2014


................................................................................................... 4
........................................................................................... 5
...6-8

1. . 9-10
2. ...11
3. . 12
4. . 13-14
4.1. 1:
... 15
4.2 2: . 16-18
4.3 3:
4.4 4: ,
.. 20-22
( 5-8-2013)... 23-46
. 47-59

1
... 60-69
2 .......,
.......-........70-72
3 ..73-76
4 .......,
...77-80
5
,
..81-86
6
..87-98
7 .. ..99
8 ... 100-102


. ,
, .
. , -
, .
. ,
, / ,
( . .
).
. , , .
. ,
, .
. ,
....., .
. ,
....., (
. ).
. - , ,
.
. , /
, .
. ,
, .
. ,
, .
. ,
, .


Task Force (TFGR):
Drs Th.J.A.M. de Bruijn
Aurelie Vandeputte
Eva Loidl

Goran Carlsson
Theo Strijker
Juha Keranen

15 2013

2 2013

17 2013

9 2013

27 2013

23 2013

3 2013

30 2013

14 2013

6 2013

18 2013

14 2013

25 2013

20 2013

9 2013

28 2013

30 2013

11 2013

5 2013

20 2013

21 2013

9 2014

29 2013

22 2014

3 2013

29 2014

19 2013

5 2014

26 2013

27 2014

41, , 10676
.: 210 7251073, 6944746147 fax: 210 7212621
e-mail: info@idme.gr nklamaris@idme.gr
, 13.3.2014

1.
.
2.

: . , . ,

,


.

1.
1.1.
1.2.

1.3.
..
.

1.4.
,
-
.
1.5. ,
.
1.6.
.
1.7.

.
1.8.
.. . . (
).

2.
2.1.
,


.
2.2.

2.3.
2.4. .
2.5.

.
2.6.
...
.
2.7.

.
2.8.
.
2.9.
(
).

2.10. .
,

.

..:
17 .
.. ,
.

1.

,


. ,
,
. : ,
, ( ),
, .
,
, , , ,
, ,

( ) ( )

(
) ,
.
.
.

.
.
.

, , ()
.

.

 .

( )

. ,

. ,
.


( , ,
..)
.
:
, ,

, ,

.


( , ,
, , C-PAP, B-PAP, ,
, , ..).

10

2.
, ,
,
,
.
,

.
, ,

.

,
,

,
.

, ,

.

11

3.


:


TFGR
,
EHFCN (European Healthcare Fraud & Corruption Network)
.P. Vincke, 18.6.2013


, ,

12

4.

. ,
, , ,
.

, ,
,
, .

,

,
.
, ,
,
, ,
.

.
,
,
.

4.1. 1:

4.2 2:

13

4.3 3:
4.4 4: ,

,

. (6)

14

4.1.
1:

(....., ......).


.


.

(...., , ...., ..),
. *.

..
(
).

, Task Force

EHFCN (European Healthcare Fraud & Corruption Network).

*
.

15

4.2. 2:


.
,
.
:

, ,
. . 121/2008 ,
.

,
.

.

( 31 ),
,

..

,
.
:

16

1.

.
.

.
2. (
) .
3. ( )
CPV
GMDN . (
).
4.

.
5.
.
6. (-
...)
.
7.
.
8.
.
9. .
( ).
10.
.
( ).

1.K
( :
---)

17

 ,
. (
).
2. CPV, GMDN .
(--)
).
3.
( , .
refNo, catalogNo) .


. (E
).
4.
.
5. .
6.
.
7.
(RefNo, CatalogNo)

,
.

18

4.3.
3:

(, )

, ,
,
. ,
. .

.

19

4.4 4: ,

-

.
.

.
:

, , :

(- ,
- , -
, ) .

.

.
, .
site
, . ...
site .

()

20

.

.
( )
:

(
,
).

.
.

:



( ).


.

,
.....,
,
, ...

21

:
.

.
.
.
.

.

.....,
(, , ..)
(.. ..).
.....

.

.

..... ( ) ....
(, ...),

..

22

 .

, 5.8.2013

, . . .
,
,
,

.
21 28
2013.

,

.
(. 6944746147)

23

5/8/2013
:



.
31/5/2013 .
3 . .
,
( ), /

, ,
Task Force for Greece (TFGR).

,
.
,
, ,
.

.

:
-
-

-
- Workshop
(EHFCN) . Paul Vincke

11 .
, (
)
( ..) . . 9.7.2013.


:
- T
-
-

2013.

2013.

24

25

, ....... (
) ..... (
).

.2676/99 32 ( .......), ..
275/2001 ( ,
), .3144/2003 19 32
.2676/99, .3607/07 (
, .......),
.3918/11 ( .......
, 25
....... -

.....
), , . 5 3054/18.11.2012
( .....,
,
.....).
.....
.2920/2001, ( , , ,
, ), .. 1008/./01-08-2001 (
), .. 1147/./03-09-2002
( 16.9.2002), ..278/2002 (
), .3204/2003
37 ( ,
- ,
. ) , .3252/04 ( 2 .35
.2920/2001).
.......
....... :


....

.

.

,
.

.

.
.....,
,
.....

26

....... .
.......
.....
..... :

,
,
,
,
,

.

1. ..... ,
, :
) , , , , ,
,
, ,
.
, 159 161 ..
141/1991 ( 58 ).
) ,
,
,
,
.
) , ,
.
) , (...),
,
,
.
2.
,
, .

,
.

.

- / /
/ ..
-
-
-

27

-

- /
/
- , ,
, ..
-
-/
-

- -
- , ,

-
- , ,
- -

-
-
- ,
, ..
-

-

-
- .....
- ,

-
/
-
- /
..... (
)
-
-
- internet
,

- ...
-
-
.....
-
- ,
......
-

28


( , ..)
- ..... /
-
-

-

-

-


-
-
-
-
/Internet
-
..
-

..... ....... 2012.

.

.

:

-
- /
/
-
- / /
/ ..
-
-

29

-
-

- -
-
- , ,

- ,
, ..

-

- ,

-
/
-
- /
..... (
)
-
,

-
.....
- ...
-
- ,
......
-
-

-
/Internet
-
..
-


)
....... 2012 . . 578/22-4-2013,
) /
.......

30

. .......
2012 85%
15% .
83,5% ,
.
37%
11%
...... :
-
25% ( )
75% . 121/2008

11% ...
.....
4% ( )
.
-

, ,
, .
, 190,
60 ()
().
....... ,
130,

,
.......
. .......,
, 60 (, ,
, ).
, ,

, ,
. ,
,
.

.
, :
)
.

31

 ,
.
) . ,
2012

.

32

/
-""
-

/


.

3%

3%

2%

1%

(
).
-



.
-

- ...,
.....
-
,

-
-

(

)
-

.3528/2007

, .2362/1995
,

.
,

33

.3418/2005

- /

11,00%

-
,
,
,
..
-

1%

23,50%

. 8, 20, 22

. 3459/2006 (
103/25.5.2006)
"
"

34

5%

-
.....

-
-

/

.....

-

(
, PC
..)

35

.....
-

....()
-

.. 121
183/3.9.2008

,


,




. 32 .
3846/2010 (
66/11-5-2010)
80 .
3996/2011 (
170/5.8..2011).

.... . . 5
3054 18.11.2012.
. 4 .
3892/2010
"H

"

-
,
,


,

6%

-




(

.....)

-
,

-



.....

(
, )

(

)

5%

36

N. 3418/2005/A-287
"
"

-
,
,
,
..

5%

. 8, 20, 22

. 3459/2006 (
103/25.5.2006)
"
"

37

5%

.....
-




(

.....)
-

....


(
)

-
-

-

.....

.....

38

.. 121/2008

- 84/2001

[

. .4.
. 7 .
4093/12,.
.. 3//. 24948
( 713/13.3.2012)]
,

.... . . 5
3054 18.11.2012,
. 4 .
3892/2010
"H

"

.....

- ,

/

-

5.5%

,
-
.....

39

.. 121
183/3.9.2008

,


,




. 32 .
3846/2010 (
66/11-5-2010)
80 .
3996/2011 (
170/5.8..2011).

. .
3457/2006
'

" (
93), . 11 .
1963/91 .

)
-

3%

- .....

/

.....

40

. .191
234/27.9.2005

,

-

/

..... (

..340/1993

(
/)

. 9, 20, 22

. 3459/2006 (
103/25.5.2006)
"
"

internet

41

 ,







.

-
...

.....
-




(

.....)
-

/

.....
-

-


-


.....
( )
-

,

42

/



-

-

.. )
-

(

)

.. 121/2008

( )
-. 517/91, .
235/2000, ...

.



.....

.. 4/.
18051/27.3.2012 (
946)

.....

(
,
..)

- .....


/
.

. 7 . 38
. 4042/2012, .
. . 146163 (
1537 /8.5.2012)

10%

-
.....

.....)
-

43

.. 191/2005

-

-
.

.....
-

(

)

44

/3/83657/2006

-

-

5%

5%

.. 96/1973 (172)


,

. 3580/2007,
3918/2011, .
370/2005.
.
1316/1983 "

,

..."
3/14185/2004

.2188/1920,
.4844/1930,
.4086/1960,
.3498/2006
1/4841/1979,
2/2600/2001,
43504/2005

45

/internet

-
...

1%

- /

46

.1316/1983
...

. 727/1977, .
1339/1985, .
3601/1928,
.1384/1938,
.328/1976

..

1.

(

) ( 2)

( 3)

Q3 2013

,
,

Q4 2013

Q1 2014

( 4)

..

..

1)

47

(Q2 2013)

2013

 5)

..

Q1 2014

..-

,
,

.




.

Q1 2014

48




(....,
, ...., ..),

. .

,
,
, .
., ,
, .

..
(
).

. . , .

,
,
, .
., ,
, .

. European Healthcare Fraud &
Corruption Network

.
,
European
Healthcare
Fraud &
Corruption
Network
,
,

49

2.

,
,

..,

..

, .

Q1 2014

, ,
,

. . 121/2008
,

. ..

, ,
,

Q1 2014

50

..

Q1 2014

..

..

,
, ,

Q1 2014

51

3.

(, ,
)

,
, ,

Q1 2014

&

Q1 2014

2
,
,

Q1 2014

52

 .......
, .

.......

(....., , ...,
..... .)
.
4.
,

,
, ,
.... ..

HRSC Sub
committee

Q1 2014

-
Health in Action
,
.

Q1 2014

53

Q1 2014

Q4 2013

,
,

,

.


.

Q1 2014

WHO

Q2 2013

, .
,
.
,
.

,
,

Q1 2014

Q1 2014

Q1 2014

54

Q1 2014

( )

.

Q1 2014

(- , ,

(..
- ,
,
,
- ,

,
,

,
,

,
(, , , ,

)
&
.
,

)




, .
,
Q1 2014
,

:
. ,

- .
.

- .

- .
.

55

-

.
-
. ( 6)




:

.



.

,
.

.
.

Q1 2014

,
.

Q1 2014

56




(, ).



.



site
.

.

.....

, .

Q1 2014

&

Q1 2014

Q1 2014

Q1 2014

57

,
.








.
.

,




(, ..)

(.. ..)

,
/

Q1 2014

, ,

&

Q1 2014

( ),

Q1 2014

58

Q1 2014

.....,

,
.
..... (
)
.... (,
...).
.....,
, ..
,
......

, .

, ...
..,

Q1 2014

, .

, ,
... ..

Q1 2014

Q4 2013

, ...
..

Q1 2014

/ ,
.

59

 1
- , 1106-2013

....... - , 13-6-2013
..... - . , 6-6-2013 29-11-2013

, .......
( ) .....
( ).

.2676/99 32 ( .......),
.. 275/2001 ( ,
), .3144/2003 19 32
.2676/99, .3607/07 (
, .......),
, .3918/11 ( .......
).
.....
.2920/2001, ( , , ,
, ), .. 1008/./01-08-2001 (
..... ), .. 1147/./0309-2002 ( ..... 16.9.2002), ..278/2002
( ..... ), .3204/2003
37 (
....., -
, . ),
.3252/04 ( 2 .35 .2920/2001), .3918/11
(.64-66, .....).
.......
....... :


....

.

.

60


,
.

.
[ ]
. - .

. 2 32 . 1 . 80 . 3996/11, -170 /5-8-11

. 2 18 . 3846/10, -66 /115-10 [ ]
[ ]

.....
, ,
........

......

,

.

....... ,
.... ....., ,
,
.

........
,
....... .. 121/2008
( 183) ,
1 32 . 3846/2010, .

......., ,
, , (5)
,
.
(30)
4
18 . 3846/2010.

,
.
.

,
() ,
.
.......
3 2,
3 3 15 4 .. 121/2008,

61

 1 32 . 3846/2010.
,
.
.......

. - . . 3 32
. 2 . 80 . 3996/11, -170 /5-8-11 . 3
18 . 3846/10, -66 /11-5-10[ ]

.......

,
.
.
,
, ,
.......
,
.
...
.

, ,
,
.
.......
[ ]

....... . [ ]
,
.

.
. 5 32 . 10 . 33 . 3863/10,
-115 /15-7-10 [ ] . . 5 32
. 1
. 3607/07, -245 . . 2 . 3607/07 [ ]
[ ]

.......

.

....
.
,
.

,
,
. , , ,

62


.
, ,
. . 5 . 2
19 . 3144/03, -111 [ ]

, ,
, ,
, , .......
.

'
.......
.
,
, .......
,
.
.......
....... ,
.
, ,
95 5
.

.

(5) ,
.

, ,
,
....

' ' .2
25 .1943/91.
6

, ,
.
.......

.
[ ]

.......
. . 7 . 3 19 . 3144/03, -111 .
. . 4-5 19 . 3144/03 [ ]
[ ]

63

9. )
.......
.

.......
) . 5 19 . 3144/ 2003 ( 111/)
....... . . 9
32 . 4 . 3607/07, -245 /1-11-07 [
]

.....
..... :

,

, ,
,
,

.

1. ..... :
) ,
.
) , ..
, ,
.
) .... ,

.
) ,
.
) , ,

, ,
, ,
.
) , ,
.
2. ..... .
,
, ......
, ,
.
, .
, ,

......

64

 -
1. ..... :
) - .
) - .
) .
2. - , :
)
,
,
:
(1)
,
.
(2) ...
(3) .
(4) .
(5) .
) ,
, ,
.
) H ,
,
,
.
)
, ,
, .
)
, ,
,
.
,

65

 ,
,
,
.
) ,
,
,
(...).
)
.
)
(....) (...)
.
3. - , :
) ,
, .....,

.
) ,
.
) , ,

,
......
)

,
.
) .
) , , ,
, ,

,
56 . 2362/1995 ,
( 247 ).
[ ]

. , ,
,
...,

66

 . . . 3 3
. 2 35 . 3252/04, -132 [ ]

4. , :
)
,
, ... ~ ,

,
,
, , , ,
,
.
) ,
,
,
.
) ,
,
.
) ,
,

.
) ,
, 5 . 2646/ 1998,
,
.

1. ....., ,
, :
) , , , , ,
,
, ,
.
, 159 161
.. 141/1991 ( 58 ).
) ,
,
,
,
.
) , ,
.

67

) , (...),
,
,
.
2.
,
,
.

.......

.......

.....

2011

2012

86

199

30

18

78

166

.......
(
) ........

68

.....

.....

2011

2012

113

225

54

65

36

13

21

( 6-6-2013)

2011

113

123

86

45
/
157

524
( 29-11-2013)

2012
58
16
21
54
58
207

2011
2012
4
3
7
4
1
0
1
22
4
34
12

2011
2012
22
4
37
4
6
3
0
26
2
91
13

69

 2 .......,
.......-..... - ....... ,

.......

/ ,
.......
....... (
.......).
.

.......

/
...

/
.

/
.

/ ....... .

/
....... /.

.......-.....

(, ) ,
:
. ...... ,
.....
..121/2008, . ......
..... ( .....). ......

70

 80 . 3996/2011 .
....... ,
....., ,
......
......
(, , ).
.....
.
......
(10)
, .
. ..... , .
.... .
,
,
- ,
, .......
, .
,
, ,

,
(....) ...

. , .....
....
.....
.
,
....., .
..... .
.....
.

71

,
( ). .....
. .......
.
:
, ,
...... .....
.

,
, , ,

. *
* 19
2014 . . .
:

, ,
...... .....
.

. , .....
....... ,

.....

72

 3
......., 22-1-2014

.
. . 8 . 3074 /2002
, ..... .......
(....)
(. 2 .1)

. 7 6 . 3491/06, -207 :
. , , ,
-
, ,
, ,
,

.
. -
.

.
. ...


...
8 . 3074/2002
(....)
1. 8 . 2477/1997 ( 59 ),
4 14 . 2946/2001 ( 224 ),
(....)
.....
. 2 1 .

73

2. ....
.....,

. 2 1

..,
.

. . 1 . . .4152/2013

,
.
. 2 , .2 :
)
.
) ,

.
. 1 . :
) ) .
. .3.
, .
. 3 . .3.
, ,

.

.



.

74


.

,


....

(....).

,

2013,
,
( )
,

...

(Transparency International), TI,
" "
.
: 2013

,

( -)

75

&
/

-
/

-


-



-

-


-

/ .
.

76

 4 .......,


.
, , .

.......
.......
.....
, ,
. . . 1786/5-9-2012, 151/2012-2012 / ...., 19
.... (. 5/18-11-2012, 3054) .......
.....

80 . 3996/2011.
,

, ,
.
....... (.. 275/01,
.3 . .3607/07 . 19
.3144/2003 . 32 .2676/99) 130 ,
. ......


....... ...... ,

.
....... ..... . 3918/2011
.
.

77


(. 2685/1999 .35/)
,
.

, ,

.
.......
, .....,
..... .
.
.......
.
......,
, :
49 ( , , , ...),
16 ( , ),
4 (..),
8 (., ..).
8
/ ..... . .
....... ,
.

........ , ,

.

/ .

78



, , ,
. ,
190,
60 () ().

, ,
,
, . ,
,

.

, :
) *
.
, .

) . ,
2012

.

, , :
20% .....
,
(9) .....

79

 ....
.

* . 17.3.2014 :
, ,

, . P. Vincke .

80

 5
,

. .......,
27-9-2013

(....., ......).


.


.

(...., , ...., ..),
. .

..
(
).

, Task Force

.
, ..

81



,

-
.

.

.
:

(manuals)

,
:

, ,
. . 121/2008 ,
.

82

, , :

(- ,
- , - ,
) .

.

,
.

.
, .
site ,
. ... site
.
,
,
:

83

()

.

.

(, )

, ,
,
. ,

.
( )

(
, ).

.
.

84




( ).


.

,
.....,
,
, ...

.. . . )
.
.
.
.

.

.....,
(, , ..)
(.. ..).
......

85

.

.

..... ( ) ....
(, ...),

..

86

 6


, 21-6-13

:
.

.

,

.
( ) ,

,
,
.

1. .. 496/1974,

87

( 204//19-7-1974) . .2/42053/0094/26-7-02
41 . 496/1974
(2.500 ).
2. . 2198/1994 ( 43//22-3-1994), 24 (
).
3. . 2286/1995,
( 19//1-2-1995) . 1/3305 ( 1789//12-11-10)
2
.2286/1995.
4. . 2362/1995, ( 247//27-11-1995)
. 35130/739 ( 1291//11-8-10)
83 . 1 . 2362/1995.
5. . 2328/1995 ( 159//95) .2372/1996 (
29//96) 11 .2414/1996 ( 135//96) 14
.. 82/96 ( 66//96) ..

,
8 . 3310/2005 ( 30//2005) 8 .
3414/2005 ( 279//2005).
6. . 2503/1997, , , ... ( 13
) ( 107//30-5-1997).
7. . 2741/1999, ... ( 8
) ( 199//28-9-1999).
8. . 2955/2001, ...
( 256/2-11-2001).
9. . 3204/2003
( 14 . 1 &
14 . 3 ) ( 296//23-12-03).
10. . 3329/2005
( 81//4-4-05) . 3527/2007 ( 25//9-207).

88

11. . 3310/2005
(
30//14-2-2005), . 3414/2005 ( 279//10-11-2005).
12. . 3580/2007 (
134//18-6-07), 14 . 3846/2010 ( 66//11-510).
13. . 3867/2010 27
( 128//3-8-10).
14. . 3886/2010,
( 173//30-9-10).
15. . 3861/2010 ( 112//13-710).
16. . 3863/2010 68
, ( 115//15-7-10).
17. . 3868/2010 22
( 129//3-8-10).
18. . 3897/2010 21

CE ( 208//1012-10).
19. . 3918/2011
( 31//2-3-11).
20. . 4013/2011
( 204//15-9-11)
. 4072/2012 ( 86//11-4-12).
21. . 4038/2012 9 .. 118/2007 ( 14//2-2-12).
22. . 4052/2012 . & . (
41//1-3-12).
23. .. 82/1996

( 66//11-4-1996),
8 . 3310/2005 8 .
3414/2005.

89

24. .. 166/2003 2000/35/29-62000

( 138//5-6-2003).
25. .. 60/2007
2004/18/ ( 64//16-3-07),
, , 2005/51/

2005/75/

16 2005.
26. .. 118/2007 ( 150//10-7-2007)
..
60/2007.
27. . 20977/23-8-2007
. 3310/2005, . 3414/2005 ( 1673//23-8-2007).
28. . 1108437/2565//15-11-2005
(
1590//16-11-2005).
29. . 6/.36932
2%
. 3 . 3580/2007 ( 545//24-309).
30. .

08/31.5.2010

10 . 3580/07 ( 777//4-6-10).
31. . 1862/8-3-12
( 680//8-3-12).

90

.
1. ()
().
2.
. .
3. .
4. ,

(..).
5. ..
.. : )
.. )

.
6. .
7. ..
8.
.
9.
( 1.000 ).
10. .
11.
1.000.000 ( 5.000.000 )
12.
. ( ).
13. : )

,
)
, (

), ) usiness Exchanges

91

 ( - / /
- /
),

( 1.000 ).

. (2012)

1. 2012:
.

2012

- 2012 ,

2011 9,27%.

: To

2011 2010.
2. 2012 ..:
2012 ,

.
3. 2012: 3 2012 .
- ..
20-10-12, 17
).
- 30-6-13
. (
).
4.

2012 :
. 8-4-13 ..
- ..
- 2011 (
2013 2011 ).
. 31-5-13 ..
-
2012 (

92

 ..
..).
5. 30-6-13 (
).
6.

31-12-13

, ).
7. 2014 2015.

() . 213/2008

(CPV).

CPV . CPV


.
CPV
CPV.
:

2012 CPV
33696200-7 ,
CPV 33696100-6 .

93

E. (..)

(---)
(
-
EsyNet), CPV (
CPV),
GMDN (
).

( )

.

,
( ,
) (
).

, (
) ,
.

,



-.

94

 1:
( )
.
2:
,
.
3: (4.2.55 1,30 4.2.56 1,388 1,38 ).

4.2.57

;
;
.

. - .

, .

.

( )
.
(2012)
-2 (2010) +3 (2015).
(5)

95

 . (

,
).

( 5 ).

,
.

()
20.000
60.000 , CPV

CPV .

(1311:
1359: )
.

. .

11.

.
.

96

12.
.
13.
CPV GMDN
.
14.

.
15.
.
16. (-
...)
.
17.
.
18.
.
19. .
( ).
20.
. (
).

1.K
( :
---)
,
.
).

97

2. CPV, GMDN .
(--)
).
3.
( , . ref
No, catalog No) .

. (E

).
4.
.
5. .
6.
.
7.
(Ref No, Catalog No)

,
.

1. .
2. .
3. .
4.
..
5. .

98


. .



.
33 - 10681

10-3-2014

. ,
, 6-2-2014 ,

, .
, , ,
.
, ,
.
.


.

( )
.
, ,
, .
, , ,
,
. ,
,
, , .
, 27 . 4025/2011
2 70 11 /7
1957 (` 225) :

., .

.
,



.

.
.

99