tate Representative
Kate M. Harper
61st Legislative DistrictateHarper.net
November 2009
Dear Neighbor
,
Budget Resolved: Result Pleased No One
“It has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried.” – Sir Winston Churchill
he budget, required to be balanced by June0th each year, was finally settled in October. Ivoted against the final budget because it madedeep cuts in the Educational Improvement TaxCredit, used the doctors’ assessments in theMCARE fund to plug holes in the General Fund,and virtually requires unlimited drilling in our state forests to balance. I thought there was abetter way.Revenues were down this year because of the poor economy. Sales taxes, income taxesand corporate taxes all lagged, reflective of theweak economy, leaving us with a $3 billion holein our $27 billion budget that is required to bal-ance each year. Most of the delay in balancingthis year’s budget was due to the Governor’searly insistence on raising “recurring revenues,”and his preferred method was a 16 percent hikein the personal income tax.Many of you made it clear to me that youdidn’t want your taxes increased in a recessionunless there was no other way to get the budgetdone. You told me you believe governmentought to do what you are doing – budgetingcarefully and cutting back on extras, vaca-tions, splurges and dinners out to make surethe money’s there for the important things likethe mortgage, food, health care and education.Ultimately, however, any legislator can vote for or against only those proposals that reach theHouse Floor.I always believed it would be possible toget the budget to balance without eliminatingnecessary government services and withoutraising taxes. I believe this because I saw suchbudget proposals. They did not make it to theFloor for a vote.
Thus, when the Legislature began todebate the possibility of leasing our stateforest lands for natural gas drilling
initiallyI thought it would be possible to lease some of the forest land safely. We have done that in thepast—limited acreage, carefully selected, under the watchful eye of the Department of Conserva-tion and Natural Resources—and the proceedswere deposited into an account that benefits thestate forests and parks.
This year, despite my efforts to get anamendment requiring that only land wheredrilling could be accomplished withoutadverse environmental impacts be consid-ered, and a bipartisan agreement to limit theamount of acreage that could be leased, andset a “floor” for the minimum bid price thatcould be accepted, the final version of thebudget contained none of those safeguardsand requires the land to yield more than $100million in this fiscal year.
Our state forests are Commonwealth assetsin so many ways. They are beautiful places thatallow for recreation and tourism opportunities. Above the ground, they contain millions of treesthat can be safely and selectively timbered fromtime to time and below the ground, valuable min-erals that can be mined or drilled. On the other hand, the forests also contain pristine, environ-mentally advantageous lands and streams thatprotect the sources of clean drinking water. Allof those trees help us filter impurities out of thevery air we breathe. Exploiting the natural gasbelow the surface without carefully mitigating theadverse environmental impacts from clearingfor roads and pipelines, as well as planning for risks due to the chemicals used in the process,is simply irresponsible.It just isn’t right, and it didn’t have to be thisway.The Governor and the Democratic majority inthe House spent very little time looking for waysto tighten our belts and thus were forced to lookfor ways to increase revenue. Left untouched,for reasons known only to the Governor, was atax on smokeless tobacco products and a tax onnatural gas. Instead we endured weeks wherewe considered increasing income taxes and atax on school children visiting the Art Museum.There are times in all of our lives when wemust clearly state what we stand for and whatwe will not stand for. This budget battle was oneof those times. . er
Be Safe:Call BeforeYou Dig
Pipeline accidents can cause major property damage and serious, or evenatal, injuries. Excavation activities arehe leading cause of these types of acci-dents, but they can be avoided by simplycalling
Pennsylvania One Call SystemInc. at 8-1-1
(or 1-800-242-1776). Statelaw requires contractors and others plan-ning any type of digging or excavation tocontact One Call three days in advanceo allow utilities to come to the excavationsite and mark the location of undergroundutilities. One Call operates 24 hours aday, seven days a week. For more infor-mation, visit
www.pa1call.org
.
Rep. Kate Harper hosted threeconstituent breakfastmeetings thissummer, includingone at the CentralMontco TechnicalHigh School. Thebreakfasts providethe opportunity totalk about people’sconcerns with what’shappening in theCommonwealthand in MontgomeryCounty.
R
Add a Comment