Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
P. 1
The Scandal of Enlightenment and Birth of Disciplines: Is International Law a Science?

The Scandal of Enlightenment and Birth of Disciplines: Is International Law a Science?

Ratings: (0)|Views: 300|Likes:
Published by Prabhakar Singh
12:1 International Community law Review,(2010) Martinus Nijhoff Press and to be re-printed Sanford Silverburg, (Ed.) International Law: Current Issues and Future Problems (Boulder/Colorado: Westview Press, 2010).
12:1 International Community law Review,(2010) Martinus Nijhoff Press and to be re-printed Sanford Silverburg, (Ed.) International Law: Current Issues and Future Problems (Boulder/Colorado: Westview Press, 2010).

More info:

Categories:Types, Research, Law
Published by: Prabhakar Singh on Nov 02, 2009
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/02/2013

pdf

 
«
 Eihkheckbe` Orkcc HW# C`kd`h
# ?:6: .6? K
HT@_HFTKIHFC
A
ILLPHKT[ 
C
 F]
_
@WK@]
.Tn` H`tn`rcfhdq2 LfrtkhpqHkbnigg Zr`qq# ?:6:# girtnailkhm+ fhd ti o` r`zrkht`d kh K
HT@_HFTKIHFC
C
 F]
2
 
A
IHT@LZI_F_[ 
K
QQP@Q FHD
G
PTP_@
Z
_IOC@LQ
.Q( Qkcw`roprm `d(# Oipcd`r)Aicirfdi2 ]`qtwk`} Zr`qq# ?:6: girtnailkhm+(
T
N@
Q
AFHDFC IG
@
HCKMNT@HL@HT FHD
T
N@
O
K_TN IG
D
KQAKZCKH@Q
2
 
K
Q
K
HT@_HFTKIHFC
C
 F] 
 F 
 
Q
AK@HA@
9
Zrfonfefr Qkhmn"
 Fqqkqtfht Zrig`qqir# Bkhdfc Mciofc Cf} Qaniic# Khdkf
 
 Foqtrfat
Tidf{‛q lfkhqtr`fl kht`rhftkihfc cf} qanicfrqnkz .LKCQ+ kq aiha`rh`d zrklfrkc{}ktn tn` kqqp` ig ktq qak`htkgkakt{( Tnkq orkhmq pq ti tn` cfrm`r `zkqt`licimkafc vp`qtkihqig ckh`fr lid`rhkt{# hfrrftkw`q ig akrapcfr zrimr`qq# ric` ig aicihkqftkih fhd r`b`atkihig zr`,qak`ha`( Kht`rhftkihfc Cf} kq hit f q`cg,aihtfkh`d r`mkl` fq kt drf}q khqkmntq gril fcc tn` itn`r dkqakzckh`q tnft }`r` oirh fgt`r tn` @hckmnt`hl`ht( Tnkq frtkac`lfe`q f zq{anicimkafc khw`qtkmftkih pqkhm Hfhd{‛q zq{ani,zicktkafc grfl`}ire phd`rTnkrd ]ircd‛q Fzzrifan`q ti Kht`rhftkihfc Cf} .T]FKC+( Kt fcqi q``q# fq f afq` kh zikht# tn` khwfqkih ig lid`rhkt{ wkf cft` afzktfckql khti trkofc ckg` fq lid`rhkt{‛qfzicim{ gir tn` –tnkrd“ dkq`hanfhtl`ht( Kht`rhftkihfc Cf}‛q `wicptkihfr{ qak`htkgkakt{#tn`r`gir`# nfq o``h `~flkh`d tnripmn zq{anicim{ fhd l{tnicim{ kh tn` ziqt,aicihkfc}ircd(
E`{ ]irdq2
@hckmnt`hl`ht# T]FKC# Hfhd{# fhtk,lid`rhkql# `litkw` fhd zq{anicimkafc fqz`at ig ZKC# nkqtir{ w`rqpq L{tnicim{# aicihkqftkih# q{qt`lq ig ehi}c`dm`(
 
K(
 
Khtridpatkih
Kh r`a`ht {`frq kt nfq o`ail` gfqnkihfoc` –kh tn` Ziqtlid`rhkqt aflz# tidkqdfkh tn` @hckmnt`hl`ht fq okfq`d# gfakc`# q`cg,d`cpd`d# iw`r,iztklkqtka#@pria`htrka# klz`rkfckqtka# fhd pctklft`c{ d`qtrpatkw`“(
6
Opt }` nfw` hi}liw`d gril f ziqtlid`rhkqt ti fh fhtk,lid`rhkqt dkqaiprq`q# fhd qil` hih,]`qt`rh qanicfrq cke` Fqnkq Hfhd{ nfw` kd`htkgk`d tn` @hckmnt`hl`ht fq ftiic pq`d ti ioqapr` hih,@priz`fh nkqtir{ }nkc` n`czkhm tn` c`mktklkqftkih ig aicihkqftkih(
?
  [`t Bórm`h Nfo`rlfq di`q hit tnkhe tnft ziqtlid`rhkql fhdfhtk,lid`rhkql fr` dkgg`r`ht( Hih`tn`c`qq# Cftkh –lid`rhpq“ gril }nkand`rkw`q tn` t`rl lid`rhkt{ }fq gkrqt qzie`h ig kh tn` gkgtn a`htpr{ tidkqtkhmpkqn tn` lid`rh Anrkqtkfh }ircd gril ktq _ilfh fhd zfmfh zfqt2 tnpqfqqiakftkhm lid`rhkt{ ihc{ ti
_`hfkqqfha`
kq tii hfrri}(
1
 Khqtfhtc{ }` q``
"I( Z( Bkhdfc Mciofc Phkw`rqkt{# Qihkzft# Hftkihfc Afzktfc _`mkih# Khdkf( Fh `frc{ w`rqkih ig tnkq zk`a` }fqqpolktt`d fq tn` tn`qkq gir l{ CC(L( kh Kht`rhftkihfc @aihilka Cf} ' Zicka{ .K@CZI ?::>,:;+ ft tn`Phkw`rqkt{ ig Ofra`cihf# Qzfkh( K fl tnfhegpc ti Qt`zn`h ]`ftn`rkcc fhd fh fhih{lipq r`wk`}`r grilKAC_ gir aill`htq( Ni}`w`r izkhkih `~zr`qq`d fr` fcc lkh`( .zrfonfefrqkhmn(fdwJmlfkc(ail
 
6
Bihftnfh Kqrf`c#
@hckmnt`hl`ht Aiht`qt`d2 Znkciqizn{# Lid`rhkt{# fhd tn` @lfhakzftkih ig Lfh 67=:‑ 6=0? 
.H`} [ire2 IPZ# ?::7+(
?
 
Q``
# Fqnkq Hfhd{#
Tn` Khtklft` @h`l{2 Ciqq fhd _`aiw`r{ ig Q`cg phd`r Aicihkfckql# kh
F( Hfhd{ .`d(+@~kc`d ft Nil` .?
hd
klzr`qqkih# H`} D`cnk2 IPZ# ?::?+ zz( w,6?6(
1
Bórm`h Nfo`rlfq#
Lid`rhkt{ w`rqpq Ziqtlid`rhkt{
# ?? H`} M`rlfh Arktkvp` .6;>6+ zz( 1,64# ft 1(
 
Lfrtkhpq Hkbnigg Zr`qq Kq Kht`rhftkihfc cf} f Qak`ha`9 ?
tnft tn` nkqtir{ ig lid`rhkt{ kq aiht`~tpfckq`d kh @priz`fh `~z`rk`ha`#}nft`w`r tn` hfl`# nkqtir{ ir f d`qzkafoc` zfqt( Ih` qnipcd tn`h `~z`at fdkgg`r`ht hfrrftkih gril tn` z`rqz`atkw` ig tn` aicihkq`d5 Khdkf# gir `~flzc`#o`afpq` tn` `~z`rk`ha` ig tn` –lid`rhpq“ kh Khdkf fhd @priz` }`r` hit qfl`ir `w`h kd`htkafc(Gfat r`lfkhq tnft tn` @hckmnt`hl`ht wkrtp`q cke` q`apcfrkqftkih# tic`rftkih#`vpfckt{# d`liarfa{# khdkwkdpfc gr``dil# fhd cko`rt{ ig `~zr`qqkih tnftanfcc`hm`d lihfran{# frkqtiarfa{# fptnirkt{# fhd trfdktkih kh @priz` aipcdhit zr`w`ht tn` aicihkqftkih c`d `~zciktftkih ‑ qiakfc# zicktkafc# zq{anicimkafc#fhd lft`rkfc—ig tn` hih,@priz`fh ir tn` –itn`r“ }ircd( Tn` phkw`rqfckt{ ig tn` @hckmnt`hl`ht tnpq kq f gfra` fhd kg ft fcc qil` ig ktq kd`fq trkaec`d di}hkhti aicihk`q# kt }fq hit kht`htkihfc( Aicihkfc cfhd }fq gkrqt qipmnt ti o`akwkckq`d o{ Anrkqtkfh lkqqkihfrk`q fhd cft`r tn` afzktfckqtq# dkq`hanfht`dgril r`ckmkih# pq`d aicihkfc r`aiprq`q gir tn` `aihilka o`h`gktq ig lfre`t# fhdop{khm zicktkafc aprr`ha{ ofae nil`( Aicihkqftkih# fq f w`nkac`# }fq pq`d tiqzr`fd tn` tn`l`q ig @priz`fh r`wicptkih# tn` okrtn ig qak`ha` fhd tn`oprd`h ig klzfrtkhm akwkckqftkih ti tn` –itn`rq“( Tn` h`~pq o`t}``h tn`loitn2 tn` lkqqkihfrk`q fhd tn` afzktfckqtq o`afl` iowkipq }n`h kht`rhftkihfccf} o`mfh tfekhm qnfz` kh t}i Nfmp` z`fa` aihg`r`ha`q( Tn` }ireq ig r`ckmkipq qanicfrq# }ni }`r` liqtc{ hftprfc kh fzzrifan# }`r` akt`d fq tn`qipra`q kh f okd ti phkw`rqfckq` kht`rhftkihfc cf}( M`htkck# Qpær`# Mritkpq#fhd lfh{ qpan hfl`q }`r` tn`h akt`d ti d`g`hd aicihkqftkih }ktn tn`fqqpl`d oprd`h ig akwkckqkhm z`izc`(
4
 Kht`rhftkihfc cf} }fq ihc{ f bpqtkgkaftkih gir favpkqktkih fhd lfhfm`l`ht ig tn` aicihk`q tnft hi} zr`q`ht`d kll`hq` lfre`t zit`htkfc( F zfrtkapcfrapctpr`‛q nkqtir{ kq ciafc fhd ihc{ dprkhm tn` z`rkid ig aicihkqftkih# nkqtir{}fq zprqp`d fq f zrib`at ig phkw`rqfc `~z`rk`ha`( Tn` vp`qtkih tnpq friq`2 kqtn` hih,]`qt kh m`h`rfc fhd Khdkf kh zfrtkapcfr# gir `~flzc`# phakwkckq`d9 F tnkrd }ircd fzzrifan ti qtpd{ tn` q{qt`lq ig ehi}c`dm`# ig }nkankht`rhftkihfc cf} kq f zfrt# kq `qq`htkfc ti dkqaiw`rkhm aiht`qt`d nkqtirk`q ig tn` hih,@priz`fh ]ircd( T]FKC zptq aicihkqftkih kh tn` a`htr` ig kht`rhftkihfc cf} girlftkih(
0
 A`rtfkhc{# tn` hih,@priz`fh }ircd ziq`dhpl`ripq zrioc`lq ti tn` kht`rhftkihfc q{qt`l( Ni} }`r` tn`q` z`izc`q tio` miw`rh`d9
7
 Ih }nft c`mfc ofqkq aipcd tn`kr cfhdq o` iaapzk`d9 Opt# khkht`rhftkihfc cf}# tn`q` }`r` wk`}`d fq q`aihdfr{ zrioc`lq tnft dkd hitklzkhm` ih tn` mr`ft tn`ir`tkafc kqqp`q aihgrihtkhm tn` dkqakzckh`(
=
Fqqkmhkhmf q`aihdfr{ ftt`htkih ti aiha`rhq ig tn` –itn`r“ }ircd kh kht`rhftkihfc cf}tn`irkqftkih ail`q gril tn` tn`h dilkhfht wk`} ig @priz` foipt tn`aicihkq`d fq n`ftn`h# d`qzkafoc`# phq{qt`lftka# phapctpr`d# phqak`htkgka fhd}nft hit9
4
Q`` f dkqapqqkih fhd ailzfrkqih ig aihtrkoptkihq ig tn`q` tnr`` qanicfrq kh# Tn`idir L`rih#
Aillih_kmntq ig Lfhekhd kh M`htkck# Mritkpq fhd Qpfr`
# >0 Fl`rkafh Biprhfc ig Kht`rhftkihfc Cf} .6;;6+zz(66:,66?(
0
Fhtih{ Fhmnk` #
Tn` @wicptkih ig Kht`rhftkihfc Cf}2 Aicihkfc fhd Ziqtaicihkfc _`fcktk`q
# ?=20 Tnkrd]ircd Vpfrt`rc{ .?::7+ zz( =1; ‑ =01# ft =4:(
7
 
Kd
(# ft =46(
=
 
Kd
(
 
Zrfonfefr Qkhmn)Kht`rhftkihfc Aillphkt{ Cf} _`wk`} 6? .?:6:+
1
 L{ zrklfr{ fkl n`r` kq ti `~ziq` tn` qak`htkgka d`t`rlkhkql fhd nkqtirkafcr`dpatkihkql fkckhm kht`rhftkihfc cf}‛q mciofc fdlkhkqtrftkw` zrib`at
wkf
fdkqapqqkih ih tn` nkqtir{ fhd tn` hih,]`qt`rh q{qt`lq ig ehi}c`dm`( Tn`dkqakzckh`q ig qiakicim{ fhd znkciqizn{ nfw` qz`ht flzc` tkl` d`cko`rftkhm ihlid`rhkt{( Kht`rhftkihfc cf}# ni}`w`r# nfq q`cdil `hmfm`d }ktn f dkqaiprq`ih lid`rhkt{( Tidf{# ih tn` ih` nfhd# kht`rhftkihfc cf} kq tn` cfhmpfm` ig khqtrpatkhm ipr aicc`atkw` mciofc apctprfc# gkhfhakfc# zicktkafc fhd qiakfc`~kqt`ha`( Ih tn` itn`r# qak`ha`# lid`rhkt{# q`apcfrkql# zrimr`qq# t`anhicim{#cko`rfckql# phkw`rqfckql# fhd nplfhktfrkfhkql fr` fcc tniq` }irdq tnftaicc`atkw`c{ d`gkh` tidf{‛q akwkckqftkih fhd kht`rhftkihfc c`mfc tnipmnt(
>
 Opttnkq lid`rh kd`f ig f h`} }ircd }fq gkrqt trk`d ipt kh aicihk`q o{ –}`cc,l`fhkhm# nfrd,}irekhm# lkddc` acfqq lkqqkihfrk`q# cko`rfcq# lid`rhkqtq# fhdo`ck`w`rq kh qak`ha`# `vpfckt{ fhd zrimr`qq“(
;
 ]n{ f aiha`zt tnft }fq oirh kh@priz` fq f r`qpct ig tn` Tr`ft{ ig ]`qtznfckf ig 674> `w`htpfcc{ o`afl` tn`qic` tiic ti d`gkh` tn` frankt`atpr` ig kht`rhftkihfc cf} fhd tn` miw`rhfha` ig hih,]`qt`rh qtft`q fhd ktq z`izc`9 Hi }ihd`r# tn` aiht`lzirfr{Kht`rhftkihfc cf} kq zr`iaapzk`d }ktn tn` vp`qtkih ig ktq qak`htkgkakt{ tnft }fqf zridpat ig @priz`‛q ziqt,@hckmnt`hl`ht lid`rhkt{ dkqaiprq`q(
6:
 @zkqt`licimkafcc{# tn` okrtn ig dkqakzckh`q cke` nkqtir{# `aihilkaq# qiakicim{#fhd `hwkrihl`htfc qak`ha` `ta( gril tn` w`r{ o`mkhhkhm q`t tn` t`rlq ig tn`dkqaiprq` ti tn` fdwfhtfm` ig LKCQ( Mciofckqftkih kq ihc{ qpzzirtkhm tn`krh`} afpq` fq tn` lfrmkhfc q{qt`lq ig ehi}c`dm` fr` wfhkqnkhm `w`h gfqt`r(Kht`rhftkihfc cf}# tidf{# nfq ti }ire ipt f ofcfha` o`t}``h ktq afzktfckqtq{lzftn{ fhd `gg`atq ,, qiakfc# apctprfc fhd zicktkafc ,, ig ktq khw`qtl`htq khtn` phd`rd`w`ciz`d aiphtrk`q fhd z`izc`q( F r`dpatkihkqt fzzckaftkih ig Kht`rhftkihfc @aihilka Cf}# gir `~flzc`# igt`h kmhir`q tn` apctprfc aiqt ig ktq ailzckfha` o{ tn` lfrmkhfckq`d qpofct`rh# trkofc fhd khgfht q`atirq }nkc`c`mktklkqkhm f phkw`rqfc fzzckaftkih ig tn` zrkhakzc`q ig `aihilkaq(Kht`rhftkihfc cf} kq hi} tn` h`} cfhmpfm` ig aiht`qtftkih o`t}``h qak`ha`#hih,qak`ha`# d`w`cizl`ht fhd ofae}frdh`qq# kg q``h gril T]FKCz`rqz`atkw`(
66
 Tn`r`gir`# q`atkihq KK# KKK# KW# W# WK fhd WKK ig tnkq frtkac` dkqapqq tn`nkqtirkafc# fhtnrizicimkafc fhd zq{anicimkafc fqz`at ig lid`rhkt{ fhd tn`fzzckaftkih ig qak`ha` kh aicihkfc lfhfm`l`ht( Ktq dkqtkhatkw` fqz`at kq tn` pq`ig Hfhd{‛q zq{anicimkafc fhfc{qkq }ktn f tkhm` ig Gipafpct( Tn` kht`rzr`tftkw`diatrkh`q ig kht`rhftkihfc khw`qtl`ht cf}# gir `~flzc`# nfw` }kth`qq`d fHirtn,Qiptn gfpct fhd khw`qtl`ht kh tn` Qiptn qtkcc `wie`q qa`ztkakql(
>
Hfhd{#
qpzrf
hit` ?(
;
 
Kd
( ft wkk(
6:
Fl`rkafh Qiak`t{ ig Kht`rhftkihfc Cf})@priz`fh Qiak`t{ ig Kht`rhftkihfc Cf} Bikht Aihg`r`ha`#
Afcc gir zfz`rq# Anfhmkhm Gptpr`q9 Qak`ha` fhd Kht`rhftkihfc Cf}
.N`cqkhek# ?::;+
ft
66
 
Q``
# Fqnkq Hfhd{#
 Fct`rhftkw` Qak`ha`q2 Ar`ftkwkt{ fhd Fptn`htkakt{ kh T}i Khdkfh Qak`htkqtq
.?
hd
`d(#H`} D`cnk2 IPZ# ?::6+ z( 7>(
6?
L( Qirhrfbfn#
Kht`rhftkihfc Cf} ih Gir`kmh Khw`qtl`ht Cf}q
.?
hd
`d(# Lfqqfanpq`ttq2 APZ# ?::4+(
Q``
#Bfl`q Tnpi Mftnkk#
]fr‛q C`mfa{ kh Kht`rhftkihfc Khw`qtl`ht Cf}
# 6624 Kht`rhftkihfc Aillphkt{ Cf}_`wk`} .?::;+ zz( 101,1>7(

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
Meraj Ahmad liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->