• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
Download
 
THOUGHTS ONTHE 1971 EASTPAKISTANDEBACLEBy
A.H AMINAnalysis of Book Review byAhmad Faruqui
THE PAKISTAN ARMY CONSISTING INLARGE PART OF RANKERS OR RANKERSSONS HAD NO TRADITION OF MISSIONORIENTED MODIFICATION OF ORDERSKNOWN AS AUFTRAGSTAKTIKS.ITSOFFICERS MAY BE BRAVE OR SPIRITED
 
LACKED INITIATIVE,AND MADE THEIRWAY UP THE LADDER BY SYCOPHANCY  AND YES MAN SHIP.THIS WAS THEFACTOR IN EAST PAKISTAN AND THESAME MEDIOCRITY SIGNIFIES THEPAKISTAN ARMY TILL TO DATE.AN ARMY LED BY OFFICERS WHO ARE CLERKS ANDEMPTY WINDBAGS IN SPIRIT. A.H AMIN ,2000
BOOK REVIEW The Betrayal of East PakistanBY A.A.K NIAZIAHMAD FARUQUI reviews the book of the former Commander Eastern Command in1971. PUBLISHED IN DEFENCE JOURNAL 2000On December 16, 1971, under clear skies, and in front of a restless crowd of nearlya million Bengalis, Lieutenant General A. A. K. Niazi, Commander, Eastern Commandof the Pakistan Army, surrendered “first his pistol, then his sword, and then half hiscountry” to Lieutenant General Jagjit Singh Aurora of the Indian Army.2 In WestPakistan, the President of Pakistan, its Chief of Army Staff, and its Chief Martial LawAdministrator, General Yahya came on the radio to reassure his shocked nation thateven though fighting had ceased on the eastern front “due to an arrangement
 
between the local commanders,” the war with India would continue. However, onthe very next day, realizing that his chances of surviving a fullscale war with Indiaon the western front without US or Chinese support were nil, he agreed to aceasefire. An exultant Indira Gandhi, Prime Minister of India, and daughter of India’sfirst Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, declared that “we have avenged the Muslimcapture of Somnath and our history of a thousand years.”3 General Yahya hadboasted earlier in the year that if India choose to declare war on Pakistan “I willshoot my way out of it.” He had also boasted about how he had escaped from aprisoner of war camp in Italy during the Second World War, while Sam Manekshaw,now the Indian Chief of Staff, was one of many fellow prisoners who had beenunable to escape. Now, in vastly different circumstances, a chastened General Yahya sought to justify the ceasefire by stating that “I have always maintained thatwar solves no problem.” However, as Oxford historian Robert Jackson noted inSouth Asian Crisis, “the victors in Dacca knew otherwise.” East Pakistan had passedinto the history books, and with it some argued the “two nation theory” that had ledto Pakistan’s independence. How did things come to such a sorry pass for Pakistan?A nation as proud of its martial traditions as Pakistan has still not to come with thissad legacy. Heir to the glorious traditions of the Arab, Turkish and Moghul armies of Muslim history, the Pakistani army was expected to fight to the “last man, lastround” in East Pakistan, and to do anything but surrender itself to the Indian Army.Several years later, a Pakistani general officer summed up the nation’s feelingswhen he said that “Never before had a Muslim sword been turned over to a Hindu.In Islam, surrender is taboo; you either return with the land, or you bathe it in yourblood4.”
of 00

Commenting has been disabled.