Prolif Stuff Copy

Embed Doc
Copy Link
Readcast
Collections

CommentGo Back

Download

Arizona Debate Institute 2009

1Frappier/Russell/Stables LabProlif Core

Prolif Core

Prolif Core ...................................................................................................................................................................1

Prolif Core ......................................................................................................................................1

***PROLIF BAD*** .................................................................................................................................................4

***PROLIF BAD*** .....................................................................................................................4

Prolif Not Inevitable ....................................................................................................................................................4

Prolif Not Inevitable ......................................................................................................................4

Prolif Bad – Prolif is Fast (1/2) ...................................................................................................................................5

Prolif Bad – Prolif is Fast (1/2) .....................................................................................................5

Prolif Bad – Prolif is Fast (2/2) ...................................................................................................................................6

Prolif Bad – Prolif is Fast (2/2) .....................................................................................................6

Prolif Bad – **Utgoff** (1/2) .....................................................................................................................................7

Prolif Bad – **Utgoff** (1/2) ........................................................................................................ 7

Prolif Bad – **Utgoff** (2/2) .....................................................................................................................................8

Prolif Bad – **Utgoff** (2/2) ........................................................................................................ 8

Prolif Bad – Accidents ................................................................................................................................................9

Prolif Bad – Accidents ................................................................................................................... 9

Prolif Bad – Causes Nuke War (1/2) ........................................................................................................................10

Prolif Bad – Causes Nuke War (1/2) ..........................................................................................10

Prolif Bad – Causes Nuke War (2/2) ........................................................................................................................11

Prolif Bad – Causes Nuke War (2/2) ..........................................................................................11

Prolif Bad – Causes Conventional War ....................................................................................................................12

Prolif Bad – Causes Conventional War .....................................................................................12

Prolif Bad – Causes Miscalc .....................................................................................................................................13

Prolif Bad – Causes Miscalc ........................................................................................................13

Prolif Bad – Deterrence Fails (Generic) ...................................................................................................................14

Prolif Bad – Deterrence Fails (Generic) .....................................................................................14

Prolif Bad – Kills Heg ...............................................................................................................................................15

Prolif Bad – Kills Heg ..................................................................................................................15

Prolif Bad – No Civilian Control ..............................................................................................................................16

Prolif Bad – No Civilian Control ................................................................................................16

Prolif Bad – No 2nd Strike Capability ......................................................................................................................17

Prolif Bad – No 2nd Strike Capability .......................................................................................17

Prolif Bad – Nuclear Escalation ................................................................................................................................18

Prolif Bad – Nuclear Escalation ..................................................................................................18

Arizona Debate Institute 2009

2Frappier/Russell/Stables LabProlif Core

Prolif Bad – Nuclear Winter .....................................................................................................................................19

Prolif Bad – Nuclear Winter .......................................................................................................19

Prolif Bad – Preemptive Strikes ................................................................................................................................20

Prolif Bad – Preemptive Strikes ................................................................................................. 20

Prolif Bad – Rogue States .........................................................................................................................................21

Prolif Bad – Rogue States ............................................................................................................21

Prolif Bad – Terrorist Acquisition ............................................................................................................................22

Prolif Bad – Terrorist Acquisition ..............................................................................................22

Prolif Bad – A2: Deterrence Empirically Successful ................................................................................................23

Prolif Bad – A2: Deterrence Empirically Successful ................................................................23

Prolif Bad – A2: Rationality Checks .........................................................................................................................24

Prolif Bad – A2: Rationality Checks ..........................................................................................24

***PROLIF GOOD*** ............................................................................................................................................25

***PROLIF GOOD*** ...............................................................................................................25

Prolif Inevitable .........................................................................................................................................................25

Prolif Inevitable ............................................................................................................................25

Prolif Good – Prolif is Slow (1/2) .............................................................................................................................26

Prolif Good – Prolif is Slow (1/2) ................................................................................................26

Prolif Good – Prolif is Slow (2/2) .............................................................................................................................27

Prolif Good – Prolif is Slow (2/2) ................................................................................................27

Prolif Good – Prevents Wars (1/2) ............................................................................................................................28

Prolif Good – Prevents Wars (1/2) .............................................................................................28

Prolif Good – Prevents Wars (2/2) ............................................................................................................................29

Prolif Good – Prevents Wars (2/2) .............................................................................................29

Prolif Good – Prevents Miscalc ................................................................................................................................30

Prolif Good – Prevents Miscalc ..................................................................................................30

Prolif Good – Solves Entanglement/Escalation ........................................................................................................31

Prolif Good – Solves Entanglement/Escalation .........................................................................31

Prolif Good – Conventional > Nuclear War (1/3) .....................................................................................................32

Prolif Good – Conventional > Nuclear War (1/3) .....................................................................32

Prolif Good – Conventional > Nuclear War (2/3) .....................................................................................................33

Prolif Good – Conventional > Nuclear War (2/3) .....................................................................33

Prolif Good – Conventional > Nuclear War (3/3) .....................................................................................................34

Prolif Good – Conventional > Nuclear War (3/3) .....................................................................34

Prolif Good – Solves Poverty ...................................................................................................................................35

Prolif Good – Solves Poverty .....................................................................................................35

Arizona Debate Institute 2009

3Frappier/Russell/Stables LabProlif Core

Prolif Good – Poverty > Nuke War ..........................................................................................................................36

Prolif Good – Poverty > Nuke War ............................................................................................36

Prolif Good – A2: Accidents .....................................................................................................................................37

Prolif Good – A2: Accidents ........................................................................................................37

Prolif Good – A2: Anonymous Attack .....................................................................................................................38

Prolif Good – A2: Anonymous Attack .......................................................................................38

Prolif Good – A2: Asymmetry ..................................................................................................................................39

Prolif Good – A2: Asymmetry ....................................................................................................39

Prolif Good – A2: Civil Wars ...................................................................................................................................40

Prolif Good – A2: Civil Wars ......................................................................................................40

Prolif Good – A2: Hair Trigger Alert .......................................................................................................................41

Prolif Good – A2: Hair Trigger Alert ........................................................................................ 41

Prolif Good – A2: Military Control is Unstable .......................................................................................................42

Prolif Good – A2: Military Control is Unstable ........................................................................42

Prolif Good – A2: No 2nd Strike Capabilities ..........................................................................................................43

Prolif Good – A2: No 2nd Strike Capabilities ...........................................................................43

Prolif Good – A2: Nuke Blackmail Undermines Heg ..............................................................................................44

Prolif Good – A2: Nuke Blackmail Undermines Heg ...............................................................44

Prolif Good – A2: Preemptive Strikes ......................................................................................................................45

Prolif Good – A2: Preemptive Strikes ........................................................................................45

Prolif Good – A2: Proximity .....................................................................................................................................46

Prolif Good – A2: Proximity .......................................................................................................46

Prolif Good – A2: Rogue/Failed States .....................................................................................................................47

Prolif Good – A2: Rogue/Failed States ...................................................................................... 47

Prolif Good – A2: Terrorists (1/3) ............................................................................................................................48

Prolif Good – A2: Terrorists (1/3) ..............................................................................................48

Prolif Good – A2: Terrorism (2/3) ............................................................................................................................49

Prolif Good – A2: Terrorism (2/3) ..............................................................................................49

Prolif Good – A2: Terrorism (3/3) ............................................................................................................................50

Prolif Good – A2: Terrorism (3/3) ..............................................................................................50

Prolif Good – A2: Unstable Rivalries .......................................................................................................................51

Prolif Good – A2: Unstable Rivalries .........................................................................................51

***PROLIF BAD***

of 00

Leave a Comment