WASHINGTON — The anti-abortion provision in the healthcare bill passed by the House lateSaturday was the biggest victoryfor abortion opponents in yearsand has emboldened them head-ing into what is sure to be a pitchedbattle in the Senate.The provision would block theuse of federal subsidies for insur-ance that covers elective abor-tions.The provision, inserted in thebill Saturday as an amendmentunder pressure from conserva-tive Democrats, was the result inpart of forceful lobbying by theU.S. Catholic Bishops. The healthlegislation is now moving to theSenate, which will have to decidewhether to include any abortionrestrictions in its version. Presi-dent Obama has so far remainedsilent on the issue, but as the de-bate continues he could be forcedto take sides.It would apply only to insurancepolicies purchased with the feder-al subsidies that the health legisla-tion would create to help low andmiddle-income people buy healthcoverage, and to policies sold by agovernment-run insurance plan.Abortion-rights advocatescharged Sunday that the provisionthreatened to deprive women of abortion coverage because insur-ers would drop the procedure fromtheir plans in order to sell them inthe new market of people receiv-ing subsidies. The subsidized mar-ket would be large because anyoneearning less than $88,000 for a fam-ily of four — four times the povertylevel — would be eligible for a sub-sidy under the House bill.Women who received subsidiesor public insurance could still payout of pocket for the procedure. Orthey could buy separate insurance“riders” to cover abortion, thoughsome evidence suggests fewwould, in part because few plan forunintended pregnancies.Not many women who undergoabortions file private insuranceclaims in any case. A 2003 studyby the Alan Guttmacher Institutefound that 13 percent of abortionswere billed directly to an insur-ance company. Only about half of those who receive insurance cov-erage from their employers havecoverage of abortion in any event,according to a study by the KaiserFamily Foundation.But the abortion battle has beenplaying out over incrementalchanges in the courts and in leg-islation, most of which in recentyears have gone against advo-cates of abortion rights.“This is going to make it thatmuch more challenging on theSenate side,” said Nancy Keenan,president of NARAL Pro-ChoiceAmerica.
DAVID D. KIRKPATRICKand ROBERT PEAR
In House Bill, Victory for Abortion Opponents
WASHINGTON — House Dem-ocrats were thrilled by the passageof their major health care legisla-tion on Saturday, but were particu-larly tickled by denying Republi-cans a solid wall of opposition withthe solitary vote of Rep. Anh Cao of Louisiana.Cao, a freshman Republicanfrom New Orleans and a Vietnam-ese-American representing a pre-dominantly black, heavily Demo-cratic district, was elected lastyear in an upset victory over Rep.William J. Jefferson, a Democratwho was under indictment at thetime and has since been convictedof federal corruption charges.“I have a constitutional dutyto make the right decision for mydistrict whether or not the decisionwas popular,” Cao said in an inter-view Sunday on CNN. “A lot of myconstituents are uninsured, a lot of them are poor.”In a statement posted on his Website shortly after the vote on Satur-day, he said he had secured a per-sonal commitment from PresidentObama on health issues importantto Louisiana, including disparitiesin federal reimbursement rates forMedicare.While many Democrats com-plained that tighter restrictions oninsurance coverage for abortionshad threatened their support forthe bill, Cao, a onetime Jesuit semi-narian, said those tougher restric-tions were essential for his vote.This was not the first time Caohas broken with his party. He wasone of 29 Republicans to join Dem-ocrats this year in voting to reau-thorize the Children’s Health In-surance Program, which typicallycovers children whose families donot qualify for Medicaid.Democrats, teasingly, claimed amantle of bipartisanship for theirhealth care legislation.“This was, as you observed, abipartisan vote,” the House major-ity leader, Steny H. Hoyer of Mary-land, said at a news conference tocelebrate the passage of the bill.
DAVID M. HERSZENHORN
One Republican Breaks Ranks in Health Vote
BANGOR, Me. — For years,the location of this city’s needleexchange program, in a strip mallclose to highways and bus lines,was seen as a major asset.But now, AIDS activists say, thatlocation could undermine whathappens inside.A bill working in Congress wouldlift a ban of more than 20 years onusing federal money for needleexchange programs. But the billwould also ban federally financedexchanges from being within 1,000feet of a school, park, library, col-lege, video arcade or any placechildren might gather — a provi-sion affecting most of the country’sapproximately 200 exchanges.“This 1,000-foot rule is simplyinstituting the ban in a differentform,” said Rebecca Haag, execu-tive director of the AIDS ActionCouncil, an advocacy group.Under a separate bill, all ex-changes in Washington withinthe 1,000-foot perimeter would bebarred from receiving city moneyas well as federal money.“Let’s protect these kids,” saidRep. Jack Kingston, R-Ga., whointroduced the Washington bill.“They don’t need to be playingkickball in the playground andseeing people lined up for needleexchange.”Both bills have passed the Houseand await Senate action.
KATIE ZEZIMA
Bill to Help Needle Exchanges Would Hurt Most of Them
Prescriptions
Follow the progress, and thedebate, on the health bill.
Shting in Ca
A 63-year-old man suspectedof fatally shooting one personand wounding three others in aVail, Colo., bar has been arrest-ed in what authorities say wasan apparently random shooting.Richard Moreau of Vail is ac-cused of firing shots outside andin the Sandbar Sports Grill. Po-lice say he was arrested Satur-day at the scene on suspicion offirst-degree homicide.
(AP)
Tansit Stike
Commuters in Philadelphiahave been told to gear up fora second week of finding otherways to work after the collapseof a proposed deal to end a six-day-old strike by about 5,000 busdrivers, subway and trolley con-ductors and mechanics.The largest union represent-ing workers of the SoutheasternPennsylvania TransportationAuthority wants an indepen-dent audit of pension funds. Theunion is also rejecting languagethat could reopen the contractif SEPTA’s costs increase dueto national health care reform.
(AP)
Amy Chief f StaffWants Me Tps
Gen. George Casey, the Armychief of staff, on Sunday be-came the latest U.S. military of-ficial to advocate sending moretroops to Afghanistan as Presi-dent Obama nears a decision ona new strategy.
(Reuters)
Psecuts SeekStuents’ Gaes
A Northwestern Universityprofessor and journalism stu-dents who spent three years in-vestigating the case of a manconvicted in the 1978 killing ofa security guard believe theyhave evidence that shows pros-ecutors put the wrong man be-hind bars. But Cook Countyprosecutors issued subpoenasto David Protess, the professor,seeking his students’ grades,his syllabus and their privatee-mails. Prosecutors claim thestudents may have been underpressure to prove the case toget a good grade.
(AP)
In Brief
NATIoNAl
Monday, noveMber 9, 2009
3
Leave a Comment