'11 "~.11N D. .STh,lCEllJ8ARN~.78i.~ ..... 1':mDA. 8\0 G9t.DMAN.~AR NO.

ID165}

.2 . :MAIUAN' :L SELVAGGIO (BAR NO.ll4O:i2) :LAVELY & SINGER

3 ;~PF8sIoNAi.·COBPO;BAnON

~.~rm:k~ ~24OQ

4 . LoW .AD8tles. ~, ;n.N\I ,=29OCS,

'·Tcl.~: (3.10) S~3S01 .

s: . :f~w]Je: (310)' 55.6-3615

I •

is :Atttmleys ftu DAVID ~

1

S'~'~TO" 'R' .r'l"ioT ~;T'·O·D '!1j"ri'e COT> A·T!'~· nor;: ,...., 11,]11' 'l"r:ftjl:l'!I'-D".'" ·Ut.l"·;a:.~N.I ',. . !\..r-VY'~ ... ·r ,~,~ Ill! lo,n '= ~ v,r ~v~~~.

iii I 7' (

'enn, "l'T1[1::' CO'tTII.'I'T'V OF" .: " 'LOS" - AN" nrC'l: ceo . "n:FEi'f'!'I" 1:''1iJl·C''Ij'jD'rr,cr·· :

rv,~ &~ ,-:;-- V.l;,~I.~. . .-", '':''--, ~~ ~ ''''.D;;),I r~'.I."""'I: .. ,

10 :1

, I j.. '. . .' -... - ., .

11 ,DAVID SCH.'\VIMMER,. an ~'1

12 i, Plaimiff~

.

L'"A'~ fJoil';O'

'V" I.:JlCI;L 1J'I. I.

- -

£'to:"':n"J"II' it 'llJlLi;iII; ~"'D "'11" "'!I,,'N·,,'I:!'r.I, -v . ~,,:U'" ~".1. rUA ~"I[U~

.1."

..

'20: 1, This actIcm arises, O'll{ of ex~ deb.mdory sta(~ abom PWmtiff

• • I •

... ·1· ~'AVID' . ~11'1..n.~ (!!'nl .... :_~':~·\ ....... ""..1"" M.. n""~d ... _,j. jI, '" 'mi'O'N' TO··"'ko~· (' ·"T~"'t.-"') .,. ,

;Ii,.', !l.1' ';" '.' '~¥~ -" .L.LYl.L¥~ ," .r ~.U: j:wuau~ ~Jf ~.:s,~~ ~ - '. . . "I,"~"', ' ~~v,aa'. :II. lAo •

'. ,

..... I "".....w~~i &"111UO .... :.. ... """loF.."W· .i!.-_~..;I 00' . ., _ .. ......:i ~.:".<!i;-':"" ............. D,;,. ... ~iII .... on i'"-:t~ ~.!Ii_.t.......A

~ '~u.'fI"~ J..~'~BII.\1.-:)1[.,;n"r: .~ : :;I.l. ............. mAI~ .&IUOII.. J;'~,~',I!,.II~.III6.". ~ ~,RCU

.; ~ I • .. • "

. .,;~ - • + r 1'.: ........ t..........:_ ... '..;- 1''1' nmA·4t.......i D"· ~t:._ ... 'Pl~' ~ i=~ e.....,~..:~~,.. n...A

~ mmiR'@A~j'.'~~.·V~l'CtiVe' •• r FWw .. e:s~ ,.~~..,w: nm·'own..Ii~~pm.~

.

24 • i :oot« spite., mOludiDg; lies ab¢nt PJaintiff wmdl TOllb;;D told to ftLe media. socb e, ~~ " - .

: I ' ..

;u- Ii: pUJblished m·the ~ 22~. 2004 im.re of The NarioMl Enqrdm m an ardde ,e;gtided

I ' '.

1..6 ['~u.oUyWODd Prmd-RaUiDg., CELEBRI1Y GREED~.lll~ New Book says.,~ ami.

-' ,

'''1''' b· ... j~..:,.~I·., ....... ·ii) ... ;.....A1 w~· ~·M .. ··~rlll~ ... _ .. .,.,f~". ~''i' iI""1h~.i':i,' .. 'C..~ 4< ,IL..-li! .... 1 .. ~'!i In £.'iI~_ --.:I dJ~- ..... -,nil

~J. .J."u.UUL'hl\ ~ AA&.~ . - .,1' !.ILI.UY~ .Ii ... A~IUi ~'U.lL ~,1J"1 \Y1Y /'U~ lp.. .I.JU.bIII; ,~ ~,~: .. ;.r.'

.. . ..

r .. .. ..

2S ' ~emeiUS 1nadle many tn lliiId parUfS. mclu.dtng ~ of the ;u:l«Iw and- spec.lfi.cally ·tablbici"

, .

,

1

coMif'U1Nr '

i'

.. 1, reporter Mnre WUktr,~' TQnke~ ~y ~ that ~bad'~ to pull out of'a

I ~'L"""", - • "_1 .,",'" T i.. .. .Al

2 1!1~,I!ty. e:'IIeJ;d: 'IIJ1l\ess he: was given a pat( of t;~pe1ll!l"ve RwQ; '~, that ... Onken~,'

~ ..:.----~,~ i .. , +l..e· "'..-.- o'f'm·· unii ... ,_ t ..... ~II...- .. ~"'. t..~ '''~AI m- .£. 'I!'Ili'~""~""'" ... Il'Iilll'i'li" .... r

J ~~Ii~ I....L:IJ UI. J.W~, ~ 'II..., .. ~ "" ~,"II.J.'I~~ UI<IJ.,J.R'i ~ 1 Jl;iJ. ~~ g, ~ v

, .

4 . R' .... t..",.., 'W'~""'j.,· ....... .iC.o.. .. Pl··,.· "'~"~#""i!" .. po!'i.OT .... "'.....".,.,.~.c:: I'LtV'L ......... ,",,-, ...... ~'~ C':Ilr!lNi th' .. D,_j ........ ., ......... l._

. . ~~ _ ~w ,LW . ~ !P.~l lAo ~-L W v .. ~ ~'Jl\JUU • .aI.LIi.I 'UJ.iJ,~ .l~, ~ ..... ' .Ip ~~ -t.TiIli~~

, .

I j •

,S' 10 P9aintlff as a quid'pro qui)' ~ed ~y f,iamttffi lUI' hlB ~_1':,a.nce at dle cib:a.rity eveul'

~. -,r,~' _

, ':I~We Schwimmer r'en.s.-cd to be, chm:rimbl.e ualess be receilWd tJJ.U personal benefit (dm '.

,. , I

- I I "I

7 ~Stat;~ts"'). HC)'wever" T'Cloke:n. i$ a, ~ J?81boI~gi.e.a1 :Iiar~ beDt on caslig,ad~ll.g

':S 11:B~~ :M(i,'other celdlritics 'by co~d:bi1;g OO,gtlS stories ~dl·~ tbls hl an efibrne,jusIify' Ii 9 ~ontemt:g, nwn ekedt $Wd U'E'.t~ such as T~'s ~Jc ,~ct tbart r!$~ in ,m

..

1ft ,ru".""",;i~ ,/!.",.- _-:,t , ... ~ ,. £.... ..... Ii' 'I.::'I'I...:J- :I.""...:r~ ......... ...A ""'...... ..:II~' pJ ·ntiff ~

yi ~'M'lon 'J.IIN, ,1,WIJu,:m.N W'Ife! ,IJ,ii!;uy. . or I/.Iu.,rufio, CJ;I.<U:i!~ ,ilWii.& .~" uV,notS. )8!I~' i, .... es i01iI.

• ~ r

I . .

11 I irlorIml!tion and :t>elid'that ToDkm dLVened. rocmie.s ~. foI; canc.et charitia ;mel other

"o"'jI ~ ....... }il ...... ....1l ".'......,:i .• , 1~ .:' .. ~~"~ . .-1.. ....... t.,"~ . ... ~"'"' .iI..-~ . ....,iI ... A.S!

Y .i!!U~.Le call.se.g) ii:W!.I oonru"",, to ;ra11ooa tcl;.C w.o' , .. ~iN.Uc:t 'lI'J V,li.'Vn~Dg ;Wl:. Oil ~ ~.~ V.l

I .

1~, li..'i. ·lI.L "" ., "'-1..~'i"i'!I""" --..I .. , _ . ......:11 ~t..._ Ai T' ~i , Q....'I....J: ,,.,.,.., ~ .........

. ~ ~;~ .. .I,~ ow~ 'Iti} ~n-~~- dUU, wnG'IpI. ~_LU' '=WUI;w: 'i..!~ JI~,.,J,IWal!Clil W~ ~-~.1riI! !Ii!I1LN1U.

I '

r

16 tmd ~ by :biD;i to' be &l,te., s~:am.on,g ,~theI '1:bingsJ" pla:m:tiff ~ demanded nor

'S,7' i _"y....;r ilI,mi R- 'i~ ..... ,..,.0'1._ ,. . "",,-AQn.mno' ..t .... r ~,rin 010 .. a ....... '!I .... w. """' ' n' .1:::'..:1 10 .... o!>'U\IIiP

JJi..' I, L"""",,",I·.·W -.:I ,o.~ '"~ m e .... ,~...; l'W. '~~,.,;...:.g&: 'I,,:,U,""""'~ ... ' ... T'OL;i.U ~r\LBJ,~ ......... ;r,

18 I,:reeeiw any &lex w~cIles from Toruren 'fur any p1J.IpDse:. .~ ~~ m:ade by lookeJl.. I:

I L I •

, D'·', iime cJ.cu:ly hlt~ '10 ,palm P,lmmiff~, a col\d.~ ~t wb,1) de,manded a :prlcey

,.'. I

,lD, \~ pro ,goo fur appearin,g at a ,c.barlry ev«\t~ thertby ~ attentioo from TOllbn who

21 ':'w 'pled' guilty to.federal ftaOd. dlalg'e$. m4 faces additional charges :f.&r·di:vtrting t'imd! from

, .

, '

2Z ~, charities for 1ti:s OWD 1V'!1i',oomal use. These SW~ ,oomtirute ~,faJ5m"'"

. , J:""""'"

I ,

.13 J.and have ,~jol'i1" damag~ DiH'~# ..

I - • - t;a""""'jf _ , ,J;.Q C J.1A1U,W~.

,

24:1

,The Paltis: 00, the Disrmts

'P'~-!l;'ft<:='"'D.·;,.AVlD· . - $C.' ~1TJo.~~ li,. ....... '", .... ,:"i,] ~ ............ , ....:!.....,~ '1t ... 'W'Gt"'" W ""~ i!), . ~~,I!...lI.,;r. n -._ . ~Q; -"'J.4TA!-~, p;J., ~ QI, ~; , IIW..l..J..l'l.. ~~y,an, UW IJ...I\:I;)I' __ ~ IF.III

, .

2tt 'I (!:i~ 'of the State ,of Ctdi.W\I!'Wa. H¢ is: an ,a.oco.mp.US~ Aewt" Pfodjll..cer &Dd, DiJet:i01"~ ~

'1:l 'I Mtably ~ w mi.e as ADM Geller 'Qil tbe, 'popW8l' NBC tel~ sbow "FriendJ'. ~ As a lesWt

. .

28 : af b.iis hnd wotk :am use (Ill' ~ talent iii tb.t field of emt~t~ Wld l:iliJ fuvoJ,¥eme.UI: in

1

'.I

I

, i

-

1[ variom charitable or,g:tnlrations, PhdJJtiff has enjoym a ~ replltatiox. that lw beat

I _

""rI ,:",._:.",1,.-A b ,,,.......-.t...-., ..:1:::.0.- e .+ . f,olb ... '~ ..

J:j. 1 i ~J,:LIiiN!LW ''1 ~~, ~ ~~ 0 ' '~!;:;J;,~mM.

-

3 l 4-. PJamtiff'ls 'Wo~ and Wlieves that De~, AARON xO'NKEN is, am at

, 4" ~ times F~lewm hereto bas ~n ,iI'dtizen Q'f the State [ef CaJi~, and 'that Tontem Is a seJf~

-

'5 I· ~, Mscam ankt" who ~i~ml;t;d in HoUywocxt and oeIebrity ~$ing ~ ~

;. I I •

tiC . ~ .. l"'" .0><...,..1 .•. ~\J......i "oil. H' 'Il" .. ,~~..I[ ~Ii-:L. .~.... to '~ .. ~"'M.l!,.,.;jI . -.~~

!iii f!ilUl~ ~ ~~,Wl~ ~, (II, !yw~ ~n~ pnol , . I~ ~ tm U~

"1 dm;t,es,~ mel MJl)itti!ng· . thii1 the ~~~' pliv,c;n to :hi.m hu d~s and ~:ters WJ$ div.c:m::d

1rI' e, e.~~~:J ~ '" J I

,!ill' 10 , .. ;....u , .... "',;;,.~-~, .. -'" ,....,..'k .... '04. ...... n!!ll!f:"" ~':O , • .,...,. ... t.~~, to w' .'t.. ....... L .'l.. ... ,,, -.u"""';' : ...... -.::...1--'1, 'n'I...Ji-rS·i. '

'·0 . I'~; ~ ~Iri]i .Il,~.L ~ ~U! I" ~ WIAU,~~ _ _ WYl ,11I...M;i,z '" W~ UI:lIY«.Rl~.. Z:-iI.WN.Y.1lt,.,

, 'II ' _

, I

ii. ,:;...~ ........ , ... _A ".,...,;:..,...- ~ ...... T ... _"---'- pl'" _,,'Ii ...,.,.ri1itv to' Ii'L._ .c.....J .......... l ... h"' ............. "'i. ... t ~ ... ~, ... -!I_ .~""~ '7 ~W-~41.11.1 ~"",,,~, ~Jl. <.l~.- gJl'5Y.1,~"~· ,tUK: .R;I.J'='l'iliMl~'6~ UJ.a:·I~'!!d'I.!I..U~,~~

10 ..i....A n~A""---=.;I. __ ! M '.t. ... Bo·n· '!i.!'Wood ch:a.ritu! ~ .......... he ........- ... ;~,M "and 'L ... ~ t..~ ~ W over

~i~W,i[;~13i'.- Wv.,. _;,.... - I',~,.. '!IiIo;~ ".'~~'_'.'" ~~ ~ ,1.,," ['.1 .... --_

ll:l I'~ Attorney ~, h3.s aloo, :fi1ed suit"agIDn!St Tontcn ati.smg from Tonktm,"s

I -, •

1'2· ..i~""";;;..1_! -..i.l"Il'I'iliiOEo ...... ~d;I .. c1'.· .. ·...ii..: .....

. ;1i r..a~OII~,~'~ ~ I.U ,Ill "·,IIaI.~, ;1J.Li9...t.~.

14, .S, Plai.ntiff'is ignorant of dle: "true 1)Rmes :and capacities of Def~ sued herein IS"I i. is Does 1 "t.h.rOllgb so, mclusive~' ~ therdb:ro SUe! s~ Defe.1iI.1alim ~y.mcb. 'fiC1irtiQLQ. JJ8D1¢9;. ,16] ,[: ~laintiff vt.Jt .~ 'this eompiaint eo aIleg.e 1lb.e nne _ and capacitks of 5tiCb, &titkmsly ,

11 : .' n "" __ .Ai...... ' ... -~ 1-... b' "'~~.A p] ... ':O"";;.:i:E.- - ,. - - ...... .iI b"'-u"",," "

.. ' WI.m!:d beil!~ts W,~ UJ:e: same.u.a.W: 'een. ~,~. .. iiU..I.I.~ IS mJbl'm:Cd iaWi.:r. ~".·es,

_ ':' • . -- .•. . ~ . " r' "". - . ' - L - - - •

18 ~, based 'lberoon alleges 1hu each of tJJc;-'fittmously named Defendants is ~1e' in some

:19 1 ~ fur me oocmit\~! ~,and Ombsions aDeged h.~, and, that fbfuti1f's dJlmag~'

I' ,-

• . I! :' 1:' '. 1 ,I, " ,. '!", _ '.

~ ~e PI'oxi.matety emlSed'by tIIey ~ndn'Clt', For' CO.ll~~, each, ~ ·ro, a Datm~,

- -

21 ',~ herem sb.aili refer: to the Doe, De:~ '1Ol1 eacb, of 1hew.

,22 .

6,

'DiI ... :,~...:,.a" ~ :",~....;;j ~_.:II 1,._1: ' .....:.. .... ':s.. ..... _....1' ... k..~. ....11 .. """' ..... at ~1t, ..... ~.........::_1:

,!;",I:4,W..U;.U lS WJiUil.~ ,;;:i.nu ~evcs mru 11i~ W'I;;iI,.:;v:!I]; au.e,·e:g ~L . "~,~J.~

, 2J t:rmes DefendaDts, and cacb ·of dJem were die ZI,lbl'!FIts ,~~,,,,:,,~ P .. ~ inint veniuR:rn. ee-

. - , , ,~ . , .. -,. ""b~~" ~ . 'IIV:J~ .. " .• ' "'[~ "' '

-

, ~, ! ,cnfttmljr.afOll:: .r.n~, 'li'lri ~lo[:.:and Pnm~nua:s ,o,r the i!:'ieQlairrlni ~ and ,each of - '

_ '~:r. 1 Y·In'~'~i;;t. r-· 1w:L~1f - .~...uJ: , ";" . - .' " - - - .. . p. - -". -- •

-'II!!' .d.~ ..,..A, ........ -'1., ... 1i1 <io-l ..... ~ h" ...... ~ ... - ..... ,. ~ . • .. 1.: ........ _. ,- . n . ..A··, "f

., I ~.! ~ sre, ii1II.iu. m: ~ ~ , ' e:rem lYI;;.,gY\l'~ ,:-r.e::re. ,actmg W1.ULW u,u; ~'~ scope ,;(lI'"

26 ';1. ~£ q'ene,y ~ ~Io~~ ~ship~ OOD$piracy, own(;1'~ and!JQr jo,int ventJiJre. Plahriift'is i; :I.~, mtmmtd and belfuves and ~ tIwuon aU:eges 'that b acu ,eM ·conduct alleged

28' .1 "b::reI!D. 'were mown'tn .. aDd mlIhorlttd and/!(If nrlfim ~, '[h~, offie;ert. d:ittd<ri-s. :and :ma!}3'lrin~,

I , .. <.r)." / ~

-

, '~lWi-l.~roQiJi.(QI,'II'p!i

I i,

i,

!

,.

i I'

t: . ;~, oftbe ~!: Bmd·eaca f)f~ ~·is mronried and bliliC!:~ and based

e I: - .

2 j' ~ .aD.~ t.b:It the offieerS~ diredars ,andJ'Qi ~ ~gems of DeieD6anbi:, aad each of

3' , ldiem., .~~ dJ~ andJOJ :ratified the wrmagfW acts: ,of Dct~da.llts and am

! .

I ;' ~

... b . -. t..;1 . - , .. :N

4if~'liallile: to f.Iam~.

. :r, . '.,

S.. ~ , nera..!iYts~ False StattimtDl$

-

AS 3lIleged htteln, :P1a.imi1l a1l~ 'W iDt~ .~. bdiefUiat Toolcn. muy :1

.,

"'. imade. .... '1;.. 't:;:':~ __ ,,: .. to 'tru:id partie8 :iochri;.-; .... W'Wl'ODt 'r-~-·:L- 'a..:::r.-;e W· .. rn.......· ~'""-wil!i& and

, .. ~'!ii'W_. '. .", ... ~ .. '~,II,!I!IJ.Ii,IHllYI.iI.1l.III'J~.. ~t 1/JJ6Y-- .........

:8 ItbltMdiiil. t1w: me ~ would be puhtis.hed ,am dJiserolMtoo in. rbe ~~ and lll1t

, .

ri , ~ODbn"s .statementS,." ·whiclt. WtIe fmae" fabd~ and ~!' offeasivcty d'Cpicted,

~ 1 i

10 IlI!!Il.tiff .... ·,'I.. .=: • ~'L .. d--:_._~ ~ ... 1._::......iL'lo • 'm_!-&:-"' ,A...-~_

'. '.~ ~~"as. JIG"O~1 ,pI0'.IlL_ to Wt;; ~WA;]J.L ·0.11' ~:iUW.L'e (!I!E'~. r.liUWJ .. U,' Jiwil UiEJ..

1 " - .. ..

,11 " ·Iall~.g.m on w:onnati.01i. and 'l;KiHef that .among; other. false and. dl~ sm~ by To:okie:a . i

. . .

i • .

12' '~t. PWmlff!. "lbuell. clalmed tlJat be had an invoice liImt. $.how,~. nat be had. ~~ md

.. -

13'1 given to Ptamtifftwo R.otex W3.tCb..es w:onb 'oveX;$l6ttDOO ~.ed. 'from, XW'l{an~. :ttd .. ·in·

II _" ." ~. - ..

14 '.i:i;~. 1 H:'Iii (.ioI'V'n,J .~_ ..... !It'l. . 1o.;~'i:.. 'T ........ h. t..~,~ ... 'b;, ...... ,'IL .. ~~"j . d .. d......:l I-..-u- 1':J;j"":_,,:l¥'

~.aXrliler "/ .. · .. u.S· ,A.I~'~.i:W}:h w~, uJ.ii...en '~:1 ~ 'were' cmat!:~ '1q If 1!IIWlUJ!J. as a '. .

1:5 "gUldpro quo ftlr'1;weariD,s at ~ ,charity event. TIlt: S~;tte: slRJJderoils on lhe.ir..~

I -. t.

','

l" ,'s1n.ce i:h~ ~i~JD$ly. and !.roklt:Mly portray PlaiJUiff ;at· a. ·ooJd~ ~rm:ntst .st:e:a.Iing

I,' fi'om Charities fur his ·own personal gam., 'whe:g~ in fact,. Topb:n ~. 1bt Plairitiff never

:i

I ..

1· ,i). " 1.--n\l'~~'Mi ... :.,.... ~,::.li lit .. ~;;rve 6'i'IJ'V .... ...."""" .. ~: .... ,, .. +-~ ........ ~r ~'I.~. M~ .... u-"'-'JI. '!!i~~'~. o ;~·I'I:lL~~ ~ RN,.,U:'W ,,~ ... QUI' ~~VM JJU lL.IW!L ~~"1' '¥-'If~, ~~/~.

• 1'1

'1'; ,~t. ,'P'lain;tiff is info:rmt!d :a.ud bLdi~·es. ;md nrer~ al),e.ge; that: ·r~ mlli.cio·PSly,

ZO I ~I w.i~t imtific:ni.OD<> and wirJlcrot prlweae" made·dlc ~~ ~ the ~ of

..... '111 ' o!rorn'b.l':",""'::"'- .,. ~'" rn·' ... "i;;:....,,;-: .... .,..; .lo.-.. li'Hn ... ; dr - • ....,..;.- .... o5r!Jt'ft- .... _·...-.::0 &...

..;liIJl }'...y.L.f.l,,;4Ii1,VJA ~ -i-..'""(j 'IJI~I. t'",;,.!IJ~u.uJWl>~. 'U,Ki: . .....-.~.:...·rifi~· SEory;. m UJi:w.;iw ~.~Q ~ J.W a I

.2.2 1 ~te.ll4;';' book" -tOr Whim Tnnken ~ reemtly .~ be:baS ~. a 1nilli(!B doftaq W. pre-

" • I . •

I

2]J ~es.

'D.~ .m~ .. ~~~ ...... .:1 "':",,'Iev~ :.o;·....!i·,;.lbat- ~",' -. a.[] ... ~ ........ T ........ ~ ..... .....,iI .... -L.",:" Ii.' Jlli .l!!llU.m.aw;u_~ I,J!G.II, . 'Ira' i;;I;,LII;;I. QI!oIl... 1I!1«i:Ii18. _, "b~ w;.iII. ~ Jl..~ ~

""1 llo. .... _"'"""'"-'il:_- ._J. __ .. "". ~-...1 ~F .. '.

..... I J.I.UiIJ~. ~p, ~~.~ E!!Il.U ~1S~0l!l.

I • • ~

. 4

- ..

1.1 II

-

Z ftiabltiff'in tms lII3ttUe manner ~ing ~t die deplcti.oo.·was faJ!.se, . or wJ1t!loot uy teaS~lc

. .

31 inFnn.,·d.,.; fa·' -. ~t ..... ~ ... it' to ........ :Hoo"'" ~1i"'e. ''1r'~'''''''''''' 'fro.'"'~ :'- ,~~ ·iF'I'I;'tt' ... ". ... ~ 4i. ........ ""'"'\"";\;" ...... ~

.- 1.!I5'"'''-'''"''-"'''>:r ~'.lI.II.I5 . IIA> '~--j ~UO. ,!!.v.Im.CU.liJAl.iJ1I' !III '~~ .. ~ .... ~ ILI,'CW~ """..,-

[ I ~ .

4 ,:L,~~i#, ~- ... ,-!", .QH_- j;", ~, ~ ........ _ 'fn- .• ~_. r..,.___ D't .... ~ .l:.--.:L~ ................. -,

, I ,f~. <WIIJ. .1IJi:;, "';"""~t;;lU, i!ijlg.S~l!SS Paa.II..U!;,oJ,. m~ ~~e~. HlIIWW:r. lIl,aURa' o..v...;§..o 'on

" .

. -

5. ~ and llelief that T<mten ~. that rbeFe 'was: 'no i,tnvo:ire that ~ ,oono~ his

I I •

· -, I 5talem~ts aOO;'m.at Tanken sn:h.;~I.t>Mhr teStified lWd~ OOih'tllat 00 such :iirv'olce •

. 1j' .. ," m·· •. , ': ~~, "._. _.- -. .."' '.

, .

7_- w.rro:~d'i:1il!l' +~ demnakfl:"ji' ~atemeutS exis:ts

_ ... ' .~,iIi&~ ~. . .... ,,~ -.Ji~~. .'._ II

8; ': n,. 11ms'1 P1rd.nUff' a.lleges on infotmario.n and ~U~ that Tonken. ~: tbBit. ~

II -

, I 'I ~. welt fuk. P~:hn1he.r mte:g.~ QIl information:md betid 1hBt iIO~

I'

· 110 '!f~'~s bGWledgethat the: Smt~, wm f&.lse, he ~ted them to thhd parties .lkt:io'wfog

;, ,.'

- ,.;

U I ' ~ Intend.mg dlat t:h~ 'Would be fu.ftb« pnblislKd aud. d..wemm-t~~ Plainrciiff aU~8es on,

I. .

it", , i ~ ... t'n ".:..."" .... _ .... ' ...... 1;·....l" .. 1;,... ,.~ .1..,~ -eo.. ......... ~....- .. T'-1'--:'- ,....dl '".'1:.. .1';;

.:I..M' i ~ ... fII]iI.":U.UJl ,UN ~:";'J 'wat: J.U :manug ~ \Jl~~ uU.r.,;;,u .. acto;::v W'lw mauc.e.

jf I

l ' .,

·13 :

· '14

! i .'

15' I

, I",

! :

:1.6

(For' Slander apiRSi Def'fllulBDt'Tomkeo)

il2.··. :'C'I""w. ... f(· ~'~'!i ' .......... 'II-:-iIl',- ,,,..A ' rn~'"""~·.......,.. ~ ~ .. ~~"'- ... '~l 't., ~ .. i ..

.II. s: ~ _ iI!~y--..,..,... J.~~,r..q. ~ 1/rI<!II¥..,~I~ Vl ~Q,~t~;11I'..P¥ ~:'IU,~~-~ .II, ~

'17 ~l~. IDcluslve,. mtbis COmplaimt. as if'fhU'y set fottb bere.w.

, '! •

. I

18 " 1 ]3. Platnriff:is: infOrmed ~n(i"1:I¢.1lie'Ves and thereou allcg'l3 mat TQnbn mally. miIC..,· to' :'

2{j lu",oice te, p:~e.tb:at PJla.intiff receiVed Rom. W1I.~ in el:~e' for appea:rlug ata_

, . I' .

31 : I elj~t flaibtiff MLeges: on info.tmaIioo and 'oo1id·Ib~. Trubn lMeDliowillY ~ Pkdmtiff

, 'I" - - . -, . , . 3 ., .- .' '. ~ • • ' '. . , '_. ~ -, (. • - L _ ••

22 :,': ~ ~ OOtrnc mlmncr;~wmg tbar ~ depiro~ was .,' ,or wirtbonl any ~&.JJaNe.. gtonWIB.

-I·

'23 fur ~ it to be, nue, Pl.adntiff ;alleW;;S on iDfonoatWn and belief ~t. Tonbn knew' tb: ': I

24, SlatciDcnts were ~ ~f among mhcr ~t ToJ1ken knew that. be had ~ Ute I"

• • • 'I

'.".'';:-,'' ~ ..... i~ ..... _ ... es : :I'...., .. r. \;,'~""'~'i-ii'· """'-Ii 'i.~ .... , ... ~r.,a;a-,""' .. :ij ":;~iness p' ... :~ ...... 'C ............. C- ..... ~ ... "'.iob.D-_ ""'~ ~Jo. ...... '~ 1.!"' . .;i1

~'l ~VJ""'" -lA"~:"", J!·V~ ~. AIJU. .11£1. .~yO'C:U; U~_ .., , Q;;l ~ I! ,~~a.:w:~:r. .ili.1AI! .IiI.&A\ ,aP.;i ~

- - ~ .

26: dw'i:!:ed the: w*bes to ~e's credit cam .

. t. ':. ~ ~ - .. .... _' .. .. . . . " •..

I ,

· 27' : 14. PlIaitttiffftmhe:r aJleg~, '0.0. infunmlioo aDibelidtbat th~ s~ by'ToDk'eD

28 i were ~"'b]to to a defu.tnattory meaning 00 '~ir face im 'Lliat they 'bav,e: a d!rect tendency to

1 .

, ,

1 !

. -

·t ".' PI~·: ... ~~F .. ,.:::..1I.. ~ .. <¥:'r< '1..,_ .." ... ~ ... ~ ~~iI ... 4I:",,"' .............. :'tI ~.. . .""., ... t.. ......... ~ .... _.:11 'L~ ..... :;;...;.,'"

:.. 'Ii'i1~m-e - ~, Y!" ullJ JI,. . .. 'w ,Wls ii'l!I'!r~ iIWIJ. nt([l,~W·;:uU.IIi.1J. . , . I .. on w.i.cu,~ ~ lJ!III;lI~ -

. ;N;IoJ." '- ' . . - .. -. I.. ~. - . ¥I - '. -' . ,. -. '. 'I' ~

,., , ':''";'.JI .&\..·~t -f"'_~' -e .~.,. ....... W,(-JIoJ. .."....., .... '1 ,"!", ... 1:~.. ~~ ..... , 11-1,. ... '1,-... ........ 11 .. 4, ...... , ... &.- ,t'h~ ~ ~'~~-, i ,', ."'~ a' ~ ,ilJ!IU UIIII UJlf;i:J 'How.'. ~, , . IW ~'!MQ. ~2' WJUIi, u~ ~'!1I',I;~~ ~~]' n ........... ~,11 "ill' ...,.,~

3 ~~es5, dis~ tot tbe truth.

4.1 • l:t Plaintiff further au~ m, ,mtb~oo and btelie.{ ~ ~ St.aJt~ by Tonkea

, .

I:. ~ .,.,'l"H"itv..{'I""i:J'_AI ~.-..:I ~1 ........ '1._ 'il....-.~w ...... ~ .... ,:i,.'i ......... ""':~ ..r.: ... .-u·.......,4' .............. c= __ .. ,""-'0 •• 'i.._

~ ,~!\r,~~ u.u.r.·..-~~w.i! ~ WiI,1j. J;;IA:r ~ • ·~tL J.~~J .~~:~~~ ~ UI.W ~, tLUW

'1 ~ ~ dunage to his ~ in the lem~ mdustxy.

" .

S;. 16. As a pro~te ~e:su:h: of the a~.~cribed cond~ by Tonken" Pl~ bas

:9, $Uffered g:e~al ,and speeial 4ama~ m m am,@1lnt not pre81mtly :k;no.1VJ1 to Plaintiff but

II . . '

10 iIe)k.~ to. ~ not kss than T-wo·:Mil.1li.oD 0011118 ($2,000,.000) :Iocludi;u.g ~~~ to Pla.imitPg

, I!

1.1' ~Oii &nd standin~ 10 the c(nnummf'!j' aB a 'result o,f tbl!\ manne! or oon:text m which TcdteD

I'; , I:J.'~

• I 1 • -

12 fIas eJtpJo.lted hi8 D'~~ :rhru:ogapb and. Likeness, 10, additWo to shame,. mO~j b1m

13: feclmgs embar;ras·smmt lrumi1iMiOOl damage to 'the v:atu.e of 'Parun~5 'name ~ and

II . '. -' !II ..' - J' • ' -:WI' - • - '" - - I!' .. .

14 I goodw.ill. A!th'ffi.lJgh 11he, .:l\lll nat.u::re:, ~, aDd ~ of 1h~e' ldama.ges are at1'Rntly

. 15'·, ' .• '-,j-.......,...... ~ ... : .. r'~l~'" ~":~J '1:. ............ ~_ ...... A ........... ' ,,"',," 'I. .... c- .... ......,. .....:~1 ..... ~ __ ........ t.. J-~~--.:OD ::.;:,' _ .• ..,'1;.,

. ' L ~WI1!II II.l.mIl~, IliLlIJi., W B ~~,t;:Y iIi!P.P. V~a. ~'v.~'\;- U iW. II-V !1..Il.I.:IW,II. .:I,~ I.!IJl.I.UIDJ.tU.I ' .I.IL ~~

1 •

"1' ':~; is deemell ~aTY'by the Court.

11

17"

18 ' kts of Tom:en 'was, done ID'telilitiomllY or· with a ,~.,dis:regm1l of Pla.iJIl:lfrs, rights, ,~

. - -

. . .

ll,n : •. ;.. •. , • fit~=-.:,a:: _. &.... . . .." ~,-.~

;,.' '(I,I'.ulUi aIt lJ)1eIl1 too vex : )Jll'Lll:1"e or ~ r ~~I!U. sucn as Wi !C:OtlStdllkl: iF1lID'li~1iI', . rraua ,m'

" ' . ~' .. -I- -:,I ~~J-. -- ' ... ' . .. . . --:- ~r'~~~- -

I .

. 20 I:,~ ttn1S.~ Plw.ntiff to e.xe:roplary _and, pnnidw daDa,get, in aA a:m0\l!Jlt ~ to

, .

-24 I \VHEREJrORE Plainfff Da\'id SthlWimmer il'IH~ :for'J-'ud~"""~ -:',O'airusJ 'Dcf'Clldiinit A:uon

- , - ., ,~. _ 1. -. - . 'F'"'""i/-...' ~ ~. .-. .., . . '.

. .

,

. .

!

L

. .

for general damages. q,afus;t .To~ in an mIKlllDt of not [c:55 thaD Two, MiUion

". . .

- 27 I" DQlJ.lars ('~ fVrIrIl.IOOO)'- '0," "'rJ"- r;.IIf ... -~; ... w:;,tb,· nn"Ifli·· ... t- triaJ ·n"".1,..u ~th·· .i'>f!..,..~ r1-..~ at '''~~

.~~"-"I;.!V~. .. .. .... , .po ~I!Ji.N!,\;..,. ... . .r.,~,~...;z.!,. __ ~ """~!,Ij/ _ ,iIW"VJ;. ll.U,W-"'.... ~

I. r

2S 1. rate;, - .

, "

;,

•

,I

,I

I,'

l'r. !.

,

,I

2 It'I"II,._,:~1:. M _t,~ .... ii'T-!n'ir,;f!.1· ... n~I'J'I ................ · ......... to A m..:L ......... -~-·~ft .'1.- ~---_

r-~ v.L I:tV1;. ~'-"'~'" 'v;li J.~ ~ . ~~'". G!.:L :~I.v.li~.N.II UMP.. Ju~w.·I!;i.

3, lOf~ ~ ~ be Subj~ to proof' at the ~ fi),f ttiaJ;

I~ .,

" 3,u 'FN' ~m of mit ~~ .

, ,

'S I,

6,! "1 't,:

. 8: ~1,,~Am': '~ /!J:.. 2004

19 '

'lOl'.,:

:1

'][1

13 ,.'14"; ':

.. I

15 i 16 I.,

II

11 1,1'1,

.. 1" I,

:to I ,;

211:

I

"22 .; . I!

%3,

. ~ I

:24

25, ..

-'i;i! I ."-0

'I· 27 '

28;'

1

• !

I'

i

, [