Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Marvel CMU Enhancement Opinion

Marvel CMU Enhancement Opinion

Ratings: (0)|Views: 76 |Likes:
Published by Markman Advisors
Enhancement, royalty and injunction opinion.
Enhancement, royalty and injunction opinion.

More info:

Published by: Markman Advisors on Mar 31, 2014
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

04/01/2014

pdf

text

original

 
 "# $%& '#"$&( )$*$&) (")$+",$ ,-'+$ .-+ $%& /&)$&+# (")$+",$ -. 0&##)123*#"*
"#$%&'(& )&**+% ,%(-&$.(/01 2345675881 9:; )#$-&** /&"<%+*+'0 '$+,21 */=; >7 43;1 =>8>6?467:; @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @ "5953 #A75B6 %B; CDEFDC GH?I> %BJ4 K4JJL M5:AN>J
4&4-+*#('4 -0"#"-# "5
 
"#$+-(',$"-#67*,89+-'#(
/N5: 5: 4 O47>67 568J56I>P>67 A4:> QJBHIN7 QL 234567588 "4J6>I5> )>33B6 ,659>J:57L
(“CMU”), against Defendants Marvell Technology Group, Ltd. and Marvell
 .>P5AB6?HA7BJ1 (6A;
(collectively “Marvell”), alleging that Marvell has infringed two of its patents,
,;.; 247>67 %B:;
6,201,839 (the “‘839 Patent”) and 6,438,180 (the “‘180 Patent”) (collectively, the “CMU
247>67:
”),
 8BJ RN5AN 7N> "BHJ7 AB6?HA7>? 4 8BHJER>>S THJL 7J543 8JBP %B9>PQ>J 7B =>A>PQ>J B8 FCUF; V=BAS>7 %B; WXC@; /N> THJL J>6?>J>? 57: 9>J?5A7 B6 =>A>PQ>J FX1 FCUF 56 849BJ B8 "), B6 568J56I>P>671 9435?57L 46? R5338H36>::1 46? 4R4J?>? ?4P4I>: 56 7N> 4PBH67 B8 YU1UXD1UZC1FWU;CC; V=BAS>7 %B; WXF@;
U
 /N> "BHJ7 N4: AB6756H>? 7B OJ>:5?> B9>J NB73L AB67>:7>?
U
 #: 7N> O4J75>: 4J> R>33 4R4J> B8 7N> 84A7H43 46? OJBA>?HJ43 Q4ASIJBH6? B8 7N5: A4:> 46? 7N> "BHJ7 N4: 43J>4?L RJ577>6 >[7>6:59>3L B6 7N> 84A7: B8 7N5: A4:>1 V
 !""
 =BAS>7 %B:; DCC1 DCU1 DFC@1 7N> "BHJ7 R533 35P57 57: ?5:AH::5B6 7B 7N> Q4ASIJBH6? 6>A>::4JL 8BJ 7N> J>:B3H75B6 B8 7N> AHJJ>67 PB75B6:; MBJ AB69>65>6A>1 7N> "BHJ7 A57>: 7B 7N> ?BAS>7 6HPQ>J: 4::BA547>? R57N 7N>:> OJ>95BH:3L 5::H>? BO565B6: B6 57: BR6 ?BAS>7 7NJBHINBH7 7N5: ?>A5:5B6 QH7 6B7>: 7N47 7N> BO565B6: J>:B3956I OB:7E7J543 PB75B6: 4J> 494534Q3> 47 7N> 8B33BR56I A57475B6:\ VU@ ?>6L56I 7N> P5:7J5431
 !"" $%&'"()" *"++,' -')./ ./ *%&."++ 0"12/ 3&4/5 678/
1 "59; #; %B; CDEFDC1 FCU] ^* Z_UUFD] V^;=; 24; #HI; F]1
2013); (2) resolving the parties’ motions for judgment as a matter of law (“JMOLs”),
 !"" $%&'"()" *"++,' -')./ ./  *%&."++ 0"12/ 3&4/5 678/
1 "59; #; %B; CDEFDC1 EEE M; .HOO; F? EEEE1 FCU] ^* _]]FUC`1 47 aZUEZF V^;=; 24; .>O7; F]1
!"#$ &'()*+,*((&)(*-./ 01+23$45 )66 /78$9 (6:6;:;< =">$ ; 1? @&
 
F  OB:7E7J543 OJBA>>?56I: 56 7N5: A4:>1 RN5AN N4: 56A3H?>? >[7>6:59> QJ5>856I 46? OB:7E7J543 >95?>6754JL :HQP5::5B6:1 4 7RBE?4L PB75B6 N>4J56I1 :HOO3>P>6743 QJ5>856I B6 ?5:OH7>? 3>I43  OB567: 46? O>J5B?5A TB567 :747H: J>OBJ7: 8JBP 7N> O4J75>:
as to Marvell’s continuing sales of the
568J56I56I 7>AN6B3BIL; /N> "BHJ7 N4: PB9>? :>bH>675433L 7NJBHIN 7N> OB:7E7J543 PB75B6: 46?
issued a number of decisions, including: (1) denying Marvell’s motion for a mistrial
1 V=BAS>7
 No. 900); (2) resolving the parties’
AN433>6I>: 7B 7N> :H885A5>6AL B8 7N> >95?>6A> :HOOBJ756I 7N>
 jury’s verdict on liability, damages and willfulness
 QH7 J>:>J956I JH356I B6 7N> 85646A543 O>6437L
to be imposed as a result of Marvell’s willful infr 
56I>P>671 V=BAS>7 %B; DCU@c 46? V]@ ?>6L56I
Marvell’s equitable defense of laches, which could have
:HQ:74675433L
reduced the jury’s award
1 V=BAS>7 %B; DFC@; #33 B8 7NB:> ?>A5:5B6: 4J> 56ABJOBJ47>? QL J>8>J>6A> N>J>56; V=BAS>7 %B:; DCC1 DCU1 DFC@; #7 7
his juncture, the jury’s verdict of $1,169,
UZC1FWU;CC1 RN5AN N4: Q>>6 4?BO7>? 4: 4  TH?IP>67 853>? B6 G46H4JL UZ1 FCU]1 N4: Q>>6 :H:7456>?; V=BAS>7 %B:; WXF1 WXD1 DCU@; /N>
 jury’s verdict represents one hundred percent (100%) of the compensatory damages s
BHIN7 QL "), 47 7J543
for Marvell’s infringement of the patented methods
; V
 98/
@; (7 43:B :5I6585>: 7N47 7N>  THJL RNB33L 4?BO7>? 7N> 7>:75PB6L B8
CMU’s
 ?4P4I>: >[O>J71 "47N4J56> *4R7B61 RNB BO56>? 7N47 4 NLOB7N>75A43 6>IB75475B6 Q>7R>>6 7N> O4J75>: RBH3? N49> J>:H37>? 56 4 J>4:B64Q3> JBL437L B8 YC;_C O>J #AAH:>? "N5O :B3? QL )4J9>33 ?HJ56I 7N> J>3>9467 75P> O>J5B? V7N> JBL437L Q4:>@ 46? RBH3? J>:H37 56 7N> >[4A7 ?4P4I>: 85IHJ> RN5AN R4: 4R4J?>? QL 7N> THJL; V=BAS>7 %B; X`X 47 XU@;
Ms. Lawton’s
 BO565B6: N49> Q>>6 N>4953L :AJH7565d>? QL 7N> "BHJ7 56 OJ5BJ ?>A5:5B6: V56A3H?56I
 :%;<"&7
AN433>6I>: QB7N Q>8BJ> 46? ?HJ56I 7J543@ 46? 7N> ?>A5:5B6: B6 7NB:> 5::H>: 4J>
FCU]@c 46? V]@1 ?>6L56I 7N> PB75B6 8BJ TH?IP>67 B6 34AN>:1
 !"" $%&'"()" *"++,' -')./ ./ *%&."++ 0"12/ 3&4/5 678/
1 "59; #; %B; CDEFDC1 FCUZ ^* U`]FUF V^;=; 24; G46; UZ1 FCUZ@;
!"#$ &'()*+,*((&)(*-./ 01+23$45 )66 /78$9 (6:6;:;< =">$ & 1? @&
 
] 35S>R5:> 56ABJOBJ47>? QL J>8>J>6A> N>J>56; V=BAS>7 %B:; Z_U1 WU]1 DCU@; $>3>9467 N>J>1 ):; *4R7B
n’s
7>:7585>? 7B 7N> 8B33BR56I ?4P4I>: ABPOH7475B6:\ =4P4I>: 2>J5B? $BL437L K4:> $BL437L $47> =4P4I>: ]eXeC]E]e_eCD U1UCD1UCC1CCX YC;_C Y__Z1__C1CC] ]eXeCDEWeF`eUF U1FFD1U`C1_]X YC;_C YXUZ1_DC1FX`
:6;6<:=>6?@6A? ?B::@B:@<BCD? E<5C< EABA;FBAD<B?>A
V=BAS>7 %B; X]]EU 47 W@; ^N53> 7N> OB:7E7J543 PB75B6: R>J> O>6?56I1 7N> "BHJ7 BJ?>J>? 4 6HPQ>J B8 OB:7E7J543 4AABH6756I:
regarding Marvell’s continuing sales
 B8 #AAH:>? "N5O:
F
 46? 7N> O4J75>: 853>? :747H: J>OBJ7: OJB95?56I :HAN 568BJP475B6; V=BAS>7 %B:; ``_1 ``X1 DCZ@; /NJBHIN 7N5:  OJBA>::1 7N> O4J75>: P>7 46? AB68>JJ>? 46? I>6>J433L 4IJ>>?
]
 7N47 )4J9>33 N4: P4?> 7N> 8B33BR56I :43>: B8 #AAH:>? "N5O: 56 7N> :HQ:>bH>67 O>J5B?:\
0GHIJK )LMGN
WeFDeUF
 – 
 UeUZeU] U_D1UCC1_WX UeU_eU]E`e]eU] FCZ1X_F1CCD `eZeU]
 – 
 UUeFeU] DZ1]DC1__D V=BAS>7 %B:; ``D1 DCW1 DCU 47 6;U]X@; /N> "BHJ7 N4: 6B7 BJ?>J>? 4??575B643 :747H: J>OBJ7: 47 7N5: 75P> Q>A4H:> 7N> :4P>
are unnecessary to the Court’s present
?>A5:5B6:; <BR>9>J1 HO?47>? 4AABH6756I: R533 Q> BJ?>J>? 56 AB6TH6A75B6 R57
h the Court’s rulings set forth below.
F
 
As noted in the Court’s prior Opinions, “Accused Chips” refers to Marvell’s read channel and SOC chips
 AB6745656I 7N> 568J56I56I 7>AN6B3BIL; V
=""
 =BAS>7 %B; DCU 47 UX@;
]
 (6 7N> 347>:7 :747H: J>OBJ7 ?47>? %B9>PQ>J F1 FCU]1 7N> O4J75>: ?5:OH7> 7N> 4PBH67 B8 J>9>6H> I>6>J47>? 8BJ 7N5: O>J5B? B8 75P> 46? "), BQT>A7: 7B )4J9>33 OJ>:>6756I 7N> :43>: ?474 56 4 8BJP RN5AN QJ>4S: BH7 567>J6475B643
and domestic sales of Marvell’s products
; V=BAS>7 %B; DCW@; /N>:> ?5:OH7>: N49> 6B Q>4J56I B6 7N> 56:7467 P477>J:;
!"#$ &'()*+,*((&)(*-./ 01+23$45 )66 /78$9 (6:6;:;< =">$ 6 1? @&

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->