You are on page 1of 7

If any person can prove any reference to be wrong, he is entitled to a reward.

Through the grace of Almighty Allah, I have scholastically discussed every issue the
Deobandis differ with. In them, however, are some which do not necessitate Imaan being
brought upon [i.e. one does not become a Kaafir if he doesn't accept some of the laws previously
discussed]. Rather, a difference of preferability or dislike may be found within.

On the other hand, the affair which resulted in the Learned Ulama of the Arab and non-Arab
world declaring Deobandis to be Kaafirs have to do with the beliefs which existed in them
contrary to Islamic ones. We present a list of these beliefs for our knowledge and understanding.
In contrast to each false belief, we shall also produce the correct Islamic one. The following are
documented in their printed books and literature. If any person can prove any reference to be
wrong, he is entitled to a reward.
INCORRECT BELIEF 1: Allah can speak lies.- Baraheen-e-Qaatia, Pg. 278
by Khalil Ahmed Ambetbwi & Fataawa Rashidia, Vol. 1, Pg. 20 by Rashid Ahmed
Gangohi

Speaking a lie is a fault, just as how stealing, fornicating, etc. are faults. Without doubt,
Allah is free from faults.
The Holy Quran states, 25.1 Also, the qualities of Allah are Sure
(Waajib), not probable. Thus, to say, "Allah can probably ... is not Islamically correct.

INCORRECT BELIEF 2: The glory of Allah is that whenever He wishes, He
can know the Unseen (Ghaib). Allah has not bestowed any Saint, Prophet
, Jinn or Angel with this ability. - Taqwiyatul-lmaan by Ismail Dehlwi

Allah is the Knower of the Unseen (Aalimul-Ghaib) at all times. His knowledge is His
quality and is Sure (Waajib). Saying, "Whenever He wishes, He can know ...." means that if
Allah doesn't wish, He remains ignorant. This is infidelity (kufr).
The qualities of Allah are not choices for Him, but are sure for Him. Also, He has blessed
His beloveds with knowledge of the Unseen. The Holy Quran

INCORRECT BELIEF 3: To believe Allah to be free from time, place, form
and being a composite is Innovation (Bidat). - Izaahul-Haqq by Ismail Dehlwi

Allah is free from time, place, form and composition. He doesn't live in a place, have an
eye or is made up of parts. Unfortunately, Deobandis have accepted this belief of kufr as well. -
Books of Ilme-Kalaam (Scholastic Theology)
Allah does not have knowledge of the servant's actions beforehand. Only when the servant
does a good or bad deed, then does Allah gain knowledge of it. - Bulgatul-Hairaan, Pg. 57
by Maulwi Husain Ali, a student of Rashid Ahmed Gangolri
INCORRECT BELIEF 4: Allah is the Knower of everything from always and
His knowledge is Sure and Eternal (Qadeem). Any person who believes Allah
to be unaware of anything is one out of the deen of Islam. - General books of Beliefs
(Aqaaid)

Deobandis refute even the Knowledge of the Unseen of Allah! So if they reject the Holy
Prophets Knowledge of the Unseen, what is so surprising?

Speaking a lie is a fault, just as how stealing, fornicating, etc. are faults. Without doubt,
Allah is free from faults.

Also, the qualities of Allah are Sure, not probable. Thus, to say, "Allah can probably
is not Islamically correct.

INCORRECT BELIEF 5: To accept Khaatimun Nabiyeen (the Last and Final
Prophet) to mean that Rasoolullah is the final Messenger and Prophet
is wrong. Rather, it means that he is the original and permanent Prophet
and all others are temporary. Thus, if another Prophetappears after
Rasoolullah, still too will there be no difference in him being the final Prophet
- Tahzeerun Naas, Pg. 18 and 34 by Qaasim Nanautwi, who is the founder
of Darul Uloom Deoband

"Khaatimun-Nabiyeen" means that our Holy Prophet is the Final Messenger. It is impossible
for a person to become a Prophet either during the time of our Beloved Huzoor or after it. This is
the meaning upon which the entire Muslim Ummah has agreed upon and is also the meaning
explained in the Hadith. Anyone who rejects this is an apostate (Murtad), i.e. the Qadiyanis and
Deobandis

INCORRECT BELIEF 6: When it comes to deeds (a'maal}, then outwardly, the
followers (Ummatis) are often equal and, in fact, even surpass the Prophets. -
Tahzeerun-Naas, Pg. 7 by Qaasim Nanautwi.

Any non-Prophet, whether he is a Saint (Wali), Ghaus or Companion (Sahaabi), cannot equal a
Prophet in any excellence, be it in either knowledge or practice. In fact, a non-Sahaabi cannot
even equal a Sahaabi. Only a little amount of charity given by a Companion of a Prophet
is better than the vast amounts of charity that we give. - Hadith Sharif

INCORRECT BELIEF 7: A likeness and equal to the Holy Prophet is possible. -
Yak-roozi, Pg. 144 by Ismail Dehlwi

Allah is the glorious Creator and His Beloved Muhammad Mustapha is the incomparable
mercy unto all creation and the intercessor for the sinners. Due to these qualities, an equal to the
Holy Prophetis absolutely impossible. Risaala Imtinaa 'un-Nazeer by Maulana Fadhle-Haqq
Khairabadi .
INCORRECT BELIEF 8: To address the Holy Prophet as "brother" is correct
because be is also a human. - Baraheen-e-Qaatta, Khalil Ahmed Ambethwi &
Taqwiatul-Imaan, Pg. 51 by Ismail Dehlwi

Using common words to address the Prophet is Haraam and, if it is done with the intention of
disrespect, it is infidelity (kufr). - The Holy Quran

Saying, "Ya Rasoolallah (O Prophet of Allah), and "Ya Habeeballah" (O Beloved of
Allah) is necessary.

INCORRECT BELIEF 9: The Knowledge of Shaitaan and the Angel of Death is
more than the Holy Prophets knowledge. - Baraheen-e-Qaatia, Pg. 55 by Khalil
Ahmed Ambethwi

Any person who accepts any creation to have more knowledge than Sayyiduna Rasoolullah
is a Kaafir. -Shifaa Sharif

The Holy Prophet is the most knowledgeable of alt of Allahs creation.

INCORRECT BELIEF 10: The Knowledge of the Prophet is like or equal to the
knowledge of children, lunatics and animals. - Hifzul-Imaan, Pg. 15 by Ashraf Ali
Thanwi

To compare any quality of the Noble Messenger to disgraceful things or say that it is equal to
such things is an explicit blasphemy and infidelity (kufr).

INCORRECT BELIEF 11: The Holy Prophet learnt bow to speak Urdu from
Madrassah Deoband - Baraheen-e-Qaatia by Khalil Ahmed Ambethwi

Allah had taught Hadrat Adam all languages. The Holy Prophets
if knowledge is more extensive than his. So, whoever says that the Prophet learnt a
language from a certain Madrassah is someone out of the deen.

INCORRECT BELIEF 12: Every creation, whether revered (Prophet, Saint) or
not, is more disgraced than a cobbler in front of Allah's glory. Taqwiatut-
Lmaan, Pg. 18 by Ismail Dehlwi

Allah states, , 25.2 and , 25.3
The person who accepts the Nabi to be disgraced in comparison to Allah is himself more
dishonored than a cobbler.

INCORRECT BELIEF 13: To think of the Holy Prophet in namaaz is worse than
becoming captivated in the thought of your donkey and ox. Siraate-Mustaqeem, Pg.
97 by Ismail Dehlwi
The namaaz which does not have the thought of Rasoolullah's greatness is rejected, because
Salaam is made to the Holy Prophet in "At-Tahiyaat ... " How can that namaaz, which has no
remembrance of he who taught us namaaz, be worthy of being called namaaz?! - Refer to the
Discussion of Haazir & Naazir

INCORRECT BELIEF 14: I saw the Holy Prophet in a dream wherein he took me
to the Pul Siraat (bridge over Jabaunam to enter Jannat). After a little while, I noticed
that he was falling from it and so I stopped him from falling. - Butghatut-Halraan, Pg.
8 by Husain Ali.

Some slaves of the Holy Prophet shall pass over the Pul Siraat like lightning. Those who will
stumble on it will gain stability through Sayyiduna Rasoolullahs help. He will make dua
saying, "Rabbi Sallim!" (Peace, Ya Allah) Hadilh Sharif.

Whoever claims to have saved the Holy Prophet from falling from the Pul Siraat has no Imaan.

INCORRECT BELIEF 15: When Ashraf Ali Thanwi Deobandi was a senior-citizen,
he married a very young female student. Before this, a disciple (mureed) of bis had a
dream in which be saw Sayyidah Aisha approaching Ashraf Ali's house. Ashraf Ali
began to interpret this dream as follows, "Soon, a very young woman will come into
my care, because when the Nikah of Sayyidab Aisha was made to Rasoolullah
, she was 7 years old. The same is of relevance here. I am an old mao and my
wife is a minor." -Risaala al-Imdaad by Ashraf Ali Thanwl

All of the wives of the Holy Prophet are the Mothers of the Muslims. - The Holy Quran

It is the unique glory of Sayyidah Aisha

that all the mothers of this world can be


sacrificed at her feet. If a vile person had to see his mother in a dream, he wouldn't interpret her
to symbolize a wife, yet this Ashraf Ali did. This is very disrespectful to Sayyidah Aisha

. In fact, it is open abuse against her! How can any self-respecting Muslim deduce his
mother to represent a wife?

Section 2

The above are only a few examples of the corrupt beliefs of the Deobandis. If all their infamous
beliefs had to be gathered together, journals would be needed. The Shias spew abuse against the
Sahaaba and the Khaarij slandered the Able Bait, but not even Allah was spared from the
Deobandis! They have insulted the Holy Prophet B, the Sahaaba, the Able-Bait, the Ummul-
Mu'mineen and the Friends of Allah. If a person had to say to any self-respecting
individual, "I have seen your mother in a dream and have interpreted her to mean a wife," the
latter will not be able to bare this. We, the slaves of the Prophet, cannot bear such ridicule for
our Mother, Sayyidah Aisha

. Through my pen, I am informing Muslims to stay


far away from such people until they repent from such filthy beliefs.

An accusation made against the Ahle-Sunnah is that we are Peer-worshippers and equate the
Holy Prophet and our Shaikhs to Allah. Thus, we are polytheists (Musriks). .

However, I shall now demonstrate the level of Peer-worship committed by the Deobandis
themselves and what they believe their Peers to be. Mautwi Mahmoodul-Hasan has written in
the eulogy (marsiya) of his Shaikh, Maulwi Rashid Ahmed Gangahi,





In this stanza, the grave of Maulwi Rashid has become the mountain Tur, and Maulwi
Mahmood is the person who says, "Arini'' (show me). [i.e. he is equated to Hadrat Musa
Shouldn't Maulwi Rashid be the Rubb through this? Of course Maulwi Mahmood has
called his Shaikh "Rubb" in this marsiya. He further writes,





Here, Maulwi Mahmood calls Maulwi Rashid the second of the founder of Islam,
Muharnmadur-Rasoolullah .He continues,





and, in this, has further likened Maulwi Rashid to Hadrat Abu Bakr Siddique


and Hadrat Umar-e-Farooq

as well. He also states,







According to him, the slave of Maulwi Rashid is so beautiful that he has been given the title of
being the second Yusuf (Allah forbid!).

Readers, pay attention. From Allah to Farooq O, what rank hasn't been given to Maulwi
Rashid? The entire marsiya is worth a look at, including this stanza,





Here, Maulwi Mahmood has challenged even Roohullah, Hadrat Esa by saying, "O
Esa ! You only gave life to the dead. My Rashid Ahmed both gave life to the dead and
didn't let the living die." In other words, he has asserted that Rashid Ahmed Gangohi is greater
than Hadrat Esa .

Once, a disciple of Maulwi Ashraf Ali Thanwi wrote to him that in a dream, he read
the Kalima in the following manner, "Laa ilaaha illallaaah Ashraf Ali
Rasoolullah". He wished to recite the Kalima correctly but this was the only thing
coming out of his mouth. When he awoke, he read Durood Sharif in the following
words, "Allahuma Salle alaa Sayyidina wa Nabiyyina Ashraf Ali." The
disciple was now in a predicament because he was not dreaming anymore but was
awake and in a state of consciousness. Maulwi Ashraf Ali replied to him, "There is
satisfaction in this incident because the person who you are turning to [i.e. Ashraf
Ali] is the follower of the Sunnah by the help of Allah - At-lmdaad, Pg.35

Reading the Kalima of Ashraf Ali and his Durood is permissible for Deobandis.

It has been stated by Aashiq Ilaahi Meerti that once, Haaji lmdaadullah Sahib

had a dream in which he saw his sister-in-law preparing food for his guests.
At that moment, the Holy Prophetarrived and said to her, "Get up. You are no fit to
cook food for the guests of Imdaadullah. His guests are the Learned (i.e. the
Deobandi Maulwis). I shall cook food for them." - Tazkiratur-Rashid, Vol. J. Pg. 49
by Aashiq Il aahi Meerti

Allah Forbid! Never before did any devotee elevate his Shaikh to such levels.

In spite of all this, no fatwa of polytheism (shirk) or infidelity (kufr) has been given concerning
them, nor have they been called grave-worshippers.

Whatever I have written is not to display any competence in Islamic knowledge. I possess only
basic ability and knowledge. This entire book is the Sadaqah of my Murshid and teacher, Huzoor
Sadrul-Afaadhil, Maulana Sayed Naeemuddin Muraadabadi

. The aim behind


this work is for Muslims to recognize their foes and friends and keep the treasure of Imaan safe
from thieves who wish to seize it.
Whoever benefits from this book is requested to make dua for this beggar in the Court of
Allah and His Rasool) (Mufti Ahmed Yaar Khan). May Allah Biil grant me death
with Imaan. Aameen! May Allah elevate Islam, keep Muslims finn on the straight path
(Siraate-Mustaqeem) and accept these humble and sincere words of this faqeer. Aameen.

Ahmed Yaar Khan Naeemia Ashrafi Patron Madrassah Ghousia Naeemia, Gujrot, Pakistan 2 Zil-
Qadah 1361 AH, Monday

After writing this book, I received a letter from Huzoor Amir-e-Millat, Muhaddith Alipuri in
which he brought up an academic and Islamic point and ordered me to record it in my book. As a
result, I now proudly present it to my readers.

Those people who say that the Messenger is a man like them have no Noor of Imaan. Verily
the glory of Sayyiduna Rasoolullah is beyond explanation. Whatever gains a connection to him
becomes matchless and unrivalled. The Holy Quran states, Wives
of the Prophet! You are not like other ordinary women.25.9 We know that the Mothers of the
Faithful are wives without equal.

"(O Muslims!) You are the best Ummat.',25.10 - Surah Aale-lmran, Verse 110

Moreover, we come to know that the Ummah of the Holy Prophet O is the unequalled Ummah,
Madina Munawwara is the unrivalled city, the blessed Qabr of Rasoolullah is the incomparable
piece of earth, the water that flowed from his fingers is matchless water and his blessed
perspiration has no equal. So why should he, through whose association these things became
elevated, not be incomparable himself? It is eloquently stated in Hadaaiqe-Bakshish,




From head to toe, the Holy Prophet is the glory of Allah.

He is a human but there is no human like him.

The Quran says that he is Imaan but Imaan says that he is the soul and life of every Believer. -
Alahazrat Imam Ahmad Raza

.

Shirk Thehre jismeTazim E Rasoolullah Salla Allahu ta'ala'alayhi wa sallam
Aese Bure Mazhaab pe Lanat Kasrat Kijiye.

This is the Iman of This Deobandi Sect (so called Muslims) and Then they say that Barelwi's
called Muslims Kafir

If This is the Belief of any Muslim Then he is called a Kafir not by Barelwi's but by THE HOLY
QURAN and HADITH SHREEFS

May ALLAH Azzawajal Protect us from this Deviant Sects and guide us on the straight path of
Siraat el Mustakeem till our last Breath in his Beloved Salla Allahu ta'ala'alayhi wa sallam's
Waseela Aameen Summa Aameen

You might also like