Microsoft Excel 12.0 Answer Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.

xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 8/20/2012 4:53:01 PM

Target Cell (Min) Cell Name $C$11 Cost = $ =

Original Value Final Value 0 7300

Adjustable Cells Cell Name $C$5 Cincinnati New York $D$5 Cincinnati Dallas $E$5 Cincinnati Detroit $C$6 Atlanta New York $D$6 Atlanta Dallas $E$6 Atlanta Detroit $C$7 Pittsburgh New York $D$7 Pittsburgh Dallas $E$7 Pittsburgh Detroit

Original Value Final Value 0 0 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 150 0 50 0 0

Constraints Cell Name $C$8 TV Sets Shipped New York $D$8 TV Sets Shipped Dallas $E$8 TV Sets Shipped Detroit $F$5 Cincinnati TV Sets Shipped $F$6 Atlanta TV Sets Shipped $F$7 Pittsburgh TV Sets Shipped

Cell Value 150 250 200 200 200 200

Formula $C$8=$C$10 $D$8=$D$10 $E$8=$E$10 $F$5<=$H$5 $F$6<=$H$6 $F$7<=$H$7

Status Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Binding Binding

Slack 0 0 0 100 0 0

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Sensitivity Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 8/20/2012 4:53:01 PM

Adjustable Cells Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7 Name Cincinnati New York Cincinnati Dallas Cincinnati Detroit Atlanta New York Atlanta Dallas Atlanta Detroit Pittsburgh New York Pittsburgh Dallas Pittsburgh Detroit Final Reduced Objective Allowable Allowable Value Cost Coefficient Increase Decrease 0 0 16 1E+30 0 0 0 18 0 3 200 0 11 8 1E+30 0 4 14 1E+30 4 200 0 12 4 1E+30 0 8 13 1E+30 8 150 0 13 0 1E+30 50 0 15 3 0 0 9 17 1E+30 9

Constraints Cell $C$8 $D$8 $E$8 $F$5 $F$6 $F$7 Name TV Sets Shipped New York TV Sets Shipped Dallas TV Sets Shipped Detroit Cincinnati TV Sets Shipped Atlanta TV Sets Shipped Pittsburgh TV Sets Shipped Final Shadow Constraint Allowable Allowable Value Price R.H. Side Increase Decrease 150 16 150 50 0 250 18 250 100 0 200 11 200 100 200 200 0 300 1E+30 100 200 -6 200 0 100 200 -3 200 0 50

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Limits Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Limits Report 1 Report Created: 8/20/2012 4:53:01 PM

Target Cell Name $C$11 Cost = $ =

Value 7300

Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7

Adjustable Name Cincinnati New York Cincinnati Dallas Cincinnati Detroit Atlanta New York Atlanta Dallas Atlanta Detroit Pittsburgh New York Pittsburgh Dallas Pittsburgh Detroit

Value 0 0 200 0 200 0 150 50 0

Lower Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Upper Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Answer Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 8/22/2012 5:02:04 PM

Target Cell (Min) Cell $C$11 Cost = $ =

Name

Original Value Final Value 0 7300

Adjustable Cells Cell Name $C$5 Cincinnati (1) New York (A) $D$5 Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) $E$5 Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) $C$6 Atlanta (2) New York (A) $D$6 Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) $E$6 Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) $C$7 Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) $D$7 Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) $E$7 Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C)

Original Value Final Value 0 0 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 150 0 50 0 0

Constraints Cell Name $C$8 TV Sets Shipped New York (A) $D$8 TV Sets Shipped Dallas (B) $E$8 TV Sets Shipped Detroit (C) $F$5 Cincinnati (1) TV Sets Shipped $F$6 Atlanta (2) TV Sets Shipped $F$7 Pittsburgh (3) TV Sets Shipped

Cell Value 150 250 200 200 200 200

Formula $C$8=$C$10 $D$8=$D$10 $E$8=$E$10 $F$5<=$H$5 $F$6<=$H$6 $F$7<=$H$7

Status Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Binding Binding

Slack 0 0 0 100 0 0

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Sensitivity Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 8/22/2012 5:02:04 PM

Adjustable Cells Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7 Name Cincinnati (1) New York (A) Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) Atlanta (2) New York (A) Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C) Final Reduced Objective Allowable Allowable Value Cost Coefficient Increase Decrease 0 0 16 1E+30 0 0 0 18 0 3 200 0 11 8 1E+30 0 4 14 1E+30 4 200 0 12 4 1E+30 0 8 13 1E+30 8 150 0 13 0 1E+30 50 0 15 3 0 0 9 17 1E+30 9

Constraints Cell $C$8 $D$8 $E$8 $F$5 $F$6 $F$7 Name TV Sets Shipped New York (A) TV Sets Shipped Dallas (B) TV Sets Shipped Detroit (C) Cincinnati (1) TV Sets Shipped Atlanta (2) TV Sets Shipped Pittsburgh (3) TV Sets Shipped Final Shadow Constraint Allowable Allowable Value Price R.H. Side Increase Decrease 150 16 150 50 0 250 18 250 100 0 200 11 200 100 200 200 0 300 1E+30 100 200 -6 200 0 100 200 -3 200 0 50

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Limits Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Limits Report 2 Report Created: 8/22/2012 5:02:04 PM

Cell $C$11 Cost = $ =

Target Name

Value 7300

Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7

Adjustable Name Cincinnati (1) New York (A) Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) Atlanta (2) New York (A) Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C)

Value 0 0 200 0 200 0 150 50 0

Lower Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Upper Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Answer Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 11/26/2012 8:06:31 PM

Target Cell (Min) Cell $C$11 Cost = $ =

Name

Original Value Final Value 0 7300

Adjustable Cells Cell Name $C$5 Cincinnati (1) New York (A) $D$5 Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) $E$5 Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) $C$6 Atlanta (2) New York (A) $D$6 Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) $E$6 Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) $C$7 Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) $D$7 Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) $E$7 Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C)

Original Value Final Value 0 0 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 150 0 50 0 0

Constraints Cell Name $C$8 TV Sets Shipped New York (A) $D$8 TV Sets Shipped Dallas (B) $E$8 TV Sets Shipped Detroit (C) $F$5 Cincinnati (1) TV Sets Shipped $F$6 Atlanta (2) TV Sets Shipped $F$7 Pittsburgh (3) TV Sets Shipped

Cell Value 150 250 200 200 200 200

Formula $C$8=$C$10 $D$8=$D$10 $E$8=$E$10 $F$5<=$H$5 $F$6<=$H$6 $F$7<=$H$7

Status Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Binding Binding

Slack 0 0 0 100 0 0

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Sensitivity Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 11/26/2012 8:06:31 PM

Adjustable Cells Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7 Name Cincinnati (1) New York (A) Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) Atlanta (2) New York (A) Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C) Final Reduced Objective Allowable Allowable Value Cost Coefficient Increase Decrease 0 0 16 1E+30 0 0 0 18 0 3 200 0 11 8 1E+30 0 4 14 1E+30 4 200 0 12 4 1E+30 0 8 13 1E+30 8 150 0 13 0 1E+30 50 0 15 3 0 0 9 17 1E+30 9

Constraints Cell $C$8 $D$8 $E$8 $F$5 $F$6 $F$7 Name TV Sets Shipped New York (A) TV Sets Shipped Dallas (B) TV Sets Shipped Detroit (C) Cincinnati (1) TV Sets Shipped Atlanta (2) TV Sets Shipped Pittsburgh (3) TV Sets Shipped Final Shadow Constraint Allowable Allowable Value Price R.H. Side Increase Decrease 150 16 150 50 0 250 18 250 100 0 200 11 200 100 200 200 0 300 1E+30 100 200 -6 200 0 100 200 -3 200 0 50

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Limits Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Limits Report 3 Report Created: 11/26/2012 8:06:31 PM

Cell $C$11 Cost = $ =

Target Name

Value 7300

Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7

Adjustable Name Cincinnati (1) New York (A) Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) Atlanta (2) New York (A) Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C)

Value 0 0 200 0 200 0 150 50 0

Lower Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Upper Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Answer Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 11/27/2012 5:06:33 PM

Target Cell (Min) Cell $C$11 Cost = $ =

Name

Original Value Final Value 0 7300

Adjustable Cells Cell Name $C$5 Cincinnati (1) New York (A) $D$5 Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) $E$5 Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) $C$6 Atlanta (2) New York (A) $D$6 Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) $E$6 Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) $C$7 Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) $D$7 Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) $E$7 Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C)

Original Value Final Value 0 0 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 200 0 0 0 150 0 50 0 0

Constraints Cell Name $C$8 TV Sets Shipped New York (A) $D$8 TV Sets Shipped Dallas (B) $E$8 TV Sets Shipped Detroit (C) $F$5 Cincinnati (1) TV Sets Shipped $F$6 Atlanta (2) TV Sets Shipped $F$7 Pittsburgh (3) TV Sets Shipped

Cell Value 150 250 200 200 200 200

Formula $C$8=$C$10 $D$8=$D$10 $E$8=$E$10 $F$5<=$H$5 $F$6<=$H$6 $F$7<=$H$7

Status Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Not Binding Binding Binding

Slack 0 0 0 100 0 0

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Sensitivity Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Sheet1 Report Created: 11/27/2012 5:06:33 PM

Adjustable Cells Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7 Name Cincinnati (1) New York (A) Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) Atlanta (2) New York (A) Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C) Final Reduced Objective Allowable Allowable Value Cost Coefficient Increase Decrease 0 0 16 1E+30 0 0 0 18 0 3 200 0 11 8 1E+30 0 4 14 1E+30 4 200 0 12 4 1E+30 0 8 13 1E+30 8 150 0 13 0 1E+30 50 0 15 3 0 0 9 17 1E+30 9

Constraints Cell $C$8 $D$8 $E$8 $F$5 $F$6 $F$7 Name TV Sets Shipped New York (A) TV Sets Shipped Dallas (B) TV Sets Shipped Detroit (C) Cincinnati (1) TV Sets Shipped Atlanta (2) TV Sets Shipped Pittsburgh (3) TV Sets Shipped Final Shadow Constraint Allowable Allowable Value Price R.H. Side Increase Decrease 150 16 150 50 0 250 18 250 100 0 200 11 200 100 200 200 0 300 1E+30 100 200 -6 200 0 100 200 -3 200 0 50

Microsoft Excel 12.0 Limits Report Worksheet: [Chapter 4_Transportation Example_Exhibit 4.15_Excel Solver.xlsx]Limits Report 4 Report Created: 11/27/2012 5:06:33 PM

Cell $C$11 Cost = $ =

Target Name

Value 7300

Cell $C$5 $D$5 $E$5 $C$6 $D$6 $E$6 $C$7 $D$7 $E$7

Adjustable Name Cincinnati (1) New York (A) Cincinnati (1) Dallas (B) Cincinnati (1) Detroit (C) Atlanta (2) New York (A) Atlanta (2) Dallas (B) Atlanta (2) Detroit (C) Pittsburgh (3) New York (A) Pittsburgh (3) Dallas (B) Pittsburgh (3) Detroit (C)

Value 0 0 200 0 200 0 150 50 0

Lower Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

Upper Target Limit Result 0 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 200 7300 0 7300 150 7300 50 7300 0 7300

A Transportation Example, Chapter 4, page 130, Exhibit 4.15 Store Dallas (B) 0 200 50 250 = 250 TV Sets Shipped Constraint 200 <= 200 <= 200 <=

Warehouse New York (A) Cincinnati (1) 0 Atlanta (2) 0 Pittsburgh (3) 150 TV Sets Shipped 150 Constraints = Demand 150 Cost = $ 7300

Detroit (C) 200 0 0 200 = 200

Supply 300 200 200

Objective is to Minimize Cost: Z = $16x 1A + 18x1B + 11x1C + 14x2A + 12x2B + 13x2C + 13x3A + 15x3B + 17x3C
Objective Function in Cell C11 contains Cost paramters as in: 16*C5 + 18*D5 + 11*E5 + 14*C6 + 12*D6 + 13*E6 + 13*C7 + 15*D7 + 17*E7

x1, x2, double-scripted variable, ij

x1A, x1B,

Since Supply was 700 total and Demand was 600 total, we place a <= sign for Supply = sign for Demand

Enter into Data > Solver Target cell is Cost = $ cell, C11 By Changing Cells: C5:E7

3x3A + 15x3B + 17x3C

Subject to Constraints:
C8:E8 = C10:D10 F5:F7 <= H5:H7 Demand Supply