2
Internet News Record
(Most Popular - Google News)
Submi t t ed at 10/ 9/ 2009 9: 10: 02 AM
Have you decided what you're
going to do about the swine flu
vaccine yet? Have you heard
anybody yet talk about it that you
trust? Will you take your chances
with the swine flu or the vaccine?
Will you take the vaccine and
give it to your children? How
much do you trust your
government?
I think that's the main question.
Do you trust your government in a
couple of things: A, that this crisis
is even real, and B, that they have
competently worked with the best
medicine to develop, distribute
and administer a potentially
lifesaving vaccine? Do you
believe that?
Are you even troubled by the
fact that we have to ask these
questions of ourselves? I am,
quite honestly. I can't believe that
we live in a world that we do
now, where there is such a lack of
trust.
Unfortunately, there is that
credibility issue in Washington,
with science \u2014 with the science
that comes from the world
organizations like the WHO, or
really it's the U.N. that bothers me
so much. We have been lied to
before. We have been lied to by
the media. We have been lied to
by both sides of the aisle, and
politicians \u2014 with politician and
doctors are wrong. I'm not alone
in asking these questions.
There is a recent poll out by
Consumer Reports that found that
two-thirds of parents planned to
delay or skip giving their children
the H1N1 shots altogether. I
thought about how to do this
show, and I thought about it long
and hard. I have made my
decision about the swine flu
vaccine, but because of the
enormity of the ramifications
here, we are facing a potential
pandemic. I believe in pandemics
and I believe we're due for one.
Trying to decide what is best to
protect my family is what I have
done, but that's now in your
hands, finding out how you're
going to protect your family.
Therefore, I'll keep my decision
private.
I'm trying to give you the facts
with no opinion. So, what I want
to do is arm you with as much
information as possible, so you
can make the best choice for your
family. We have worked hard to
compile the best information from
the best doctors and experts
available. I've personally spoken
to a couple of the best doctors in
the world and some of the experts
on both sides in order to help you
make an informed decision. So,
let's start with some facts that we
already know.
Flu pandemics have struck
before, and with deadly results.
The biggest one was 1918 to
1919. It was the Spanish flu
pandemic. It swept the planet,
killing at least 40 million people
worldwide. This was the nasty
one here in America. More than
500,000 people died in the United
States. Forty years later, there was
another one \u2014 in 1957-1958,
Asian flu hit the world, causing
about 70,000 deaths in the United
States. We also had the Hong
Kong flu from 1968 to 1969 that
caused about 34,000 deaths in the
United States. Earlier this year,
there were hundreds of reported
deaths from H1N1, but it paled in
comparison to the death rate of
even the annual garden variety
flu, about 36,000 people each year
die just from the seasonal flu here
in the U.S.
Right now, according to the
experts I have talked to, H1N1
may actually be less virulent than
its predecessor earlier this year,
although it still has proven at
times to be capable of taking life.
The fear, of course, is that a more
deadly strain of H1N1 will
circulate. That's what happened in
1918-1919. First, I think it started
in about 1916 and it was fine;
1917, fine; and then 1918, it
swept through and killed a lot of
people. The World Health
Organization recently warned that
H1N1 could kill millions and
cause anarchy in third world
countries unless $1.5 billion is
raised to help poor countries pay
for the vaccine.
OK. We also know that here in
New York, it has been mandated
that 500,000 health care workers
must be vaccinated. Well, as you
can imagine, that's not going well
with some workers here in
America. These people were
protesting, I think it was last
week. Americans generally bristle
at the mere thought of being
forced to have something injected
into their bodies, whether that's
some bureaucrat saying that it's
good for us or a doctor or not, it
doesn't matter. Some of these
people may have actually believed
it was for the best. But once
freedom of choice is removed
from the equation, to many, the
rest of the argument is moot.
However, one physician with
whom we spoke, Dr. Marc Siegel
put it this way, "The decision
whether to make the vaccine for
the novel H1N1 flu mandatory for
health care workers is not a moral
or ethical problem. It is simply a
question of health mathematics. In
this case, the math is on the side
of the vaccine."
By the way, Dr. Siegel will be
appearing later on this program,
but I was bothered by the "simple
math" part of that. I mean, I'm not
a number. These people were not
numbers. Those who are being
forced to take the injection, it's
not numbers. If they don't take
their injections, they lose their
jobs. It may or may not be a moral
or ethical problem, but it certainly
raises questions of freedom and
liberty. Were their rights
trampled?
I don't think I can go that far,
because you do have the option of
not receiving the vaccine. You
just have to go and find other
employment. Again, as
Americans, something, though,
seems inherently wrong in that
scenario, and the off repeated
refrain from Ben Franklin jumps
to mind, "Those who are willing
to sacrifice their freedom for
safety deserve neither and will
lose both." We can debate Ben
Franklin some other day.
I want to focus on helping you
make the best decision for this
vaccine for your family. So, let's
start here: Why should you get the
vaccine?
Well, according to the Centers
for Disease Control, swine flu,
"can be life threatening in some
people with underlying health
conditions. The H1N1 vaccine
can help prevent infection and
also help people prevent the
serious complications that can
lead to death in some people."
Certain age groups should be
particularly concerned. Make sure
they receive the vaccine. "These
groups include pregnant women,
people who live with or care for
children younger than six months
of age, health care and emergency
medical service personnel, and
persons between the ages of six
months and 24 years old, also
people ages 25-64 years of age
who are at a higher risk for 2009
H1N1 because of chronic health
disorders or compromised
immune systems."
Another compelling reason to
receive the vaccine is that this
particular strain, if it gets nasty,
you and your family are going to
be completely unprotected and at
its mercy without the vaccine, and
you might be wishing you took it.
There were no vaccines for the
Spanish flu in 1918. How many
lives could have been saved?
Even the last time around for
swine flu in America in 1876, we
were nowhere near where we are
today in terms of medical
advancement. When this shot
does become available
nationwide, it will be a two-stage
process for children under nine.
Doctors tell me that makes all the
difference in the world.
But there are those on the other
side of the issue with some
compelling arguments as well.
Among the most compelling,
there is a concern that the vaccine
was rushed to market in just a few
months. Was it developed
carefully enough? Who developed
it? What was the process? Is it
reasonable that we went from zero
to 60 this quickly with this
vaccine? The vaccine also
contains thimerosal. Some experts
believe it can cause severe
damage in some people. They
argue that the vast majority of
people who take this vaccine
would tolerate it just fine, but
there would be some that would
Top News/
H1N1: page 4
Leave a Comment