(658.5817) NENIG
- The UKGovernment says the consultation isbased on the recommendations of theCommittee on Radioactive WasteManagement (CoRWM) for a deeprepository - however critics say theGovernment is ignoring CoRWM'sreservations about a repository, its callfor much greater research, forconsideration of interim storage and itsstatements that it was only consideringthe management of existing wastes, notwastes from any new reactors.The consultation also looks at theconcept of 'voluntarism' - wherecommunities express an interest inhousing a possible repository ratherthan having on forced upon them - andthe technical aspects of developing anunderground repository. The details of apossible repository given in theconsultation documents are very similarto those produced by Nirex in the 1990sfor Sellafield.
Scottish Executive says no
The Scottish Executive has refused totake part in the consultation - rejectingany idea of a deep undergroundrepository in Scotland. Environmentsecretary Richard Lochhead said herecognized the challenge of dealing withradioactive waste but they did notaccept "that geological disposal is theright way forward. This is a matter ofprinciple for us and I have no doubt thatpublic opinion in Scotland supports ourview." He said they supported CoRWM'srecommendations for interim storageand further research on long-term wastemanagement. "This out of sight out ofmind policy should not extend toScotland." Mr Lochhead said theexecutive would work with the UKgovernment and other devolvedadministrations on waste managementissues where they had sharedobjectives. The LibDem environmentspokesman, Mike Rumbles, commentedthat the executive now had "a duty totell the people of Scotland whatproposals they have for dealing withScotland's share of the nuclear wasteburden."
Cumbria says 'no' to Scottish wastes
Following the Scottish Executive'swithdrawal from the consultationCumbria County Councillors have saidthey will oppose taking Scottishradioactive wastes to Sellafield. TheHunterston and Torness reactors sendspent fuel to Sellafield for reprocessingand while Dounreay manages its ownwastes, there are proposals to sendspent fuel from the site to Sellafield.Timothy Heslop, executive member onthe county council for nuclear issues,said the Scottish Executive had taken itsstand and "let them accept that theirwaste is not coming across the border."Although it has agreed to take part inthe consultation the Welshadministration in Cardiff made it clearthey have not agreed in any way to arepository being build in Wales.The Nuclear Decommissioning Authoritywelcomed the Government'sconsultation and noted the responsefrom the Scottish Government. TheNDAsaid it would have to "carefullyconsider" this news.
No choices yet
Environment minister Ian Pearson thisweek denied that Sellafield had alreadybeen chosen by the Government as thesite for a deep underground wasterepository. Mr Pearson said they hadnot started the site selection processand still needed to decide how siteselection will be made.The Nuclear Free Local Authorities gavea cautious welcome to the consultation.NFLAchair Mike Rumney said theGovernment's plan for new reactors wasdriving the timetable for radioactivewaste management and this could leadto a loss of public confidence.The inspector on the 1995 planninginquiry into Nirex plans for a deeprepository at Sellafield has said the siteis unsuitable for such a development.Mr Chris McDonald said the siteselection process at the time wasflawed, not taking safety as the mostimportant factor and the irrational desireto build a repository as close aspossible to Sellafield. The site is notsuitable for a repository "andinvestigations should be movedelsewhere".Full details of the consultation, that endson 2nd November 2007, are availableat:www.defra.gov.uk/environment/radioactivity/waste/hilw/index.htm
Source:
N-Base Briefing 532, 1 July2007
Contact:
NENIG, The Quarries, Gruting,Bridge of Walls, Shetland ZE2 9NR, UKTel: +44 1595 810266Email: briefing@n-base.org.ukWeb: http://www.n-base.org.uk
SCOTLAND OPTS OUT OF NEW WASTE CONSULTATION
The UK Government and the Welsh and Northern Ireland administrations launched a newconsultation on “Managing Radioactive Waste Safely: A framework for implementing geologicaldisposal.” However the Scottish Executive has refused to take part, arguing that it rejectsbuilding a deep underground waste repository.
The U.K. government Thursday gave the preliminary go-ahead to the design of four nuclear reactors, even though ithas yet to decide whether to formally support nuclear power.Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., Areva, GE Energy, andWestinghouse Electric Co. have all submitted individualdesigns for the four reactors. Before the generic designs ofthe nuclear power plants are completely approved or pre-licensed, the government's new Department for Business,Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, established by newPrime Minister Gordon Brown, must consider the designsmore carefully.The initial stages of pre-licensing are taking place at thesame time and are subject to the outcome of a nuclearconsultation, which is expected to close in October. The U.K.government previously gave its support for nuclear powerafter a public consultation, and claimed new nuclear reactorswere needed in order to meet the U.K.'s climate changeobjectives, while at the same time securing reliable energysupplies. But the government had to launch a furtherconsultation after environmental group Greenpeace won alegal challenge in February which found that thegovernment's initial consultation was "legally flawed".
Dow Jones, 5 July 2007
No decision yet on nuclear power, but go-ahead to 4 nuclear reactor designs.
Leave a Comment