Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UMBER *UNE
1SPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSET
GPSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPOJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUBOE
PUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
!IM AND SCOPE
4HE )NTERNATIONAL 2EVIEW OF THE 2ED #ROSS IS A PERIODICAL
PUBLISHED BY THE )#2# )TS AIM IS TO PROMOTE REFLECTION ON
HUMANITARIAN LAW POLICY AND ACTION IN ARMED CONFLICT AND
OTHER SITUATIONS OF COLLECTIVE ARMED VIOLENCE ! SPECIAL
IZED JOURNAL IN HUMANITARIAN LAW IT ENDEAVOURS TO PROMOTE
KNOWLEDGE CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE LAW AND
CONTRIBUTE TO THE PREVENTION OF VIOLATIONS OF RULES PROTECTING &EJUPSJO$IJFG
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND VALUES 4HE 2EVIEW OFFERS A FORUM FOR 5POJ1GBOOFS
DISCUSSION ABOUT CONTEMPORARY HUMANITARIAN ACTION AS WELL *$3$
AS ANALYSIS OF THE CAUSES AND CHARACTERISTICS OF CONFLICTS SO
AS TO GIVE A CLEARER INSIGHT INTO THE HUMANITARIAN PROBLEMS &EJUPSJBM#PBSE
"INFE"CPV&M8BGB
THEY GENERATE &INALLY THE 2EVIEW INFORMS ITS READERSHIP ON $BJSP6OJWFSTJUZ
&HZQU
QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO THE )NTERNATIONAL 2ED #ROSS AND 2ED %BOJFM#BS5BM
#RESCENT -OVEMENT AND IN PARTICULAR ON THE ACTIVITIES AND 5FM"WJW6OJWFSTJUZ
*TSBFM
POLICIES OF THE )#2# "OOFUUF#FDLFS
6OJWFSTJUÊ1BSJT9
'SBODF
"OUÔOJP$BOÉBEP5SJOEBEF
6OJWFSTJUZPG#SBTJMJB
#SB[JM
.BSJLB'BIMFO
*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFPGUIF3FE$SPTT .JOJTUSZGPS'PSFJHO"GGBJST
4UPDLIPMN
5IF *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PNNJUUFF PG UIF 3FE $SPTT *$3$
4XFEFO
JT BO JNQBSUJBM
OFVUSBM BOE JOEFQFOEFOU PSHBOJ[BUJPO #FSOBSE)BZLFM
XIPTFFYDMVTJWFMZIVNBOJUBSJBONJTTJPOJTUPQSPUFDUUIF /FX:PSL6OJWFSTJUZ
64"
MJWFTBOEEJHOJUZPGWJDUJNTPGXBSBOEJOUFSOBMWJPMFODF 74.BOJ
BOEUPQSPWJEFUIFNXJUIBTTJTUBODF*UEJSFDUTBOEDPPS (VKBSBU/BUJPOBM-BX6OJWFSTJUZ
EJOBUFT UIF JOUFSOBUJPOBM SFMJFG BDUJWJUJFT DPOEVDUFE CZ (BOEIJOBHBS
(VKBSBU
*OEJB
UIF .PWFNFOU JO TJUVBUJPOT PG DPOGMJDU *U BMTP FOEFBW )FSGSJFE.ÛOLMFS
PVST UP QSFWFOU TVGGFSJOH CZ QSPNPUJOH BOE TUSFOHUI )VNCPMEU6OJWFSTJUZ
#FSMJO
(FSNBOZ
FOJOH JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX BOE VOJWFSTBM .POB3JTINBXJ
IVNBOJUBSJBOQSJODJQMFT&TUBCMJTIFEJO
UIF*$3$ 0GGJDFPGUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT)JHI
JTBUUIFPSJHJOPGUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FE$SPTTBOE3FE $PNNJTTJPOFSGPS)VNBO3JHIUT
(FOFWB
$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU &MJ[BCFUI4BMNÓO(ÃSBUF
1POUJGJDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUÓMJDBEFM1FSÙ
-JNB
1FSÙ
.FNCFSTPGUIF$PNNJUUFF
.BSDP4BTTÖMJ
1SFTJEFOU+BLPC,FMMFOCFSHFS 6OJWFSTJUZPG(FOFWB
4XJU[FSMBOE
7JDF1SFTJEFOU0MJWJFS7PEP[
.JDIBFM/4DINJUU
1FSNBOFOU7JDF1SFTJEFOU+BDRVFT'PSTUFS (FPSHF$.BSTIBMM&VSPQFBO$FOUFSGPS
4FDVSJUZ4UVEJFT
(BSNJTDI1BSUFOLJSDIFO
+FBO"CU 1BPMB(IJMMBOJ (FSNBOZ
+FBO1IJMJQQF"TTBM $MBVEF-F$PVMUSF 5FSFODF5BZMPS
$ISJTUJOF#FFSMJ +BDRVFT.PSFJMMPO *OUFSOBUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFGPS4USBUFHJD4UVEJFT
1BPMP#FSOBTDPOJ (BCSJFMMF/BODIFO -POEPO8BTIJOHUPO%$
6,64"
&SOTU"#SVHHFS :WFT4BOEP[ #BLIUJZBS35V[NVLIBNFEPW
4VTZ#SVTDIXFJMFS %BOJFM5IÛSFS %JQMPNBUJD"DBEFNZ
.PTDPX
3VTTJBO
'FEFSBUJPO
+FBOEF$PVSUFO "OESÊWPO.PPT
8FORJ;IV
-BX4DIPPM
3FONJO6OJWFSTJUZPG$IJOB
#FJKJOH
1FPQMFT3FQVCMJDPG$IJOB
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
1SPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFT
BOETBGFHVBSET
GPSJOUFSONFOU
BENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPOJOBSNFE
DPOóJDUBOEPUIFS
TJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
+FMFOB1FKJD
+FMFOB 1FKJD JT -FHBM "EWJTPS BU UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PNNJUUFF PG UIF 3FE $SPTT BOE
)FBE PG UIF *$3$ 1SPKFDU PO UIF 3FBîSNBUJPO BOE %FWFMPQNFOU PG *OUFSOBUJPOBM
)VNBOJUBSJBO-BX
"CTUSBDU
%FQSJWBUJPO PG MJCFSUZ GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT JT BO FYDFQUJPOBM NFBTVSF PG DPOUSPM
UIBUNBZCFUBLFOJOBSNFEDPOGMJDU
XIFUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM
"ENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO PG QFSTPOT CFMJFWFE UP SFQSFTFOU B UISFBU UP 4UBUF
TFDVSJUZJTBMTPCFJOHNPSFBOENPSFXJEFMZQSBDUJTFE PVUTJEF PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU
TJUVBUJPOT5IJTQBQFSBSHVFTUIBUCPUIJOUFSONFOUBOEBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO
BSF JOTVGGJDJFOUMZ FMBCPSBUFE GSPN UIF QPJOU PG UIF WJFX PG UIF QSPUFDUJPO PG UIF
SJHIUTPGUIFQFSTPOTBGGFDUFE%SBXJOHPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXBOEPO
IVNBOSJHIUTMBXBOETUBOEBSET
UIFQBQFSQSPQPTFTBTFUPGQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFT
BOE TBGFHVBSET UIBU TIPVME BT B NBUUFS PG MBX BOE QPMJDZ CF BQQMJFE BT B
NJOJNVNUPBMMDBTFTPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZGPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOT
*OUFSONFOUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTEFĐOFEBTUIFEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZPG
BQFSTPOUIBUIBTCFFOJOJUJBUFEPSEFSFECZUIFFYFDVUJWFCSBODIOPUUIFKVEJDJ
BSZXJUIPVUDSJNJOBMDIBSHFTCFJOHCSPVHIUBHBJOTUUIFJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWF
ĂFWJFXTFYQSFTTFEJOUIJTBSUJDMFSFēFDUUIFBVUIPSTPQJOJPOTBOEOPUOFDFTTBSJMZUIPTFPGUIF*$3$
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
EFUBJOFF*OUFSONFOUJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSFPGDPOUSPMUIBUNBZCFPSEFSFE
GPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOTJOBSNFEDPOēJDU
PSGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGQSPUFDUJOH4UBUFTFDV
SJUZPSQVCMJDPSEFSJOOPODPOēJDUTJUVBUJPOTQSPWJEFEUIFSFRVJTJUFDSJUFSJBIBWF
CFFONFUĂFQVSQPTFPGUIJTUFYUJTUPPVUMJOFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGF
HVBSETUIBUHPWFSOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJOBSNFEDPOēJDUBOEJO
PUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFBTBNBUUFSCPUIPGMBXBOEPGQPMJDZ
*OUIFUFYU
UIFUFSNTiJOUFSONFOUuBOEiBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOuBSF
JOUFSDIBOHFBCMZVTFE5IFEFGJOJUJPOPGJOUFSONFOUUIFSFGPSFEPFTOPUJODMVEF
UIFMBXGVMQSFUSJBMEFUFOUJPOPGBQFSTPOIFMEPODSJNJOBMDIBSHFT
XIFUIFSJO
PSPVUTJEFBSNFEDPOGMJDU"MTP
GPSUIFQVSQPTFTPGUIJTUFYU
JUEPFTOPUJODMVEF
UIF JOUFSONFOU PG QSJTPOFST PG XBS 108T
JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT
XIJDIJTBTQFDJGJDBOETFQBSBUFSFHJNFPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ
*OTPGBSBTBSNFEHSPVQTJOWPMWFEJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
EFQSJWF QFSTPOT PG MJCFSUZ JO QSBDUJDF SFHBSEMFTT PG UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG TVDI
DPOEVDUUIFZBSFCPVOECZUIFBQQMJDBCMFUSFBUZCBTFEBOEDVTUPNBSZSVMFT
PGJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXHPWFSOJOHOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
TVNNBSJ[FE JO UIJT UFYU 8IFSF QSBDUJDBMMZ GFBTJCMF
UIF PUIFS QSJODJQMFT BOE
TBGFHVBSET TFU GPSUI CFMPX TIPVME BMTP CF BQQMJFE BT B NFBOT PG FOTVSJOH UIF
QSPUFDUJPOPGQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZ
5IFSFBTPOGPSPVUMJOJOHUIFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETUIBU
HPWFSOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUIBUBMUIPVHIUIJTUZQFPGEFQSJ
WBUJPOPGMJCFSUZJTPGUFOQSBDUJTFEJOCPUIJOUFSOBUJPOBMBOEOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BSNFEDPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
UIFQSPUFDUJPOPGUIFSJHIUTPG
UIFQFSTPOTBGGFDUFECZJUJTJOTVGGJDJFOUMZFMBCPSBUFE
'VSUIFSNPSF
JU JT GBJSMZ DPNNPO UIBU JO QSBDUJDF QFPQMF JOUFSOFE PS
IFME JO BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO BSF OPU PS BSF POMZ WBHVFMZ JOGPSNFE PG UIF
SFBTPOTGPSUIFJSEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ5IFSFJTPGUFOOPNFDIBOJTNJOQMBDFUP
SFWJFX
JOJUJBMMZ BOE QFSJPEJDBMMZ
UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPO PS
JG UIFSF JT POF
JUT MBDL PG JOEFQFOEFODF QSFWFOUT JU GSPN FGGFD
UJWFMZFYBNJOJOHDBTFT5IFRVFTUJPOPGMFHBMBTTJTUBODFUPJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSB
UJWFEFUBJOFFTJODIBMMFOHJOHUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGUIFJSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPOSFNBJOTDPOUFOUJPVT
BTEPPUIFSJTTVFT
TVDIBTDPOUBDUGPSJOUFSOFFT
BENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTXJUIUIFJSGBNJMJFT
GBNJMZWJTJUTUPUIFN
FUD
4FF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPMTPG+VOFUPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOTPG"VHVTU
*$3$.BSUJOVT/JKIPć1VCMJTIFST
(FOFWB
i$PNNFOUBSZPO1SPUPDPM*SFMBUJWFUPJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BSNFEDPOēJDUTu
"SU
QBSB
ĂF SFMFWBOU DSJUFSJB
XIJDI BSF FYQMBJOFE JO HSFBUFS EFUBJM CFMPX
BSF MBJE EPXO JO "SUJDMF PG UIF
*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PWFOBOUPO$JWJMBOE1PMJUJDBM3JHIUT *$$13
ĂFUFSNiPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFuSFGFSTUPTJUVBUJPOTCFMPXUIFUISFTIPMEPGBSNFEDPOēJDUBOEJODMVEFT
TJUVBUJPOTPGiJOUFSOBMEJTUVSCBODFTPSUFOTJPOTuBTTQFDJĐFEJO"SUJDMF
PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**
ĂFUFSNiJOUFSONFOUuJTBMTPJOUFOEFEUPDPWFSUIFOPUJPOPGiBTTJHOFESFTJEFODF
uUPXIJDIJEFOUJDBM
QSPWJTJPOTPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBQQMZ
ĂJT TIPVME JO OP XBZ CF SFBE BT SFGFSSJOH UP PS MFHJUJNJ[JOH
UIF QSBDUJDF PG IPTUBHFUBLJOH
XIJDI
JT TUSJDUMZ QSPIJCJUFE CZ JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX ĂF *$3$T QPTJUJPO JT UIBU IPTUBHFT NVTU CF
JNNFEJBUFMZBOEVODPOEJUJPOBMMZSFMFBTFE
'PS EJćFSFODFT JO UIF MFHBM SFHVMBUJPO PG JOUFSONFOU JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE
DPOēJDUTBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFTFFTFDUJPO*
i-FHBMTPVSDFT
uCFMPX
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
-FHBMTPVSDFT
5IFMFHBMTPVSDFTPOXIJDIUIFQSFTFOUTUBOEBSETBSFCBTFEBSFUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB
$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF PG "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM * UP UIF (FOFWB $POWFOUJPOT
XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFGMFDUDVTUPNBSZJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX"SUJDMFDPNNPO
UPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**UIFSFUPBOEDVTUPNBSZSVMFT
PGJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX
&WFOUIPVHIJOUFSONFOUJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTSFHVMBUFECZ
UIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBOE"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*
UIFTFUSFBUJFTEPOPU
TVGGJDJFOUMZFMBCPSBUFPOUIFQSPDFEVSBMSJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT
OPSEPUIFZTQFDJGZ
UIFEFUBJMTPGUIFMFHBMGSBNFXPSLUIBUBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZNVTUJNQMFNFOU*O
OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTUIFSFJTFWFOMFTTDMBSJUZBTUPIPXBENJOJTUSB
UJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUPCFPSHBOJ[FE"SUJDMFDPNNPOUPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT
XIJDIJTBQQMJDBCMFBTBNJOJNVNTUBOEBSEUPBMMOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPO
GMJDUT
DPOUBJOTOPQSPWJTJPOTSFHVMBUJOHJOUFSONFOU
JFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFO
UJPO GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT
BQBSU GSPN UIF SFRVJSFNFOU PG IVNBOF USFBUNFOU
*OUFSONFOUJT
IPXFWFS
DMFBSMZBNFBTVSFUIBUDBOCFUBLFOJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BSNFEDPOGMJDU
BTFWJEFODFECZUIFMBOHVBHFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**
XIJDI
NFOUJPOTJOUFSONFOUJO"SUJDMFTBOESFTQFDUJWFMZ
CVUMJLFXJTFEPFTOPUHJWF
EFUBJMTPGIPXJUJTUPCFPSHBOJ[FE#FBSJOHJONJOEUIFQSJODJQMFTPGIVNBOJUZ
BOEUIFEJDUBUFTPGQVCMJDDPOTDJFODF UIF.BSUFOTDMBVTF
UIFQSJODJQMFTBOE
SVMFTPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPONBZ
JOQSBDUJDF
TFSWFBTHVJEBODFJO
OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JO SFTPMWJOH TPNF PG UIF QSPDFEVSBM JTTVFT
NFOUJPOFEJOUIJTUFYU
*OBEEJUJPOUPIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX
UIFQSFTFOUBOBMZTJTESBXTPOIVNBO
SJHIUTMBX
PGCPUIBCJOEJOHBOEBOPOCJOEJOHOBUVSF iTPGUMBXu
BTBDPN
QMFNFOUBSZTPVSDFPGMBXJOTJUVBUJPOTPGBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSBTBOBVUPOPNPVT
TPVSDF PG MBX PVUTJEF PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU 5IF DPNQMFNFOUBSZ SFMBUJPOTIJQ
CFUXFFO IVNBOJUBSJBO BOE IVNBO SJHIUT MBX IBT NPTU SFDFOUMZ CFFO DPO
GJSNFECZUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVSUPG+VTUJDF
UIF6/TQSJODJQBMMFHBMCPEZ*O
B+VMZ"EWJTPSZ0QJOJPO
UIF$PVSUTUBUFEUIBUIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBO
SJHIUTMBXBSFCZOPNFBOTNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWF"DDPSEJOHUPUIF$PVSU
TPNF
SJHIUT BSF QSPUFDUFE POMZ CZ IVNBO SJHIUT MBX
TPNF BSF QSPUFDUFE POMZ CZ
IVNBOJUBSJBOMBX
BOEiZFUPUIFSTNBZCFNBUUFSTPGCPUIUIFTFCSBODIFTPG
JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXu
5IF SJHIUT PG QFSTPOT JOUFSOFE GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT JO BSNFE DPO
GMJDUXIFUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMNBZCFTBJEUPGBMMJOUP
UIFDBUFHPSZPGSJHIUTUIBU
JOUIF*$+TXPSEJOH
BSFiNBUUFSTuPGCPUICSBODIFT
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
PG MBX (JWFO UIF BGPSFTBJE BCTFODF PG SVMFT GPS UIF JOUFSONFOU PG JOEJWJEVBMT
JOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
JUJTOFDFTTBSZUPESBXPOIVNBOSJHIUT
MBXJOEFWJTJOHBMJTUPGQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETUPHPWFSOJOUFSO
NFOUJOTVDIDPOGMJDUT5PBMBSHFFYUFOUUIFTBNFNBZCFTBJEXJUISFHBSEUP
BOZFGGPSUUPDMBSJGZUIFSJHIUT
BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFMFHBMQSPUFDUJPO
UIBUTIPVMECF
BDDPSEFEUPQFSTPOTDPWFSFECZUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOPS"EEJUJPOBM
1SPUPDPM*JOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
3FDPVSTF UP IVNBO SJHIUT MBX BT B MFHBM SFHJNF DPNQMFNFOUBSZ UP
IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX JT FYQSFTTMZ SFDPHOJ[FE JO CPUI "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPMT UP UIF
(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT
"DDPSEJOHUP"SUJDMFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*iĂFQSPWJTJPOTPGUIJT
4FDUJPO<i5SFBUNFOUPGQFSTPOTJOUIFQPXFSPGBQBSUZUPUIFDPOēJDUu>BSFBEEJ
UJPOBM UP UIF SVMFTDPODFSOJOHIVNBOJUBSJBOQSPUFDUJPOPGDJWJMJBOTBOEDJWJMJBO
PCKFDUTJOUIFQPXFSPGB1BSUZUPUIFDPOēJDUDPOUBJOFEJOUIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPO
QBSUJDVMBSMZ1BSUT*BOE***UIFSFPG
BTXFMMBTUPPUIFSBQQMJDBCMFSVMFTPGJOUFSOB
UJPOBMMBXSFMBUJOHUPUIFQSPUFDUJPOPGGVOEBNFOUBMIVNBOSJHIUTEVSJOHJOUFSOB
UJPOBM BSNFE DPOēJDUu FNQIBTJT BEEFE
ĂJT BSUJDMF BMMPXT SFDPVSTF UP IVNBO
SJHIUTMBXBTBOBEEJUJPOBMGSBNFPGSFGFSFODFJOSFHVMBUJOHUIFSJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT
XIPCFMPOHUPiQFSTPOTJOUIFQPXFSPGBQBSUZUPUIFDPOēJDUu
ĂFSFBSFUXPGVSUIFSJOEJDBUJPOTJO"SUJDMFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*
XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFGMFDUDVTUPNBSZMBXUIBUIVNBOSJHIUTMBXNBZCF
ESBXOPOUPGJMMUIFHBQT'JSTU
BOEUIJTNVTUCFTUSFTTFE
"SUJDMF
TUBUFT
UIBUQFSTPOTGBMMJOHXJUIJOJUTTDPQFTIBMMFOKPZUIFQSPUFDUJPOQSPWJEFEGPSCZ
UIJTBSUJDMFiBTBNJOJNVNu FNQIBTJTBEEFE
(JWFOUIBU"SUJDMFJTBiTBGFUZ
OFUu NFBOU UP DPWFS BMM QFSTPOT XIP EP OPU FOKPZ NPSF GBWPVSBCMF USFBUNFOU
VOEFSUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOTPS1SPUPDPM*
BOEXIFOJUJTSFBEJODPOKVODUJPO
XJUI"SUJDMF
JUOFDFTTBSJMZGPMMPXTUIBUUIFiNJOJNVNuNFOUJPOFEJTTVQQMF
NFOUFECZPUIFSQSPWJTJPOTPGIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
4FDPOEMZ
BOZ QPTTJCMF EPVCU UIBU "SUJDMF DPOTUJUVUFT B NJOJNVN
CFODINBSL PG QSPUFDUJPO JT EJTQFMMFE CZ UIF GJOBM DMBVTF UIFSFPG i/P QSPWJ
TJPOPGUIJT"SUJDMFNBZCFDPOTUSVFEBTMJNJUJOHPSJOGSJOHJOHBOZPUIFSNPSF
GBWPVSBCMFQSPWJTJPOHSBOUJOHHSFBUFSQSPUFDUJPO
VOEFSBOZBQQMJDBCMFSVMFTPG
JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX
UPQFSTPOTDPWFSFECZQBSBHSBQIu5IFBQQMJDBCMFSVMFTPG
JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXJODMVEFIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG $PNNPO
"SUJDMFBOEPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**BSUJDVMBUFNJOJNVNTUBOEBSETUIBUNVTU
CFBQQMJFEJOJOUFSONFOU8IFSFUIFQBSUJFTUPBOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDU
CSJOH JOUP GPSDF
CZ NFBOT PG TQFDJBM BHSFFNFOUT
BMM PS QBSU PG UIF QSPWJTJPOT
PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO
UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG TVDI BO BHSFFNFOU
QSFWBJM*UNVTUCFOPUFEUIBUQSFBNCVMBSQBSBHSBQIPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
FTUBCMJTIFT UIF MJOL CFUXFFO UIF 1SPUPDPM BOE IVNBO SJHIUT MBXCZ TUBUJOH UIBU
iJOUFSOBUJPOBMJOTUSVNFOUTSFMBUJOHUPIVNBOSJHIUTPćFSBCBTJDQSPUFDUJPOUPUIF
IVNBO QFSTPOu ĂF $PNNFOUBSZ PO UIBU 1SPUPDPM TQFDJĐFT UIBU UIF SFGFSFODF
UP JOUFSOBUJPOBM JOTUSVNFOUT JODMVEFT USFBUJFT BEPQUFE CZ UIF 6/
TVDI BT UIF
*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PWFOBOUPO$JWJMBOE1PMJUJDBM3JHIUT *$$13
BOEUIF$POWFOUJPO
BHBJOTU5PSUVSF
BTXFMMBTUIFSFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFT
ĂFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPO
XIJDIJTUIFQSJNBSZGPDVTPGUIJTUFYU
JT
JOUFSBMJBQSPWJEFEGPSJO"SUJDMF
PGUIF*$$13"4UBUF1BSUZNBZEFSPHBUF
GSPN TVTQFOE
JUTPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSUIBUUSFBUZVOEFSWFSZTUSJDUDPOEJUJPOT
POF
PGXIJDIJTUIFFYJTUFODFPGBQVCMJDFNFSHFODZUISFBUFOJOHUIFMJGFPGUIFOBUJPO
/POJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUJTBOFYBNQMFPGBQVCMJDFNFSHFODZJOXIJDI
NFBTVSFTPGEFSPHBUJPOOFDFTTBSZGPSFOBCMJOHJOUFSONFOUXPVMECFMBXGVM
VOEFS UIF $PWFOBOU QSPWJEFE UIF PUIFS SFRVJTJUF DPOEJUJPOT IBWF CFFO NFU
*OOPODPOēJDUTJUVBUJPOT4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIF*$$13NVTUMJLFXJTFDPNQMZXJUI
UIF EFSPHBUJPO DMBVTFT PG UIF $PWFOBOU JO PSEFS UP JOTUJUVUF NFBTVSFT BćFDUJOH
UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ PG QFSTPO
TVDI BT BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO 5IF QSFTFOU
BOBMZTJTJTCBTFEPOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUJOUFSONFOUJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE
DPOēJDU BOE BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JNQMFNFOUFE JO OPODPOēJDU TJUVBUJPOT
DPNQMZXJUIUIFEFSPHBUJPODSJUFSJBTQFDJĐFEJOUIF*$$13
)PXFWFS
FWFO JO FNFSHFODZ TJUVBUJPOT UIF TPDBMMFE iIBSE DPSFu PG
IVNBO SJHIUT
XIJDI JODMVEFT UIF SJHIU UP MJGF BOE UIF QSPIJCJUJPO PG UPSUVSF
BOE PUIFS DSVFM
JOIVNBO PS EFHSBEJOH USFBUNFOU PS QVOJTINFOU
DBOOPU CF
EFSPHBUFEGSPNVOEFSBOZDJSDVNTUBODFT5IFKVSJTQSVEFODFPGJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BOESFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTCPEJFTIBTEFUFSNJOFEXIJDIPUIFSIVNBOSJHIUT
BQBSUGSPNUIPTFFYQSFTTMZMJTUFEJOUIFUSFBUJFT
TIPVMEBMTPCFDPOTJEFSFEOPO
EFSPHBCMF"NPOHUIFNJTUIFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZUPDIBMMFOHF
UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO IBCFBTDPSQVT
XIJDIJTBOFTTFOUJBMFMF
NFOUPGUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPO
)VNBOSJHIUTTPGUMBXJOTUSVNFOUTBOEKVSJTQSVEFODFQSPWJEFGVSUIFS
TUBOEBSETUIBU
JUJTTVCNJUUFE
TIPVMEBTBNBUUFSPGQPMJDZBOEHPPEQSBDUJDFCF
BQQMJFEXJUISFTQFDUUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
5IFDPNNFOUBSZUPUIFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETPVUMJOFE
JOUIJTUFYUNFOUJPOTUIFEJGGFSFOUMFHBMTPVSDFTHPWFSOJOHEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ
GPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOTJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE
DPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF*UJTQSFDJTFMZUIFTJNJMBSJUZJODPOUFOU
PGUIFWBSJPVTMFHBMTPVSDFTSFWJFXFEUIBUHVJEFEUIFTQFDJGJDGPSNVMBUJPOPGUIF
QSPDFEVSBM QSJODJQMFT BOE TBGFHVBSET MJTUFE
BOE XIJDI BMMPXT UIF DPODMVTJPO
UIBUUIFZDBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBNJOJNVNBQQMJDBCMFJOBMMDBTFTPGEFQSJWBUJPOPG
MJCFSUZGPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOT
(FOFSBMQSJODJQMFTBQQMJDBCMFUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSF
ĂF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO NBLFT JU FYQMJDJUMZ DMFBS UIBU JOUFSONFOU BOE
BTTJHOFE SFTJEFODF
BSF UIF NPTU TFWFSF NFBTVSFT PG DPOUSPM UIBU B EFUBJOJOH
BVUIPSJUZPS0DDVQZJOH1PXFSNBZUBLFXJUISFTQFDUUPQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOTBHBJOTU
XIPNOPDSJNJOBMQSPDFFEJOHTIBWFCFFOJOJUJBUFE*OCPUIDBTFTJUJTTUJQVMBUFE
UIBUSFDPVSTFUPUIFTFNFBTVSFTNBZCFIBEPOMZJGUIFTFDVSJUZPGUIF4UBUFNBLFT
JUiBCTPMVUFMZOFDFTTBSZu ($*7
"SUJDMF
PSGPSiJNQFSBUJWFSFBTPOTPGTFDV
SJUZu ($*7
"SUJDMF
ĂFFYDFQUJPOBMOBUVSFPGJOUFSONFOUMJFTJOUIFGBDUUIBU
JUBMMPXTUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPEFQSJWFQFSTPOTPGMJCFSUZXIPBSFOPUTVCKFDU
UPDSJNJOBMQSPDFTT
CVUBSFOFWFSUIFMFTTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFQSFTFOUBSFBMUISFBUUPJUT
TFDVSJUZJOUIFQSFTFOUPSJOUIFGVUVSF"TUIF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB
$POWFOUJPOFYQMBJOT
i*UEJEOPUTFFNQPTTJCMFUPEFĐOFUIFFYQSFTTJPOATFDVSJUZ
PGUIF4UBUFJOBNPSFDPODSFUFGBTIJPO*UJTUIVTMFĔWFSZMBSHFMZUP(PWFSONFOUT
UPEFDJEFUIFNFBTVSFPGBDUJWJUZQSFKVEJDJBMUPUIFJOUFSOBMPSFYUFSOBMTFDVSJUZ
PGUIF4UBUFXIJDIKVTUJĐFTJOUFSONFOUPSBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFu8IJMFUIJTNBZCF
UIFDBTFJUJTDMFBS
GPSFYBNQMF
UIBUJOUFSONFOUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOGPS
UIFTPMFQVSQPTFPGJOUFMMJHFODFHBUIFSJOH
XJUIPVUUIFQFSTPOJOWPMWFEPUIFSXJTF
QSFTFOUJOHBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ
DBOOPUCFKVTUJĐFE
ĂBUJOUFSONFOUJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSFJTBMTPUSVFJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BSNFEDPOēJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
CBTFEPOUIFHFOFSBMQSJODJQMF
UIBUQFSTPOBMMJCFSUZJTUIFSVMF
BOEPOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUUIFDSJNJOBMKVTUJDF
TZTUFN JT BCMF UP EFBM XJUI QFSTPOT TVTQFDUFE PG SFQSFTFOUJOH B EBOHFS UP 4UBUF
TFDVSJUZ
*UTIPVMEBHBJOCFOPUFEUIBUUIJTUFYUEPFTOPUEFBMXJUIUIFJOUFSONFOUPGQSJTPOFSTPGXBSJOJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BSNFEDPOēJDUT
XIJDIJTHPWFSOFECZUIFĂJSE(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO"TBMSFBEZNFOUJPOFE
JUJTBTTVNFE
UIBUUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPOIBTCFFOEFSPHBUFEGSPNJOLFFQJOHXJUI"SUJDMFPGUIF*$$13
4FF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOTPG"VHVTU
7PM7
(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOSFMBUJWFUPUIF
1SPUFDUJPOPG$JWJMJBO1FSTPOTJO5JNFPG8BS
"SU
Q4FFBMTPUIF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMF
BU
QBHF
XIJDISFJUFSBUFTUIBUi*OBOZDBTFTVDINFBTVSFTDBOPOMZCFPSEFSFEGPSSFBMBOEJNQFSBUJWF
SFBTPOTPGTFDVSJUZUIFJSFYDFQUJPOBMDIBSBDUFSNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEu
4JNJMBSMZ
JOUFSOJOHPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOJOHQFSTPOTGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGVTJOHUIFNBTiCBSHBJOJOH
DIJQTuJTBMTPOPUKVTUJĐBCMFBTBSFBTPOGPSJOUFSONFOU4VDIEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZXPVMEJOGBDUBNPVOU
UPIPTUBHFUBLJOH
XIJDIJTQSPIJCJUFE
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTOPUBOBMUFSOBUJWFUPDSJNJOBM
QSPDFFEJOHT
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTBNFBTVSFPGDPOUSPMBJNFEBUEFBMJOH
XJUIQFSTPOTXIPQPTFBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ
DVSSFOUMZPSJOUIFGVUVSF
JO TJUVBUJPOT PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU
PS UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZ PS QVCMJD PSEFS JO
OPODPOGMJDU TJUVBUJPOT JU JT OPU B NFBTVSF UIBU JT NFBOU UP SFQMBDF DSJNJOBM
QSPDFFEJOHT " QFSTPO XIP JT TVTQFDUFE PG IBWJOH DPNNJUUFE B DSJNJOBM
PGGFODF
XIFUIFSJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
IBTUIFSJHIU
UP CFOFGJU GSPN UIF BEEJUJPOBM TUSJOHFOU KVEJDJBM HVBSBOUFFT QSPWJEFE GPS JO
IVNBOJUBSJBOBOEPSIVNBOSJHIUTMBXGPSDSJNJOBMTVTQFDUT
XIJDIJODMVEFUIF
SJHIU UP CF USJFE CZ B SFHVMBSMZ DPOTUJUVUFE
JOEFQFOEFOU BOE JNQBSUJBM DPVSU
6OMFTTJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOBOEQFOBMSFQSFTTJPOBSFPSHBOJ[FE
BTTUSJDUMZTFQBSBUFSFHJNFTUIFSFJTBEBOHFSUIBUJOUFSONFOUNJHIUCFVTFEBT
BTVCTUBOEBSETZTUFNPGQFOBMSFQSFTTJPOJOUIFIBOETPGUIFFYFDVUJWFQPXFS
CZQBTTJOHUIFPOFTBODUJPOFECZBDPVOUSZTMFHJTMBUVSFBOEDPVSUT5IFSJHIUTPG
DSJNJOBMTVTQFDUTXPVMEUIVTCFHSBWFMZVOEFSNJOFE
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPODBOPOMZCFPSEFSFEPOBOJOEJWJEVBM
DBTFCZDBTFCBTJT
XJUIPVUEJTDSJNJOBUJPOPGBOZLJOE
"DJWJMJBODBOCFJOUFSOFEJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUPOMZPOUIFCBTJTPGBO
JOEJWJEVBMEFDJTJPOUBLFOJOFWFSZTQFDJGJDDBTF5IFOPUJPOUIBUJOUFSONFOUDBO
OPUCFBDPMMFDUJWFNFBTVSFJTFTUBCMJTIFEVOEFSUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO
JOTJUVBUJPOTPGPDDVQBUJPO&OCMPDJOUFSONFOUPGFOFNZOBUJPOBMTJOB4UBUFT
PXOUFSSJUPSZJTBMTPQSPIJCJUFE
BTJUXPVMEBNPVOUUP
BOEWJPMBUFUIFHFOFSBM
QSPIJCJUJPOPG
iDPMMFDUJWFQVOJTINFOUTuVOEFS"SUJDMF
E
PG"EEJUJPOBM
1SPUPDPM*5IJTEPFTOPUNFBOUIBUBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZDBOOPUJOUFSOBMBSHF
OVNCFS PG QFSTPOT
CVU UIBU CPUI UIF JOJUJBM EFDJTJPO PO JOUFSONFOU BOE BOZ
TVCTFRVFOUEFDJTJPOUPNBJOUBJOJU
JODMVEJOHUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU
NVTU
CFUBLFOXJUISFTQFDUUPFBDIJOEJWJEVBMJOWPMWFE
*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JO XIJDI DPMMFDUJWF QVOJTI
NFOUTBSFBMTPQSPIJCJUFEBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
CPUIUIFJOJUJBM
ĂFBSHVNFOUUIBUBENJOJTUSBUJWFBOEDSJNJOBMEFUFOUJPOBSFUXPEJTUJODUSFHJNFTJTBUĐSTUHMBODF
VOEFSNJOFECZ"SUJDMFPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOXIJDIEFBMTXJUIQFUUZPćFODFTDPNNJUUFE
CZQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOTJOPDDVQJFEUFSSJUPSZĂF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMF
IPXFWFS
SFDUJĐFTBOZQPTTJCMF
QFSDFQUJPOPGPWFSMBQCFUXFFOUIFSFHJNFTPGBENJOJTUSBUJWFBOEDSJNJOBMEFUFOUJPOUIBUUIFXPSEJOH
PG UIF QSPWJTJPO TVHHFTUT *U SFBET i*OUFSONFOU JT B QSFWFOUJWF BENJOJTUSBUJWF NFBTVSF BOE DBOOPU CF
DPOTJEFSFE B QFOBM TBODUJPO *U JT OFWFSUIFMFTT NFOUJPOFE IFSF VOEFS UIF TBNF IFBE<JOH> BT TJNQMF
JNQSJTPONFOU
CFDBVTFUIFBVUIPSTPGUIF$POWFOUJPOXJTIFEUPNBLFJUQPTTJCMFGPSUIFNJMJUBSZDPVSUT
PGUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSUPHJWFQFSTPOTHVJMUZPGNJOPSPćFODFTUIFCFOFĐUPGDPOEJUJPOTPGJOUFSONFOU
FNQIBTJTBEEFE
QSPWJEFEGPSJO"SUJDMFFUTFRĂFQSPWJTJPOXBTBIVNBOFPOFBOEXBTJOUFOEFE
UPESBXBEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOTVDIPćFOEFSTBOEDPNNPODSJNJOBMTu$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7
PQDJU
OPUF
QQm
*CJE
"SU
Q
"1**
"SU
C
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
EFDJTJPOPOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOBOEBOZTVCTFRVFOUEFDJTJPO
UPNBJOUBJOJUNVTUCFUBLFOPOBOJOEJWJEVBMCBTJT&WFOUIPVHIIVNBOJUBSJBO
MBXHPWFSOJOHOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTTJMFOUBTUPUIFQSPDFEVSBM
SJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT
VOEFSIVNBOSJHIUTMBXBOZNFBTVSFEFSPHBUJOHGSPNUIF
SJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPONVTUCFiTUSJDUMZSFRVJSFECZUIFFYJHFODJFTPGUIFTJUV
BUJPOuPGQVCMJDFNFSHFODZOFDFTTJUBUJOHUIFEFSPHBUJPOJUNBZCFUBLFOPOMZ
UPUIFFYUFOUSFRVJSFEUIFSFCZ
BOENVTUUIVTCFJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIFQSJODJ
QMFPGQSPQPSUJPOBMJUZ
" 4UBUFT FO CMPD
OPOJOEJWJEVBM EFUFOUJPO PG B XIPMF DBUFHPSZ PG QFSTPOT
DPVME JO OP XBZ CF DPOTJEFSFE B QSPQPSUJPOBM SFTQPOTF
SFHBSEMFTT PG XIBU UIF
DJSDVNTUBODFTPGUIFFNFSHFODZDPODFSOFENJHIUCFĂFJEFBPGDPMMFDUJWFNFBTVSFT
PGBOZLJOEJTBOUJUIFUJDBMUPUIFSVMFT
TQJSJUBOEQVSQPTFPGIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
%FDJTJPOT PO JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO NVTU BMTP OPU CF
UBLFOPOBEJTDSJNJOBUPSZCBTJT5IFQSJODJQMFPGOPOEJTDSJNJOBUJPOJTBCBTJD
UFOFUPGCPUIIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOT
GPSJUDFBTFUPFYJTU
0OFPGUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOUQSJODJQMFTHPWFSOJOHJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFO
UJPOJTUIBUUIJTGPSNPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZNVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFJOEJWJEVBM
DFBTFTUPQPTFBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ
NFBOJOHUIBUEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ
POTVDIHSPVOETDBOOPUCFJOEFĐOJUF*OWJFXPGUIFSBQJEQSPHSFTTJPOPGFWFOUTJO
BSNFEDPOēJDU
BQFSTPODPOTJEFSFEUPCFBUISFBUUPEBZNJHIUOPUQPTFUIFTBNF
UISFBUBĔFSBDIBOHFPGDJSDVNTUBODFTPOUIFHSPVOE*OPUIFSXPSET
UIFMPOHFS
JOUFSONFOUMBTUT
UIFHSFBUFSUIFPOVTPOBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPQSPWFUIBUUIF
SFBTPOTGPSJUSFNBJOWBMJEĂFSBUJPOBMFPGUIFQSJODJQMFJTUIVTUPGBDJMJUBUFUIF
SFMFBTFPGBQFSTPOBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOTKVTUJGZJOHUIFDVSUBJMNFOUPGMJCFSUZOP
MPOHFSFYJTUĂFQSJODJQMFUIBUJOUFSONFOUNVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOTGPS
JUDFBTFUPFYJTUJTDMFBSMZFOVODJBUFEJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF
BOEJO"SUJDMF
PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*
XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFēFDU
DVTUPNBSZJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT
*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF
UIJTQSJODJQMFNVTU
JGBOZUIJOH
CFFWFONPSFTUSJOHFOUMZPCTFSWFE
QBSUJDVMBSMZ
BT IVNBO SJHIUT KVSJTQSVEFODF SFKFDUT UIF OPUJPO PG JOEFGJOJUF EFUFOUJPO *O
PSEFSUPFOTVSFUIBUBEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZJTOPUBSCJUSBSZ
XIJDIXPVMECFUIF
DBTFJGUIFSFBTPOTGPSJUEPOPUPSOPMPOHFSFYJTU
UIF*$$13 "SUJDMF
QSP
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
WJEFTUIBUBOZPOFEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZIBTUIFSJHIUUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPG
IJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPOĐMFBQFUJUJPOGPSIBCFBTDPSQVTPSUIFFRVJWBMFOUJOPSEFS
UIBUBDPVSUNBZEFDJEFiXJUIPVUEFMBZuXIFUIFSIFPSTIFJTCFJOHIFMEMBXGVMMZ
PSOPU8IJMFUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZJTOPUBNPOHUIFOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUTMJTUFE
JOUIF*$$13
UIFKVSJTQSVEFODFPGCPUIVOJWFSTBMBOESFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUT
CPEJFTIBTDPOGJSNFEUIBUUIFSJHIUUPIBCFBTDPSQVTNVTUJOGBDUCFDPOTJEFSFE
OPOEFSPHBCMF
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUDPOGPSNUPUIFQSJODJQMF
PGMFHBMJUZ
*OUIFDPOUFYUPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO
UIFQSJODJQMFPGMFHBMJUZ
NFBOT UIBU B QFSTPO NBZ CF EFQSJWFE PG MJCFSUZ POMZ GPS SFBTPOT TVCTUBOUJWF
BTQFDU
BOE JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI QSPDFEVSFT QSPDFEVSBM BTQFDU
UIBU BSF QSP
WJEFEGPSCZEPNFTUJDBOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX
ĂF (FOFWB $POWFOUJPOT BOE UIFJS "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPMT
BT XFMM BT
IVNBOSJHIUTMBX
QSPWJEFUIFJOUFSOBUJPOBMMFHBMTUBOEBSETUIBUBSFUPCFBQQMJFE
UP JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JO BSNFE DPOēJDU BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT
PGWJPMFODF*OUFSNTPGSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU
UIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPOTQFDJĐFT
UIBUBQSPUFDUFEQFSTPONBZCFJOUFSOFEPSQMBDFEJOBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFPOMZJG
iUIFTFDVSJUZPGUIF%FUBJOJOH1PXFSNBLFTJUBCTPMVUFMZOFDFTTBSZu "SUJDMF
PS
JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ
GPS iJNQFSBUJWF SFBTPOT PG TFDVSJUZu "SUJDMF
*O
BEEJUJPOUPTQFDJGZJOHUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU
UIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPOMBZT
EPXO DFSUBJO QSPDFEVSFT UIBU NVTU CF GPMMPXFE GPS JOUFSONFOU UP CF MBXGVM
CPUI JO UIF UFSSJUPSZ PG B QBSUZ UP DPOGMJDU BOE JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ *O UIF
MBUUFS DBTF
GPS FYBNQMF
"SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI $POWFOUJPO TUJQVMBUFT UIBU
EFDJTJPOTSFHBSEJOHBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFPSJOUFSONFOUiTIBMMCFNBEFBDDPSEJOH
UPBSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFUPCFQSFTDSJCFECZUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSJOBDDPSEBODF
XJUI UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF QSFTFOU $POWFOUJPOu %FQSJWBUJPO PG MJCFSUZ UIBU JT
OPUJODPOGPSNJUZXJUIUIFWBSJPVTSVMFTQSPWJEFEGPSJOUIF$POWFOUJPONBZ
DPOTUJUVUFiVOMBXGVMDPOGJOFNFOUu
)VNBOSJHIUTTUBOEBSETBQQMJDBCMFJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
BOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFQSPWJEFFWFONPSFEFUBJMFEQSPWJTJPOTBJNFEBU
FOTVSJOHSFTQFDUGPSUIFQSJODJQMFPGMFHBMJUZ6OEFSUIF*$$13 "SUJDMF
GPS
FYBNQMF
QFSTPOTNBZOPUCFEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZiFYDFQUPOTVDIHSPVOET
BOEJOBDDPSEBODFXJUITVDIQSPDFEVSFBTBSFFTUBCMJTIFECZMBXu8IFSFB4UBUF
EFDJEFT UP EFSPHBUF GSPN UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ
TVDI B EFDJTJPO NVTU
JOUFS BMJB
CF PGGJDJBMMZ QSPDMBJNFE TP BT UP FOBCMF UIF BGGFDUFE QPQVMBUJPO UP LOPX UIF
FYBDUNBUFSJBM
UFSSJUPSJBMBOEUFNQPSBMTDPQFPGBQQMJDBUJPOPGUIBUFNFSHFODZ
NFBTVSF
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
1SPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSET
3JHIUUPJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPO
"OZQFSTPOJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFENVTUCFJOGPSNFEQSPNQUMZ
JO
B MBOHVBHF IF PS TIF VOEFSTUBOET
PG UIF SFBTPOT XIZ UIBU NFBTVSF IBT CFFO
UBLFOTPBTUPFOBCMFUIFQFSTPODPODFSOFEUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPS
IFSEFUFOUJPO5IFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOUPLOPXXIZIFPSTIFIBTCFFOEFQSJWFE
PGMJCFSUZNBZCFTBJEUPDPOTUJUVUFBOFMFNFOUPGUIFPCMJHBUJPOPGIVNBOUSFBU
NFOU
BT B QFSTPOT VODFSUBJOUZ BCPVU UIF SFBTPOT GPS IJT PS IFS EFUFOUJPO JT
LOPXOJOQSBDUJDFUPDPOTUJUVUFBTPVSDFPGBDVUFQTZDIPMPHJDBMTUSFTT
/FJUIFS UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO OPS IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX BQQMJ
DBCMF JO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT DPOUBJO FYQMJDJU QSPWJTJPOT PO UIF
EVUZ UP QSPWJEF JOGPSNBUJPO BCPVU UIF SFBTPOT GPS XIJDI B QFSTPO IBT CFFO
EFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZ5IFGPSFHPJOHQSPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSEJT
IPXFWFS
POFPGUIF
i'VOEBNFOUBM(VBSBOUFFTuMBJEEPXOJO"SUJDMF
PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*
*UJTNPSFPWFSQSPWJEFEGPSJONPTUPGUIFSFMFWBOUIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFTBOEJT
TQFMUPVUJOTPGUMBXJOTUSVNFOUTBTXFMM
5IFJOGPSNBUJPOHJWFONVTUBMTPCFTVGGJDJFOUMZEFUBJMFEGPSUIFEFUBJOFE
QFSTPOUPUBLFJNNFEJBUFTUFQTUPDIBMMFOHF
BOESFRVFTUBEFDJTJPO
POUIFMBX
GVMOFTT PG UIF JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO TFF CFMPX
*OGPSNBUJPO
PO UIF SFBTPOT GPS JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO NVTU CF DPOWFZFE
QSPNQUMZ
TP BT UP FOBCMF UIF QFSTPO JO RVFTUJPO UP BMTP QSPNQUMZ SFRVFTU B
EFDJTJPO PO UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG EFUFOUJPO
BOE NVTU CF DPOWFZFE JO B MBOHVBHF
IFPSTIFVOEFSTUBOET8IFSFBOJOJUJBMEFDJTJPOPOEFUFOUJPOJTNBJOUBJOFEPO
SFWJFX
UIFSFBTPOTGPSDPOUJOVFEEFUFOUJPONVTUCFQSPWJEFEBTXFMM
3JHIUUPCFSFHJTUFSFEBOEIFMEJOBSFDPHOJ[FEQMBDFPGJOUFSONFOU
BENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO
"OZQFSTPOJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFENVTUCFSFHJTUFSFEBOEIFMEJOBO
PGGJDJBMMZSFDPHOJ[FEQMBDFPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO*OGPSNBUJPO
UIBUBQFSTPOIBTCFFOUBLFOJOUPTVDIDVTUPEZBOEPOBOZUSBOTGFSTCFUXFFO
QMBDFTPGEFUFOUJPONVTUCFBWBJMBCMFUPUIBUQFSTPOTGBNJMZXJUIJOBSFBTPOBCMF
UJNF
VOMFTTIFPSTIFIBTFYQSFTTFEBXJTIUPUIFDPOUSBSZUIFGBNJMZTIPVME
BMTPCFOPUJGJFEPGUIFQMBDFPGDVTUPEZ5IFTBNFJOGPSNBUJPONVTUCFTVQQMJFE
UPUIF*$3$XIFOIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXPSTQFDJGJDBHSFFNFOUTTPSFRVJSF
)VNBOJUBSJBOMBXBQQMJDBCMFUPJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTDPOUBJOT
OVNFSPVT QSPWJTJPOT BOE FYUFOTJWF SFRVJSFNFOUT DPODFSOJOH UIF SFHJTUSBUJPO
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
PG QSPUFDUFE QFSTPOT EFQSJWFE PG UIFJS MJCFSUZ BOE OPUJGJDBUJPO PG UIFJS PXO
DPVOUSZT BVUIPSJUJFT
WJTJUT UP QMBDFT PG EFUFOUJPO BOE UIF USBOTNJTTJPO PG
JOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUTVDIQFSTPOTUPUIFJSOFYUPGLJO
BNPOHPUIFST5IFFOUJSF
TZTUFNPGEFUFOUJPOMBJEEPXOCZUIF$POWFOUJPOT
BOEJOXIJDIUIF*$3$QMBZT
BTVQFSWJTPSZSPMF
JTCBTFEPOUIFJEFBUIBUEFUBJOFFTNVTUCFSFHJTUFSFEBOE
IFMEJOPGGJDJBMMZSFDPHOJ[FEQMBDFTPGEFUFOUJPOBDDFTTJCMF
JOQBSUJDVMBS
UPUIF
*$3$ )VNBO SJHIUT KVSJTQSVEFODF BOE TPGU MBX JOTUSVNFOUT DPOUBJO TJNJMBS
FYQMJDJU QSPWJTJPOT PO UIF PCMJHBUJPO UP SFHJTUFS EFUBJOFFT BOE UIF QSPIJCJUJPO
PGVOBDLOPXMFEHFEEFUFOUJPOXIJDIBSFSFMFWBOUJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE
DPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
'PSFJHOOBUJPOBMTJOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO
"QFSTPOTVCKFDUUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOIBTUIFSJHIUUP
DIBMMFOHF
XJUIUIFMFBTUQPTTJCMFEFMBZ
UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO
8JUISFHBSEUPJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO
JO
"SUJDMFBQQMJDBCMFUPUIFJOUFSONFOUPGQFSTPOTJOUIFUFSSJUPSZPGBQBSUZUP
UIFDPOGMJDU
TUJQVMBUFTUIBUBOZQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOJOUFSOFEPSQMBDFEJOBTTJHOFE
SFTJEFODFJTiFOUJUMFEUPIBWFTVDIBDUJPOSFDPOTJEFSFEBTTPPOBTQPTTJCMFCZBO
BQQSPQSJBUFDPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEEFTJHOBUFECZUIF%FUBJOJOH1PXFS
GPS UIBU QVSQPTFu 6OEFS "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI $POWFOUJPO
BQQMJDBCMF UP
UIF JOUFSONFOU PG QFSTPOT JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ
EFDJTJPOT SFHBSEJOH BTTJHOFE
SFTJEFODFPSJOUFSONFOUiTIBMMCFNBEFBDDPSEJOHUPBSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFUPCF
QSFTDSJCFE CZ UIF 0DDVQZJOH 1PXFS JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF
QSFTFOU $POWFOUJPO 5IJT QSPDFEVSF TIBMM JODMVEF UIF SJHIU PG BQQFBM GPS UIF
QBSUJFTDPODFSOFE"QQFBMTTIBMMCFEFDJEFEXJUIUIFMFBTUQPTTJCMFEFMBZu
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
8IJMF UIF $POWFOUJPO EPFT OPU TQFDJGJDBMMZ TQFBL PG UIFTF BDUJPOT BT
DIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPO
UIBUJTXIBUUIFZFTTFOUJBMMZBSF5IF
QVSQPTF PG UIF iSFDPOTJEFSBUJPOu PS iBQQFBMu JT UP FOBCMF UIF DPNQFUFOU CPEZ
UPEFUFSNJOFXIFUIFSUIFQFSTPOXBTEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZGPSWBMJESFBTPOTBOE
UPPSEFSIJTPSIFSSFMFBTFJGUIBUXBTOPUUIFDBTF5IFBVUIPSJUZUIBUJOJUJBMMZ
EFQSJWFEBQFSTPOPGMJCFSUZBOEUIFCPEZBVUIPSJ[FEUPDPOEVDUUIFSFWJFXPO
BQQFBMNVTUOPUCFUIFTBNFJGUIFSJHIUPGQFUJUJPOJTUPCFFGGFDUJWF5IFDIBS
BDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFMBUUFSCPEZBOEUIFFYJTUFODFPGPUIFSQSPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSET
NFOUJPOFECFMPX
BSFUIFDSVDJBMGBDUPS
5IFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO
JOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFJTBLFZ
DPNQPOFOUPGUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPOVOEFSIVNBOSJHIUTMBX&WFOUIPVHI
UIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZNBZCFEFSPHBUFEGSPNJOTJUVBUJPOTPGFNFSHFODZ
IVNBO
SJHIUT TPGU MBX BOE KVSJTQSVEFODF IBWF FTUBCMJTIFE UIBU UIF SJHIU UP DIBMMFOHF
UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGPOFTEFUFOUJPOCFGPSFBKVEJDJBMCPEZNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEJOBMM
DJSDVNTUBODFT*UNBZJOQBSUJDVMBSOPUCFEJNJOJTIFEXIFSFUIFDIBMMFOHFUP
MBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPOTFSWFT
JOUFSBMJB
UPQSPUFDUOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUT
TVDI
BTUIFSJHIUUPMJGFPSGSFFEPNGSPNUPSUVSFBOEPUIFSDSVFM
JOIVNBOPSEFHSBE
JOHUSFBUNFOUPSQVOJTINFOU
"TNBZCFDPODMVEFEGSPNUIFTPVSDFTBCPWF
BSFWJFXPGUIFMBXGVMOFTT
PGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOXJUIJOBTIPSUUJNFJTSFRVJSFECZCPUI
IVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
3FWJFXPGUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUCF
DBSSJFEPVUCZBOJOEFQFOEFOUBOEJNQBSUJBMCPEZ
"SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO TUJQVMBUFT UIBU BO iBQQSPQSJBUF
DPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEuTIBMMCFDIBSHFEXJUISFDPOTJEFSJOHUIFJOJUJBM
EFDJTJPOPOUIFJOUFSONFOUPGBDJWJMJBOJOUIFUFSSJUPSZPGBQBSUZUPUIFDPO
GMJDU "DDPSEJOH UP "SUJDMF BQQMJDBCMF JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ
B EFDJTJPO PO
JOUFSONFOUNVTUCFNBEFQVSTVBOUUPBiSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFuQSFTDSJCFECZUIF
0DDVQZJOH1PXFSJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIF$POWFOUJPO"SUJDMFBEETUIBUUIF
QFSJPEJDSFWJFXFOWJTBHFENVTUCFVOEFSUBLFOCZBiDPNQFUFOUCPEZTFUVQuCZ
UIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFS%FTQJUFUIFEJGGFSFODFJOMBOHVBHFiDPVSUPSBENJOJT
USBUJWFCPBSEuJO"SUJDMFWFSTVTiSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFuJO"SUJDMFUIFDPN
NFOUBSZPOUIFMBUUFSBSUJDMFTUBUFTUIBUUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSiNVTUPCTFSWFUIF
TUJQVMBUJPOTJO"SUJDMFuBOEUIBUJUJTVQUPUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSiUPFOUSVTU
UIFDPOTJEFSBUJPOPGBQQFBMTFJUIFSUPBADPVSUPSBACPBSEu
"4UBUFTGSFFEPNUPDIPPTFCFUXFFOBiDPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEu
BT QSPWJEFE GPS JO "SUJDMF BOE "SUJDMF CZ BOBMPHZ
JT FYQMBJOFE JO UIF
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
$PNNFOUBSZBTBMMPXJOHiTVGGJDJFOUGMFYJCJMJUZUPUBLFJOUPBDDPVOUUIFVTBHFJO
EJGGFSFOU4UBUFTu5IF$PNNFOUBSZBEETUIBUiXIFSFUIFEFDJTJPOJTBOBENJOJT
USBUJWFPOF
JUNVTUOPUCFNBEFCZPOFPGGJDJBMCVUCZBOBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSE
PGGFSJOH UIF OFDFTTBSZ HVBSBOUFFT PG JOEFQFOEFODF BOE JNQBSUJBMJUZu *U NBZ
CFQSFTVNFEUIBUKVEJDJBMTVQFSWJTJPOPGJOUFSONFOUXPVMENPSFMJLFMZDPNQMZ
XJUIUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTPGJOEFQFOEFODFBOEJNQBSUJBMJUZ*UJTUIFSFGPSFTVCNJU
UFEUIBUKVEJDJBMTVQFSWJTJPOXPVMECFQSFGFSBCMFUPBOBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEBOE
TIPVMECFPSHBOJ[FEXIFOFWFSQPTTJCMF5IFSFWJFXJOHCPEZNVTUBUUIFWFSZ
MFBTU
BTTUBUFEJOUIF$PNNFOUBSZ
CFDPOTUJUVUFEBOEGVODUJPOJOBXBZUIBU
BMMPXT JU UP CF JOEFQFOEFOU BOE JNQBSUJBM "O FMFNFOU PG UIF SFRVJSFE JOEF
QFOEFODFPGTVDIBCPEZJTUIBUJUNVTUIBWFUIFBVUIPSJUZUPSFOEFSGJOBMEFDJ
TJPOTPOJOUFSONFOUPSSFMFBTF
8IJMFUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBMMPXTUIF4UBUFUPDIPPTFCFUXFFO
BDPVSUBOEBOBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
IVNBO
SJHIUT MBX BOE KVSJTQSVEFODF BQQMJDBCMF UP TJUVBUJPOT PG OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BSNFE DPOGMJDU PS PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF VOFRVJWPDBMMZ SFRVJSF UIBU
DIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOCFIFBSE
CZBDPVSU6OEFSUIF*$$13
BOZPOFEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZJTFOUJUMFEUPiUBLF
QSPDFFEJOHTCFGPSFBDPVSU
JOPSEFSUIBUUIBUDPVSUNBZEFDJEFXJUIPVUEFMBZ
POUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTEFUFOUJPOBOEPSEFSIJTSFMFBTFJGUIFEFUFOUJPOJTOPU
MBXGVMu
"T IBT BMSFBEZ CFFO TUSFTTFE BCPWF
FWFO UIPVHI UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ
PG QFSTPO NBZ CF EFSPHBUFE GSPN JO TJUVBUJPOT PG FNFSHFODZ
TVDI BT OPO
JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDU
IVNBO SJHIUT TPGU MBX BOE KVSJTQSVEFODF IBWF
FTUBCMJTIFEUIBUUIFSJHIUUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGPOFTEFUFOUJPOCFGPSFB
KVEJDJBMCPEZNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEJOBMMDJSDVNTUBODFT*UNBZJOQBSUJDVMBSOPU
CFEJNJOJTIFEXIFSFUIFDIBMMFOHFUPMBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPOTFSWFT
JOUFSBMJB
UPQSPUFDUOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUT
TVDIBTUIFSJHIUUPMJGFPSGSFFEPNGSPNUPSUVSF
BOEPUIFSDSVFM
JOIVNBOPSEFHSBEJOHUSFBUNFOUPSQVOJTINFOU
*UTIPVMECFSFJUFSBUFEUIBUUIFSFBTPOGPSDIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPG
JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUPQVUBOFOEUPUIFEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJC
FSUZJGJUJTOPUKVTUJGJFE5IJTNFBOTUIBUBOJOUFSOFFNVTUCFJOGPSNFEXJUIPVU
EFMBZPGBOZEFDJTJPOUBLFOPOBQQFBMBOECFJNNFEJBUFMZSFMFBTFEJGUIFQFUJ
UJPO JT VQIFME &WFO UIPVHI UIF PCMJHBUJPO PG TQFFEZ JOGPSNBUJPO BOE SFMFBTF
JT OPU FYQMJDJUMZ NFOUJPOFE JO FJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO PS IVNBO SJHIUT MBX
BOZ
EFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZXJUIPVUBMFHBMCBTJTJTDPOTJEFSFEUPCFBWJPMBUJPOPGUIF
HFOFSBM MFHBM QSJODJQMF QSPIJCJUJOH BSCJUSBSZ EFUFOUJPO *G B QFSTPO JT LFQU JO
JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOEFTQJUFBGJOBMSFMFBTFPSEFS
UIBUJTBDMFBS
DBTFPGBSCJUSBSZEFUFOUJPO
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTIPVMECFBMMPXFEUPIBWFMFHBM
BTTJTUBODF
/FJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO OPS IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUZ MBX FYQMJDJUMZ QSPWJEF GPS UIF
SJHIUUPMFHBMBTTJTUBODFGPSQFSTPOTJOUFSOFEPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFE UIBU
SJHIUJTHVBSBOUFFEUPQFSTPOTTVCKFDUUPDSJNJOBMDIBSHFT
*UNVTUCFOPUFE
IPXFWFS
UIBUMFHBMBTTJTUBODFUPJOUFSOFFTJOJOUFSOB
UJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTOPUQSPIJCJUFE5IF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMFPGUIF
'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO JO GBDU TUBUFT UIBU UIF iQSPDFEVSF QSPWJEFE GPS JO
UIF$POWFOUJPOJTBNJOJNVNuBOEUIBUiJUXJMMCFBOBEWBOUBHF
UIFSFGPSF
JG
4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIF$POWFOUJPOBGGPSECFUUFSTBGFHVBSETu*UNBZCFTBJEUIBU
OPXBEBZTUIFSJHIUUPFGGFDUJWFMFHBMBTTJTUBODFJTOPUKVTUBOiBEWBOUBHFu
CVUB
CBTJDQSPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSE
)VNBO SJHIUT TPGU MBX BOE UIF KVSJTQSVEFODF PG IVNBO SJHIUT CPEJFT
QSPWJEF FYUFOTJWF TUBOEBSET UIBU GJMM UIF HBQT JO USFBUZ MBX BQQMJDBCMF JO OPO
JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF 5IF SJHIU UP
FGGFDUJWF MFHBM BTTJTUBODF JT UIVT DPOTJEFSFE UP CF BO FTTFOUJBM DPNQPOFOU PG
UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ PG QFSTPO 5IF SFMFWBOU TPGU MBX TUBOEBSET QSPWJEF GPS UIF
SJHIUPGQFSTPOTJODVTUPEZUPMFHBMDPVOTFMSFHBSEMFTTPGUIFUZQFPGEFUFOUJPO
JOWPMWFE 5IFZ BMTP DPOUBJO QSPWJTJPOT PO UIF NPEBMJUJFT PG DPNNVOJDBUJPO
XJUIBMBXZFS
8IFSF OFDFTTBSZ
SFBTPOBCMF TFDVSJUZ BSSBOHFNFOUT NBZ CF NBEF
TVDIBTSFRVJSJOHTFDVSJUZDMFBSBODFGPSBOJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFT
MFHBMDPVOTFM
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFIBTUIFSJHIUUPQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFX
PGUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGDPOUJOVFEEFUFOUJPO
1FSJPEJDBMSFWJFXPGBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJGUIFJOJUJBMEFDJTJPOPOEFUFOUJPO
JTDPOĐSNFEBĔFSiSFDPOTJEFSBUJPOu "SUJDMF
PSPOiBQQFBMu "SUJDMF
JTB
CBTJDDPNQPOFOUPGUIFQSPDFEVSFMBJEEPXOJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO
"SUJDMFTQFDJĐFTUIBUQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFXTIBMMUBLFQMBDFiBUMFBTUUXJDFZFBSMZ
u
XIJMF"SUJDMFQSPWJEFTUIBUTVDISFWJFXTIBMMUBLFQMBDFiJGQPTTJCMFFWFSZTJY
NPOUITu
5IFQVSQPTFPGUIFQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFXJTUPBTDFSUBJOXIFUIFSUIFEFUBJOFF
DPOUJOVFT UP QPTF B SFBM UISFBU UP UIF TFDVSJUZ PG UIF EFUBJOJOH QPXFS BOE UP
PSEFS SFMFBTF JG UIBU JT OPU UIF DBTF "MM UIF TBGFHVBSET UIBU BQQMZ UP UIF JOJ
UJBMSFWJFXNVTUBQQMZUPUIFQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFX T
BTXFMM
XIJDI
BNPOHPUIFS
UIJOHT
NFBOTUIBUUIFSFWJFXIBTUPCFFGGFDUJWFBOENVTUCFDPOEVDUFECZBO
JOEFQFOEFOUBOEJNQBSUJBMCPEZ
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
5IFSFJTOPTQFDJGJFEQFSJPEJDJUZPGSFWJFXBWBJMBCMFUPQFSTPOTEFUBJOFE
JO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT PS PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF
CFDBVTF
IVNBOSJHIUTMBXEPFTOPUMJNJUUIFGSFRVFODZPGDIBMMFOHFTUIBUNBZCFTVC
NJUUFE CZ BO JOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZ EFUBJOFE QFSTPO UP UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG
EFUFOUJPO IBCFBTDPSQVTQFUJUJPOT
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOXJMM
JO QSBDUJDF CF SFHVMBUFE CZ UIF EPNFTUJD MBX PG UIF 4UBUF JOWPMWFE JO B OPO
JOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSPUIFSTJUVBUJPOPGWJPMFODF
NFBOJOHUIBUBQFS
TPOTBCJMJUZUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPOXJMMCFSFHVMBUFECZUIPTFOPSNT
*GUIFSFMFWBOUEPNFTUJDMBXNBLFTOPTVDIQSPWJTJPO
JUJTTVCNJUUFEUIBU
BUMFBTUTJYNPOUIMZSFWJFXTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOTIPVMECF
QSPWJEFEGPS
TJNJMBSUPUIFSVMFTBQQMJDBCMFJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPSIFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWF
TIPVMECFBCMFUPBUUFOEUIFQSPDFFEJOHTJOQFSTPO
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPSIFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTIPVME
BT B HFOFSBM SVMF
CF BCMF UP CF QSFTFOU BU UIF JOJUJBM SFWJFX PG UIF MBXGVMOFTT
PG JOUFSONFOU
BT XFMM BT BU QFSJPEJDBM SFWJFXT
JO PSEFS UP CF BCMF UP QSFTFOU
UIF JOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUBJOFFT QPTJUJPO BOE DPOUFTU UIF DMBJNT NBEF
BHBJOTUIJNPSIFS8IFSFOFDFTTBSZ
SFBTPOBCMFBSSBOHFNFOUTGPSUIFQSFTFSWB
UJPOPGDMBTTJGJFEJOGPSNBUJPONBZCFNBEF
TVDIBTSFRVJSJOHTFDVSJUZDMFBSBODF
GPSUIFJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWF
8IJMF OFJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO OPS IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUZ MBX FYQSFTTMZ
NFOUJPOUIFSJHIUPGJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTBOEPGUIFJSMFHBMSFQ
SFTFOUBUJWF UP CF QSFTFOU BU QSPDFFEJOHT SFMBUFE UP JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPO
JU IBT CFFO PCTFSWFE JO QSBDUJDF UIBU UIFJS BCTFODF PGUFO MFBET UP
IFBSJOHT JO XIJDI UIFJS DBTF JT HJWFO JOBEFRVBUF BUUFOUJPO #FDBVTF TVDI QSP
DFFEJOHTSFTVMUJOEFDJTJPOTPOUIFDPOUJOVBUJPOPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF
EFUFOUJPO
JUJTTVCNJUUFEUIBUUIFJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPS
IFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTIPVMECFBMMPXFEUPCFQSFTFOUBUUIFQSPDFFEJOHT*G
UIFZEPOPUVOEFSTUBOEUIFMBOHVBHFPGUIFDPVSU
UIFZXJMMOFFEUPCFQSPWJEFE
XJUIBOJOUFSQSFUFS
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFNVTUCFBMMPXFEUPIBWFDPOUBDUTXJUI
UPDPSSFTQPOEXJUIBOECFWJTJUFECZNFNCFSTPGIJTPSIFSGBNJMZ
5IF QSFTFSWBUJPO PG GBNJMZ MJGF BOE DPOUBDUT JT POF PG UIF CBTJD BJNT PG
JOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXBOENBZCFTBJEUPDPOTUJUVUFBOFMFNFOUPGUIF
CSPBEFSPCMJHBUJPOUIBUQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZJOCPUIJOUFSOBUJPOBM
BOE OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT NVTU CF USFBUFE IVNBOFMZ 5IJT
TBGFHVBSE
BTXFMMBTUIFUXPMJTUFEJNNFEJBUFMZCFMPX
CFMPOHUPUIPTFBJNFE
BU FOTVSJOH QSPQFS DPOEJUJPOT BOE USFBUNFOU JO EFUFOUJPO
XIJDI JT OPU UIF
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
TVCKFDUPGUIJTUFYU5IFZIBWFCFFOJODMVEFEIFSFCFDBVTFPGUIFJSJNQPSUBODF
GPS FOBCMJOH UIF PUIFS QSPDFEVSBM TBGFHVBSET EFBMU XJUI JO UIJT UFYU UP CF
JNQMFNFOUFE
5IF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPODPOUBJOTQSPWJTJPOTGBDJMJUBUJOHDPOUBDU
CFUXFFOJOUFSOFFTBOEUIFJSGBNJMJFTUIBUBSFUPPOVNFSPVTUPSFQFBUIFSF*O
CSJFG
UIF HFOFSBM QSFTVNQUJPO JT UIBU GBNJMZ DPOUBDUT DPSSFTQPOEFODF BOE
WJTJUTNVTUCFBMMPXFEXJUIJOBSFBTPOBCMFUJNFGSBNFJOBMMCVUWFSZFYDFQ
UJPOBMDJSDVNTUBODFT*OOPDBTFNBZBEFUBJOFFTDPOUBDUXJUIIJTPSIFSGBNJMZ
CFNBEFEFQFOEFOUPOIJTPSIFSiDPPQFSBUJWFOFTTuXJUIUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZ
PSCFVTFEBTBGPSNPGJODFOUJWFPSSFXBSEGPSPUIFSCFIBWJPVS
"EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM ** BMTP DPOUBJOT QSPWJTJPOT EFTJHOFE UP NBJOUBJO
GBNJMZ DPOUBDUT BOE OVNFSPVT OPOUSFBUZ IVNBO SJHIUT TUBOEBSET IBWF UIF
TBNFBJN
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFIBTUIFSJHIUUPUIFNFEJDBMDBSFBOE
BUUFOUJPOSFRVJSFECZIJTPSIFSDPOEJUJPO
5IFSJHIUUPNFEJDBMDBSFBOEBUUFOUJPOJTBDPNQPOFOUPGUIFFTTFOUJBMPCMJHB
UJPOUIBUBMMQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZNVTUCFUSFBUFEIVNBOFMZ.FEJDBM
DBSFBOEBUUFOUJPOTFSWFBNPOHPUIFSUIJOHTUPQSFWFOUJMMUSFBUNFOUBOEBMTP
UPSFGVUFUIFBENJTTJCJMJUZPGFWJEFODFBHBJOTUBQFSTPOUIBUIBTCFFOPCUBJOFE
CZUPSUVSFPSPUIFSGPSNTPGJMMUSFBUNFOU5IFZBSFNFOUJPOFEJOUIJTDPOUFYU
CFDBVTF B QFSTPOT IFBMUI JT PCWJPVTMZ B QSFSFRVJTJUF GPS IJT PS IFS BCJMJUZ UP
DMBJNNPTUPGUIFQSPDFEVSBMSJHIUTPVUMJOFEJOUIJTUFYU
ĂFHFOFSBMSVMFMBJEEPXOJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF
TUJQVMBUFT UIBU i1BSUJFT UP UIF DPOGMJDU XIP JOUFSO QSPUFDUFE QFSTPOT TIBMM CF
CPVOEUPQSPWJEFGSFFPGDIBSHFGPSUIFJSNBJOUFOBODF
BOEUPHSBOUUIFNBMTP
UIFNFEJDBMBUUFOUJPOSFRVJSFECZUIFJSTUBUFPGIFBMUIu.PSFTQFDJGJDSVMFTPO
IZHJFOFBOENFEJDBMBUUFOUJPOBSFDPOUBJOFEJO"SUJDMFTBOE
*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT
"SUJDMF
C
PG "EEJUJPOBM
1SPUPDPM**TUJQVMBUFTUIBUJOUFSOFFTiTIBMM
UPUIFTBNFFYUFOUBTUIFMPDBMDJWJM
JBOQPQVMBUJPO
CFQSPWJEFEXJUIGPPEBOEESJOLJOHXBUFSBOECFBGGPSEFETBGF
HVBSETBTSFHBSETIFBMUIBOEIZHJFOFBOEQSPUFDUJPOBHBJOTUUIFSJHPVSTPGUIF
DMJNBUFBOEUIFEBOHFSTPGUIFBSNFEDPOGMJDUu1SPWJTJPOTPOBDDFTTUPBEPDUPS
BOE NFEJDBM BUUFOUJPO BSF BMTP DPOUBJOFE JO UIF SFMFWBOU IVNBO SJHIUT OPO
USFBUZJOTUSVNFOUT #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT
1SJODJQMFTBOE
*U NVTU CF TUSFTTFE UIBU BDDFTT UP NFEJDBM DBSF UIBU NJHIU CF SFRVJSFE
CZBQFSTPOTDPOEJUJPODBOOPUJOBOZDJSDVNTUBODFTCFNBEFEFQFOEFOUPOIJT
PS IFS iDPPQFSBUJWFOFTTu XJUI UIF EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZ PS CF VTFE BT B GPSN PG
JODFOUJWFPSSFXBSEGPSPUIFSCFIBWJPVS
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFNVTUCFBMMPXFEUPNBLFTVCNJTTJPOT
SFMBUJOHUPIJTPSIFSUSFBUNFOUBOEDPOEJUJPOTPGEFUFOUJPO
#PUIJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX "SUJDMFPGUIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPO
BOEIVNBOSJHIUTTPGUMBXTUJQVMBUFUIBUJOUFSOFFTQFSTPOTTVCKFDUUPBENJOJT
USBUJWFEFUFOUJPOIBWFUIFSJHIUUPNBLFTVCNJTTJPOTUPUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZ
SFHBSEJOH UIFJS USFBUNFOU BOE DPOEJUJPOT PG EFUFOUJPO 5IF QVSQPTF PG UIJT
TBGFHVBSEJTUPFOBCMFUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPQSFWFOUBOETUPQQPTTJCMFWJP
MBUJPOTPGUIFMBX5IFBVUIPSJUJFTBSFUIVTPCMJHFEUPQVUJOQMBDFBQSPDFEVSF
UIBUBMMPXTUIFTVCNJTTJPOBOETQFFEZBTXFMMBTFGGFDUJWFFYBNJOBUJPOPGQFUJ
UJPOTPSDPNQMBJOUT5IFTVCNJTTJPOPGTVDISFQSFTFOUBUJPOTNVTUOPUIBWFBOZ
BEWFSTFDPOTFRVFODFTGPSUIFQFUJUJPOFS
"DDFTTUPQFSTPOTJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFE
*$3$ BDDFTT UP QFSTPOT JOUFSOFE JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JT QSPWJEFE
GPSJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF
XIJDIBMTPMBZTEPXOUIF
DPOEJUJPOTBOEQSPDFEVSFGPS*$3$WJTJUTBOEFTUBCMJTIFTUIFEVUZPGBEFUBJOJOH
BVUIPSJUZUPHSBOUBDDFTTBOEUPSFTQFDUUIFTBJEDPOEJUJPOTBOEQSPDFEVSF
*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE JO PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJP
MFODF
UIF *$3$ NBZ PGGFS JUT TFSWJDFT BOE DPODMVEF BHSFFNFOUT XJUI UIF
EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZ PO WJTJUT UP QFSTPOT EFQSJWFE PG UIFJS MJCFSUZ GPS TFDVSJUZ
SFBTPOT
BOEUPPUIFSQFSTPOT5IF*$3$TSJHIUPGBDDFTTJOUIFTFTJUVBUJPOTJT
XJEFMZSFDPHOJ[FE
#ZNFBOTPGWJTJUTUPQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZUIF*$3$
XIJDI
JT BO JOEFQFOEFOU
JNQBSUJBM BOE OFVUSBM IVNBOJUBSJBO PSHBOJ[BUJPO
TFFLT UP
FOTVSFUIBUUIFZBSFUSFBUFEIVNBOFMZJOBMMDJSDVNTUBODFTBOEUIBUUIFJSGVO
EBNFOUBMSJHIUTBSFSFTQFDUFE*UJTUIVTDPODFSOFEFTTFOUJBMMZXJUIUIFJSDPOEJ
UJPOTPGEFUFOUJPOBOEUIFJSUSFBUNFOU
JODMVEJOHSFTQFDUGPSGVOEBNFOUBMQSP
DFEVSBMHVBSBOUFFTBUBMMTUBHFTPGEFUFOUJPO
$FSUBJO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE SFHJPOBM IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUJFT
UPP
QSPWJEF
GPS POTJUF WJTJUT UP TVDI QFSTPOT CZ WJTJUJOH NFDIBOJTNT FTUBCMJTIFE VOEFS
UIPTFUSFBUJFT5IFSFBSFMJLFXJTFBOVNCFSPGOPOUSFBUZNFDIBOJTNTDSFBUFE
VOEFSUIFBVTQJDFTPGUIF6/$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUTUIBUNBZDBSSZPVU
WJTJUTUPQMBDFTPGEFUFOUJPO
6OEFS "SU PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO
*OUFSOFF $PNNJUUFFT BMTP IBWF UIF SJHIU UP NBLF
SFQSFTFOUBUJPOTUP
JOUFSBMJB
UIF*$3$
*U TIPVME CF OPUFE UIBU VOEFS IVNBO SJHIUT TPĔ MBX UIF MFHBM DPVOTFM
B GBNJMZ NFNCFS PS BOPUIFS
QFSTPOXIPIBTLOPXMFEHFPGUIFDBTFNBZBMTPNBLFTVCNJTTJPOTSFHBSEJOHUIFUSFBUNFOUPGBQFSTPOJO
BENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO4FF#PEZPG1SJODJQMFT
PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF
BOE
4FF"SUDPNNPOUPUIFGPVS(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT
4FF"SU
PGUIF4UBUVUFTPGUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FE$SPTTBOE3FE$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU
&HUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJUUFFGPSUIF1SFWFOUJPOPG5PSUVSFBOE*OIVNBOPS%FHSBEJOH5SFBUNFOUPS
1VOJTINFOUTFUVQCZUIF&VSPQFBO$POWFOUJPOGPSUIF1SFWFOUJPOPG5PSUVSFBOE*OIVNBOPS%FHSBEJOH
5SFBUNFOUPS1VOJTINFOU
&HUIF6/$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUT8PSLJOH(SPVQPO"SCJUSBSZ%FUFOUJPO
5IF3FWJFXJTQSJOUFEJO&OHMJTIBOEJT
QVCMJTIFE GPVS UJNFT B ZFBS
JO .BSDI
+VOF
4FQUFNCFSBOE%FDFNCFS
5IFBSUJDMFTQVCMJTIFEJOUIF3FWJFX
$PWFSQIPUP BSFBWBJMBCMFGSFFPGDIBSHFPOMJOFBU
¥*OUFSOBUJPOBM.VTFVNPGUIF3FE$SPTT XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
BOE3FE$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU
4VCNJTTJPOPGNBOVTDSJQUT 4VCTDSJQUJPOT
5IF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FWJFXPGUIF3FE$SPTTJOWJUFT 5IF QSJOU SVO JT MJNJUFE 5IF 3FWJFX JT
TVCNJTTJPOTPGNBOVTDSJQUTPOTVCKFDUTSFMBUJOH EJTUSJCVUFE UP TFMFDUFE JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE
UP JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX
QPMJDZ BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPOT 'VSUIFS EJTUSJCVUJPO JT
BDUJPO .PTU JTTVFT GPDVT PO QBSUJDVMBS UPQJDT
TVCKFDUUPBWBJMBCJMJUZ
EFDJEFE CZ UIF &EJUPSJBM #PBSE
XIJDI DBO CF
DPOTVMUFEVOEFSUIFIFBEJOH'VUVSF5IFNFTPO 3FRVFTUTGPSTVCTDSJQUJPOTDBOCFNBEFUP
UIFXFCTJUFPGUIF3FWJFX4VCNJTTJPOTSFMBUFEUP UIFGPMMPXJOHBEESFTT
UIFTFUIFNFTBSFQBSUJDVMBSMZXFMDPNF *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFPGUIF3FE$SPTT
*$3$
XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX