Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A six-month consultancy was carried out in the 738.6 km² Nam Theun Corridor, located in
central Lao PDR, from May to November 2000. The Nam Theun Corridor is one of the
proposed extensions to the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA, and was given a protected area status
in June 2000 by the Government of Lao PDR. The Nam Theun Corridor serves as a link
between the 3,532 km² Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA and the 1,500 km² Phou Hin Poun NBCA.
This consultancy is one of the three components of the Nam Theun Social and Environmental
Project (Year 2000 Activities). The other two components include a study on rural access and
agricultural extension.
The primary objectives of this consultancy comprised the assessment of movements and
seasonal migration patterns of wildlife in the lower Nam Theun, focussing on the Nam Theun
Corridor; the recommendation of management guidelines for the study area; and the training
of the NBCA staff and other relevant personnel in basic field conservation techniques and in
developing a system for monitoring and protection of biodiversity resources.
Training comprised theory and practical training based at the NBCA’s headquarters; field-
based on-the-job training, gathering actual data; and HQ-based training in data compilation,
analysis, interpretation and presentation of actual data gathered. Trainees comprised three
PAFO staff assigned to the NBCA, one Nakai District Army personnel, one Nakai District
Police personnel, and a Khammouane-based Lao volunteer. The training of NBCA staff and
other relevant personnel focussed on developing their understanding and skills in the field
management of protected areas; in the use of maps and compass; in conducting surveys for
wildlife and key wildlife habitats; in recording and assessing human impacts on wildlife and
habitats; and in data analysis and report writing.
Training met with mixed success. While skills and knowledge could be imparted to most
trainees, yet it is felt that the skills and knowledge obtained would be put to little use as
leadership, motivation and coordination (with relevant stakeholders) are still lacking.
Furthermore, there is very little hope for the conservation and protection of biodiversity
resources when the patrolling and monitoring unit is active only during donor-funded projects
that include related activities. Also, patrolling and monitoring activities cannot be adequately
implemented when there exists a staff of only two to three persons, and when staffing of
NBCA personnel change so often - a common feature with most Lao PDR’s protected areas.
With the exception of the Asian elephant, surveys suggested that most wildlife species in the
Nam Theun Corridor currently exist at low levels. This is primarily due to poaching (for local
use, and for both local and international trade), followed by the loss and disturbance of habitat.
Species of conservation significance that were recorded in the Nam Theun Corridor during
this study include the Asian elephant, gaur, large-antlered muntjac, tiger, dhole, clouded
leopard, douc langur, gibbon sp., Asiatic black bear, sun bear, and hornbills. Surveys also
recorded the presence of mineral licks that were identified as critically important habitats to
herbivores.
The study on wildlife movements and seasonal migration focussed on the Asian elephant.
This is primarily because it is the only animal species in the Nam Theun Corridor having any
significant population size, and it is difficult not to miss evidence of its presence. The study
revealed that there is a resident sub-population of the Asian elephant in the Nam Theun
Corridor; that there is a seasonal shift in range of the Nakai Plateau elephants into the Phou
Hin Poun NBCA during the wet season; that there is a wider distributional range during the
wet season; and that different elephant groups come to gather by a certain area along the
Nam Theun during the peak wet season, probably to socialize and possibly to exchange
genes.
Priority recommendations for wildlife conservation before and after the reservoir fills in include
the need for proactive patrolling and law enforcement activities; the need for transboundary
2
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
cooperation to clamp the further loss of irreplaceable biodiversity resources; the protection
and management of the critical wildlife habitats (mineral licks); the establishment of artificial
mineral licks at suitable locations in the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA above the inundation area;
conducting a study on the ecological importance of mineral licks and their influence on the
elephants’ ranging patterns; increasing the availability of fodder by reforestation of degraded
areas in the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA above the inundation area; acquiring a team of
experienced experts and training of the support staff for the rescue and release operation; and
the need to consider the elephants’ distributional range and the possible movement of the
displaced elephants when carrying out human resettlement.
Looking at the broader picture, There is an urgent need to establish and maintain a discrete
patrolling and monitoring unit. This unit’s primary objectives are to address the needs of
research, surveys, patrolling, and law enforcement in the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA and its
extensions, to arrest the rapid decline of the area’s unique biodiversity resources, and to
maintain its integrity as a globally significant ecoregion.
3
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Several individuals and agencies have been instrumental in the successful outcome of this
component of the project. Foremost is the Nakai District Governor and members of his
administration. Others and other agencies that deserve mention is the Nakai District Army,
the Nakai District Police, Mr. Bountavi (Khammouane PFS Head), Dr. Bounsalong Southidara
(NTSEP Coordinator, MIH), Mr. Thongphoune Chanphengxay (Deputy Director & Chief of
Cabinet, Khammouane Provincial Committee for Rural Development), Mr. Soukatha Vannalat
(Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA Head), Ms. Latsamay Silavong (Field Manager), Mr. Keo Oudone
(Consultant, Rural Access & Agricultural Extension), Ban Thalang residents, and the staff at
the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA and at the IUCN Lao PDR office. Bryan Stuart of WCS Lao
PDR office kindly identified the photographs of reptiles and amphibians. Lastly, but not the
least, the trainees themselves, who discovered the ‘joys’ of field activities (made more
‘exciting’ by project’s timing to coincide with the wet season), and who had to endure the
demands of their ‘instructor’.
Ramesh Boonratana, Ph.D.
a.k.a. Zimbo
4
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
5
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY______________________________________________2
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ______________________________________________4
6
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
7
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Table 4.1 Elephant Crop Damage Claims of Ban Thalang (Sep. 15,
2000). ...................................................................................................................... 85
Figure 4.1 Location of Elephant Sighting and Signs (Jun-Oct. 2000) .................... 86
Figure 4.2 Distributional Range of Elephants in the Nam Theun
Corridor ................................................................................................................... 87
Figure 4.3 Elephant Movements (Jun-Oct. 2000)................................................... 88
Annex 4.1 The Asian Elephant: A Brief Description................................................ 89
Annex 4.2 Recording Format for Dung Density Transects .................................... 90
Annex 4.3 Recording Format for Dung Decomposition Rate................................. 91
Annex 4.4 Recording Format for Dung Defecation Rate........................................ 92
Plate 4.1 Photographic Summary of Activities I...................................................... 93
Plate 4.2 Photographic Summary of Activities II..................................................... 94
Plate 4.3 Photographic Summary of Activities III .................................................... 95
5. CONCLUDING DISCUSSION & RECOMMENDATIONS........................................ 96
5.1 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................... 96
5.2 IMPORTANCE OF THE NAM THEUN CORRIDOR......................................... 97
5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS ..................................................................................... 97
5.3.1 Training & Training Needs ............................................................................. 97
5.3.2 Surveys, Monitoring and Research................................................................ 98
5.3.3 Patrolling and Law Enforcement.................................................................... 99
5.3.4 Zonation........................................................................................................ 100
5.3.5 Administration .............................................................................................. 101
5.3.6 Miscellaneous .............................................................................................. 101
5.3.7 Wildlife Conservation and Mitigation Measures ........................................... 102
5.4 STRATEGY FOR THE NAKAI - NAM THEUN CONSERVATION
AREA 104
5.5 CONCLUSION................................................................................................ 105
Figure 5.1 Proposed Extension and Boundary Improvements............................. 107
8
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND1
A Population and Human Resources Development (PHRD) Grant have been secured by the
government of Lao PDR (GoL) from the International Development Association (IDA) to
support preparations associated with the proposed Nam Theun II Social and Environmental
Project (NTSEP). This grant was used to finance a series of studies and activities related to
the environmental and social interventions linked to the construction and operation of the Nam
Theun II Hydropower Project.
The proposed Nam Theun II Hydropower Project includes the development of:
n a 50 m high dam;
n a 450 km² reservoir on the Nakai Plateau with the capability of storing about half the
annual water inflow;
n a diversion tunnel with a vertical drop of 350 m to a 900 MW powerhouse;
n a 38 km tunnel to channel the diverted water to the Xe Bang Fai;
n and a 140-km transmission line.
The project would also include components designed to protect the environment and water
quality in the dam’s catchment and affected areas downstream, and the resettlement and
rural development in the sub-region.
IUCN had already conducted some wildlife surveys, and initiated some conservation and
development activities in selected communities, as part of other PHRD-funded environmental
and social strategy planning for the area2. On completion of those activities, there exist urgent
needs with respect to the project area, and to the management planning. Requiring timely
attention, these needs comprise:
n concerns for food security in settlements in the upper catchment area;
n improved accessibility to remote settlements;
n unassessed wildlife movements and seasonal migration patterns in the lower Nam
Theun, particularly the Nam Theun Corridor.
All activities proposed and implemented during this project were accordingly planned in
consultation with the project management unit of the upcoming District Upland Development
and Conservation Project (DUDCP), funded by the World Bank.
1.2 OBJECTIVES
The primary objective of this consultancy is to address one of those urgent needs, while
simultaneously preparing essential information needed towards the management plans:
n To assess wildlife movements and seasonal migration in the lower Nam Theun, in
particular the Nam Theun Corridor, and identifying critical factors affecting them.
Hence, working closely with the staff of Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA to:
n assess wildlife movements and seasonal migration patterns in the lower Nam Theun,
focusing on the Nam Theun Corridor;
1
Background, objectives, and terms of reference as per contract between MIH and IUCN.
2
This is with reference to the Environmental and Social Management Plan for Nakai - Nam Theun, and earlier
field activities in the project area.
9
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
n train the NBCA staff to conduct similar studies, and establish regular monitoring of
critical factors;
n and recommend management guidelines for the lower Nam Theun, in particular the
Nam Theun Corridor.
3
The latest revised boundary demarcation as of August 29, 2000 gave this figure as the area covered by the
Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA.
10
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
and deciduous forest in some areas. Much of this vegetation has changed since then, as a
direct result of logging activities. Nevertheless, there still remains some fragmented stands of
evergreen, pine, bamboo, and riverine forest, and open grasslands/rocky flats.
There are only three settlements located within the Nam Theun Corridor (fig. 1.2): Ban
Thalang (50 households; predominantly Lao Loum), Ban Sopnian4 (53 households;
predominantly Meuy5 ethnic group) and Ban Namnian (18 households; predominantly Meuy
ethnic group). However, some residents from these three villages are found practicing
swidden agriculture scattered along parts of the lower Nam Theun and its tributaries.
A seasonal road, Route 8B, runs through the Nam Theun Corridor. Hence, the Nam Theun
Corridor can be accessed through the towns of Lak Sao in the north, and Nakai in the south.
This route is usually inaccessible to motored vehicles during the wet season due to the soft
muddy condition of the road, landslides, bridges being washed away by swollen tributaries of
the Nam Theun, and floods.
4
Previously known as Ban Sophia, i.e., before settling to its current location.
5
A distinctive ethnic group of the Tai linguistic family.
11
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
12
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
13
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
14
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
15
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
16
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
17
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
2. TRAINING
2.1 INTRODUCTION
The long-term goals of any protected area can only be realized through an effective
management plan, which incorporates the management of its wildlife, habitat, and the people
who uses it. Surveys, patrols, monitoring and law enforcement are some of the more
important field-based management activities that must be carried out by the protected area
staff to ensure the conservation, protection, and sustainability of the natural resources within
that protected area. Thus, as part of the long-term objective to strengthen the management of
Nakai – Nam Theun NBCA, it is important to impart training in field conservation techniques to
the NBCA staff and other relevant personnel.
Training and capacity building of protected area staff are recognized as two important primary
steps towards protected area management - needed for proper implementation of its
management plans and activities. For every protected area, it is essential to obtain
information on:
n the presence, distribution and abundance of the fauna and flora present;
n the habitat types and key wildlife habitats found;
n the threats to the wildlife and habitats;
n the statuses of people living in and adjacent to it, how they use it, and their impacts on
wildlife and the habitats.
This information will then assist the protected area managers/staff to effectively plan and/or
develop:
n a program for biodiversity resource monitoring;
n a program for protected area patrolling;
n effective and practicable zones for the protected area;
Hence, training and capacity building of protected area staff in gathering, interpreting, and
using this information are important steps and contributions towards making wise
management decisions in the conservation and protection of natural resources.
Bearing this in mind, six trainees were trained in basic skills needed to accomplish the said
objectives. The trainees comprised:
1. Mr. Somlor Vonglampanh (Khammouane PAFO Forestry Technician)
2. Mr. Phaymany Phimmasan (Khammouane PAFO Forestry Technician)
3. Mr. Bounthanh Suvannahong (Khammouane PAFO Forestry Technician)
4. Sgt. Phongsavath ‘Lon’ Chundala (Nakai District Police)
5. 2nd. Lt. Teh-Noy Maekhruawan (Nakai District Military)
6. Mr. Chanthala Nyannasai (Volunteer & Field Assistant)
Training was carried out over a period of five months, both in the ‘classroom’, and while ‘on-
the-job’ - carrying out actual surveys and patrols for wildlife presence and human activities.
Both theory and on-the-job training were designed to provide the most basic of field
techniques; easily understood and easy to implement, yet essential for protected area
management. Furthermore, these techniques require a minimal of monetary input. Topics
and instructions were adapted to satisfy the individual trainee’s aptitude, and to suit the needs
of the NBCA and objectives of the project. With this training, it is expected that the staff will be
able to organize and plan field trips, orient themselves in the field, indicate important
locations/evidence on a map, record significant data, and provide a legible and
comprehensible summary report for every field trip.
18
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Training was conducted in the Lao language, and primarily focused on developing the trainees
skills in:
n map reading, compass and GPS use, and orienteering;
n conducting field surveys for wildlife and key wildlife habitats, including village-based
interviews;
n observing, recording and assessing impacts on wildlife and habitats;
n mapping trails and recording locations of wildlife, and evidence of human impacts;
n compiling, analyzing, and presenting the information gathered.
Basics of Conservation
These included brief lectures and discussions on the concept of protected areas and
protected area management, conservation of natural resources, conservation biology, and
wildlife ecology and behavior. This was to give the trainees a better understanding the
objectives of the protected area and their responsibilities, and the need of reliable and relevant
information towards effectively managing species and habitats. This topic also served to
generate interest and provided some insight to the necessity and purpose of acquiring the
basic skills in field techniques. In addition, a fundamental understanding of wildlife ecology and
behavior was to assist them in recording observations in the field properly.
19
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
unidentified wildlife species, tracks, etc., and measuring or estimating their sizes in the case
of wildlife species sighting. This was to assist them in species identification. All wildlife
species and human activities observed were to be recorded onto data sheets (annexes 2.1 -
2.4). These data recording sheets or their adaptations are currently in use at Dong Hua Sao,
Phou Xiang Thong, Phou Xang He and Nam Poui NBCAs (Boonratana, 1998a & b; 1999b).
There was also an emphasis on the collection of specimens whenever opportunity arose
(annex 2.5). This included collection of scats for later analysis, hair samples, skulls from dead
animals and making plaster casts of tracks (annex 2.6). Specimens collected would serve as
important references, and as displays to impart conservation education and public
awareness.
Reporting
The process and format of reporting were explained. The report comprised a one to two
page(s) written summary highlighting significant finds, a summarized table of wildlife
recorded, a summarized table of impacts observed, map/maps for locations of key wildlife,
wildlife habitats, significant impacts, and routes traveled, and the data recording sheets
(annex 2.10). Four other protected areas in Lao PDR are currently using this format
(Boonratana, 1998a & b; 1999b).
Monitoring
The concept and purpose of monitoring was explained. Repeated surveys and patrols for an
area were emphasized to the trainees. Once initial data is collected, there should be a
program of continuous collection of data to see changes, if any, in terms of wildlife presence
and relative abundance, habitat changes, and human activity. This comprised steps and
methods to summarize and evaluate information that primarily include key species, impacts,
and effort. Discussions were made on what constitutes the base line information, then on
how to detect changes or trends, followed by the interpretation and use of the monitoring
results. Monitoring is an important component for making management decisions. A
20
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
discussion was also held on the criteria to assist the trainees in identifying key species for
monitoring purposes.
21
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Daily Debriefing
Debriefing was carried out nightly after meals. This served to review the day’s findings and
plan surveys for the next day. Teams would report the results of surveys, highlighting their
main findings. Team members would alternate on a daily basis in reporting their findings, to
encourage participation by all. Comments and suggestions were offered to improve their field
performance and skills. Discussions were also held on issues raised by the trainees and by
the instructor, hence encouraging analytical thinking.
Trip Report
At the end of every field trip, each team was given three days to submit their trip reports.
Constant guidance and corrections were made before the reports were accepted. The
reports comprised brief notes describing the trip, significant finds, obstacles, etc. The trip
reports are also accompanied by a table summarizing the wildlife recorded, a table
summarizing the impacts recorded, a map showing the routes taken and location of
significant finds (annex 2.10). A senior member of the NBCA staff was also required to submit
a copy of every trip report to the head of the Khammouane Provincial Forestry Section6
(PFS), on the completion of the report. This practice has never before been carried out by the
protected area staff of Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA and many other protected areas in Lao
PDR.
6
At the provincial level, NBCAs are responsible to the PFS.
7
This report (not for circulation) has now been submitted to the head of the Khammouane PFS.
22
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
and qualification, and their interest and attitude. During the HQ-based theory training session,
the trainees initially did not participate in the discussions and were reluctant to ask questions.
This changed when the trainees became familiar with one another and with the instructor.
More interest was observed on the field trips, when trainees started applying skills acquired
during the first training phase. In the field, most trainees worked together quite well, showing
good cooperation and division of labor. Briefings carried out every night in the field improved
their performance. Having the instructor with the different teams on a rotational basis served
to reinforce their training. In addition, it allowed doubts and questions that usually arose during
the surveys to be immediately resolved. Furthermore, several field techniques such as
detecting and correctly identifying and/or measuring wildlife signs, and orienteering could only
be clarified under field conditions. Initially, most trainees had several fears of camping out in
the forest. With time and exposure, most overcame some of those fears. Findings made
during the ‘on-the-job’ training are presented in sections 3 and 4.
Individual assessment of each trainee is presented in table 2.2. All trainees, but one, made
tremendous achievements when compared to the initial state. The one trainee that did not
make any progress was primarily due to his lack of interest and commitment. Negligible
improvements were made in spite of major efforts by the instructor and other trainees. Two
non-NBCA staff trainees made remarkable progress and achievements throughout the
training. This was mainly attributed to their interest in the subject matter and in acquiring new
skills and their commitment to project’s objectives. General observations and assessment
made during the three training and capacity-building phases can briefly be described as
follows:
Basics of Conservation
Initially, almost all trainees did not truly understand the objectives and concepts of protected
areas, protected area management and conservation of natural resources. All, however,
knew that ‘conservation was future generations’ as often aired by the media, but never
understanding what that phrase actually meant. Unfortunately, this lack of understanding is
prevalent amongst the relevant government agencies throughout the country. Hence, basics
of conservation were emphasized throughout the training exercise, beginning with
discussions at the start of the training and regularly discussing them during daily debriefings
in the field; thereby reinforcing their understanding based on actual field experience.
Understanding gradually improved with time, and by the end of the training, most trainees
fairly understood the basic concept of protected area and conservation of natural resources.
Thus, are much clearer with the tasks and responsibilities that lay ahead of them. In general,
trainees were not entirely clear about wildlife ecology, but found it much easier to comprehend
wildlife behavior.
23
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Report Write-up
To familiarize the trainees and give them the much-needed practice in data compilation,
analysis, and interpretation, each team had to prepare a trip report for every field trip carried
out. Guidance was offered and several corrections were made before the reports were finally
accepted. The quality of the reports progressed with each field trip. The major weaknesses
observed were in data analyzing and interpretation. As observed during the final training
phase, that even under guidance, the trainees had difficulty in making inferences and
correlation from the compiled data.
Equipment Care
Care and maintenance of equipment was generally weak among the trainees, particularly the
NBCA staff. Trainees would need to be repeatedly instructed to care and maintain the
equipment issued. Damp or wet binoculars, tents, and sleeping bags were usually kept in
their cases until the next field trip.
2.4 DISCUSSION
Prolonged and repeated on-the-job field training is possibly the only way to equip protected
area and relevant personnel with the basic skills and experience required to implement field
management activities (Boonratana, 1997b; 1998a, b & c; 1999a & b). An important feature of
all training programs, be it in field techniques, extension work or participatory conservation,
must be followed up with on-the-job training, actually carrying out activities. It is only in this
manner that one can hope to build the capacity of the protected area staff.
Observations made during this training exercise and earlier ones (Boonratana, 1997b; 1998a,
b; & c; 1999a & b) showed that training and capacity building of protected area staff can only
be achieved through intensive long-term on-the-job training. Such training and capacity
building are likely to be significantly more effective when provided systematically over a period
of several years within each protected area, rather than delivered in a centralized ‘one-off’
training event, which may not be adequately absorbed or acted on. However, given the short
duration of this project, it now depends on the head of the NBCA to provide the necessary
leadership and motivation. Likewise, it is equally important that the trainees translate the skills
acquired into meaningful activities, carrying forward the processes initiated during this project.
Past experiences have shown that interest is the greatest motivation for learning and fulfilling
ascribed responsibilities. Reasons for failure in achieving the desired results in capacity
building of protected area staff is primarily due to the lack of interest in fieldwork. This in turn
24
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
is partly because of the hardship involved and because it is unrewarding8. In addition, staff
change frequently, hence the PA is frequently staffed with inexperienced and unqualified
individuals, a feature frequently seen in other protected areas (Boonratana, 1998a). Much of
this is most likely because protection, conservation, and sustainable management of natural
resources do not rank high in the list of GoL’s priorities for the country. Thus, it is not an
uncommon practice for the staff lacking in capacity and capability (including those not favored
by their superiors), to be assigned to protected areas. There must be a change of attitude, to
safeguard and to arrest the rapid decline of Lao PDR’s rich biodiversity. Otherwise plans to
establish Nakai - Nam Theun Conservation Area as an ‘international class conservation area’
will merely remain an unrealized vision, even with sufficient funds.
8
NBCA staff from both the patrolling/monitoring and extension units receive equal per diems, in spite the
former having to camp outdoors, hike several kilometers a day (frequently in bad weather), consume limited
and low quality foods, and risk life and limbs to achieve the objectives. Furthermore, there is usually a
preference for the Forestry staff to be assigned duties related to timber extraction, where additional benefits
are assured.
25
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
26
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Categories:
1. Map & Compass (theory) 8. Field Craft & Ethics
2. Map & Compass (field) 9. Interest & Attitude
3. Wildlife & Impact Surveys 10. Teamwork & Leadership
4. Wildlife Observations & Identification 11. Commitment & Diligence
5. Note-taking & Data Recording 12. Written test (map & compass, landform,
6. Use of Field Guides track identification, wildlife identification)
7. Data Analysis & Report-writing
Assessment:
Trainees/Skills 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 GPA
Somlor A A A B A B A B+ A A+ A+ B+ 3.33
Vonglampanh
Phaymany B+ B B+ B+ B+ B B+ B+ B+ A A B+ 3.00
Phimmasan
Bounthanh D D C D D D C D D D D C+ 1.17
Suvannahong
Phongsavath C C+ B+ B+ B+ B B B+ B+ A A B 2.75
Chundala
Teh-Noy A B+ A B+ A B B+ B+ A A A B+ 3.21
Maekhruawan
Chanthala A A+ A B+ A B+ A A A+ A A+ A 3.54
Nyannasai
GPA: Grade Point Average
27
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Personnel:....................................................……................….......…………..................……
Location:...........................………………….......................................... Date:…………….......
Time Start:….......….....…… Time End:........................... Distance Covered:.....................km
Evidence: 5.Nests
1.Sighting (including live, dead, trophies or 6.Scrapes/Claw Marks
captive animals) 7.Feeding Signs
2.Tracks 8.Other (e.g., wallows, bathing pools, mud
3.Vocalization smears, and antler/horn marks
4.Scat/Dung 9.Reliable Report
Time Species Location Evidence Remarks
28
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
29
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Personnel:.......................................................................….………………..................………
Location:...........................…………………….................................……… Date:…….............
Time Start:………........Time End:......................….. Distance Covered:.............................km
A: Hunting Activities B: Non-Hunting Activities
1. Traps/Snares 5. Camps 1. Forest clearance 5. Livestock grazing
2. Guns/Crossbows 6. Wildlife (live/dead 2. Timber-cutting 6. House construction
3. Fishing gear 7. Other 3. Huts 7. Other
4. Hunting dogs 4. NTFP9 collection
Time Activity Location Active/Inactive Remarks
30
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
31
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
32
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Equipment needed:
• Plaster of Paris
• Bowl or mug
• Stirrer (any thin stick or bamboo measuring about 20 cm long)
• Water
• Old newspapers
Procedure:
• Clear track of fallen leaves, twigs, or stones.
• Repair track, if necessary, by slowly pressing index finger to the loose soil in and around
the track.
• Place four sticks around the track, to neatly contain the plaster. Sticks should measure at
least 1 cm in diameter, to maintain a cast thick enough that it won’t easily break.
• Add water to a bowl containing some Plaster of Paris, while simultaneously stirring the
mixture. The mixture should be of correct viscosity. Note: if the mixture is too thick, it will
harden too quickly and not enter the crevices, therefore losing much of the details; if the
mixture is too thin, it will take too long to harden.
• Slowly pour the mixture along the stirrer into the track, starting with the deeper recesses
first.
• Pour the mixture until it overflows the track. (Make more plaster of Paris mixture if
insufficient).
• Scratch a code onto the plaster cast before it finally hardens.
• Once harden, wrap the cast in several layers of newspaper to prevent it from breaking
during transportation back to the field station.
• At the field station, clean the soil off the cast by using a toothbrush.
• Once cleaned, the track-cast should be lacquered, labeled and recorded into the
specimen record book maintained at the field station
33
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
The following ethics are strongly recommended when conducting surveys and patrols:
• A patrolling/monitoring team should comprise not more than three persons per survey
route. Fewer persons mean less noise produced.
• Cigarette smoking should be totally avoided when conducting survey patrols, and be
allowed only at camps. In dense primary forest, the smell of cigarette smoke can linger for
up to three days, and be detected up to a radius of 500 meters.
• Team members should maintain a distance of at least three meters from each other, and
travel at a speed of an hour to a kilometer (or at least not less than 40 minutes to a
kilometer). Frequent pauses of at least a minute should be made every 25-30 m to
observe the general surroundings for cryptic animals and/or wildlife signs.
• Clothing and daypack should be dull-colored and inconspicuous.
• Radios at camp should be just audible to the immediate listener and not too loud as to
scare away animals or ‘drown’ wildlife vocalizations that could otherwise be heard.
• Establish camps at least 800 m away from key wildlife habitats such as mineral licks,
lakes, etc.
• Do not disturb active nests (birds, for example do not return to disturbed nests)
• Do not unnecessarily handle or corner wildlife. Traumatized and cornered animals can
easily die of shock or attack the source of threat.
34
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
35
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Note: all items except those in italics should be issued by the protected area
36
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
37
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
38
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
39
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
40
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
41
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
42
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
43
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
44
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
45
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
46
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
47
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
3.1 INTRODUCTION
Although previous surveys have provided some information on the fauna and flora in the Nam
Theun Corridor (WCS, 1996 & 1997), a general wildlife survey based on direct observations
and indirect evidence was nevertheless carried out. This was carried out in conjunction with a
training program in the Nam Theun Corridor to provide ‘hands-on’ experience and ‘on-the-job’
training to the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA staff and other relevant personnel (section 2), and in
conjunction with a study on wildlife movements/seasonal migration (section 4). Surveys were
not limited only to wildlife, but included recording signs and evidence of human activities in the
Nam Theun Corridor. The latter information was used to assess the impacts of human on
wildlife and habitats in the Nam Theun Corridor, hence identifying threats to the long-term
viability of the area and its denizens.
Survey methodology follows that as described in section 2.2.2. Wildlife surveys focused
mainly on mammals and birds. Information on reptiles and amphibians were opportunistically
gathered. No trapping was carried out. Information on human activities in the area was
recorded simultaneously while carrying out wildlife surveys.
3.2 RESULTS
Including replicated routes, both intensive and extensive surveys for wildlife and impacts
covered a total distance of approximately 1,350 km. Of this total distance, approximately 705
km was covered while conducting foot surveys, 420 km while conducting boat surveys, and
225 km using a slow-moving terrestrial vehicle. This total distance was achieved in
approximately 350 man-days or in approximately 3,150 man-hours.
3.2.1 Wildlife
With the exception of a few species, the wildlife density in the Nam Theun Corridor is
generally low. Wildlife recorded in and around the Nam Theun Corridor during this component
of the project listed 52 mammals and 85 birds (table 3.1). Of these, 22 species are
recognized as globally threatened. It must be emphasized that this list is far from exhaustive.
There are more species present in the area than recorded as the team:
n did not carry out any form of trapping or collection;
n did not focus on bats;
n did not focus on small mammals (except opportunistically recording the more
common ones);
n recorded the presence of birds, reptiles, and amphibians opportunistically;
n primarily focused on the project’s main objectives.
Table 3.2 gives the localities where various wildlife species were recorded. Apparently, most
wildlife records were from the Thalang/Poung Phai/Poung Ta-ee and the Nam Gnalong areas.
Significant Finds
Observations on species of conservation significance (figure 3.1) and significant observations
of some common species are briefly described:
n Macaques: Four species of macaques, comprising rhesus macaque, Assamese
macaque, pig-tailed macaque, and bear macaque are found the study area. The
species commonly sighted is the rhesus macaque, usually along the Nam Theun and
its major tributaries, with most encounters in the middle reaches of Nam Xot.
48
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Assamese macaques were sighted only once, in the lower Nam Xot. Captive pig-tailed
macaques were observed at Ban Bocho and in the Nakai township. Captive rhesus
macaques were observed in Ban Sopnian and Ban Namnian, and a captive bear
macaque was observed in Thakhek town.
n Douc langur: Only one group of douc langur was observed throughout the survey, and
this was at Keng Non, close to the proposed Nam Theun II hydropower site. Reports
suggest that this species are found in the hilly areas to the east and west of the
proposed hydropower site.
n Francois’s langur: Albeit none was encountered during surveys, yet there were
consistent reports of this species occurring along the Sayphou Ak.
n White/yellow-cheeked crested gibbon: Gibbons were heard at two locations, one in the
Nam Gnalong area and one in the Nam Xot area (within the Nakai - Nam Theun
NBCA). The species could not be confirmed from the vocalizations.
n Dhole: Albeit not occurring at high densities, the dhole is probably the main top
predator in the areas surveyed. Several signs mainly in the form of tracks and scats
were observed in Nam Xot, the middle reaches of Nam Gnalong, Nam Gnala, and
around the mineral licks Poung Phai and Poung Ta-ee. Several signs observed in the
rocky flats and in other areas could not be confirmed as that belonging to the dhole.
This was because there were several human and domestic dog signs in the same
areas. Scats when analyzed revealed that their diet during this study primarily
comprised rodent species, and occasionally muntjac.
n Bears: Both the Asiatic black bear and the sun bear occur in the area. This was
confirmed from fresh tracks observed. Fresh tracks of the Asiatic black bear was
observed in the Nam Gnala area, and that of the sun bear observed in the middle
reaches of Nam Gnalong. Indistinguishable bear scat, feeding signs and claw marks,
both old and recent were observed at several places, with a major concentration in the
Kouangten area.
n Clouded leopard: One set of fresh prints was observed in an ecotone (pine forest and
evergreen forest) close to a rocky flat (Thong Heen Kon), almost halfway between
Poung Phai and Nam Gnalong.
n Tiger: Two sets of fresh tiger tracks were observed on an abandoned logging track
between Ban Thalang and Poung Phai. The two sets, although of slightly different
measurements, probably belong to the same tiger, as they were made on the same
day but on different substrates.
n Elephant: The most distinguishable species recorded in the area, as their signs are
the most apparent and not easily obliterated. Details of the Asian elephant are given in
section 4.
n Eurasian wild pig: Albeit not a threatened species (by IUCN threatened species
categorization), the wild pig is an important prey base to most large predators
(including humans), therefore a species of conservation significance. This species is
widely distributed but not occurring at high densities. A significant observation made
during this study was the widespread presence of pigs' breeding nests in many areas,
particularly in Kouangten and Nam Gnalong, in late July and early August, implying a
breeding season for the species.
n Sambar: Similarly as above, this species is not designated a threatened category, but
because of its rarity (most likely as a result of human persecution), this species
deserve special consideration. Signs of sambar were mainly observed in the
Kouangten area.
n Muntjacs: Two muntjac species are confirmed from the area, the common muntjac
and the large-antlered muntjac. The common muntjac, although widespread, does not
exist at high densities. The distribution of the large-antlered muntjac appears to be
49
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
more localized, with concentrations in areas close to the mineral licks, Poung Phai,
and Poung Ta-ee. Trophies of both species can be seen in some homes. Villagers
reported finding two freshly killed large-antlered muntjacs (by dholes). One at Poung
Phai on June 28, and the other at Poung Ta-ee on June 29.
n Gaur: Evidences of gaur, otherwise rare, were observed at five locations. Close to
Ban Thalang where a lone bull was seen by some villagers close to the Nam Theun
on June 22. Also at Poung Phai, Nam Gnalong and Nam Xot. At one location near
Nam Gnalong and at Nam Xot, tracks showed the presence of at least an adult and a
young gaur, possibly a mother-juvenile pair. On June 19, villagers reported seeing two
gaurs at Poung Ta-ee.
n Southern serow: No evidence was observed, but there were consistent reports of this
species occurring in parts of the Sayphou Ak.
n Hornbills: Four hornbill species were recorded in the area, the great hornbill, wreathed
hornbill, brown hornbill, and pied hornbill. The great hornbill and wreathed hornbill
might not be resident to the area, as they were seen coming and returning in the
direction of the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA. Captive brown hornbills were observed at
Ban Nakai Tai and Ban Sopnian.
n Indochinese water dragon: This species was commonly observed along the Nam
Theun between the rivermouth of Nam Xot to Ban Sopphaen, and along the Nam Xot.
n Snakes: The two commonly observed snake species in the study area was the green
cat snake and the checkered keelback. The green cat snake was commonly observed
coiled on bamboo overhanging the river, particularly along the Nam Theun, between
Ban Thalang and Nam Gnalong. Checkered keelback was usually observed along the
logging tracks.
n Caecilian: A caecilian of indeterminate species was observed along the road close to
Ban Bocho (on the road from Muang Nakai). Although this area was outside the study
area, this taxonomic group nevertheless deserved mention, as it is rarely reported.
3.2.2 Impacts
All the impacts on wildlife and habitat observed in the Nam Theun Corridor during this study
are human-induced. They can broadly be categorized into hunting and non-hunting activities,
although most of these activities overlapped one another and are interlinked. Impacts
observed in the area are significantly high. Table 3.3 shows the frequency of impact records
by area. This can be summarized as below:
n the Keng Kung Gnai/Nam Gnala area rates the highest in terms of overall impact,
followed by Tham On/Nam Xot area, Thalang/Poung Phai/Poung Ta-ee area, and
Nam Gnalong/Huai Chike area;
n hunting activities follow the same order as above;
n snaring is high in the Keng Kung Gnai/Nam Gnala and Kouangten area;
n gunshots were heard most often in Thalang/Poung Phai/Poung Ta-ee area, followed
by Nam Gnalong/Huai Chike area, and Keng Kung Gnai/Nam Gnala area;
n non-hunting activities, primarily forest clearance for swidden agriculture was observed
in the middle reaches of Nam Gnala;
n livestock grazing was highest around Thalang/Poung Phai/Poung Ta-ee.
Significant Finds
Observations made on the direct and indirect impacts on wildlife and habitats through hunting
and non-hunting activities include:
50
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
n Snares: Two main types of snares were observed in the Nam Theun Corridor. The
more common one using nylon strings are meant for small terrestrial mammals and
birds. These snarelines usually range from 400 to 500 m long, and each snare is
placed a meter apart along a ‘fence’ that comprised branches and sapling. The use of
these snares is widespread throughout the area, and is effective in reducing the prey
base population. The other snare type observed was the use of cables, ranging from
motorcycle brake wires to truck winches. These cable snares were observed at two
localities, on both sides of the Nam Theun in the Kouangten area. These cable snares
are effective for large mammals that include bear, tiger, sambar, muntjac, and gaur.
These cable snares are placed in a similar manner as the nylon snares, although the
‘fence’ is more than a meter high, and comprise branches, saplings, and small trees.
One of these cable snarelines apparently coincided with an area that showed the
highest density of bear and sambar signs. Another newly ‘fenced’ area, very likely for
the use with cable snares was observed in the Nam Gnala area. The fencing here
resemble an enclosure and covered an area almost a square kilometer. Snares when
encountered were removed10.
n Guns: Gunshots from modern firearms (CKC, AKA, & K44) and muzzle-loading guns
were frequently heard throughout the study, although the frequency of gunshots from
modern firearms was much higher. Most modern firearms are government-issued,
primarily to the army and the village militia, although it was reported that there are
some hunters from Khamkeut District in Bolikhamxay Province frequently seen
similarly using these modern firearms. It was reported that some members of the
army and the village militia often lend their firearms to relatives and friends for hunting
purposes. It was also reported that bullets can be purchased without much difficulty
for USD 0.06 a bullet. Most disturbing was the frequency of gunshots heard in the
forest close to the NBCA’s headquarters. These shots were fired by members of the
District Military. Some of the hunted animals are sold at the Nakai District market (e.g.,
wild pig, muntjac, and civet). On August 20, some army personnel from Ban Bocho
were observed with a freshly shot rhesus macaque close to Poung Phai. In the fourth
week of September, several gunshots by army personnel (from Ban Bocho) were
heard in the Poung Phai and Poung Ta-ee area11.
n Hunting Parties: There are frequent reports of hunting parties (with modern and
muzzle-loading guns, and hunting dogs) traversing the Nam Theun Corridor into the
Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA, carrying out hunting in both the corridor and the NBCA.
These hunting parties are mainly from Khamkeut District. On July 27, three men with
hunting dogs were observed in the Nam Xot area of the NBCA. There were apparently
collecting palm fronds to make temporary shelters. Their objective was to collect
NTFPs that may include wildlife (through snaring). On July 30, in the Nam Xot area of
the corridor, a party of six to seven men with muzzle-loading guns and hunting dogs
immediately ran away upon encounter with a survey sub-team. Apparently, this route
serves as the main access into the NBCA. On August 12, a sub-team encountered
three armed men and a boy in the Kouangten area. No other information could be
obtained as the sub-team feared the hunting party. On August 18, three armed men in
military uniforms were observed travelling up the Nam Gnalong.
n Elephant: Bones of elephants were observed at two sites. Although the cause of death
could not be determined, it was nevertheless reported the elephants may have been
killed for their ivory. Resident villagers and other informants reported that there have
been several incidences of elephant poaching in the past. They further reported that
some of these poachers are professional hunters from within the region, and some
were from across the border, while the others are opportunistic hunters involved in
10
This was done only when the consultant happened to encounter the snares (and other trapping devices),
otherwise the trainees felt that it was not in their interest to remove the snares for fear of repercussions.
Similarly, trainees dare not record particulars when encountering poachers in the forest.
11
They were later requested to refrain from hunting in the area, which they complied, at least during the
presence of the wildlife team.
51
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
logging activities. WCS (1997), based on the information they gathered, suggested
that at least 30 elephants from the Nakai Plateau have been killed by poachers since
early 1990s.
n Mineral licks: Three important mineral licks, Poung Phai, Poung Ta-ee, and Poung
Mak Pat, in the Ban Thalang area are severely disturbed by the permanent presence
of green pigeon catchers (from Ban Thalang, Ban Nakai Tai and Ban Nakai Nua). The
licks are covered with branches to prevent the pigeons from landing at any other spot
other than where a trap (spring-net) is. Evidence shows regular use of licks by
elephants, ungulates and occasionally by top predators. These mineral licks are also
regularly used by domestic buffaloes. Hence, activities related to the trapping of green
pigeons severely interrupt the ecological needs of wildlife, in particular herbivores. In
addition, contagious diseases from domestic buffaloes could easily spread to wildlife
with disastrous effects.
n Wildlife trade: Wildlife traders, primarily from Lak Sao township (Bolikhamxay
Province) regularly and frequently visit Ban Sopnian, Ban Namnian, Ban Thalang and
other villages in the Nabon-Nathon area (in Phou Hin Poun NBCA), and other
settlements along the road from Ban Thalang to Muang Nakai township to purchase
wildlife and wildlife parts. Wildlife purchased was resold to other middlemen in
Vietnam. The main species sought by the traders is the pangolin, usually bought from
the villagers at USD 25/kg). Wildlife observed sold at the fresh market of Muang Nakai
included live green pigeons (USD 0.63/bird), muntjac (USD 2.25/kg), wild pig (USD
1.88/kg), and a masked palm civet (USD 3.75/animal). Domestic trade in wildlife (for
consumption) is common during the dry season with the onset of logging and related
activities.
n Captive wildlife: Captive animals observed at Ban Sopnian included two full-grown
east Asian porcupine, an infant rhesus macaque (bought at USD 0.63), three infant
common palm civet, a Bengal monitor, an Indochinese box turtle and a brown hornbill,
and a few commoner squirrels and birds. A brown hornbill and a crested serpent
eagle were observed at Ban Nakai Tai. There was also a juvenile rhesus macaque at
Ban Namnian, and a juvenile pig-tailed macaque at Ban Bocho.
n Fishing and NTFP collection: Old, recent and active camps and campsites were
observed throughout the study area, being mainly located along the Nam Theun and
Nam Xot. Although the primary objective is to fish, NTFPs (primarily rattan) were
nevertheless harvested and wildlife poached. The fishing methods observed during
the study comprised baited hooks and nets. However, there are consistent reports of
some resident villagers and ‘outsiders’ using explosives to fish in the area.
n Forest clearance: Some new clearances for agricultural purposes were observed
along the Nam Theun close to Nam Poungphai and Nam Gnala, and along the Nam
Gnala.
n Tree-felling: There are a few forms of tree felling in the area. Commercial logging and
its related impacts were observed in all areas surveyed. In several areas, timber
extraction was observed to be above the inundation area. There still exist several logs
awaiting to be transported out when access is feasible during the dry season
(beginning in November). Signs of timber extraction by resident villagers for local use
was occasionally observed. Non-timber species were often felled to harvest their
fruits, or rattan (twined to the tees), or wildlife nesting in those trees.
n Livestock: Cattle, particularly buffaloes range freely throughout the area, and regularly
use the mineral licks. These have serious implications on the wildlife population, which
include competition for resources, the spread of diseases to wildlife, and the
escalation of human-wildlife conflicts through wildlife predation on cattle. Related to
this is a large fenced enclosure built by Ban Bocho residents, in an open grassland
between Poung Phai and Poung Ta-ee, and covering an area about 80 ha, whose
objective is to ‘capture’ their semi-feral free-ranging buffaloes. This large enclosure
52
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
has direct impacts on the movement of terrestrial wildlife, and on the habitat (tree
felling for fence construction). In addition, these ‘buffalo gatherers’ partake in snaring
and hunting activities.
53
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Evidence:
1. Sighting (including live, dead, captive 6. Scrapes/Claw Marks
animals or trophies ) 7. Feeding Signs
2. Tracks 8. Other (e.g. wallows, bathing pools, mud
3. Vocalization smears, and antler/horn marks
4. Scat/Dung 9. Reliable Report
5. Nests
Mammals:
Common Name Scientific Name Lao Loum Name Evidence IUCN CITES
Chinese pangolin Manis pentadactyla Lin khoay(?) 9 NT II
Sunda pangolin Manis javanica Lin nguoa(?) 9 NT II
Northern treeshrew Tupaia belangeri Kachon 1
Slow loris Nycticebus coucang Ling lom 9 II
Pygmy/Intermediate Nycticebus Ling lom 9 V/? II/II
loris pygmaeus/intermedius
Pig-tailed macaque Macaca nemestrina Ling kang 1,9 V II
Assamese macaque Macaca assamensis Ling 1,9 V II
Rhesus macaque Macaca mulatta Ling daeng/ling 1,2,9 NT II
nam
Bear macaque Macaca arctoides Kha-dum 1,9 V II
Douc langur Pygathrix nemaeus Kha daeng E I
White/Yellow-cheeked Hylobates Thanee 3,9 DD I
crested gibbon leucogenys/gabriellae
Dhole Cuon alpinus Ma nai 2,3,4,9 V II
Bear spp. 6,7
Asiatic black bear Ursus thibetanus Maeauy 2,9 V I
Sun bear Ursus malayanus Mi 2,9 DD I
Back-striped weasel Mustela strigidorsa V
Yellow-throated Martes flavigula Ma nai mai 9
marten
Hog badger Arctonyx collaris Mou lung 2,9
Large-toothed ferret Melogale personata Lung tong 8,9
badger
Otter spp. Nak 4
Smooth-coated Lutrogale perspicillata Nak teen pet 2,9 V II
otter(?)
Oriental small-clawed Aonyx cinerea Nak teen ma 2,9 NT II
otter
Large Indian civet Viverra zibetha Haen hang kaan 2,9
Small Indian civet Viverricula indica Haen 1,2,9
Common palm civet Paradoxurus Haen om/Haen 1,9
hermaphroditus teen tam
Binturong Arctictis binturong Haen hang 9
khaw/khawt
12
Taxonomic names of wildlife (unless indicated otherwise) and order of listing follow that used in Duckworth
et al., (1999) for ease of comparison.
54
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
khaw/khawt
Small Asian Herpestes javanicus Chon-phon 1,9
mongoose
Crab-eating Herpestes urva Chon-phon 1,9
mongoose
Leopard cat Prionailurus bengalensis Seua nok/Seua 2,9 II
meo
Fishing cat(?) Prionailurus viverrinus NT I
Asian golden cat Catopuma temminckii NT I
Clouded leopard Pardofelis nebulosa Seua takout/kalout 2,9 V I
Leopard Panthera pardus Seua dao 9 I
Tiger Panthera tigris Seua/Seua 2,9 E I
ngai/Seua krong
Elephant Elephas maximus Xang 1,2,3,4,7, E I
8,9
Eurasian wild pig Sus scrofa Mou paa 1,2,4,5,7,
8,9
Lesser oriental Tragulus javanicus Kaai/Faan kaai 1,2,9
chevrotain
Sambar Cervus unicolor Kouang 2,8,9
Muntjac sp. 3
Red muntjac Muntiacus muntjak Faan/Faan 1,2,4,8,9
thamada
Large-antlered Megamuntiacus Faan dong 1,2,9 V I
muntjac vuquangensis
Gaur Bos gaurus Meauy 2,9 V I
Southern serow Naemorhedus Nyearng pha 9 V I
sumatrensis
Black giant squirrel Ratufa bicolor Khadang 1,3,9 II
Pallas squirrel(?) Callosciurus erythraeus Kahok 1
Inornate squirrel Callosciurus inornatus Kahok 1 V
Cambodian striped Tamiops rodolphii Kalaen 1,3
squirrel
Red-cheeked squirrel Dremomys rufigenis Kanai 1
Berdmore’s squirrel Menetes berdmorei Ketae 1
Large flying squirrel Petaurista sp. Baang loua 3,9
sp.
Phayre’s flying squirrel Hylopetes phayrei Baang tong 9
East Asian porcupine Hystrix brachyura Min 1,7,9 V
Asiatic brush-tailed Atherurus macrourus Hon 1,7,9
porcupine
Siamese hare Lepus peguensis Katai 1,9
Hoary bamboo rat Rhizomys pruinosus On 1,7,9
Birds:
Common Name Scientific Name Lao Loum Name Evidence IUCN CITES
Chinese francolin Francolinus pintadeanus 1
Bar-backed partridge Arborophila 1,3
brunneopectus
Scaly-breasted Arborophila charltonii Nok khaw 1,3 V
partridge
55
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
56
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
57
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
58
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
1. Thalang, Poung Ta-ee & Poung Phai 8. Thalang - Sop Gnalong (river)
2. Lower to mid Nam Gnalong 9. Sop Gnalong - Keng Kung Gnai (river)
3. Mid to upper Nam Gnalong 10. Tham On - Thalang (road)
4. Keng Kung Gnai & Nam Gnala 11. Sopnian - Namnian (road)
5. Nam Xot & Tham On 12. Thalang - Nam Xot (river)
6. Kouangten 13. Tham On - Namnian (road)
7. Nakai - Thalang (road) 14. Thalang - Namnian (road)
15. Thalang - Sopphaen (river)
Mammals:
Common Name 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Northern treeshrew 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Loris sp. 3 3
Pig-tailed macaque 3 3 3 3 3 3
Assamese macaque 3
Rhesus macaque 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Bear macaque 3
Douc langur 3
White/Yellow-cheeked crested 3 3
gibbon
Dhole 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Bear sp. 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Asiatic black bear 3
Sun bear 3
Otter sp. 3 3 3
Smooth-coated otter(?) 3
Oriental small-clawed otter 3
Large Indian civet 3 3 3
Small Indian civet 3
Common palm civet 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Small Asian mongoose 3 3 3 3 3 3
Crab-eating mongoose 3 3
Leopard cat 3 3 3 3 3 3
Fishing cat(?) 3
Asian golden cat 3 3
Clouded leopard 3
Tiger 3
Elephant 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Eurasian wild pig 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Lesser oriental chevrotain 3 3 3
Sambar 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Red muntjac 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Large-antlered muntjac 3
13
Through sighting and other physical evidence only, and exclude verbal information.
59
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Gaur 3 3
Black giant squirrel 3 3 3 3 3
Pallas squirrel(?) 3 3 3
Inornate squirrel 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Cambodian striped squirrel 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Red-cheeked squirrel 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Berdmore’s squirrel 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Large flying squirrel sp. 3 3
East Asian porcupine 3 3 3 3 3 3
Asiatic brush-tailed porcupine 3 3 3 3
Siamese hare(?) 3
Hoary bamboo rat 3 3 3
Birds:
Common Name 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Chinese francolin 3 3 3 3
Bar-backed partridge 3 3 3 3 3
Scaly-breasted partridge 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Red junglefowl 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Silver pheasant 3 3 3 3 3 3
Siamese fireback 3 3 3
Yellow-legged buttonquail 3 3
Barred buttonquail 3
Speckled piculet 3 3 3 3
Rufous woodpecker 3 3
Lesser yellownape 3
Laced woodpecker 3 3
Red-collared woodpecker 3
Common flameback 3
Great barbet 3 3 3 3
Red-vented barbet 3
Lineated barbet 3 3 3
Oriental pied hornbill 3 3 3 3
Great hornbill 3
Brown hornbill 3 3 3
Wreathed hornbill 3 3
Orange-breasted trogon 3 3
Red-headed trogon 3
Indian roller 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Blue-eared kingfisher 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Stork-billed kingfisher 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
White-throated kingfisher 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Blue-throated bee-eater 3 3 3
Indian cuckoo 3 3 3 3 3 3
Green-billed malkoha 3 3 3 3 3 3
Greater coucal 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
60
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Lesser coucal 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Grey-headed parakeet 3 3
Oriental bay owl 3 3
Mountain scops owl 3 3 3 3
Oriental scops owl 3
Fish owl sp. 3
Collared owlet 3 3
Asian barred owlet 3 3
Great eared nightjar(?) 3
Large-tailed nightjar(?) 3
Oriental turtle dove 3 3 3 3
Barred cuckoo dove 3
Spotted dove 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Emerald dove 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Thick-billed green pigeon 3 3 3 3 3 3
Mountain imperial pigeon 3 3
White-breasted waterhen 3
River lapwing 3
Red-wattled lapwing 3 3 3
Jerdon’s baza(?) 3 3 3
Black kite 3
Lesser fish eagle(?) 3
Crested serpent eagle 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Little egret 3
Intermediate egret 3
Cattle egret 3
Chinese pond heron 3
Cinnamon bittern 3
Dusky broadbill 3
Banded broadbill 3
Blue-winged leafbird 3
Orange-bellied leafbird 3
Brown shrike(?) 3
Long-tailed shrike 3
Red-billed blue magpie 3 3
Large-billed crow 3 3
Ashy woodswallow 3
Black-naped oriole(?) 3
Black-hooded oriole 3
Black drongo 3 3 3 3 3 3
Ashy drongo 3
Bronzed drongo
Lesser racket-tailed drongo 3 3 3
Spangled drongo 3 3 3
Greater racket-tailed drongo 3 3 3 3 3
White-rumped shama 3
61
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Common myna 3 3 3 3
Hill myna 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Black-headed bulbul 3 3 3
Black-crested bulbul 3
White-crested laughingthrush 3 3 3 3 3 3
Yellow wagtail 3 3 3 3
Grey wagtail 3
62
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
63
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
14
Excluding elephant - this is described in section 4.
64
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
65
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
66
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
67
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
68
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
69
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
70
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
71
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
72
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
73
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
74
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
75
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
76
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
4.1 INTRODUCTION
This section addresses one of the primary objectives of this consultancy, that is to assess
wildlife movements and seasonal migration in the lower Nam Theun, focusing on the Nam
Theun Corridor, and identifying critical factors affecting them. Firstly, it must be clarified here
that the term ‘seasonal migration’ would mean the movement of a population (or the majority
of a population from one area to another during a certain season within a 12-month cycle.
There are two distinct seasons in the study area, the dry and wet season. Given the short
duration of the project, only one season, the wet season, was covered. Hence, data gathered
during the course of this project most likely represent neither movements nor migration for a
12-month cycle. However, based on information from earlier related studies, and based on
verbal information gathered from residents living in and close to the study area, movements
and migration for both seasons, will nevertheless be presented and discussed.
It should also be noted that information regarding movements and migration was limited to
only one species, that is the Asian elephant15. This was primarily because data on other large
mammals (e.g., gaur and tiger) was scanty, which in turn was very likely due to the fact that
most large mammals in the Nam Theun Corridor exist at low densities (section 3.2.1). Hence,
all information with regard to wildlife movements and seasonal migration presented in this
section refers to the Asian elephant (unless specified otherwise).
Besides assessing movements and seasonal migration of the Asian elephant in the Nam
Theun Corridor, and identifying critical factors affecting them, this study attempted to estimate
the density of the Asian elephant. For species management purposes, obtaining ‘elephant
numbers’ is equally as important as assessing their travel routes and migratory patterns.
Likewise, it is also important to gather information on their ecology and behavior, and human-
elephant conflict. However, because of the duration and nature of this project, only some
information on the species ecology and behavior could be obtained, but nevertheless
presented here.
4.2 METHODS
15
At the request of the Nakai District Governor’s Office and the Forestry Section of the Khammouane PAFO, the
Asian elephant is briefly described in Annex 4.1.
77
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Location of elephant presence recorded during surveys were obtained using Garmin 12XL
GPSs, aided by 1:25,000 topographic maps and Silva compasses. Elephant dung when
observed were categorized into five categories:
n A = All boli intact, fresh, moist, with odor;
n B = All boli intact, but dry, no odor;
n C1 = More than 50% of all boli intact;
n C2 = Less than 50% of all boli intact;
n D = All boli broken up or in a flat mass;
The locations of all evidence were then transferred onto a master map comprising a few
1:25,000 topographic maps that will be maintained for future work in the area.
78
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Defecation Rate:
Dung defecation rate of the Asian elephant depends on the its diet, which in turn depends on
the habitat type and the season (Dawson, 1992). Obtaining data on defecation rates of wild
elephant was not possible for obvious reasons. Thus, the closest approximation to it, is
monitoring free-ranging domestic or captive elephants fed entirely on natural fodder.
Monitoring, both night and day, should be carried out over a continuous 12-hour time block,
over a minimum of 20 time blocks (annex 4.4), and there should also be at least one individual
from each age/sex class (Dawson & Dekker, 1992). This, however, was not possible as there
were no captive elephants close to the study area. Hence, the rate of 13.2033±0.789 dung
piles per day obtained from another study (Dawson, 1992) was used.
4.3 RESULTS
79
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Theun NBCA was not limited to that presented in figure 4.1. In addition, figures 4.1 and 4.2
clearly show that the elephant’s distributional range extended southwards beyond the
proposed boundary of the Nam Theun Corridor.
Based on the above data on elephant presence and distribution, the movement (and probable
movement) of elephants can be summarized as (figure 4.3):
1. Within the Nam Theun Corridor (and adjoining areas 17):
18
n from Nam Xot to Highway Route 8B , to Kouangten, to Nam Gnalong, to the mineral
licks (and vice-versa);
n from Nam Xot to Nong Pak Tok, to Nam Theun River (south of Kouangten), to
Kouangten, to Nam Gnalong, to the mineral licks (and vice-versa);
n from Nam Xot to Nong Pak Tok, to Nam Theun River, across the Nam Theun River, to
the mineral licks (and vice-versa);
n from Nam Xot to Nong Pak Tok, to Nam Theun River, across the Nam Theun River, to
Nam Gnalong (and vice-versa).
2. From the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA into the Nam Theun Corridor (and vice-versa):
n across the lower Nam Xot;
n across the Nam Theun River, between Ban Thalang and Ban Sopphaen.
3. From the Nam Theun Corridor into Phou Hin Poun NBCA (and vice-versa):
n across the Say Phou Ak at Laat Mak Heun.
Based on this study, studies by earlier workers (WCS, 1997; Steinmetz, 1998), and verbal
information, the seasonality in habitat use can be summarized as follows:
n wider use of area during the wet season as opposed to the dry season;
n use of the mineral licks throughout the year by the Nam Theun Corridor sub-
population, and intermittently throughout the year by the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA
sub-population;
n use of the Nam Theun Corridor throughout the year by the resident sub-population,
being mainly concentrated around the mineral licks, Ban Thalang area, Nam Theun
(between Ban Sopphaen and Kouangten), Kouangten and Nam Gnalong;
n use of the Nam Theun Corridor for some parts of the year by the Nakai - Nam Theun
NBCA sub-population;
n high use of the Nam Theun riverside and riverine habitats during the peak wet season;
n use of parts of the central forest area, primarily at Kuan Xam, in Phou Hin Poun NBCA
during the wet season.
[Note: it was reported that elephants used to range until the present-day Nakai township until
1990-91.]
17
Excluding the Nakai - Nam Theun and Phou Hin Poun NBCAs.
18
This is a seasonal road that is not passable to motor vehicles during the wet season.
80
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
The strip width of the transects was calculated to be 5 m, and this reduced the samples
observed to 65 dung piles. As the transects were of unequal lengths, therefore the number of
samples observed were weighted against each transect length. Thus, obtaining a dung
density at 3101.16 (±2098.07) droppings per km². The low precision of this estimate suggest
that an increase in the total length of the transects is needed. Nevertheless, proceeding with
this figure, an elephant density of 1.52 (±0.99) elephants per km² was obtained. In terms of
density, this figure is more likely an overestimate of actual elephant density found in the area.
Nevertheless, it gives an indication of the number of elephants using that area during the wet
season.
19
This southward direction joins a logging road that leads to the mineral licks.
81
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
forests. Mud smears observed on some trees near these muddy patches and mud wallows
suggest that the elephants frequently rub their bodies against trees after a mud bath.
The presence of elongated gashes on the bark of some trees suggest that the elephants
frequently rub their tusks against those trees. Occasionally, holes were observed in the sides
of some mud wallows and embankment, apparently made by the elephants’ tusks.
4.4 DISCUSSION
Based on all the observations and findings, it can safely be concluded that it is incorrect to
suggest that there is a seasonal migration of elephants from the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA
into the Phou Hin Poun NBCA, as only some elephants use the central forest area of Phou
Hin Poun NBCA during the wet season, and the area is merely an extension of their range.
Steinmetz (1998) and resident villagers reported the presence of elephants in the said area
only during the wet season, and into the early dry season. The term ‘migration’ in the context
of this study would mean the movement of a majority, if not all, of the elephant population from
the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA into Phou Hin Poun NBCA. Furthermore, the presence of a
resident sub-population in the Nam Theun Corridor does not support the existence of a
seasonal migration between the two NBCAs. Hence, the movements observed during the wet
season is very likely a range extension of their dry season range, i.e., a seasonal shift in
range, and not a seasonal migration.
Steinmetz (1998) suggested that water availability is one reason why elephants might be
using the central forest area of Phou Hin Poun NBCA during the wet season only. He further
suggested that the central forest area could possibly represent a sub-optimal habitat that are
82
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
being used only by subordinate elephants or small group of young bulls, or that the area is a
range extension for the Nakai Plateau population, that started using the area after more food
became available through human activities (secondary growth and stands of bamboo).
Observations from this study does lend support to the idea that part of the central forest area
is a range extension for the Nakai Plateau population, although possibly for different reasons
However, the reasons proposed in this study are more likely in addition and/or in relation to
that proposed by Steinmetz (1998). One possible reason for this range extension is the use of
mineral licks at Kuan Xam, located in the southern portion of the central forest area.
Secondly, the elephants use the area during the wet season, possibly to reduce pressure on
the food resources on the plateau during the wet season, when there is an increase in
elephant numbers. A third possibility is related to the elephants’ need to socialize (search for
mates and exchange of genes) with elephants from other population or sub-population,
possibly from Phou Hai - Phou Mon that similarly uses the central forest area.
There also appears to be some changes to the seasonality and patterns in ranging over the
past years. In the past, elephants were found close to human settlements only during the wet
season. Whereas in recent years their presence are reported throughout the year. Thus, the
seasonality in distribution and movement as currently observed may reflect adaptations in
response to disturbance, habitat change, and food availability.
Evidence has shown that major rivers on the Nakai Plateau do not restrict movements of the
elephants. Studies on the Asian elephant in southeastern Sri Lanka (McKay, 1973), and
northern Borneo (Boonratana, 1997a) observed that the elephant is capable of swimming,
and is apparently a common feature with this species. Both Peacock (1933) and Tun Yin
(1967) wrote that the Asian elephant in Myanmar are excellent swimmers, able to cross
water-bodies that are more than a kilometer wide. In addition, when crossing smaller water-
bodies, the elephant often walked the floor with an upraised trunk for breathing (Tun Yin,
1967). McKay (1973) observed that only the top of the elephant’s head and the tip of its trunk
were above water, while the rest of its body remained submerged when swimming.
Synthesizing the observations, findings and above discussions, it is expected that the
reservoir (once it fills in) will disrupt and restrict the movements and gene flow of the
elephants, and fragment their existing habitats. Over time, however, the reservoir may not
necessarily form a barrier, as the estimated distance (over water), along some of the known
travel routes is less than 1.5 km at the full supply level (538 m amsl), and not more than 400
m at minimum operating level (527.5 m amsl). Nevertheless, this is merely an assumption,
therefore mitigation measures must be implemented, whether the elephants are able to swim
across parts of the reservoir and use their remaining habitats or not. However, the serious
loss and fragmentation of habitats (and loss of food supply) will require proactive human
intervention that includes making available suitable habitats, and ensuring abundant food
supply.
The density estimate of elephants (1.52 elephants/km²) obtained for the study area where
transect surveys were carried out was very likely an over-estimate due to a bias influenced
by:
n the low precision of the dung density estimate;
n the elephants’ preference to habitats close to roads and rivers;
n the elephants’ preference for the mineral licks;
n the movement of elephants from the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA into the Nam Theun
Corridor during the wet season;
n the gathering of several elephants groups by Nam Theun during the peak wet season
Nevertheless, based on this estimate, the number of elephants using the study area during
the wet season was calculated to comprise 268 (±174) individuals. This area (fig. 4.1),
calculated to be 176 km², was the area within the ‘incomplete’ convex polygon, joining the
83
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
extreme-most locations of elephant evidence, until Nam Xot and Nam Theun (which forms the
southwestern boundary of Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA).
This figure, for the same reasons listed above, may likely represent the number of elephants
that can use the area during the wet season. For species management purposes, it is
probably more realistic to use the lower density estimate obtained (0.52 elephants/km²).
Hence, using this conservative approach, the lower population estimate was calculated to be
94 individuals, therefore very likely representing the size of the resident sub-population.
However, more detailed exercises are needed to confirm these findings.
Fresh elephant signs were commonly observed along the Nam Theun, on both riverbanks,
between Sop Poung Phai and Sop Gnalong during the peak rains of July, strongly suggesting
that different elephant groups made a ‘scheduled’ presence by the river. A similar observation
was made during a study on elephants in North Borneo, where different groups, comprising
more than 100 individuals came to gather by the major rivers during the peak rains
(Boonratana, 1997a). Interviews with local villagers in the Nam Theun area revealed that this
was a common feature with the elephants in that area during peak rains. This gathering of
elephants by a distinctive topographical feature (a major river) during a certain period of the
year strongly suggest a need for the different elephant groups to socialize, and possibly
exchange of genes (Boonratana, 1997a).
Evidence of elephant activity by major rivers and tributaries strongly suggest the species’
dependence on waterways and its associated riverine habitats. River systems and their
associated habitats provide both large quantities of water and food important to the elephant,
hence the elephants movement would therefore, be governed by the spatial distribution and
temporal availability of food and water (Boonratana, 1997a; McKay, 1973; Sukumar, 1989).
Furthermore, elephants are known to be attracted to bamboo patches during the wet season
to feed on shoots, stems and leaves (pers. obs; Lekagul & McNeely, 1997). Besides
supplying the elephant’s needs for water and food, major river systems possibly serve as
important points of reference or landmarks, particularly for wide-ranging species. Major
waterways are therefore most likely the most readily recognizable landmarks in habitats
(particularly in a tropical rainforest) where visibility is limited (Boonratana, 1997a). Thus,
historically, their range would include habitats associated with river systems.
Similarly, there is a preference for elephants to travel along or very close to roads in forested
areas. Most likely, this is due to the greater food availability by roads and the relative ease by
which the elephants can travel (Boonratana, 1997a).
Frequent and regular visits to mineral licks clearly indicate the importance of these sources to
the Asian elephant. Hence, the species distribution and movement also governed by the
distribution of these mineral sources (Boonratana, 1997a; Davies & Payne, 1982; Olivier,
1978; Sukumar, 1989). Mineral licks are important not only to elephants but also to other
herbivores, and indirectly to carnivores that prey on these herbivores. Constituents of mineral
licks are usually different for different mineral licks, therefore there is a tendency for elephants
to visit as many mineral licks as possible (Lekagul & McMeely, 1997). In addition,
observations by Lekagul and McMeely (1997) showed that mineral licks are visited more often
during the wet season or after rains, when water dissolve the nutrients, therefore easily
consumed. Thus, ensuring the viability of the mineral licks is one of the key factor towards
ensuring the long-term viability of the elephants in the area (section 5.3.7).
Wallowing behavior in the Asian elephant might serve to moisten the skin and to protect the
animals against ectoparasites, and possibly assist in thermoregulation (Boonratana, 1997a).
Based on observations and findings, human conflicts with elephant in the Nam Theun
Corridor and adjoining area arose as a result of loss of habitat, poaching, disturbance from
logging and related activities, and the elephants’ acquired taste for agricultural crops. Loss of
habitat in the Nakai Plateau is primarily through agricultural expansion, swidden agriculture
and timber extraction (that did not conform to ecologically sound prescriptions). Furthermore,
a major loss of habitat, as a result of the hydropower construction, will escalate human-
elephant conflicts, primarily through competition for the remaining habitats.
84
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Table 4.1 Elephant Crop Damage Claims of Ban Thalang (Sep. 15, 2000).
Claimant Rice (kg) Banana Sugar cane Cassava Papaya Amount (in
(stems) (stems) (stems) (stems) Kip20)
Thongsee - 350 300 1500 - 5,000,000
Khaentae - 150 60 300 - 4,500,000
Pho Intong 20 120 150 300 - 3,000,000
Thavong 10 100 105 - - 3,500,000
Thao Khamnoo - 120 109 - - 3,000,000
Mae Maikhoon - 108 90 - - 3,500,000
Lung Kamphong - 50 10 - - 2,000,000
Thao Siangkaew 25 50 25 - - 3,500,000
Pa Pan 10 10 30 50 10 1,500,000
Lung Siangchampa 25 - - - - ?
Pao Buathong 30 - - - - ?
Pho Bounyang 35 - - - - ?
Pho thao 25 150 209 200 25 1,000,000
Khamkhong
Pho Nangnok - 39 40 10 - 3,000,000
Thao Maison - 60 70 150 45 3,500,000
Phothao Sopha - 30 - - - ?
Phothao Khamla - 200 10 100 - 3,500,000
Bounkhern 40 - - - - ?
Khamkhong 24 60 70 - 30 2,000,000
20
USD1 = c. Kip8,000.
85
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
86
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
87
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
88
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
89
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Personnel_____________________________________Location_______________
Habitat Type_________________Topography_____________Season____________
Transect No.__________Transect Length_________Compass Bearing___________
Weather_________ Date__________Start Time__________End Time___________
Distance along Perpendicular distance Stage of Remarks
transect (m) to dung pile (m) decay *)
* A = All boli intact, fresh, moist, with odour; B = All boli intact, but dry, no odour; C1 = More than 50% of all boli intact; C2
= Less than 50% of all boli intact; D = All boli broken up or in a flat mass.
90
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Personnel:________________________________Location:____________________
Habitat type:______________ Season:________Start date:_______End date:_______
Sample Date No. of Progressive decay stage by days *
no. boli
1 3 5 7 14 21 28 35 42 49 56 63 70
91
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Personnel: __________________________________________________________
Location:_________________________Season:____________Date:____________
Age/Sex_______________ Age/Sex_______________ Age/Sex______________T
Time block_____________ Time block ____________ ime block ___________
Time No. of boli Time No. of boli Time No. of boli
92
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
93
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
94
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
95
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
5.1 INTRODUCTION
The primary objectives of this component of the Year 2000 Activities of the Nam Theun Social
and Environmental Project comprise the:
n assessment of movements and seasonal migration patterns of wildlife in the lower
Nam Theun, focussing on the Nam Theun Corridor;
n training and strengthening of NBCA staff and relevant personnel to conduct similar
studies and to establish a regular monitoring of critical factors;
n recommendation of management guidelines for the lower Nam Theun, focussing on
the Nam Theun Corridor.
All the above objectives (and more) were achieved to varying degree of success, in spite of
obstacles faced as a direct result of the wet season - continuous rains, floods, landslides,
difficult access, food shortage, and health-related problems. Hence, the team had to put in
twice the effort to achieve the desired results.
Besides carrying out the activities towards achieving the objectives mentioned above, this
component undertook a few other minor activities that nevertheless bore significant
contributions and implications. These included:
n NBCA HQ Management: There is no permanent presence of any NBCA staff member
at the NBCA’s headquarters in Muang Nakai. Staff can be seen at the headquarters
only when there are some activities (usually project-related). Thus, this has resulted in
the poor condition of the headquarters - overgrown grass and shrubs, litter, missing
electrical wires, etc. Thus, to remedy this, two guards cum handymen were hired to
maintain the headquarters; computer, walkie-talkies, and the water pump were
repaired21; electrical wires and other basic utensils (rubbish bins 22, buckets, brooms,
etc.) were purchased. Albeit this may appear trivial, it was nevertheless necessary to
maintain a healthy working environment for the headquarters. This, however, badly
reflect the attitude of the NBCA management authority and other personnel towards
cleanliness, and the care and maintenance of equipment.
n Conservation Awareness: T-shirts depicting the different components of this project
were distributed to the relevant district agencies, schools, and villages to generate
awareness and appreciation for the project. As the team belonging to this component
of the project could travel through settlements not usually visited by officials from
relevant agencies, it allowed a good opportunity to distribute other conservation
materials that included several different posters, calendars, and conservation story
books (The Story of “Noi”). At schools, teachers were requested to award a T-shirt
each to a male and a female student of every class that had achieved high grades in
their studies. This will hopefully allow other students to similarly work hard at their
studies. While on the subject of conservation awareness materials, it is indeed
unfortunate that in spite of the efforts and costs invested into producing those
materials over the past years by different agencies, they rarely reach the target group.
Most never get distributed beyond the provincial and district offices. Even if it reached
settlements, the village headmen tended to ‘hoard’ all the materials for himself and his
immediate family members. It is not uncommon to see five to six of the same posters
on the walls of the headmen’s and family members’ homes.
21
Computer breakdown was primarily due to lack of knowledge of use, and the use of the computer for
‘karaoke sessions’. Walkies -talkies were apparently used as ‘telephones’ - long conversations.
22
In spite of installing rubbish bins and constant reminders, staff, relevant personnel, members of the other
components of this project, and visitors still have difficulty in proper rubbish disposal.
96
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS
Recommendations offered here do not only pertain to the Nam Theun Corridor and in relation
to the activities carried out during this consultancy, but applies to the whole Nakai - Nam
Theun Conservation Area. Most often than not, some of these recommendations are
applicable to other protected areas in Lao PDR.
97
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
98
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
24
It has been observed that NBCA management activities usually come to a standstill when a project e nds.
99
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
5.3.4 Zonation
n Demarcate zones and establish rules.
Identify and demarcate zones within the NBCA and its extensions and develop rules
and regulations for those zones. The delineation of areas within a protected area into
management zones is to allow specific objectives to be fulfilled by allowing or not
allowing certain activities to be carried out within those zones. The ultimate goal,
however, is to provide long-term protection and conservation of natural resources of
the protected area through better implementation of activities and better planning for
future activities. With clear management zones, the conflict among stakeholders can
be avoided or will greatly be reduced. Zoning exercises should be done in consultation
with a wildlife biologist, a land use planning specialist, and the stakeholders.
n Complete land allocation and land use exercises.
Land allocation and land use exercises should also be carried out in all villages within
and adjacent to the NBCA to prevent further loss of viable forested areas. Village ‘rules
and regulations’ should be developed in consultation with all the concerned
stakeholders (and in consultation with a wildlife biologist), as these will significantly
impact on the traditional rights and livelihoods of the local communities. It could be
simultaneously developed while carrying out the land allocation exercises. Besides
abiding the rules and regulations, villagers need to commit efforts towards patrolling
and monitoring of areas within their village boundaries. Compliance with rules and
regulations can possibly be achieved through an exchange for privileges, which can
include agricultural extension, health care, and better schooling.
n Mineral licks should receive a special protection status.
Mineral licks must be made off-limits to detrimental human activities, domestic
animals, and to unauthorized individuals. Domestic animals, particularly cattle, should
not be allowed to range freely into the protected areas, to prevent competition for the
same food resources, human-wildlife conflict (e.g., predation on domestic animals),
and spread of diseases to wildlife. Furthermore, all domestic animals in and around
the conservation areas should be inoculated against potentially dangerous diseases.
This could be included into the activities of extension assistance.
100
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
5.3.5 Administration
n Ensure the permanent presence of protected area staff at the NBCA headquarters.
There is a need for the presence of at least two senior ranking staff (on a rotational
basis), and other administrative staff at the NBCA headquarters in Muang Nakai at any
given time, to manage the headquarters, deal with daily and/or urgent needs, and
address issues. Currently, the headquarters is more or less deserted unless there are
donor-funded project activities, or because the existing staff are all involved in the field-
based activities of the project.
n Establish rules and regulations with regard to equipment and vehicle use.
Equipment and vehicles should be issued to the staff and relevant personnel only, and
only when they are on assignments. The equipment and vehicles should be returned
and checked immediately after the assignment. The NBCA should develop regulations
regarding the use of equipment and vehicles, and the vehicles should be insured and
drivers should have valid licenses.
n Establish a system for care and maintenance of equipment and vehicles.
Field equipment and vehicles should be cleaned after every field trip. Equipment like
compasses, binoculars, cameras, and GPSs should be kept out of their cases and
placed in airtight containers safely in the cabinets. Similarly, vehicles should be
washed and oiled at least once a week, and serviced every 5,000 km. A vehicle
maintenance logbook can be maintained for this purpose.
n Rewire the electrical supply and outlets.
There is a major need for a rewiring of electrical lines and sockets at the headquarters
to prevent damage to electrical equipment and possible fires caused by faulty wiring
and incorrect fuses (as observed currently).
5.3.6 Miscellaneous
n Involve both Bolikhamxay and Khammouane Provinces.
As the Nakai - Nam Theun Conservation Area covers both the Bolikhamxay and
Khammouane Provinces, there therefore need to be a strong partnership and
coordination amongst the relevant agencies of both provinces, and it is imperative that
donor-funded projects involve both provinces.
n Initiate and conduct a long-term conservation education and awareness program.
A conservation education and public awareness program should be carried out at
every settlement centers in and around the NBCA and its extensions. This can be
carried out by the NBCA extension staff, after receiving appropriate training, or by
‘specialists’ like the drama troupe of the Vientiane mobile library. The program should
also include topics on protected species, protected area rules and regulations, and
penalties.
n Obligation and commitment from the public sector and NGOs.
101
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
102
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
n Conduct a long-term study into the ecology and behavior of the Asian elephant on the
Nakai Plateau.
A long-term study should be conducted on the ecology and behavior of the Asian
elephant on the Nakai Plateau. This should be carried out at least for three continuous
years before the inundation, and for at least three continuous years after the
inundation. The use of radio-tracking materials will also be needed to study changes
and adaptation in response to the hydropower construction and filling in of the
reservoir. This will involve a permanent team of one qualified biologist, two assistant
field biologists, and four support staff, and the use radio telemetry. This study will also
provide an opportunity for the training of Lao graduate students.
n Reforestation of degraded forest.
A reforestation program in the in the degraded areas (above the inundation area)
should be carried out, particularly in the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA. Planting of
bamboo and tamarind species should also be included in suitable areas (for
elephants). Bamboo has been identified (during this study) as an important food
resource for the elephant during the wet season, while tamarind is an important
‘medicinal’ plant for the elephants, which the elephants use to remedy stomach
ailments.
Besides these recommendations, special measures are also needed to mitigate the impacts
of habitat loss, potential human-elephant conflicts and other related issues, arising primarily
through creation of the reservoir. The measures in order of priority are:
n Create artificial mineral licks.
Artificial mineral licks should be established in the Nakai - Nam Theun NBCA, with the
aim of drawing the elephants away from the currently existing mineral licks, to
alternate (if not better) mineral sources. Experiments should begin immediately to
allow time for improvements, and to seek other alternative measures if the artificial
mineral licks does not have the desired effects. Artificial mineral licks should be
established at different but suitable locations within the elephants distributional range
and along their more common travel routes. Experiments using different combination
of minerals should be attempted. Hides and remote photography (camera-traps)
should be established close to the artificial mineral licks to monitor the elephants’
response to the artificial mineral licks. Information from the recommended study on
the ecological use of mineral licks (see above) will be complementary towards the
creation of artificial mineral licks with near-natural mineral composition.
n Identification and improvement of elephant islands.
There is a high probability that the elephants will, in time, reuse their traditional routes.
This also implies the probability of an escalation in human-elephant conflicts. Thus,
suitable islands should be selected for habitat improvement. Criteria for selection
should include only those islands that are in the path of movements, and those islands
further most from human habitations.
n Wildlife rescue and release operation.
Establish a team and the necessary logistics required in the rescue of wildlife
stranded on non-viable islands at least six months before the reservoir fills in.
Specialists experienced with similar rescue operations have to be identified at least a
year before inundation, so that their requirements can be met and the training of the
support staff can be carried out. Improper planning and preparations can lead to an
uncoordinated rescue effort with disastrous results. The specialists would have to
make a few on site visits to identify rescue centers and locations of release, besides
preparing of list of needs (human resource, drugs, transportation, etc.).
n Human resettlement.
103
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Resettlement of affected villages should not be anywhere near the elephants’ known
distributional range. There is every likelihood for the displaced elephants to seek food
in or near human habitations. Thus, by distancing the resettled villages (and where
they are allowed to carry out agricultural activities), will lessen the chances of human-
elephant conflicts
n Proactive patrolling of reservoir islands.
There is a major need for intensive patrolling of the islands created by the filling in of
the reservoir. These islands will be the primary target for wildlife poachers, as many
wildlife species will be concentrated on these islands. At least four speedboats with a
six-person capacity, fitted with spotlights are needed to carry out this essential activity.
104
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
n village-based, whose members are the residents of the village, and will implement
activities in the concerned village’s area of jurisdiction;
n region-based, whose members comprise the remaining members of the unit
(foresters, military, police, villagers, etc.), based at a strategically located sub-stations.
The members based at the sub-station will cover the ascribed region and lend support
to the village-based members. The members at the sub-stations will be rotated on
weekly basis;
n and HQ-based, whose members similarly comprise the remaining members of the
unit who have completed their monthly tour of field duty, but who will carry out other
HQ-based activities (compilation of data, report write-up, etc.). They will nevertheless
be ‘on-call’ in the event that urgent support is needed.
However, a long-term experienced and qualified senior biodiversity conservation specialist,
having a strong background in wildlife biology, natural resources conservation, and protected
area management, assisted by two biodiversity conservation officers is needed to
successfully manage this unit, and to ensure that activities related to surveys, patrolling,
monitoring, and law enforcement are implemented. The terms of reference of the senior
biodiversity conservation specialist, besides managing the unit, is to provide and/or identify
necessary training for the unit; assist (if necessary supervise), monitor and evaluate
conservation biodiversity research and management projects; support related activities of
future conservation and development projects; advise on matters related to biodiversity
conservation (e.g., zonation, development of village rules and regulations, etc.); and to liase
with the relevant authorities of both Bolikhamxay and Khammouane Provinces. Furthermore,
the Nakai - Nam Theun Conservation Area (and other contiguous areas on both sides of the
international boundary) by virtue of its endemic, rare, diverse fauna and flora, and its ranking
among the highest globally significant ecoregions merits its own senior biodiversity
conservation specialist.
Funds required to maintain this unit is estimated to be USD 500,000 for the first year, USD
250,000 for the second year, with a 5% increment for the following years to meet inflation
costs. Budget for the first year include the costs of construction (headquarters, living
quarters, and sub-stations), the purchase of essential field and office equipment and vehicles,
salaries and per diems. Budget for the following years will mainly cover the unit’s operational
costs.
Albeit the strategy outlined above may initially appear outlandish, it is justified, and imperative
considering the stake(s) involved. Failure to seriously consider this strategy may result in the
regrettable and irreplaceable lost of biological diversity unique to the Nakai - Nam Theun
Conservation Area. Furthermore the costs involved in implementing this strategy is
insignificant compared to the cost of the loss of biodiversity - the extinction of the saola will
probably bear more significance than the loss of the ‘Mona Lisa’. Species extinction is more
than a loss of a species, because species extinction may have significant impacts on the
ecosystem - every species has an ecological role to perform. Hence, the loss or even the
reduction in numbers, will undoubtedly upset the ecosystem's delicate balance.
5.5 CONCLUSION
Training and capacity building of protected area staff and relevant personnel, particularly from
the stakeholder communities and agencies are important tools towards the effective
implementation of management activities. However, having skilled and knowledgeable staff
and relevant personnel alone does not suffice. This needs to be reinforced by strong
leadership, motivation, and institutional implementing capacity. Lacking all these and skilled
staff will inevitably hinder and constrain the implementation of management activities, very
likely more than the lack of funds.
Albeit most wildlife species in the Nam Theun Corridor exist at low densities, and much of its
habitats are disturbed, the establishment of the corridor is justified, and the protection and
management of the area is needed. This is primarily because of its importance to the Nakai
105
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Plateau elephants, and because several wildlife species of global conservation significance
exist there.
However, much of the Nam Theun Corridor and the plateau will be flooded resulting from the
hydropower construction, which in turn will directly and indirectly impact biodiversity
resources found there. The biological diversity in the Nam Theun Conservation Area is
figuratively caught between the 'devil and the deep blue sea’. On one side is the rapid loss of
biological diversity, mainly through wildlife poaching and trade, and the unsustainable and
unmanaged use of other natural resources. This in turn is primarily due to a lack of strong and
focussed management, a lack of implementing capacity, and a lack of commitment from the
relevant provincial and central authorities. On the other side is the expected loss of habitats
(and biodiversity) through the hydropower construction and flooding of the plateau.
Nevertheless, funds committed to the conservation of the Nam Theun Conservation Area
through the construction of the hydropower, will offer an excellent opportunity, that otherwise
might not be available, to make conservation 'happen'. However, conservation efforts in the
area must be focussed, and concentrate on 'time-tested' activities that can immediately
arrest the loss of biological diversity. At the same time, equal efforts must be directed towards
the capacity building and strengthening of the conservation authority's management of
implementing capacity. Furthermore, commitments are required from all parties and
stakeholders to ensure conservation activities are strictly implemented following guidelines
recommended here and by earlier workers.
The loss of biological diversity and other natural resources is not merely the 'loss of an
irreplaceable item' but its loss will severely impact human lives and the socioeconomic status
of a nation. Humans, whether living close to nature or in urban dwellings comprise a
component of the ecosystem, having to rely on the ecosystem's other components for food,
shelter, fuel, etc. Hence, the implications are obvious - human impacts on the natural
environment will equally impact the humans in return. However, there remains a chance - a
chance for humans to undo the damage and to mitigate impacts of development activities,
therefore a chance to maintain some balance within a fragile ecosystem.
106
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
107
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
LITERATURE CITED
Berkmuller, K., S. Southammakoth and V. Vongphet. 1995. Protected Area System Planning
and Management in Lao PDR: Status Report to mid-1995. Vientiane: IUCN/LSFP.
Boonratana, R. 1997a. A state-wide survey to estimate the density of the Sumatran
rhinoceros, Asian elephant and banteng in Sabah. New York: WCS.
Boonratana, R. 1997b. Field training in wildlife conservation research techniques and large
mammal survey at Nam Phui National Biodiversity Conservation Area, Lao PDR.
Vientiane: IUCN/LSFP.
Boonratana, R. 1998a. Wildlife survey training at Dong Hua Sao and Phou Xiang Thong
National Biodiversity Conservation Areas. Vientiane/Pakse: IUCN/BCP.
Boonratana, R. 1998b. Field management of Nam Poui and Phou Xang He national
biodiversity conservation areas. Vientiane: IUCN/LSFP.
Boonratana, R. 1998c. Nakai – Nam Theun Conservation Project [Phase 2]: Wildlife
monitoring techniques and participatory conservation at Nakai- Nam Theun NBCA.
Vientiane: IUCN/WCS.
Boonratana, R. 1999a. Establishment and Development of Tan Phu Elephant Sanctuary.
Hanoi: FFI.
Boonratana, R. 1999b. Training in Wildlife Survey and Data Analysis for the National
Biodiversity Conservation Areas Dong Hua Sao and Phou Xiang Thong.
Vientiane/Pakse: IUCN/BCP.
Buckland, S.T., Anderson, D.R., Burnham, K.P. & Laake, J.L. 1993. Distance sampling:
Estimating abundance of biological populations. Chapman & Hall, London. 446 pp.
Burnham, K.P., Anderson, D.R. & Laake, J.L. 1980. Estimation of density from line transect
sampling of biological populations. Wildlife Monographs 72: 1-202.
Corbet, G.B. and J.E. Hill. 1992. The Mammals of the IndoMalayan Region: A Systematic
Review. New York: Oxford University Press.
Corvanich, A. 1995. Thai Elephant. Forest Industry Organization.
Dawson, S. 1992. Estimating elephant numbers in Tabin Wildlife Reserve, Sabah. Report to
Sabah Wildlife Department, WWF Project MYS 224/92.
Dawson, S. and A.J.F.M. Dekker. 1992. Counting Asian Elephants in Forests: A Techniques
Manual. Bangkok: RAPA/FAO.
Davies, A.G. & Payne, J.B. 1982. A Faunal Survey of Sabah (IUCN/WWF Project #1692).
WWF-Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur.
Dyckworth, J.W., R.E. Salter and K. Khounboline (comps). 1999. Wildlife in Lao PDR: 1999
Status Report. Vientiane: IUCN/WCS/CPAWM.
IUCN. 1996. 1996 IUCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Gland: IUCN.
IUCN. 1997a. Environmental and Social Management Plan for Nakai - Nam Theun Catchment
and Corridor Areas. Vientiane: IUCN.
IUCN. 1997b. Khammouane Province: A Preliminary Environmental Inventory. Vientiane:
IUCN.
IUCN. 1998. Environmental and Social Management Plan for Nakai - Nam Theun Catchment
and Corridor Areas. Vientiane: IUCN.
King, B, M. Woodcock, and E.C. Dickinson. 1991. A Field Guide to the Birds of South-East
Asia. London:Collins.
Lekagul, B. and J. A. McNeely. 1977. Mammals of Thailand. Bangkok: Saha Karn Bhaet Co.,
Ltd.
108
NTSEP Year 2000 Activities: Wildlife Movement Study & Staff Training
Lekagul, B. and P.D. Round. 1991. A Guide to the Birds of Thailand. Bangkok:Saha Karn
Bhaet Co., Ltd.
McKay, G.M. 1973. Behavior and ecology of the Asiatic elephant in southeastern Ceylon.
Smith. Cont. Zool. 125:1-113.
MacKinnon, J. and K. MacKinnon. 1986. Review of the Protected Areas System in the Indo-
Malayan Realm. Gland: IUCN/UNEP.
Olivier, R.C.D. 1978. On the ecology of the Asian elephant. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
Cambridge University.
Payne, J., Francis, C.M. & Phillipps, K. 1985. A Field Guide to the Mammals of Borneo. WWF
Malaysia and The Sabah Society, Kuala Lumpur.
Peacock, E.H. 1933. A Game-Book for Burma and Adjoining Territories. H.F. & G. Witherby,
London.
Steinmetz, R. 1998. A Survey of Habitats and Mammals in and around Khammouan
Limestone National Biodiversity Conservation Area, Lao PDR. Bangkok: WWF-
Thailand.
van Strien, N.J. 1983. A guide to the tracks of the mammals of western Indonesia. Ciawa:
School of Environmental Conservation Management.
Sukumar, R. 1989. The Asian Elephant: Ecology and Management. University Press,
Cambridge.
Suwannakerd, S. 1998. Studies on Tracks of Some Mammals of Thailand. Unpublished B.Sc.
thesis. Chiang Mai University.
Tun Yin. 1967. Wild Animals of Burma. Rangoon: Rangoon Gazette Ltd.
Wiles, G.J. 1980. Faeces deterioration rates of four wild ungulates in Thailand. Nat. Hist. Bull.
Siam Soc. 28: 121-124.
WCS. 1996. Additional surveys and recommendations on the birds and mammals for the
Nam Theun 2 Hydropower Project, with emphasis on the Proposed Corridor and the
Reservoir Islands Area. Vientiane: WCS.
WCS. 1997. Environmental and Social Action Plan for the Nakai - Nam Theun Catchment and
Corridor Areas: Report of the Wildlife Survey. Vientiane: WCS.
109