso help people prevent theserious complications that canlead to death in some people."Certain age groups should beparticularly concerned. Make surethey receive the vaccine. "Thesegroups include pregnant women,people who live with or care forchildren younger than six monthsof age, health care and emergencymedical service personnel, andpersons between the ages of sixmonths and 24 years old, alsopeople ages 25-64 years of agewho are at a higher risk for 2009H1N1 because of chronic healthdisorders or compromisedimmune systems."Another compelling reason toreceive the vaccine is that thisparticular strain, if it gets nasty,you and your family are going tobe completely unprotected and atits mercy without the vaccine, andyou might be wishing you took it.There were no vaccines for theSpanish flu in 1918. How manylives could have been saved?Even the last time around forswine flu in America in 1876, wewere nowhere near where we aretoday in terms of medicaladvancement. When this shotdoes become availablenationwide, it will be a two-stageprocess for children under nine.Doctors tell me that makes all thedifference in the world.But there are those on the otherside of the issue with somecompelling arguments as well.Among the most compelling,there is a concern that the vaccinewas rushed to market in just a fewmonths. Was it developedcarefully enough? Who developedit? What was the process? Is itreasonable that we went from zeroto 60 this quickly with thisvaccine? The vaccine alsocontains thimerosal. Some expertsbelieve it can cause severedamage in some people. Theyargue that the vast majority of people who take this vaccinewould tolerate it just fine, butthere would be some that would
Top News/
H1N1: page 4
Leave a Comment