2
January 2011 |
Absolute return strategies oer modern diversication
Traditional stock and bond unds ollowbenchmark indexes
Investors turn to stocks and bonds as a way to buildlong-term wealth because these asset classes have ahistorical track record o positive perormance over thelong term. While stocks and bonds have greater risksthan short-term securities such as Treasury bills, overthe long haul investors have been historically rewardedor taking these risks by earning higher rates o return
(Figure 1)
.
Perormance is measured againsta market index
Most traditional mutual unds task the portoliomanager with outperorming a stock or bond bench-mark such as the S&P 500 Index or Barclays CapitalU.S. Aggregate Bond Index. The manager is usuallyconstrained to invest only in the domestic market orin a specifc asset class. According to the InvestmentCompany Institute 2010 Fact Book, 94% o mutual undassets are in unds ocused on a specifc asset class —stocks, bonds, or money market securities. Hybrid undsare an exception. These traditional unds have greaterexibility to invest across global asset classes. However,only about 6% o industry assets are invested in hybridunds. Furthermore, some traditional unds have eventighter constraints, such as bond unds that invest onlyin government bonds or high-yield bonds, and stockunds that invest only in small companies or growthstocks. Such constraints beneft investors in that theydiscourage a money manager rom taking a rangeo unintended risks, and they ocus eorts onsecurity selection.
Traditional unds take market risk
At the same time, constraints carry a disadvantage aswell. In a general market decline, when securities all inprice or systemic, rather than specifc, reasons, there islittle that a constrained manager can do to avoid anegative result. In act, a manager may do what isconsidered a good job — by outperorming the marketbenchmark — yet, during a bear market, the und mightpost a signifcant decline or shareholders.
Bear markets can be devastating
There have been 12 bear markets in stocks sinceWorld War II, with prices declining 22% over 14months, on average. Bear markets pose substantialrisks. For younger investors, a downturn interruptsthe compounding o returns, and this delays wealthaccumulation. For investors who have already built upsavings and may be relying on them to generate income,the impact o a bear market can be devastating. Forsaety, such investors typically avor more conservativeinvestments, which, with lower rates o return, requirea number o years to recover rom a downturn
(Figure 2)
.Since their time horizon is shorter, older investors cannotreallocate enough money to stocks to potentially beneftrom a recovery in prices and restore their wealth.
Retired investors are vulnerable
For retired investors, a bear market poses special risks.Withdrawing money during declines locks in the lowstock prices and leaves investors with a smaller posi-tion or when the market recovers. In short, retireesare particularly vulnerable to bear markets, which canshrink savings and reduce the potential or generatinga uture income stream, because retirees are unable toadd to their portolios rom occupational income.To understand the heightened bear market risk orretired investors, consider the example o the stockmarket decline o 2000–2002. Figure 3 compares two
Source: Morningstar, 2010. Stocks are represented by the IbbotsonS&P 500 Total Return Index, bonds by the Ibbotson U.S. Long-TermGovernment Bond Total Return Index, and cash by the Ibbotson U.S.30-day Treasury Bill Total Return Index. The indexes are unman-aged and measure broad sectors o the stock and bond markets. Youcannot invest directly in an index. Past perormance is not indicativeo uture results.
Figure 1. Relative return unds invest intraditional asset classes
Cash
3% Inflation
Bonds Stocks
9.9%5.5%3.6%
Annualized returns (12/31/25–12/31/10)
Add a Comment
uploaded a new revision for this document (#2)