• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • 1
    CommentGo Back
Download
 
Fascism vs. Nazism
Sat Oct 23 2004
To confuse
fascism
and
Nazism
is perhaps understandable-- both weredictatorial,antidemocraticmovements. But there are important differencesbetween them as well.First, let us unravel theterminology.
Revolutionary groups and whipping canesFascism
originated inItaly, under the leadership ofBenito Mussolini. Its name-- not itsideology-- is in part derived from certainrevolutionary workersgroups in Italy at the end of the19th century,
fasci revoluzionari 
(=revolutionarygroups). When Mussolini startedhis movement in 1919, he called his first fascist groups
fasci di combattimento 
(=combatgroups).As it happens, the similar-soundingLatinword
fasces 
(signifying abunch of whipping canes, bound around an execution axe) was anestablishedRomansymbol ofpower. In earlyRome, the entire contraption used to be displayed ritually before the powerful Romanconsuls, who before 300BChad the sole power to pass judgement as well as to mete out punishment (whippingbycaneorbeheadingby axe). After 300 BC this combined judiciary and executive power cameto an end, when Roman justicewas reformed. But this didn't botherMussolini, who used pictures of
fasces 
as his own symbols ofdictatorial power.Hence the word
fascism 
has two "separate but equal"roots: the Italianword
fasci 
and the Roman (Latin)
fasces 
.
National socialismNazism
is a contraction of the German word
Nationalsozialismus 
(derived from the officialGermanname of Hitler's party,
Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei 
,NSDAP). It stands forthetotalitarianand racist pseudo-ideology under which theAdolf Hitler's GermanThird Reichwas ruthlessly governed. During the 1930's, political analysts in the democratic West werehorrified by both of these antidemocraticcreeds, Italian fascism aswell as German Nazism. But they took care to keepthemconceptuallyapart.However, this was not the case inStalin'sSoviet Union, because the full name of the Soviet Union has one word element in common withNazism (
National 
sozialismus 
), the wordsocialism--USSRis read out as the
Union of Soviet 
Socialist 
Republics 
. Stalin, who saw
 
himself as communist and socialist (and who in other respects was just as murderous and totalitarian as Hitler), was opposed to thecompeting ideology of Nazism (=
Nationalsocialismus 
). But he didn'twant to use the
word
in his anti-Nazipropaganda, because itcontained a "good" element-- "socialism".
Hitler is a damned Nazi!-- Hell no, Hitler is a damned fascist!
So from the1930'sonwards a curious situation arose: when theWest lashed out against fascists, they meant Mussolini's Italians, but whenthe Soviets expressed anger against the fascists, they meant Hitler'sGermans. Communists in other countries followed the Soviet-established political vocabulary, using the word "fascist" when theyactually meant "Nazi".This difference inpoliticalterminology remained in place even afterthe war. The West celebrated itsvictoryover Nazism, while paradeswere held in Moscow in honour of the gloriousRed Armythat hadvanquished fascism. Both just meant the same thing-- that they werehappy to be rid of Hitler.
An ideologicallitmus paper
When discussinghistoricalWWII events during thepost-war years, you could easily tell if the speaker or writer was inspired bycommunism. If he or she talked about Nazis as "fascists", then theargument or point of view had in all probability originated incommunist circles.
Unraveling the fuzz
Both fascism and Nazism are founded onfuzzyideas, but this doesnot justify confusing them or treating them as identical.Mussolini's fascism had a shade closer resemblance to some kind ofcrackpotpolitical ideology than Hitler's Nazism, which was not basedon much else thanblindracial hatred, efficient militarism, and ruthlessapplication of totalitarian power in the interest of theMaster Race.
Corporatism-- medieval guilds warmed over
The Italian fascists regarded both parliamentary democracy andsocialist class struggle as elements that were bound to causedivisiveness in a nation. Hence they introduced the idea ofcorporatism, a kind of modernised version of themedievalguildsystem. Here representatives of alltrades andindustries,employers as well asemployees, could settle matters basedon mutualunderstanding. Of course, in reality this was mostly ideologicalwindow-dressing. Mussolini wasIl Duce(= The Leader) and had the last word.
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...

adequate primer to understanding the underestimated influence of language in each person's subjective perception of the reality we create and all to often mistake as independent & objective.

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...