You are on page 1of 4

Menelas, Robero Mike

80402-053/A047-031-788
M.V.C.I.
555 Geo Drive
Philipsburg, PA 16866
Name: Menelas, Roberto Mike
.b.U8gattm8ut 0Ju8Uc8
LXO0uUVO LU0O mrIgation KOVOW
cardc/ !mm/gatlcnHppcals
Ogccc/tbcCblc/C/cr\
5107 Leburg Pik, Suite 2000
Fall Church, Vriia 20530
DHU LIT./York Co. Prison/YOR
3400 Concord Rd.
York, PA 17402
A 047-031-788
Date of this Notice: 4/28/2014
Enclosed is a copy of the Board's decision and order in the above-referenced case.
Enclosure
Panel Members:
Hofman, Sharon
Sincerely,
Donna Carr
Chief Clerk
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
.b. 0gaIlm00l 0JB8fc0
Executive Ofce fr Immigration Review
Falls Church, Virginia ZJ
File: A04 7 031 788 - York, PA
In re: ROBERTO MIKE MENELAS
U REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS
APPEAL
ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT: Pro se
ON BEHALF OF DHS: Jon D. Staples
Assistant Chief Counsel
APPLICATION: Terination of proceedings
Decision of the Board oflmmigration Appeals
Date:
K 2 8 2014
The respondent, a native and citizen of Hati, who was previously grated lawl permanent
resident status in the United States, has appealed fom the Immigration Judge's decision dated
Januay 28, 2014. The Immigration Judge fund the respondent removable and fund him
ineligible fr relief fom removal. Te respondent has appealed the Immigration Judge's
decision, assering that he is a Un.ited States citizen, having derived citizenship through his
mother. The record will be remanded.
Wile the Immigation Judge issued an order of removal that indicates it is a sum ay of a
oral decision, that decision is not in the record. The decision of the Immigration Judge may be
either oral or witen. However, even a tanscribed oral decision must include fndings as to
removability, provide the reasons fr granting or denying any request, and end with the
Immigration Judge's order. In addition, the transcribed oral decision must be separate fom the
remainder of the transcript. ee 8 C.F.R. 1240. 2(a) Mot/er of A-P, 22 l Dec. 468 (BIA
1999).
Alteratively, if the Immigration Judge intended this decision to be a summa decision, it
would not be proper in this case. A suary decision may only be issued by a Immigation
Judge in removal proceedings in lieu of a separate written or trascribed oral .decision when the
respondent has expressly admitted to both the fctual allegations and the chages of removability
and, either (1) the respondent's ineligibility fr _any frm of relief is clearly established on the
pleadings, or (2) the respondent chooses not to apply fr any fr of relief fr which it appeas
he may be eligible, afer being given an appropriate advisement and an opportunity to do so, or
(3)the respondent only applies fr, and is granted, the relief of voluntary depaure. Otherwise, a
fll decision is needed to provide the fctual and legal basis fr the decision. ee 8 C.F.R.
1240.12(a), (b); Mo//ero] A-P-, supro.
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
A047 031 788
Because the respondent assers that he is a United States citizen, a summay decision is not
appropriate in the present case. The Immigration Judge must prepare a decision addressing the
respondent's citizenship claim. As no separate oral decision is in the record, we will remad
these proceedings to enable the Immigration Judge to prepare one.
Accordingly, the fllowing order will be entered.
ORER: The record is remanded to the Immigration Judge fr frher proceedings
consistent with the fregoing opinion.
Z
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
1D LDO MBLLOI O1
MNLLA, HULH1 MKL
HOSQODODL
- . ..
.
1M1GHA11N LUH1
4 LNLHU H, U1JL Z
YHK, A 4Z
LBSO NO' A4o
1N HLMVA HLLLLU1NG
Y , p QHLH b 1HL
1 : B BI_ O1 LDO OIBJ OC1S1OD ODLOIO OD
/J
1D1S mOmOIBDUm 1S SOJOJ_ 1OI LDO CODVOD1ODCO O1 L 11 LDO
QLOCOO1DgS SDOUJ DO BQQOBJO OI IOOQODO, LDO OI OC1S1OD w1JJ DOCOmO
O OBJ OQ1D1OD 1D LDO OBSO .
.
1DO IOSQODODL wBS OIOIO IOmOVO 1IOm LDO UD1LO LBLOS LO
HA11 OI 1D LDO BJLOIDBL1VO LO .
.

HODLS BQQJ1CBL1OO 1OI VOJUDLBI_ OQBILUIO wBS OD1O BD
IOSgODODL wBS OIOIO IOmOVO LO HA111 OI 1D LDO
BJLOLBL1VO LO
HOSQODODL`S BQQJ1CBL1OD 1OI VO1UDLBI_ OQBILQIO wBS gIBDLO UDL1J
UQOD QOSL1Dg B DOD in LDO BmOUDL O1 $
w1CD BD BJLOIDBLO OIOI O1 IGOVBJ LO HA11J.
HOSQODODL`S BQQJ1CBL1OD 1 QI;
j ) AS_JU wBS 3 }gIBDLO }OD1O3 }w1LDIBwD.
j | w1DDOJ1Dg O1 IOmOVJ wBS }gIBDLO 3 }OD1O 3 }w1LDIBw.
j ) A WB1VOI UDOI OCL1OD wBS 3 }gIBDLO 3 }OD1O }w1LDIBw.
j | LBDCOJJBL1OD O1 IOOVBJ UDOI SOCL1OD Z4A3B} wBS 3 }gIBLO } OD1O
3 }w1LDTBwD.
HOSQODODL'S BQQ11CBL1OD 1OI'
j ) LBDCOJ1BL1OD UDOI SOCL1OD Z4A3D}(1) wBS 3 } gIBDLO } OD1O
3 } w1LDIBwD 11 gIBDLO 1L 1S O IOIO LDBL LDO IOSQODODL DO 1SSUO
BJJ BgQIOQI1BLO OCUODCS DOCOSSBI_ LO g1VO O11OCL LO LD1S OIOI
LBDCOJJBL1OD UDOI SOCL1OD Z4A3D} 2) wBS 3 }gIBDLO 3 }O1O
3 }w1LDIBwD 11 gIBDLO 1L 1S OIOIO LDBL LDO IOSQODODL DO 1SSUO
BJJ BQQIOQI1BLO OCUmODLS DOCOSSBI_ LO g1VO O11OCL LO LD1S OIOI.
A_USLmODL O1 LBLUS UDOI OCL1OD wBS 3 }gIBDLO 3 }OD1O
3 }w1LDIBwD. 11 gIBDLO 1L 1S OIOIO LDBL LDO IOSQODODL DO 1SSUO
BJJ BQQIOQI1BLO OCUmODLS DOCOSSBI_ LO g1VO O11OCL

LO LD1S OIOI.
HOSQODODL`G BQQJ1CBL1OD O1 3 } w1LDDOJ1Dg O1 IGOVBJ 3 } O1OIIBJ O1
IOmOVBJ UDOI AIL1CJO 111 O LDO LODVODL1OD AgB1DSL 1OILUIO wBS
3 } gIBDLO 3 } OD1O 3 } w1LDIBwD.
HOSQODODL`S SLBLUS wBS IOSC1DO UDOI SOCL1OD Z4
HOSQODODL 1S BO1LLO LO LDO UD1LO LBLOS BS B UDL1J
AS B COD1L1OD O1 BO1SS1OD, IOSQODODL 1S LO QOSL B $ DOD
HOSQODOD 2 KDOw1DgJ_ 11O B 1I1VOJOUS BB_1Um BQQ1CBL1OD B1LOI QIOQOI
DOL1CO. .
.
HOSQODODL wBS BV1SO O1 LDO J1m1LBL1OD OD 1SClOL1ODBI_ IOJ1O1 1OI
1B1JULO LO BQQOBI BS IOIO 1D LDO 101gIBL1OD UgO`S OIBJ OC1S1OD.
] IOCOO1DgS wOIO LOIm1DBLO.
| LDOI'
DBLO' UB Z, ZJ4
. ,, , , ,,,1,; .
AQQOBJ' WB1VO/G AQQOBJ .\, .,

UgO
:

.=-.
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

You might also like