7379=/82@7

HC3 AQYNQ^_ [R G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX 8[YYU``QQ

<FCA3 G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX 6P&>[O 8[YYU``QQ
=3. =HRQSU QI UKH 1QOOLUUHH IQS UKH '
PG
2LTUSLFU DPG ALSJLPLD 0HDFK
CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC
21375<;?940 G`M`Q GQZM`[^ <^MZW JMSZQ^ TMP MZZ[aZOQP TU_ UZ`QZ`U[Z `[ ^aZ R[^ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8TMU^YMZ MSMUZ_` `TQZ&8TMU^YMZ =M^e 7eXQ^' ?Z_`QMP [R _QQWUZS MZ[`TQ^ `Q^Y% 7eXQ^
QXQO`QP `[ N[c [a` UZ RMb[^ [R 8a^`U_ 8[XSM`Q% M X[ZS&_`MZPUZS YQYNQ^ [R G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX
8[YYU``QQ' IU^SUZUM 7QMOT ^Q\^Q_QZ`QP M ZQM^ _a\Q^YMV[^U`e [R `TQ PQXQSM`Q_ R[^ `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` O[ZbQZ`U[Z% cTUOT N^QMW_ P[cZ M_ R[XX[c_'
6OO[YMOW -2 b[`Q_ .'/"
>MY\`[Z ., b[`Q_ /'+"
BQc\[^` BQc_ **- b[`Q_ *,'*"
B[^R[XW 10 b[`Q_ *)')"
B[^`TMY\`[Z *. b[`Q_ *'0"
IU^SUZUM 7QMOT ..+ b[`Q_ /,'-"
>;>18 $XJUIPVU @JSHJOJB 2FBDI%0 +)/ WPUFT +.(-#
?9?/6. -,% WQUHT &%%"
HTQ a_Q [R _XM`UZS TM_ M TU_`[^e UZ IU^SUZUM \[XU`UO_ PM`UZS NMOW `[ FQb[Xa`U[ZM^e `UYQ_% cTQ^Q
YQYNQ^_ [R `TQ IU^SUZUM >[a_Q [R 7a^SQ__Q_ c[aXP _QZP PQXQSM`Q_ `[ `TQ <U^_` MZP GQO[ZP
8[Z`UZQZ`MX 8[ZS^Q__ `[ ^Q\^Q_QZ` `TQ cUXX [R `TQ YMV[^U`e'
?Z Y[^Q ^QOQZ` `UYQ_% `TQ \^MO`UOQ [R _XM`UZS cM_ a_QP `[ _QZP PQXQSM`Q_ `[ `TQ G`M`Q
8[ZbQZ`U[Z PaQ `[ XUYU`M`U[Z_ \XMOQP [Z `TQ _UfQ [R PQXQSM`U[Z_ UY\[_QP Ne `TQ DM^`e DXMZ% M_
[a`XUZQP UZ 6^`UOXQ I???% GQO`U[Z > [R `TQ DM^`e DXMZ' 7e `TQ QM^Xe \M^` [R `TQ +)))_% `TQ_Q
*
XUYU`_ cQ^Q QM_QP UZ MZ QRR[^` `[ MXX[c Y[^Q UZPUbUPaMX_ `[ \M^`UOU\M`Q UZ O[ZbQZ`U[Z_% M_ `TQ
\^MO`UOQ cM_ UZO^QM_UZSXe a_QP M_ M `[[X `[ ^QY[bQ [\\[_U`U[Z b[`Q_ R^[Y aZU` ^Q\^Q_QZ`M`U[Z'
HTa_ cTUXQ hUZ_`^aO`U[Zi cM_ _\QOURUOMXXe \^[TUNU`QP Ne `TQ \M^`e \XMZ% h_XM`UZSi _`UXX ^QYMUZQP
M \Q^YU__UNXQ \^MO`UOQ aZPQ^ F[NQ^`_ FaXQ_ [R C^PQ^ BQcXe FQbU_QP #FCBF$'
LQ` `TQ \^MO`UOQ [R h_XM`UZSi U_ Z[` cTM` U_ M` U__aQ UZ QU`TQ^ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT [^ UZ `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO`
8[YYU``QQ' JTM` ^QYMUZ_ M` U__aQ U_ `TQ R[XX[cUZS3
*' JM_ `TQ b[`Q `[ _XM`Q OMZPUPM`Q_ M` `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT aZU` O[YYU``QQ \^[\Q^5
+' JM_ `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT YM__ YQQ`UZS \^[\Q^Xe MZP aZUR[^YXe O[ZPaO`QP5
,' JM_ `TQ b[`Q M` `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8[ZbQZ`U[Z `[ ^QO[SZUfQ `TQ PQXQSM`Q_ _XM`QP [RR R^[Y
IU^SUZUM 7QMOT \^[\Q^5
1
lnstructlon of de|egatlons - where the de|egatlon ls lnstructed by a unlt or dlstrlct commlttee to vote a certaln
way -- ls seclflca||y rohlblted by the arty |an under Art. vlll, Sec. P, sub. 4
&
-' JM_ `TQ b[`Q [R `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8[YYU``QQ `[ [bQ^`a^Z `TQ ^Q_aX` [R `TQ O[ZbQZ`U[Z
\^[\Q^5
7M_QP [Z `TQ QbUPQZOQ NQX[c% cQ RUZP `TQ R[XX[cUZS3
&$ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` ;dQOa`UbQ 8[YYU``QQ PUP Z[` U__aQ M \^[\Q^ OMXX R[^ `TQ )1 AMe +)*-
YQQ`UZS cTQ^Q `TQ ^Q_aX`_ [R `TQ O[ZbQZ`U[Z cQ^Q bMOM`QP% \Q^ F[NQ^`_ FaXQ_ [R C^PQ^
BQcXe FQbU_QP #FCBF$ MZP `TQ G`M`Q DM^`e DXMZ' 6^`UOXQ I??% GQO' 7% _aN' * #\' *0$ [R
`TQ DXMZ _`M`Q_ `TM` `TQ OMXX h_TMXX UZOXaPQ `TQ MSQZPM R[^ `TQ YQQ`UZS'i FCBF U_
Q]aMXXe OXQM^ UZ ??' +1&,. `TM` MSQZPM_ R[^ _\QOUMX YQQ`UZS_ Ya_` hOXQM^Xe MZP
_\QOURUOMXXe PQ_O^UNQ#_$ `TQ _aNVQO` YM``Q^ [R `TQ Y[`U[Z_ [^ U`QY_ [R Na_UZQ__ `[ NQ
N^[aST` a\'i BQU`TQ^ [R `TQ_Q `c[ bQ^e NM_UO O^U`Q^UM cQ^Q YQ` UZ `TQ U__aMZOQ [R `TQ
OMXX R[^ M _\QOUMX YQQ`UZS'
LQ` QbQZ UR `TQ_Q \^Q^Q]aU_U`Q_ cQ^Q \^[\Q^Xe YQ`% QSJDPL[DULQPDN OHHULPJT FDPPQU
KDWH UKHLS SHTVNUT QWHSUVSPHG EZ D WQUH QI DP HYHFVULWH FQOOLUUHH [^ M Ra`a^Q
YQQ`UZS [R `TQ N[Pe M_ M cT[XQ cU`T[a` R[XX[cUZS `TQ \^[OQPa^Q_ QYNQPPQP UZ FCBF%
`TQU^ [cZ [^SMZUfM`U[ZMX NeXMc_% [^ `TQ DM^`e DXMZ' HTQ M\\^[\^UM`Q bQZaQ `[
OTMXXQZSQ `TQ ^Q_aX`_ [R `TQ O[ZbQZ`U[Z cM_ M` `TQ O[ZbQZ`U[Z U`_QXR% [^ `T^[aST `TQ
\^[bU_U[Z_ MXX[cQP UZ `TQ NeXMc_'
'$ HTQ U__aQ MPP^Q__QP MN[bQ U_ _eY\`[YM`UO [R MZ U__aQ ^QSM^PUZS `TQ 8^QPQZ`UMX_
8[YYU``QQ [R `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8[ZbQZ`U[Z [Z +/ 6\^UX +)*- g _\QOURUOMXXe% cTQ`TQ^ `TQ
8^QPQZ`UMX_ 8[YYU``QQ U_ QY\[cQ^QP `[ _QM` PQXQSM`Q_ MOO[^PUZS `[ `TQ FaXQ_ [R `TQ
8[ZbQZ`U[Z' HTU_ MZ_cQ^ U_ QY\TM`UOMXXe OXQM^ UZ FCBF DM^` ??% 6^`' K??% GQO' 0*3
+
AIFO UIJT SFQPSU PG UIF DSFEFOUJBM DPNNJUUFF JT QSFTFOUFE JU JT SFBE FJUIFS CZ
UIF DIBJSNBO PG UIF DPNNJUUFF PS CZ UIF SFBEJOH TFDSFUBSZ& PS PGGJDJBM SFBEFS& JG
UIFSF JT POF( 6O BMM DBTFT& JU& BOE BMM PUIFS SFQPSUT& TIPVME CF SFBE GSPN UIF
QMBUGPSN( AIFO UIF DIBJSNBO PG B DPNNJUUFF DBOOPU SFBE TP BT UP CF IFBSE&
UIF SFQPSU TIPVME CF SFBE CZ B SFBEJOH TFDSFUBSZ& PS PGGJDJBM SFBEFS& XIP
TIPVME CF BQQPJOUFE JO FWFSZ MBSHF DPOWFOUJPO& TPMFMZ GPS UIF QVSQPTF PG
SFBEJOH SFTPMVUJPOT& SFQPSUT& FUD( 6G UIFSF JT B DBTF PG DPOUFTU CFUXFFO UXP TFUT
PG EFMFHBUFT BOE UIFSF JT TFSJPVT EPVCU BT UP XIJDI JT FOUJUMFE UP SFDPHOJUJPO&
UIF DPNNJUUFF TIPVME PNJU CPUI GSPN UIF MJTU BOE SFQPSU UIF GBDU PG UIF DPOUFTU(
6G UIF DPNNJUUFF& IPXFWFS& UIJOLT UIF DPOUFTU OPU KVTUJGJFE& JU TIPVME JHOPSF JU
BOE FOUFS PO UIF MJTU UIF OBNFT PG UIF MFHJUJNBUF EFMFHBUFT( $)% 1 NPUJPO TIPVME
CF NBEF UP BDDFQU PS BEPQU UIF SFQPSU& XIJDI& BGUFS JU JT TUBUFE CZ UIF DIBJS& JT
PQFO UP EFCBUF BOE BNFOENFOU( $*% 9P POF DBO WPUF XIPTF OBNF JT OPU PO
UIF MJTU PG EFMFHBUFT SFQPSUFE CZ UIF DPNNJUUFF( $+% ?QPO UIF NPUJPO UP
TVCTUJUVUF POF EFMFHBUJPO GPS BOPUIFS& OFJUIFS POF DBO WPUF( =P VQPO B NPUJPO
UP TUSJLF PVU UIF OBNFT PG B EFMFHBUJPO XIPTF TFBUT BSF DPOUFTUFE UIFZ DBOOPU
WPUF( 2VU VQPO UIF NBJO NPUJPO UP BDDFQU UIF SFQPSU& $,% BMM QFSTPOT XIPTF
OBNFT BSF PO UIF MJTU PG NFNCFST BT SFQPSUFE CZ UIF DPNNJUUFF BOE BNFOEFE
CZ UIF DPOWFOUJPO BSF FOUJUMFE UP WPUF& BOE UIFZ BMPOF( AIFO UIJT SFQPSU IBT
2
htt://www.ru|eson|lne.com/rror-12.htm
'
CFFO BEPQUFE& UIF QSFTJEFOU TIPVME JNNFEJBUFMZ DBMM VQPO UIF QSPHSBN
DPNNJUUFF GPS B SFQPSU( >IF DIBJSNBO PG UIBU DPNNJUUFF TVCNJUT UIF QSJOUFE
QSPHSBN BOE NPWFT& PS TPNFPOF FMTF NPWFT& JUT BEPQUJPO( $-% >IJT JT PQFO UP
EFCBUF BOE BNFOENFOU& BOE XIFO PODF BEPQUFE CZ B NBKPSJUZ WPUF DBOOPU CF
EFWJBUFE GSPN FYDFQU CZ B UXP'UIJSET WPUF PG UIPTF WPUJOH& PS CZ B NBKPSJUZ
WPUF PG UIF FOSPMMFE NFNCFSTIJQ( $OVNCFST BEEFE GPS DMBSJUZ%
HTQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8^QPQZ`UMX_ 8[YYU``QQ ^QMP [a` U`_ ^Q\[^` cU`T[a` OTMXXQZSUZS MZe
ZMYQ_ _aNYU``QP R[^ O[Z_UPQ^M`U[Z `[ `TQ O[YYU``QQ M_ M cT[XQ' HTU_ RMO` U_
aZPU_\a`QP Ne N[`T \M^`UQ_' ?Z cTUOT OM_Q% `TQ R[XX[cUZS \^[OQPa^Q MOO[^PUZS `[
FCBF U_ R[XX[cQP3
*' 6 Y[`U[Z cM_ YMPQ `[ MOOQ\` `TQ ^Q\[^`'
+' HT[_Q ZMYQ_ XU_`QP [Z `TQ ^Q\[^` cQ^Q QZ`U`XQP `[ b[`Q Ne bU^`aQ [R ^QYMUZUZS
aZOTMXXQZSQP Ne `TQ 8^QPQZ`UMX 8[YYU``QQ'
,' B[ Y[`U[Z_ `[ _`^UWQ [^ _aN_`U`a`Q cQ^Q \^[RRQ^QP'
-' HTQ Y[`U[Z `[ MP[\` `TQ 8^QPQZ`UMX_ 8[YYU``QQ ^Q\[^` \M__QP'
.' CZOQ MP[\`QP% M +(, b[`Q U_ ^Q]aU^QP `[ [bQ^`a^Z'
A[^Q[bQ^% UZ M ^aXUZS PM`QP *+ 6aSa_` +)**% =QZQ^MX 8[aZ_QX _\QOURUOMXXe _`M`Q_ hCZOQ
`TQ 8^QPQZ`UMX_ 8[YYU``QQ ^Q\[^` U_ MP[\`QP Ne YMV[^U`e b[`Q% U` NQO[YQ_ `TQ [RRUOUMX
^[XX [R b[`UZS YQYNQ^_ [R `TQ 8[ZbQZ`U[Z R[^ `TQ O[ZPaO` [R MXX [RRUOUMX Na_UZQ__'i
,
B[ b[`Q cM_ `MWQZ `[ [bQ^`a^Z `TQ ^Q_aX`_ [R `TQ 8^QPQZ`UMX_ 8[YYU``QQ ^Q\[^`% Z[^
cQ^Q ZMYQ_ [^ PQXQSM`U[Z_ OTMXXQZSQP Ne QU`TQ^ \M^`e bUM Y[`U[Z_' HTQ^QR[^Q% UKH '
PG
2LTUSLFU 1QPWHPULQP 1SHGHPULDNT 1QOOLUUHH DFUHG RSQRHSNZ# DPG UKH WQUH UQ
DFFHRU UKH SHRQSU QI UKH 1SHGHPULDNT 1QOOLUUHH XDT RSQRHSNZ RHSIQSOHG$
($ DQ^`MUZUZS `[ `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT =CD% `TQ ]aQ_`U[Z cM_ ^MU_QP M_ `[ cTQ`TQ^ [^ Z[` `TQ
OMXX R[^ `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT AM__ AQQ`UZS cM_ \^[\Q^Xe OMXXQP' BH EHNLHWH UKDU UKH
ALSJLPLD 0HDFK FDNN XDT RSQRHSNZ LTTVHG$
)$ DQ^`MUZUZS `[ `TQ a_Q [R _XM`UZS% UKHSH LT PQUKLPJ LP UKH >UDUH ;DSUZ ;NDP UKDU
RSQKLELUT UKH VTH QI TNDULPJ UQ GHUHSOLPH GHNHJDULQPT UQ GLTUSLFU QS TUDUH
FQPWHPULQPT$
*$ DQ^`MUZUZS `[ `TQ DPOEVDU [R `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT AM__ AQQ`UZS UZ `TQ _QXQO`U[Z [R
PQXQSM`Q_ `[ `TQ PU_`^UO` O[ZbQZ`U[Z% `TQ [\\[_U`U[Z [R `TQ _XM`UZS \^[\Q^Xe Y[`U[ZQP R[^
M PUbU_U[Z [R `TQ T[a_Q' HTU_ Y[`U[Z g cTUOT ^Q]aU^Q_ M \^QOU_Q O[aZ` g cM_ \Q^R[^YQP
Ne TMZP_ ^MU_QP cU`T Z[ `QXXQ^_ [`TQ^ `TMZ `TQ ;XQO`U[Z 8[YYU``QQ #`e\UOMXXe h`QXXQ^_i
M^Q M\\[UZ`QP R^[Y N[`T OMY\_ `[ QZ_a^Q M RMU^ b[`Q% [^ Y[^Q MOOa^M`QXe \^QbQZ` [ZQ
[^ N[`T _UPQ_ R^[Y MXXQSUZS UY\^[\^UQ`UQ_ g `TU_ cM_ Z[` P[ZQ TQ^Q$'
3
htt://rv.org/sltes/defau|t/fl|es/20110812_CC8u|lng_ConductLegls|atlveulstrlctCommlttee.df
(
FCBF _`M`Q_ `TM` hTMZP_ ^MU_QPi U_ MZ M\\^[\^UM`Q YQ`T[P [R O[aZ`UZS b[`Q_% M b[`Q
cTUOT OM^^UQP cU`T /-, g ,). cU`T 2-1 \M^`UOU\MZ`_ \^Q_QZ` MOO[^PUZS `[ `TQ YUZa`Q_
[R `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT AM__ AQQ`UZS% _XUST`Xe [bQ^ `TQ +(, b[`Q ^Q]aU^QP'
?` cM_ M` `TU_ Y[YQZ` `TM` `TQ [\\[_U`U[Z M_WQP R[^ M PUbU_U[Z [R `TQ T[a_Q Ne ^QO[^PQP
b[`Q' 6SMUZ% FCBF DM^` ?% 6^` ?I% GQO' +. U_ bQ^e OXQM^ [Z `TQ \^[OQPa^Q `[ NQ
R[XX[cQP3
-
1 4JWJTJPO PG UIF 1TTFNCMZ NBZ CF DBMMFE GPS& XJUIPVU PCUBJOJOH UIF GMPPS& BU
BOZ UJNF BGUFS UIF RVFTUJPO IBT CFFO QVU& FWFO BGUFS UIF WPUF IBT CFFO
BOOPVODFE BOE BOPUIFS IBT UIF GMPPS& QSPWJEFE UIF WPUF XBT UBLFO WJWB WPDF&
PS CZ TIPX PG IBOET& BOE JU JT DBMMFE GPS CFGPSF BOPUIFS NPUJPO IBT CFFO
NBEF( >IJT DBMM& PS NPUJPO& JT NBEF CZ TBZJOH& "6 DBMM GPS B EJWJTJPO&" PS "6
EPVCU UIF WPUF&" PS TJNQMZ CZ DBMMJOH PVU& "4JWJTJPO(" 6U EPFT OPU SFRVJSF B
TFDPOE& BOE DBOOPU CF EFCBUFE& PS BNFOEFE& PS IBWF BOZ PUIFS TVCTJEJBSZ
NPUJPO BQQMJFE UP JU( 1T TPPO BT B EJWJTJPO JT DBMMFE GPS& UIF DIBJS QSPDFFET
BHBJO UP UBLF UIF WPUF& UIJT UJNF CZ IBWJOH UIF BGGJSNBUJWF SJTF& BOE UIFO XIFO
UIFZ BSF TFBUFE IBWJOH UIF OFHBUJWF SJTF( AIJMF BOZ NFNCFS IBT UIF SJHIU UP
JOTJTU VQPO B SJTJOH WPUF& PS B EJWJTJPO& XIFSF UIFSF JT BOZ RVFTUJPO BT UP UIF
WPUF CFJOH B USVF FYQSFTTJPO PG UIF XJMM PG UIF BTTFNCMZ& UIF DIBJS TIPVME OPU
QFSNJU UIJT QSJWJMFHF UP CF BCVTFE UP UIF BOOPZBODF PG UIF BTTFNCMZ& CZ
NFNCFST DPOTUBOUMZ EFNBOEJOH B EJWJTJPO XIFSF UIFSF JT B GVMM WPUF BOE OP
RVFTUJPO BT UP XIJDI TJEF JT JO UIF NBKPSJUZ( &; 8,7</8,9 ( 3(058/;> =5;, ;5
58+,8 ;., =5;, ;5 ), *5<4;,+$ 58 ;5 ), ;(1,4 )> >,(9 (4+ 4(>9 "8522
*(22# 58 )> )(225;% '.,9, 35;/549 (8, /4*/+,4;(2 ;5 ;., 7<,9;/54 ;.(;
/9 6,4+/4- 58 .(9 0<9; ),,4 6,4+/4-$ (4+ *(445; ), +,)(;,+%
$FNQIBTJT BEEFE% AIFO EJGGFSFOU NFUIPET BSF TVHHFTUFE UIFZ BSF VTVBMMZ
USFBUFE OPU BT BNFOENFOUT& CVU MJLF GJMMJOH CMBOLT& UIF WPUF CFJOH UBLFO GJSTU PO
UIF POF UBLJOH UIF NPTU UJNF( 6O QSBDUJDF UIF NFUIPE PG UBLJOH B WPUF JT
HFOFSBMMZ BHSFFE VQPO XJUIPVU UIF GPSNBMJUZ PG B WPUF(
AIFO UIF WPUF JT UBLFO CZ CBMMPU EVSJOH B NFFUJOH PG UIF BTTFNCMZ& BT TPPO BT
UIF DIBJS UIJOLT BMM IBWF WPUFE XIP XJTI UP& IF JORVJSFT JG BMM IBWF WPUFE& BOE JG
UIFSF JT OP SFTQPOTF IF EFDMBSFT UIF QPMMT DMPTFE& BOE UIF UFMMFST QSPDFFE UP
DPVOU UIF WPUF( 6G B GPSNBM NPUJPO JT NBEF UP DMPTF UIF QPMMT JU TIPVME OPU CF
SFDPHOJ[FE VOUJM BMM IBWF QSFTVNBCMZ WPUFE& BOE UIFO JU SFRVJSFT B UXP'UIJSET
WPUF MJLF NPUJPOT UP DMPTF EFCBUF PS OPNJOBUJPOT( 6G NFNCFST FOUFS
BGUFSXBSET BOE JU JT EFTJSFE UP SFPQFO UIF QPMMT JU DBO CF EPOF CZ B NBKPSJUZ
WPUF( 9POF PG UIFTF NPUJPOT BSF EFCBUBCMF(
JTM` U_ UY\[^`MZ` `[ Z[`Q TQ^Q U_ `TM` `TQ Y[`U[Z `[ OMXX R[^ M PUbU_U[Z [R `TQ T[a_Q cM_
Z[` ^QO[SZUfQP Ne `TQ `QY\[^M^e OTMU^' BKLNH XH ODMH PQ SHFQOOHPGDULQPT
KHSH# XH GQ FQPFNVGH UKDU UKH FQPGVFU QI UKH ALSJLPLD 0HDFK 49; 7DTT
7HHULPJ XDT EHNQXUKH TUDPGDSGT GHTHSWHG XLUKLP UKH =HRVENLFDP ;DSUZ QI
ALSJLPLD% MZP Ra^`TQ^ `TM` `TQ [\\[_U`U[Z EJE OMXX R[^ M \^[\Q^ PUbU_U[Z [R `TQ T[a_Q MZP
4
htt://www.ru|eson|lne.com/rror-04.htm
)
cM_ Z[` ^QO[SZUfQP' ?Z `TQ UZ`Q^Q_` [R RMU^ \XMe MZP \^[\Q^ \^[OQPa^Q% MXX Y[`U[Z_
[aST` `[ NQ \^[\Q^Xe MO`QP a\[Z aZXQ__ _aOT \^UbUXQSQ_ M^Q UZPQQP NQUZS MNa_QP'
+$ <a^`TQ^Y[^Q% cQ M^Q bQ^e YaOT O[ZOQ^ZQP `TM` `TQ UZ`QS^U`e [R `TQ b[`Q cM_ Z[`
\^Q_Q^bQP Ne _QXQO`UbQ [^ Z[Z&QZR[^OQYQZ` [R `TQ DM^`e DXMZ cU`T ^QSM^P_ `[ `TQ
G`M`QYQZ` [R ?Z`QZ` g M YQOTMZU_Y a_QP `[ QZ_a^Q `TM` [ZXe FQ\aNXUOMZ_ MZP `T[_Q
_a\\[^`UZS FQ\aNXUOMZ_ \M^`UOU\M`Q UZ [a^ \M^`e \^[OQ__Q_'
HTQ DM^`e DXMZ _`M`Q_ UZ 6^`UOXQ I???% GQO' 6% _aN' , `TM` MXX \M^`UOU\MZ`_ UZ M AM__
AQQ`UZS% 8MZbM__% [^ 8[ZbQZ`U[Z hYMe \^Q_O^UNQ `TQ a_Q [R M \M^`UOaXM^ RUXUZS R[^Y R[^
`TQ ^Q]aU^QP _`M`QYQZ`% UZ cTUOT OM_Q `TQ [RRUOUMX \^Q&RUXUZS R[^Y Ya_` NQ UZOXaPQP cU`T
`TQ OMXX \aNXU_TQP [Z `TQ FDI cQN_U`Q'i ?KH ALSJLPLD 0HDFK 49; FDNN IQS ODTT
OHHULPJ GLG LPGHHG LPFNVGH D THFULQP SHJDSGLPJ <VDNLILFDULQPT IQS
;DSULFLRDULQP# IDLUKIVNNZ FQRLHG ISQOUKH ;DSUZ ;NDP$ ?KLT THFULQP XDT PQU
HPIQSFHG$
6Z M^SaYQZ` O[aXP NQ YMPQ `TM` hYMei P[Q_ Z[` \^QOXaPQ h_TMXXi' JQ RUZP `TU_
M^SaYQZ` `[ NQ aZO[ZbUZOUZS% M_ 6^`' *% GQO' * [R `TQ DM^`e DXMZ UZPUOM`Q_ hYMe NQ
^Q]aU^QPi UZ `TQ _QO`U[Z [a`XUZUZS YQYNQ^_TU\ MZP \M^`UOU\M`U[Z' JQ^Q U` `TQ cUXX [R `TQ
IU^SUZUM 7QMOT =CD `[ MXX[c 9QY[O^M`_ MZP UZPQ\QZPQZ`_ `[ \M^`UOU\M`Q UZ `TQ YM__
YQQ`UZS% `TQ OMXX c[aXP _UY\Xe TMbQ `[ PQXQ`Q MZP ^QY[bQ `TQ XUZQ_ ^QSM^PUZS `TQ
EaMXURUOM`U[Z_ R[^ DM^`UOU\M`U[Z g cTUOT `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT =CD PUP Z[` P[ QU`TQ^ UZ
+)*- [^ +)*+'
,$ 7QOMa_Q [R `TQ UY\^[\^UQ`UQ_ PQ`MUXQP UZ \[UZ`_ . MZP /% U` U_ _QXR&QbUPQZ` T[c `TQ
\^[OQPa^Q MZP `TQ \M^`UOU\MZ`_ c[aXP TMbQ NQQZ PU_QZR^MZOTU_QP Ne `TQ ^Q_aX` [R `TQ
_QXQO`U[Z [R PQXQSM`Q_% MZP Ra^`TQ^ T[c `TU_ c[aXP TMbQ _\UXXQP R[^cM^P `[ MZ UY\^[\Q^
^Q_aX` R[^ `TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT =CD OTMU^YMZ QXQO`U[Z' HTQ^QR[^Q% XH SHFQOOHPG
UKDU ALSJLPLD 0HDFK EH LPTUSVFUHG UQ KQNG D PHXODTT OHHULPJ TRHFLILFDNNZ
IQS UKH RVSRQTH QI HNHFULPJ D FKDLSODP# DPG SHFQOOHPG UKDU UKH THDU
SHODLP WDFDPU VPULN UKDU ULOH$
=31977382/?598> /82 79?598>
HTQ YQYNQ^_ [R `TQ O[YYU``QQ RQX` U` M\\^[\^UM`Q `[ YQZ`U[Z `TM` MXX YQYNQ^_ _`^[bQ `[
QZ_a^Q `TM` `TQ ^Q\[^` NQ O[Z_`^aO`QP UZ M RMU^ MZP UY\M^`UMX YMZZQ^' HTQ O[YYU``QQ
MPPU`U[ZMXXe RQQX_ U` ZQOQ__M^e `[ PU_OX[_Q `TM` MXX `T^QQ YQYNQ^_ PUP _a\\[^` 8a^`U_ 8[XSM`Q
QU`TQ^ bQ^NMXXe [^ UZ c^U`UZS' ?` U_ Z[ _YMXX _QO^Q` `TM` `TQ PU_`M_`Q R[^ _XM`UZS M_ M `MO`UO U_
\^[R[aZP MY[ZS YQYNQ^_ [R `TQ FQ\aNXUOMZ DM^`e [R IU^SUZUM XQMPQ^_TU\' HTQ_Q O[ZOQ^Z_
cQ^Q R[^QY[_` UZ [a^ YUZP_ cTQZ M\\^[MOTUZS `TU_ U__aQ'
*
?Z MPPU`U[Z% FDI _`MRR TM_ _\QZ` O[aZ`XQ__ T[a^_ _UR`UZS `T^[aST Z[` [ZXe QbQZ`_ UZ `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` g M `[`MX [R R[a^ _aNYU``QP M\\QMX_ ^QSM^PUZS +
ZP
9U_`^UO` MZP IU^SUZUM 7QMOT MX[ZQ
CFGPSF `TQe cQ^Q O[ZPQZ_QP UZ`[ `TQ MP T[O O[YYU``QQ g Na` R[^ R[a^ BEEJUJPOBM M\\QMX_ M_
cQXX' HTU_ TM_ Z[` NQQZ M \XQM_MZ` \^[OQ__ `[ [N_Q^bQ [^ O[Z`QZP cU`T% MZP T[\QRaXXe Y[bUZS
R[^cM^P cQ OMZ MO` MOO[^PUZSXe cTQZ `TQ_Q bQ^e \aNXUO ^UR`_ [OOa^' A[^Q aZU`Q_ a_ `TMZ
PUbUPQ_ a_% MZP _[YQ`UYQ_ cQ X[_Q MZP cUZ RUST`_ g Na` `TQ^Q U_ MZ[`TQ^ PMe MTQMP% MZP
SQZQ^MX QXQO`U[Z_ `[ cUZ'
?KH FQOOLUUHH SHFQOOHPGT UKH IQNNQXLPJ OQULQPT EH HPDFUHG.
*' 6 NPWF `TQ MP[\`U[Z [R `TQ MP T[O O[YYU``QQ ^Q\[^` [Z `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8[ZbQZ`U[Z MZP
`TQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT AM__ AQQ`UZS4 MZP Ra^`TQ^%
+' 6 NPWF UIBU `TQ G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX 8[YYU``QQ ^QO[SZUfQ 8a^`U_ 8[XSM`Q M_ 8TMU^YMZ [R `TQ
+
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8[YYU``QQ4 MZP Ra^`TQ^%
,' 6 NPWF UIBU IU^SUZUM 7QMOT NQ UZ_`^aO`QP `[ T[XP M YM__ YQQ`UZS R[^ `TQ Qd\^Q__
\a^\[_Q [R QXQO`UZS M OTMU^YMZ% MZP UZ_`^aO`_ FDI _`MRR `[ [N_Q^bQ MZP ^Q\[^` [Z `TQ
^Q_aX`_ MZP O[ZPaO` [R `TQ YM__ YQQ`UZS'
JU`T ^QSM^P_ `[ _XM`UZS% `TQ^Q U_ Z[`TUZS UZ `TQ DM^`e DXMZ [^ UZ FCBF `TM` \^[TUNU`_ `TQ
\^MO`UOQ' GaOT YQ`T[P_ M^Q UZPQQP \^[\Q^ cU`TUZ `TQ _O[\Q [R `TQ DM^`e DXMZ'
HTQ IU^SUZUM 7QMOT AM__ AQQ`UZS g `TQ _[a^OQ [R YMZe [R `TQ \^[NXQY_ UZ `TQ +
ZP
9U_`^UO` g
cM_ \^[\Q^Xe OMXXQP MZP UY\^[\Q^Xe O[ZPaO`QP' JQ ^QO[SZUfQ_ `TM` _[YQ`UYQ_ YM__ YQQ`UZS_
OMZ NQO[YQ TQM`QP% MZP `TM` YMZe `UYQ_ `TQ O[ZPaO` [R `TQ YQQ`UZS U_ [ZXe M_ S[[P M_ U`_
c[^_` YQYNQ^_' 6_ XQMPQ^_ [R `TQ FQ\aNXUOMZ DM^`e [R IU^SUZUM% cQ QZO[a^MSQ G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX
YQYNQ^_ `[ ^QUZR[^OQ \^[OQ__ [bQ^ \Q^_[ZMXU`UQ_% MZP Mb[UP `TQ_Q _[^` [R O[ZR^[Z`M`U[ZMX
YQQ`UZS_ UZ `TQ Ra`a^Q' <UbQ YUZa`Q_ [R O[a^`Q_e `e\UOMXXe Mb[UP_ RUbQ Y[Z`T_ [R O[Z`^[bQ^_e'
<a^`TQ^Y[^Q% cQ PQ`Q^YUZQ `TM` `TQ U__aQ [R cT[Y M O^QPQZ`UMX_ O[YYU``QQ OMZ _QM` U_ OXQM^
R^[Y N[`T `TQ \Q^_\QO`UbQ [R FCBF MZP \^QbU[a_ =QZQ^MX 8[aZ_QX ^aXUZS_% MZP P[ Z[` RUZP
`TM` +
ZP
9U_`^UO` 8[YYU``QQ MO`QP UY\^[\Q^Xe'
@M_`Xe% cQ c[aXP XUWQ `[ ^QYUZP YQYNQ^_ [R G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX 8[YYU``QQ `TM` cQ ^QYMUZ M N[Pe
[R XM_` ^Q_[^` cU`T ^QSM^P_ `[ `TQ \^[OQPa^MX [\Q^M`U[Z_ [R `TQ FQ\aNXUOMZ DM^`e [R IU^SUZUM'
B[ [^SMZUfM`U[ZMX N[Pe OMZ NUZP M Ra`a^Q N[Pe% MZP [ZOQ O[Z_`U`a`QP Z[ S^[a\ OMZ a\QZP `TQ
[^SMZUfM`U[ZMX R[^YM`U[Z [R `TM` N[Pe aZ`UX U`_ `Q^Y Qd\U^Q_' JTM` `TQ G`M`Q 8QZ`^MX
8[YYU``QQ PQOUPQ_ JT cTM` U_ \^[\Q^% MZP cQ QZO[a^MSQ RQXX[c YQYNQ^_ `[ P[ _[ UZ M _\U^U` [R
RMU^ZQ__ MZP O[&[\Q^M`U[Z'
JQ ^QO[YYQZP `TQ MP[\`U[Z [R `TQ ^Q\[^` cU`T `TQ MN[bQ Y[`U[Z_ M``MOTQP% MZP O[Z_UPQ^ `TQ
YM``Q^ SFTPMWFE'
+