Opinion in Shenker v. Laureate Education

Embed Doc
Copy Link
Readcast
Collections

CommentGo Back

Do}fod Qfldklp) l} oi$ s$ Io|plo}l Lm|ao}jgd) Jda$) l} oi$

) Dg$ 6) Qlr}lh`lp ]lph 022:AGPRGPO]JGDQ ( QFOPLFGIMLP MJPLA] Q\J]Q OEOJDQ] AGPRGPO]LMJPLA]GPQ ( M\]JLQ GC AGPRGPO]L MJPLA]GPQ ( UFLPL AGPRGPO]LMJPLA]GPQ LVLPAJQL DGD(HODOELPJOI M\]JLQ G\]QJML ]FL QAGRL GCHM$ AGML) AGPRGPO]JGDQ ODM OQQGAJO]JGDQ OP]JAIL ¥ 0(=2<$?&o*) Q\AF OQDLEG]JO]JDE ]FL RPJAL ]FO] QFOPLFGIMLPQ UJII PLALJSL CGP ]FLJPQFOPLQ JD O AOQF(G\] HLPELP ]PODQOA]JGD) OC]LP ]FL MLAJQJGD ]GQLII ]FL AGPRGPO]JGD OIPLOMZ FOQ @LLD HOML) ]FL MJPLA]GPQ HOZ@L IJO@IL MJPLA]IZ ]G ]FL QFOPLFGIMLPQ CGP ODZ @PLOAF GC ]FLJPAGHHGD IOU CJM\AJOPZ M\]JLQ GC AODMGP ODM HOVJHJ^O]JGD GCQFOPLFGIMLP SOI\L$

Ajpa|j} Ag|p} cgp @oi}jhgpl Aj}zAol Dg$ 0=(A(25(22233=

JD ]FL AG\P] GC ORRLOIQGC HOPZIODMDg$ 6Qlr}lh`lp ]lph) 022: DO]FOD QFLDKLP) l} oi$s$IO\PLO]L LM\AO]JGD) JDA$) l} oi$ @lii) A$N$Fopplii@o}}oeijoEplldlH|prfzLimpjmel) Ngfd A$ &Pl}jplm)Qrlajoiiz Ojedlm*Poklp) Jpho Q$ &Pl}jplm)Qrlajoiiz Ojedlm*)NN$ Grjdjgd `z Fopplii) N$ Cjilm> Dgslh`lp ?0) 022:

?

Rl}j}jgdlp `pg|ef} }fj oa}jgd gd `lfoic gc }flhlisl odm oii g}flp r|`ijafoplfgimlp gc Io|plo}l Lm|ao}jgd Jda$

0

Jdsl}gp Plrgdmld}) o mlcjdlm `z }fl Ajpa|j} Ag|p} cgp @oi}jhgpl Aj}z jd j} ??Hoz 0225 gpmlp gc mjhjoi gc }fj ij}jeo}jgd) opl @pleoi Jdsl}hld}) Aojl ml Mlrg} l}Rioalhld} m| _|l`la) Aj}jepg|r Rpjso}l Lq|j}z) Kgfi`lpe Kposj Pg`lp} # Ag$) HokldoAorj}oi) QOA Aorj}oi Hodoelhld} IIA) Qg|}flpd Apg Aorj}oi) odm QRE Rop}dlp IIA$O dg}lm `z }fl Ag|p} gc Qrlajoi Orrloi jd j} |dplrgp}lm grjdjgd jd }fj aol) Rl}j}jgdlpmjm dg} dohl Q}lpijde Aorj}oi) o mlcldmod} }g ufjaf }fl ?? Hoz 0225 gpmlp gc mjhjoi mjmdg} orriz) o o mlcldmod} jd }fljp Qlagdm Ohldmlm Aghriojd}$ ]flplcgpl) Rl}j}jgdlpo`odmgdlm }fljp aiojh oeojd} Q}lpijde Aorj}oi) dg}uj}f}odmjde }fl Ajpa|j} Ag|p}‚ mlclppoigc oa}jgd gd Q}lpijde‚ hg}jgd }g mjhj$

Qll Qforjpg s$ Qflpuggm

) 0<= Hm$ 01<) 016(1:)0<= O$0m 1<5) 1<: &?:3:*$

1

Eldlpoiiz) jd o aof(g|} &gp cpll~l(g|}* hlpelp }podoa}jgd) }fl hongpj}z foplfgimlp&gp foplfgimlp* gc }fl }opel} aghrodz llk }g eojd gudlpfjr gc }fl plhojdjde fopl jd}fl }opel} aghrodz$ ]fj j oaaghrijflm `z jdagprgpo}jde od oaq|jpjde aghrodz }gr|pafol cgp aof }fl fopl gc }fl }opel} aghrodz$ M|l }g }fl hongpj}z‚ agd}pgiijdergj}jgd jd }fl }opel} aghrodz) j} hoz cgpal odz hjdgpj}z foplfgimlp }g |ppldmlp }fljpfopl odm oaalr} }fl aof rozhld}) lccla}jsliz lijhjdo}jde }fljp jd}lpl} jd }fl }opel}aghrodz &odm ilosjde }flh uj}f dg |`lq|ld} jd}lpl} jd }fl oaq|jpjde aghrodz*$ Q|af oaof(g|} hlpelp }odm jd agd}po} }g o }pomj}jgdoi hlpelp) jd ufjaf foplfgimlp gc }fl }opel}aghrodz }poml jd }fljp fopl jd lvafodel cgp fopl jd }fl oaq|jpjde aghrodz$

Qll

&agd}jd|lm$$$*]fj aol j o`g|} alp}ojd hgmoij}jl gc oaag|d}o`jij}z jd o agprgpo}l `|jdl l}}jde$Rl}j}jgdlp opl foplfgimlp

?

gc Io|plo}l Lm|ao}jgd) Jda$ &’Io|plo}l‘*) o |aalc|ir|`ijaiz(flim Hopziodm agprgpo}jgd flomq|op}lplm jd @oi}jhgpl$ Io|plo}l‚ rpjhopz`|jdl j ijaldjde j} lm|ao}jgdoi }lafdgigez gslplo odm oaq|jpjde hodoelhld} jd}lpl}jd cgpljed agiilel odm |djslpj}jl$ M|pjde 0223 odm 0225) Io|plo}l |dmlpuld} o rpjso}loaq|jj}jgd rpgal uflpl`z alp}ojd hlh`lp gc Io|plo}l‚ @gopm gc Mjpla}gp) dohliz)@gopm Plrgdmld} Mg|eio I$ @laklp odm P$ Afpj}grflp Fglfd(Qopja) odm lslpoi rpjso}llq|j}z jdsl}gp &’Jdsl}gp Plrgdmld}‘*)

0

r|pafolm Io|plo}l }fpg|ef o aof(g|} hlpelp}podoa}jgd$

1

Rl}j}jgdlp afoiildelm }fl }podoa}jgd jd }fl Ajpa|j} Ag|p} cgp @oi}jhgpl Aj}z

of 00

Leave a Comment