Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
159Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Birther Scorecard & String Cite: Birthers Win *O* - Lose - 220 | Pending - 6 | Total - 226 | Updated January 10, 2014

Birther Scorecard & String Cite: Birthers Win *O* - Lose - 220 | Pending - 6 | Total - 226 | Updated January 10, 2014

Ratings: (0)|Views: 17,474 |Likes:
Published by Jack Ryan
List- containing: --Case Caption (and plaintiff's full name) --Court, Case Number, with Justia Docket link (or other, where available) --Dismissal Order, with link to Order where available --Appeal Dismissal Order, with link when available --Supreme Court Docket showing application/writ denied, with link --Whether Obama's Attorneys defended the case Scorecard has been updated to add explanations in the defense column to address continuing confusion regarding this issue. I added explanations in each cell about why Obama attorneys did not defend the case. E.g., -- Gov defended -- Ct dismissed sua sponte -- Obama not a defendant
List- containing: --Case Caption (and plaintiff's full name) --Court, Case Number, with Justia Docket link (or other, where available) --Dismissal Order, with link to Order where available --Appeal Dismissal Order, with link when available --Supreme Court Docket showing application/writ denied, with link --Whether Obama's Attorneys defended the case Scorecard has been updated to add explanations in the defense column to address continuing confusion regarding this issue. I added explanations in each cell about why Obama attorneys did not defend the case. E.g., -- Gov defended -- Ct dismissed sua sponte -- Obama not a defendant

More info:

Published by: Jack Ryan on Nov 18, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/10/2014

pdf

text

original

 
B
IRTHER
S
CORECARD
 
Court: Blue Agency: Green
Case Caption
Plaintiff 
s full name
Original Tribunal
Case No. Docket
 Original Decision Appeal(s) US Supreme Court
Obama Defense
F
 
Total Actions: 226 Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: 220 Pending: 6 Total Appellate Court Rulings: >90+ Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: >90+ Total Supreme Court Rulings: 25+ Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: 25+ 
Last Updated
: January 10, 2014 Page 1 of 79 WhatsYourEvidence.com
 
1.
Allen v. Soetoro 
 
(FOIA)
 
Kenneth L. Allen D. Ariz. (Federal Court) 4:09-cv-00373
H
H
H
1
 
as to Request for Obama documents 9
th
 Circuit: 10-15290
Appeal as to Obama docs
--- No
Gov. defended 
 
Remaining Claims Voluntarily
9
th
 Circuit: 11-15094 
---
Citation
 Allen v. Soetoro
, 4:09-cv-00373 (D. Ariz. Jan. 29, 2010) (dismissing FOIA action seeking documents
related to Obama’s eligibility)
aff’d 
, No, 11-15094 (9th Cir. Jul. 23, 2012);
 
2.
Allen v. Obama et al
Kenneth L. Allen
 
Arizona Pima County Super. Ct. C20121046
Amended Complaint Filed Feb. 24, 2012
 
--- --- No
 No appearance on behalf of Obama; AZ Democratic  Party defended 
 
Citation
 Allen v. Obama et al 
, No. C20121046 (Ariz. Pima County Super. Ct. Feb. 24, 2012) (dismissing complaint
challenging Obama’s eligibility to be on 2012 ballot);
 
3.
Allen v. Barack Obama et al
Kenneth L. Allen
 
Arizona Pima County Super. Ct. C20121317
 – 
 but appeal apparently abandoned thereafter  
--- No
 No appearance on behalf of Obama; AZ Democratic  Party defended 
 
Citation
 Allen v. Obama et al 
, No. C20121317 (Ariz. Pima County Super. Ct., Mar. 7, 2012) (dismissing case
challenging Obama’s eligibility to be on the 2012 ballot; finding that Obama is a “natural born citizen”
under
Wong Kim Ark 
; and expressly rejecting argument that
 Minor v. Happersett
holds otherwise);
4.
American Grand Jury
Mack H. Ellis Donald McDougall M.D. Tenn (Federal) 3:09mc00215 Justia - 
H
H
DISMISSED --- --- No
Court dismissed  sua sponte
 
Citation
 In re Am. Grand Jury,
 No. 3:09-mc-00215 (M.D. Tenn. Nov. 6, 2009) (summarily rejecting grand jury
 presentment
 challenging President Obama
s eligibility to serve as President as having no force under U.S. Constitution or law);
1
 
 Note:
The
Justia
 has easy-to-read explanations of all the various filings. The
RECAP
, while not as reader-friendly, has links to many of the pleadings filed in the case.
 
B
IRTHER
S
CORECARD
 
Court: Blue Agency: Green
Case Caption
Plaintiff 
s full name
Original Tribunal
Case No. Docket
 Original Decision Appeal(s) US Supreme Court
Obama Defense
F
 
Total Actions: 226 Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: 220 Pending: 6 Total Appellate Court Rulings: >90+ Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: >90+ Total Supreme Court Rulings: 25+ Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: 25+ 
Last Updated
: January 10, 2014 Page 2 of 79 WhatsYourEvidence.com
 
5.
American Grand Jury 
F
2
 
Robert C. Laity, Robert J. Campbell
 
W.D.N.Y. (Federal)  No Number Assigned
H
REJECTED --- --- No
Court dismissed  sua sponte
 
Citation 
 
 American Grand Jury
, No Number Assigned (W.D.N.Y. Sept. 29, 2009) (letter from court staff attorney
explaining that court could not accept “presentment” prepared by public, seeking to indict Obama for
ineligibility to hold office and related matters);
6.
Anderson v. Obama
Daniel G. Anderson
William Colliton, M.D. Richard P. Delaney, M.D. Richard Loria, M.D. Lorenzo Marcolin, M.D. Gaetano Molinari, M.D. James Ronan, M.D. Edward Sheridan, M.D. Edward Soma, M.D. Ronald Uscinski, M.D.
 
U.S. Supreme Court (Issue not raised in D.Md. and 4th Cir.) 8:10-cv-00017-PJM (D. Md.) (No birther claims made) 10-1951 (4th Cir.) (No birther claims made)  No. 10-612 Petition for Rehearing (to address birther issue) DENIED 
No
Citation 
 
Anderson v. Obama 
,
 No. 10-612, 2012 WL 1969419 (U.S. Jun. 4, 2012) (denying motion for leave to file  petition for rehearing in case challenging the Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act, where  petition sought an order compelling (a) the U.S. Marshalls to travel to Hawaii; (b) the Hawaii Department
of Health to release the “original” birth certificate of Obama to the U.S. Marshalls; (c) the U.S. Marshalls to
 bring the certificate to the Supreme Court; and (d) the U.S. Secret Service to examine and verify whether the document is a forgery);
 
2
 
 Note:
American Grand Jury has attempted to file multiple additional
 presentments,
 in at least the following courts:
H
H
 Central District (Armando Carranza); 
H
H
 (Unknown); 
H
H
 (Norman Caron); 
H
H
 (Bradley Kramer); 
H
H
H
 (Donald McDougall); Middle District 
H
H
 (Lesley Lawson). To date, however, there is no indication that any of these courts have accepted the documents as filed and, therefore, they are not
 pending.
 
 
B
IRTHER
S
CORECARD
 
Court: Blue Agency: Green
Case Caption
Plaintiff 
s full name
Original Tribunal
Case No. Docket
 Original Decision Appeal(s) US Supreme Court
Obama Defense
F
 
Total Actions: 226 Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: 220 Pending: 6 Total Appellate Court Rulings: >90+ Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: >90+ Total Supreme Court Rulings: 25+ Birthers win: 0 Birthers lose: 25+ 
Last Updated
: January 10, 2014 Page 3 of 79 WhatsYourEvidence.com
 
7.
Ankeny v. Daniels
Steve Ankeny Indiana State Court Marion Superior Court 49D10-0812-PL-55511 
DISMISSED
Indiana Appellate Court
H
DISMISSAL AFFIRMED Finding Obama is NBC 
Petition for Rehearing DENIED
Indiana Supreme Court
Transfer to Ind. Sup. Ct. DENIED
 --- No
 
Obama not a defendant
Citation
 Ankeny v. Governor of the State of Indiana
, No. 49D10-0812-PL-055511, 2009 WL 1632611 (Ind. Marion
County Super. Ct. Mar. 16, 2009) (dismissing challenge to McCain’s and Obama’s eligibility),
aff’d 
, 916  N.E.2d 678 (Ind. Ct. App. 2009) (holding that Obama, who was born in Hawaii, is a
natural born citizen
 eligible to be president),
transfer denied 
, 929 N.E.2d 789 (Ind. 2010);
8.
Archibald v. DOJ
George H. Archibald D.D.C. (Federal) 1:11-cv-02028-RBW PACER | RECAP 
---
 
---
 
No
 
Obama not a Defendant 
 
Citation
 Archibald v. U.S. Dept. of Justice
, No. 1:11-cv-02028-RBW (D.D.C., Mar. 13, 2013) (dismissing FOIA case seeking information on FBI background check of Obama in 2008 presidential campaign, alleging that records could show he was not qualified to be president);

Activity (159)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
silverbull8 liked this
Chris Strunk added this note
What Jack is saying in re NBC is that born on soil is ALL that counts notwithstanding the status of the parents. Jack you are a disreputable person I hope I meet you face to face some day. Your love of the Jesuits is only preceded by your love of yourself.
Jack Ryan added this note
If idiots reelect Obama you will be at the front of the line at the polls. The potential harm to the Constitution is those of your ilk who are perverting it, intent on shredding it and subverting the law. Barack Obama is the legally-elected, President of the U.S. and may be so again come November. And will still be legally elected.
silverbull8 added this note
In the history of the US Presidents, since September 17, 1787, Barack Obama holds the distinction, of being the only person, who was native born in the US to a foreign national, to enter a presidential election illegally, and win. If he gets reelected, then no greater harm can come to the US Constitution. Only an idiot would reelect Obama.
Jack Ryan added this note
Tell it to the Supreme Court. They disagree. Or any court for that matter.

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->