Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
51Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Ginsburg Dissent

Ginsburg Dissent

Ratings:

4.36

(28)
|Views: 237,656|Likes:
Published by Abby Ohlheiser
ginsb
ginsb

More info:

Published by: Abby Ohlheiser on Jun 30, 2014
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/21/2014

pdf

text

original

 
 
 """""""""""""""""  """""""""""""""""
# $%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45 6
7809.:6
; </; =%))'>&%>?
SU 
PREME
 
CO
RT
 
O
F
 
THE
 UN 
I
TE
D S
T
A
TE
S
8@)/ #-A-+4 (>= #-A-+B
0CDE7F 9.:GHDD; 0H$:HIF:C JK LHFDIL  F8M L.NF8 0H:E7$H0;
 HI FD
/; OHI7I7J8H:0 #-A-+4
!"
LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/;
HI FD
/
J8 G:7I JK $H:I7J:F:7 IJ ILH .87IHM 0IFIH0 $J.:I
 
JK FOOHFD0 KJ: ILH IH8IL $7:$.7I
 
 F8M
 
$J8H0IJ6F GJJM 0OH$7FDI7H0 $J:OJ:FI7J8
HI FD
/; OHI7I7J8H:0 #-A-+B
!"
0CDE7F 9.:GHDD; 0H$:HIF:C JK LHFDIL  F8M L.NF8 0H:E7$H0;
 HI FD
/
J8 G:7I JK $H:I7J:F:7 IJ ILH .87IHM 0IFIH0 $J.:I
 
JK FOOHFD0 KJ: ILH IL7:M $7:$.7I
 
P<Q>' -3; 23#4R
<
.0I7$H
6
7809.:6
; S%&T ST@U <
.0I7$H
0
JIJNFCJ:
 V@%>); (>= S%&T ST@U <
.0I7$H
9
:HCH:
 (>= <
.0I7$H
 F6F8
 V@%> () &@ (XX YQ& O(Z& 777A$A#; =%))'>&%>?/ 7> ( ='[%)%@> @\ )&(Z&X%>? YZ'(=&T; &T' $@QZ& T@X=) &T(& [@UU'Z[%(X '>&'Z]Z%)'); %>[XQ=%>? [@Z]@Z(&%@>); (X@>? S%&T](Z&>'Z)T%]) (>= )@X' ]Z@]Z%'&@Z)T%]); [(> @]& @Q& @\ (>^ X(S 1)(_%>? @>X^ &(` X(S)5 &T'^ VQ=?' %>[@U](&%YX' S%&T&T'%Z )%>['Z'X^ T'X= Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\)/ 0''
$%&'(
(& #BA4a/ $@U]'XX%>? ?@_'Z>U'>&(X %>&'Z')&) %> Q>%\@ZU [@U]X%(>[' S%&T &T' X(S; (>= =%)(=_(>&(?') &T(& Z'X%?%@>bY()'= @]&b@Q&) %U]@)' @> @&T'Z); T@X= >@ )S(^; &T' $@QZ& ='[%='); (& X'()& ST'> &T'Z' %) ( cX')) Z')&Z%[&%_' (X&'Z>(&%_'/d F>= )Q[T (> (X&'Z>(&%_'; &T' $@QZ& )Q??')&); &T'Z' (XS(^) S%XXY' ST'>'_'Z; %> X%'Q @\ &@XX%>? (> '>&'Z]Z%)' [X(%U%>? (
 
 
2 9.:GHDD
!"
 LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/ 6
7809.:6
; </; =%))'>&%>?
Z'X%?%@>bY()'= '`'U]&%@>; &T' ?@_'Z>U'>&;
)"'"(
 &T' ?'>'Z(X ]QYX%[; [(> ]%[e Q] &T' &(Y/ 0''
$%&'
; (& 4#A4-/
#
IT' $@QZ& =@') >@& ]Z'&'>= &T(& &T' K%Z)& FU'>=U'>&f) KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)' ='U(>=) Z'X%?%@>bY()'= ([[@UU@=(b&%@>) )@ '`&Z'U'; \@Z @QZ ='[%)%@>) X'(_' >@ =@QY& @> &T(& )[@Z'/ 0''
)%*+$
; (& BAg/ 7>)&'(=; &T' $@QZ& T@X=) &T(& $@>?Z')); %> &T' :'X%?%@Q) KZ''=@U :')&@Z(&%@> F[& @\ #aa- 1:K:F5; 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333YY
'& ,'-"
; =%[&(&'= &T' '`&Z(@Z=%>(Z^ Z'X%?%@>bY()'= '`'U]&%@>) &@=(^f) ='[%)%@> '>=@Z)')/ 7> &T' $@QZ&f) _%'S; :K:F ='U(>=) ([[@UU@b=(&%@> @\ ( \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>f) Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) >@ U(&&'Z &T' %U]([& &T(& ([[@UU@=(&%@> U(^ T(_' @> &T%Z=](Z&%') ST@ =@ >@& )T(Z' &T' [@Z]@Z(&%@> @S>'Z)f Z'X%?%@Q) \(%&Ti%> &T')' [()'); &T@Q)(>=) @\ S@U'> 'U]X@^'= Y^ L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')&@?( @Z =']'>='>&) @\ ]'Z)@>) &T@)' [@Z]@Z(&%@>) 'U]X@^/ O'Z)Q(='= &T(& $@>?Z'))'>([&'= :K:F &@ )'Z_' ( \(Z X')) Z(=%[(X ]QZ]@)'; (>= U%>=\QX @\ &T' T(_@[ &T' $@QZ&f) VQ=?U'>& [(> %>&Z@=Q['; 7 =%))'>&/ 7 cIT' (Y%X%&^ @\ S@U'> &@ ](Z&%[%](&' 'jQ(XX^ %> &T' '[@>@U%[ (>= )@[%(X X%\' @\ &T' 8(&%@> T() Y''> \([%X%&(&'= Y^ &T'%Z (Y%X%&^ &@ [@>&Z@X &T'%Z Z']Z@=Q[&%_' X%_')/d
 ./$%%'0 .$+'%&1220 2* 324&1'$,&'+% .$"
 _/
5$,'6
; +3+ ./ 0/ g--; g+B 1#aa25/ $@>?Z')) ([&'= @> &T(& Q>='Z)&(>=b
 iiiiii
#
IT' $@QZ& %>)%)&) %& T() T'X= >@>' @\ &T')' &T%>?); \@Z (>@&T'Z X'))Z')&Z%[&%_' (X&'Z>(&%_' %) (& T(>=* '`&'>=%>? (> '`%)&%>? ([[@UU@=(b&%@>; [QZZ'>&X^ X%U%&'= &@ Z'X%?%@Q) >@>]Z@\%& @Z?(>%k(&%@>); &@ '>[@Ub]()) [@UU'Z[%(X '>&'Z]Z%)')/ 0''
$%&'(
(& -A4/ G%&T &T(& ([[@UU@=(b&%@> '`&'>='=; &T' $@QZ& ())'Z&); cS@U'> S@QX= )&%XX Y' '>&%&X'= &@ (XX PK@@= (>= MZQ? F=U%>%)&Z(&%@>Rb(]]Z@_'= [@>&Z([']&%_') S%&T@Q& [@)& )T(Z%>?/d
 7%&'(
(& 4/ 7> &T' '>=; T@S'_'Z; &T' $@QZ& %) >@& )@ )QZ'/ 7> )&(Ze [@>&Z()& &@ &T' $@QZ&f) %>%&%(X 'U]T()%) @> &T%) ([[@UU@=(&%@>; %&QX&%U(&'X^ ='[X%>') &@ ='[%=' ST'&T'Z &T' T%?TX%?T&'= ([[@UU@=(&%@> %)'_'> X(S\QX/ 0''
$%&'(
(& 44 1cG' =@ >@& ='[%=' &@=(^ ST'&T'Z (>(]]Z@([T @\ &T%) &^]' [@U]X%') S%&T :K:F / / / /d5/
 
 
- $%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45 6
7809.:6
; </; =%))'>&%>?
%>? ST'>; () ](Z& @\ ( >(&%@>S%=' %>)QZ(>[' ]Z@?Z(U%>&'>='= &@ Y' [@U]Z'T'>)%_'; %& [(XX'= \@Z [@_'Z(?' @\ ]Z'_'>&%_' [(Z' Z')]@>)%_' &@ S@U'>f) >''=)/ $(ZZ^%>?@Q& $@>?Z'))f =%Z'[&%@>; &T' M'](Z&U'>& @\ L'(X&T (>=LQU(> 0'Z_%[') 1LL05; %> [@>)QX&(&%@> S%&T ]QYX%[ T'(X&T'`]'Z&); ]Z@UQX?(&'= Z'?QX(&%@>) Z'jQ%Z%>? ?Z@Q] T'(X&T ]X(>) &@ [@_'Z (XX \@ZU) @\ [@>&Z([']&%@> (]]Z@_'= Y^ &T' K@@= (>= MZQ? F=U%>%)&Z(&%@> 1KMF5/ IT' ?'>')%) @\ &T%)[@_'Z(?' )T@QX= '>X%?T&'> &T' $@QZ&f) Z')@XQ&%@> @\ &T')' [()')/  F IT' F\\@Z=(YX' $(Z' F[& 1F$F5; %> %&) %>%&%(X \@ZU; )]'[%b\%'= &TZ'' [(&'?@Z%') @\ ]Z'_'>&%_' [(Z' &T(& T'(X&T ]X(>) UQ)& [@_'Z (& >@ (=='= [@)& &@ &T' ]X(> ](Z&%[%](>& @Z Y'>'\%[%(Z^/
2
 O(Z&%[QX(Z )'Z_%[') S'Z' &@ Y' Z'[@UU'>='= Y^ &T' ./ 0/ OZ'_'>&%_' 0'Z_%[') I()e K@Z['; (> %>=']'>=b'>& ](>'X @\ '`]'Z&)/ IT' )[T'U' T(= ( X(Z?' ?(]; T@Sb'_'Zl %& X'\& @Q& ]Z'_'>&%_' )'Z_%[') &T(& cU(>^ S@U'>f)T'(X&T (=_@[(&') (>= U'=%[(X ]Z@\'))%@>(X) Y'X%'_' (Z'[Z%&%[(XX^ %U]@Z&(>&/d #++ $@>?/ :'[/ 2gg4# 1233a5 1)&(&'bU'>& @\ 0'>/ 9@`'Z5/ I@ [@ZZ'[& &T%) @_'Z)%?T&; 0'>(&@Z 9(ZY(Z( N%eQX)e% %>&Z@=Q['= &T' G@U'>f) L'(X&T  FU'>=U'>&; ST%[T (=='= &@ &T' F$Ff) U%>%UQU [@_'Z(?'Z'jQ%Z'U'>&) ( >'S [(&'?@Z^ @\ ]Z'_'>&%_' )'Z_%[') )]'[%\%[&@ S@U'>f) T'(X&T/ G@U'> ](%= )%?>%\%[(>&X^ U@Z' &T(> U'> \@Z ]Z'_'>&%_'[(Z'; &T' (U'>=U'>&f) ]Z@]@>'>&) >@&'=l %> \([&; [@)&
 iiiiii
2
0'' 42 ./ 0/ $/ h-33??A#-1(51#5A1-5 1?Z@Q] T'(X&T ]X(>) UQ)& ]Z@b_%=' [@_'Z(?'; S%&T@Q& [@)& )T(Z%>?; \@Z 1#5 ['Z&(%> c'_%='>['bY()'= %&'U) @Z )'Z_%[')d Z'[@UU'>='= Y^ &T' ./ 0/ OZ'_'>&%_' 0'Z_%[') I()eK@Z['l 125 %UUQ>%k(&%@>) Z'[@UU'>='= Y^ (> (=_%)@Z^ [@UU%&&'' @\ &T'$'>&'Z) \@Z M%)'()' $@>&Z@X (>= OZ'_'>&%@>l (>= 1-5 cS%&T Z')]'[& &@ %>\(>&); [T%X=Z'>; (>= (=@X')['>&); '_%='>['b%>\@ZU'= ]Z'_'>&%_' [(Z'(>= )[Z''>%>?) ]Z@_%='= \@Z %> &T' [@U]Z'T'>)%_' ?Q%='X%>') )Q]]@Z&'=Y^ &T' L'(X&T :')@QZ[') (>= 0'Z_%[') F=U%>%)&Z(&%@>d5/

Activity (51)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
Mike Hargrove reviewed this
Rated 5/5
@CherieKozisox's facile representation of the issue shows both a lack of understanding related to the issue at hand and a disturbing distancing herself from the very notion of what it means to be a civilization and society. Taking the attitude, particularly in the economic climate present today, that as a Hobby Lobby employee, if you "don't like it, find a new employer" is insipid on its face. One should not have to make a decision of where to work in order to have their rights protected. What of those people who genuinely like working at Hobby Lobby (though I can't imagine who they might be other than the religiously fanatic)? Should they have to leave their employment to receive their rights under the law?

Also, there are many things in our society that many of us don't support (e.g. wars), would rather not fund (crop subsidies), or would like to outright ban (tax exempt status for religious organizations), but a requirement for being part of a society is that you don't always get your way. And... you have to sometimes pay for what others want and value, even if you don't. I heartily encourage Ms. Kozisox to take a breath, dispense with the vitriole and chill for a few minutes. I know it's hard to breathe with your head up your ass, so perhaps if you pulled it out for a few minutes you might get some more oxygen to your brain.
Gregory Greenleaf reviewed this
Rated 5/5
It's not like Hobby Lobby was saying no to all contraceptives, just 4 out of 20 that they found to be non-Biblical. It's important to note that not every corporation or business out there will receive the same ruling as this one. Each case is taken into account by their merits, and Hobby Lobby was found to be reasonable in their request.
CherieKozisox reviewed this
Rated 5/5
"for profit corporations have no right to push their beliefs on others or deny them coverage because of their own beliefs, a shame when our court system is bought out by big money and no one seems to care" Get a grip already! "NO RIGHT TO PUSH THEIR BELIEFS AND DENY COVERAGE"? They're not PUSHING anything....unlike Americans being forced into purchasing a product (Obamacare) we don't want and therefore DENYING me my CHOICE? They're simply stating 'due to OUR OWN religious beliefs, we WILL NOT PROVIDE the coverage. Don't like it? Find an employer who will (and good luck with that since many companies are firing or laying off or cutting hours to avoid paying your masters premiums). Better yet, grow up and purchase your own birth control. Remember your uterus is none of my business and THEREFORE I insist.......NOT MY FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY! Why is it you posting have no problem with Muslims demanding Americans submit to Sharia Law (their RELIGIOUS beliefs) with all their 'tolerant and peaceful' beheadings, murder of women and rape of children regardless of anyone else's opposition to them, yet when a company stands firm on their moral beliefs, you demonize them? Adults buy their own birth control. That senile woman needs to retire.
Alison Jones reviewed this
Rated 5/5
Today's decision is an embarrassment with far-reaching implications, much like the court's recent decisions on campaign contributions.
Chris DiMarco liked this
Jim Symon liked this
Tom Pisarek liked this
BridgetSimpson added this note
I will be reading this again a few times, I'm sure, as I read the ACA. I see no compelling reason to continue to use employers as the middlemen of customers and insurance providers. Separating employers and health care (beyond workmen's compensation) would make the religion of the owners irrelevant- as they should be.
PaulAckermann added this note
The issue is NOT imposoing religious values on others. It is the government not forcing people to support a lifestyle choice. If you want to take birth control pills or abortion pills, that is your business. If do not even care if you want to take crack-cocaine. It is your body. But do not expect me to subsidize your choice.
StevenTDaniel added this note
The majority opinion is so very wrong. With women's rights it seems nothing is sacred - can't have equal pay, no paid maternity leave, hiring & advancement discrimination, and now a new loop hole to deny them birth control. I'm surprised an amendment isn't forthcoming to deny them the vote.

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->