Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 1 of 7

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

JOSEPH ARPAIO,
Plaintiff,
v.
BARACK OBAMA, ET AL.

Case 1:14-cv-01966

Defendants.
PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR HIS LIVE TESTIMONY
Plaintiff, by counsel, requests that live testimony be scheduled and accepted into
evidence, which is estimated to take approximately one hour as part of the hearing on Plaintiffs
Motion for Preliminary Injunction currently scheduled for December 22, 2014.
I.

GOVERNING LAW FOR LIVE TESTIMONY AT HEARING

Pursuant to Rule 65(1)(d) of the Local Rules of the U.S. District Court for the District of

Columbia:
. The practice in this jurisdiction is to decide preliminary injunction
motions without live testimony where possible. Accordingly, any party
who wishes to offer live testimony or cross-examine an affiant at the
hearing shall so request in writing 72 hours before the hearing and shall
provide the court and all other parties a list of the witnesses to be
examined and an estimate of the time required. The court may decline to
hear witnesses at the hearing where the need for live testimony is
outweighed by considerations of undue delay, waste of time, or needless
presentation of cumulative evidence. If practicable, the court shall notify
all parties of its ruling on the request to adduce live testimony one
business day before the hearing.
LCrR 65(1)(d).

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 2 of 7

II.

TESTIMONY BY PLAINTIFF JOE ARPAIO CONCERNING STANDING AND

HARM
Plaintiff Joseph Arpaio, as Sheriff of Maricopa County, Arizona, submitted his sworn

affidavit that his office has observed and actually experienced increased financial costs, a drain
on resources, additional workload, and greater risk of responding to a greater number of calls
from criminal incidents which result directly or indirectly from repeated announcements and
unconstitutional executive actions by President Obama and the other Defendants that he has in
effect granted amnesty to millions of undocumented illegal aliens. In addition, Plaintiff Arpaio
has received and continues to receive death threats from the illegal aliens that President Obama
and the other Defendants have granted deferred action to. This directly harms Plaintiff Arpaio
personally and in his official capacity.
Defendants seek to discredit Arpaios affidavit by contending that:

Arpaios affidavit offers only conclusory statements.

Arpaios affidavit offers only speculative claims of harm.

Arpaio has not alleged any specific injury.

Arpaio has not identified how the injuries relate to Defendants programs.

While these allegations are incorrect and simply strategic, Plaintiff Arpaios testimony
would be in the interest of due process and to further justice, as well as create a full record for
this Court to confirm his standing to sue. Plaintiff Arpaio would also offer further testimony
about the harm he and his office have suffered and will continue to suffer as a result of the
unconstitutional executive actions at issue.
Plaintiff Arpaio would testify that:

The financial impact of these illegal aliens in Maricopa County, Arizona, as

illustrated in the email attached from Casey Price titled Price Tag, incurred
2

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 3 of 7

increased expenses of $9,293,619.96 from February 1, 2014, through

December 17, 2014, for those inmates flagged with INS detainers (that is,
illegal aliens). (Exhibit 1).

After years of experience with floods of illegal immigrants crossing the border
into his jurisdiction as Sheriff, Plaintiff Arpaio has many years of empirical,
real-world experience and evidence showing how the Defendants executive
actions will directly impact his operations. The Defendants executive actions
are straining his office resources as illegal aliens who have not committed
serious crimes are not being will not be deported, but instead left to remain in
jail.

The DACA program which started June 15, 2012, has already impacted
Arpaios office finances, workload, resources, and exposure to more calls
about criminal incidents.

Arpaios empirical evidence provides a solid predictive basis for what the
impact will be from the November 20, 2014, executive actions. (Exhibit 1).

The Presidents executive actions and claimed policies and statements over six
years encouraging illegal aliens to come and seek the promised amnesty
actually causes an increase in crime in Maricopa County, Arizona, including
among those who lack any respect for U.S. laws.

In addition, under current law, Plaintiff Arpaio will turn over those
committing crimes in Maricopa County, Arizona who turn out to be citizens
of foreign countries to DHS to be deported. By contrast, under the
Defendants new executive actions, those persons will not be subject to

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 4 of 7

deportation. Therefore, they will serve out their criminal sentences in Plaintiff
Arpaios jails, costing his office enormous time and expense.

Moreover, Plaintiff Arpaio has also been threatened physically by some of

these same illegal aliens, which directly impacts his constitutional rights and
causes harm. In fact, there are multiple crimes inherent in threatening a law
enforcement official. (Exhibit 2).

Defendants are not, in fact, deporting illegal aliens convicted of crimes in

Maricopa County, Arizona. The Plaintiff has booked perpetrators of state-law
crimes into his jails, discovered that they are not citizens or Lawful Permanent
Residents (LPRs) and then handed those criminals over to ICE at DHS for
deportation. Those same illegal aliens placed in DHS custody are then rearrested for new state-law crimes in Maricopa County, Arizona relatively soon
thereafter, increasing detention costs in the countys jails.

As a result, Defendants will not lower the crime rate by reallocating resources,
but will create a waste and strain the resources of Plaintiff Arpaio and his
office.

Finally, the illegal aliens at issue, as a result of now obtaining work permits,
will then be able to receive drivers licenses which will, based on Plaintiffs
experience, allow them to fraudulently register to vote. This is true in
practice. Under the Motor Voter law, those applying for a drivers license
are encouraged to apply to vote. Many will mistake this invitation for
permission or advice that they may vote. Some will ignore the distinction

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 5 of 7

knowingly. The nations voting system operates on the honor system, without
an investigation unless there is a complaint brought first.

Meanwhile, Plaintiff Arpaio, as an elected official who has already been

subjected to one failed recall in 2012, will thus be directly impacted by illegal
aliens who will again seek to remove him from office by voting unlawfully.
(Exhibit 3).

Therefore, Plaintiff respectfully requests that he be permitted to testify on these points

pivotal to his standing to legally challenge the unconstitutional and illegal actions of the
Defendants, and the harm which flows therefrom to him and his office. This will aid the Court in
reaching a fair and just disposition of Plaintiffs Motion for Preliminary Injunction by creating a
full record. It will also allow Defendants counsel to cross examine Plaintiff Arpaio, which is
also in the interest of justice to get to the full and uncontroverted truth of what he has pled in the
Complaint and his supporting affidavit. Live testimony is generally permitted when jurisdiction
and standing are subject to challenge. See generally, McNutt v. Gen. Motors Acceptance Corp. of
Ind., 298 U.S. 178, 189 (1936).
III.

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the Court should respectfully allow live testimony of Plaintiff
Arpaio at the hearing now scheduled for December 22, 2014.
Dated: December 17, 2014

Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Larry Klayman
Larry Klayman, Esq.
Washington, D.C. Bar No. 334581
Freedom Watch, Inc.
2020 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W., Suite 345
Washington, D.C. 20006
(310) 595-0800
leklayman@gmail.com
5

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 6 of 7

Attorney for Plaintiff

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17 Filed 12/17/14 Page 7 of 7

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 17th day of December, 2014 a true and correct copy of
the foregoing motion was served by electronic filing through the Court to the following:

ADAM D. KIRSCHNER, Esq.

HECTOR G. BLADUELL
BRADLEY H. COHEN
KYLE R. FREENY
JULIE S. SALTMAN
Trial Attorneys
Civil Division, Federal Programs Branch
U.S. Department of Justice
P.O. Box 883
Washington, D.C. 20044
Tel.: (202) 353-9265
Fax: (202) 616-8470
Adam.Kirschner@usdoj.gov
Attorneys for Defendants

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-1 Filed 12/17/14 Page 1 of 2

Exhibit 1

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-1 Filed 12/17/14 Page 2 of 2

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-2 Filed 12/17/14 Page 1 of 4

Exhibit 2

Login
Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-2 Filed 12/17/14 DesktopAlerts
Page 2 of
4

iOSapp(http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/thehuffingtonpost/id306621789?mt=8)

CreateAccount

Androidapp(https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.huffingtonpost.android&hl=en)
December17,2014 More(/bignews/#latinovoices)

(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/latinovoices)
Edition:U.S.

Like

22k

Follow

Newsletters

HuffingtonPostSearch

FRONT PAGE
POLITICS
BUSINESS
ENTERTAINME
(HTTP://WWW.HUFFINGTONPOST.COM) (HTTP://WWW.HUFFINGTONPOST.COM/POLITICS/) (HTTP://WWW.HUFFINGTONPOST.COM/BUSINESS/) (HTTP://WWW.HUFFINGTONPOST.C
LatinoVoices(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/latinovoices/) HispanicHeritage(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/hispanicheritage/)
Immigrants(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/immigrants/) LatinoEntertainment(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/latinoentertainment)
LatinoPolitics(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/latinopolitics/) Prosperity(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/latinoprosperity/)
LatinoLife(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/lvlife/) HispanicHeritageMonth(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/hispanicheritagemonth/)

Voces(enespaol)(http://voces.huffingtonpost.com)

(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/17/raul
castrospeech_n_6341802.html)

(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/14/missing(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/15/california
(http://www.huffingtonpos
studentsmexico_n_6321866.html)
undocumentedimmigrantdrivers
bell/howlatinosdochrist

license_n_6330608.html)
differently_b_6064610.ht
RaulCastroWelcomesRenewalOf
DamningReportClaimsMexican
UndocumentedImmigrantsFlockTo
HowMyLatinoFamil
RelationsWithU.S.
FederalPoliceParticipatedIn
GetDriver'sLicensesUnderNew
ChristmasDifferently
(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/17/raul
DisappearanceOf43Students
CaliforniaLaw
(http://www.huffingto
castrospeech_n_6341802.html)
(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/14/missing
(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/12/15/california
bell/howlatinosdoc
studentsmexico_n_6321866.html)
undocumentedimmigrantdrivers
differently_b_606461
license_n_6330608.html)

SheriffJoeArpaioThreatenedBy
InmateSamuelMattaFor
DeportingFamily
Reuters
Posted:07/11/201211:02pmEDT

Updated:09/10/20125:12amEDT

SUGGESTED FOR YOU

2.McDonald'sToRemove8Items
FromItsMenu.WeanYourselves
Now,America.

3hoursagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.com
HuffingtonPost.com(AOL)Carly
LedbetterCarlyLedbettermcdonald's
profits
1.'Getouttahere!'HerAmbush
Makeoverleaveseveryonespeechless
55 (javscript:void(0))
Like

32
Share

6daysagotoday.com(sponsored)

KyleMichaelMillerKyleMichael
(http://www.reuters.com/)
(https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.huffingtonpost.com%2F2012%2F07%2F11%2Fsheriffjoearpaio
18

threatenedbysamuelmatta_n_1666926.html)
Tweet

ByDavidSchwartz

(https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?

Millerkatemiddletonbabybump
3.IfAnnouncingADivorceWasAs
ExcitingAsAnnouncingA
Pregnancy

lang=en&text=Inmate+Allegedly+Planned+Revenge+Killing+On+%27America%27s+Toughest+Sheriff%27+http%3A%2F%2Fhuff.to%2FMlApaN)

PHOENIX,July11(Reuters)Aninmatehasbeenindictedforallegedlyplottingto
killahardlineArizonasherifftoholdhim"personallyaccountable"fordeportinghis
(https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/11/sheriffjoearpaiothreatenedbysamuel
401
familymemberstoMexico,sheriff'sofficialssaidonWednesday.
matta_n_1666926.html)
Comment

SamuelMatta,29,wasservedwiththeindictmentinprisononWednesdaystemming
fromanallegedschemetoassassinateMaricopaCountySheriffJoeArpaiowitha
highpoweredrifle,saidSergeantBrandonJones,asheriff'sspokesman.
Matta,whoauthoritiessayisadocumentedgangmember,plannedtoactontheplot
oncehewasreleasedfromprison,Jonessaid.
Arpaio,whostyleshimselfas"America'stoughestsheriff,"isoneoftheleading
proponentsoftheMexicoborderstate'scrackdownonillegalimmigrantspassedin
2010,butpartiallyblockedbythecourts.

5daysagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.comAOLForex
LeighWeingusLeighWeingus
pregnancyannouncement
4.TheMostPowerfulWayTo
RespondToNegativePeople

InMay,theU.S.JusticeDepartmentfiledsuitagainstArpaioaccusinghimofcivil
Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-2 Filed
rightsviolationsandsayingheandhisofficeintentionallyengagedinracialprofiling
andunlawfularrestofLatinosinviolationoftheirconstitutionalrights.
Thetacticsusedbythesheriff,whohasdeniedanyabusesandhasvowedtofightthe
suit,willcomeunderscrutinybeginningJuly19whenanotherracialprofilinglawsuit
isheardinU.S.DistrictCourtinPhoenix.

12/17/14 Page 3 of 4

adayagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.com
HuffingtonPost.com(AOL)OWN
OWNsteveharvey
5.The13MostHorrifyingFastFood
MenuItemsOf2014

Sheriff'sinvestigatorssaidtheyweretippedtotheassassinationplotbyajailinmate
andlearnedthatMattawasangrythathisfamilyhadbeendeportedtoMexicofrom
theirhomeinElMirage,Arizona,westofPhoenix.
TheinvestigationintotheallegedplotalsorevealedplansbyMattaandtwoother
inmatestokillanotherprisoner.Sheriff'sdetectivessaidthethreemenwerecaught
ontapeplottingtokilltheinmatebecausehewasrivalgangmember.
LateinJune,theU.S.SupremeCourtupheldakeypartofArizona'scrackdownon
illegalimmigrants,requiringpolicetochecktheimmigrationstatusofpeoplethey
stop.

5daysagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.comAOLForexKate
BratskeirKateBratskeirdunkin
donuts
6.30PerfectlyImperfectHoliday
CardOuttakes

Itthrewoutthreeotherprovisionsthathadbeenchallengedbythefederal
government.(EditingbyTimGaynor)
MORE: InmateThreatensArpaio,MaricopaCountySheriffJoeArpaio,Reuters,ArizonaPolitics,Arizona
Politics,SamuelMatta,Arizona,InmateThreatensSheriff

6daysagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.com
HuffingtonPost.com(AOL)Jessica
SamakowJessicaSamakowfunny
holidayphotos
7.TheseAreTheBestGiftsTeachers
HaveEverReceivedFromStudents

Suggestacorrection

YouMayLike

1.
WhyIsTheDominicanRepublicDenyingIts
BlackAncestry?6monthsagolive.huffingtonpost.comHuffingtonPost.com
(AOL)dominicanrepublican
AroundtheWeb

2daysagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.com
HuffingtonPost.com(AOL)Rebecca
KleinRebeccaKleinMostPopularon
HuffPost
8.TheTop10ReasonsPeopleStay
InUnhappyMarriages

MCSO:GangsterWasPlanningto"PubliclyAssassinate"JoeArpaio,butDidn't...
(http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/valleyfever/2012/07/mcso_gangster_was_planning_to.php)

Arpaiowon'tcontestjudgeinracialprofilingcase
(http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/2012/06/28/20120628arpaioracialprofilingjudge.html)

JoeArpaioDeniedBirtherDonations,RandyParrazBlastsAndyKunasek
(http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/bastard/2012/06/joe_arpaio_denied_birther_dona.php)

2.

RalDeMolinaStandsBySofiaVergara's

ChasesuspectidentifiedaccusedofArpaiodeaththreatduringrecentarrest

(http://www.azfamily.com/news/ChasesuspectidentifiedChasesuspectidentifiedaccusedof

2daysagohuffingtonpost.com
huffingtonpost.comAOLForex
BrittanyWongBrittanyWong
reasonspeoplestaymarried

Arpaiodeaththreatduringrecentarrest159381475.html)

MesamanarrestedforthreateningtokillSheriffArpaio

FOLLOWHUFFPOST

(http://www.examiner.com/article/mesamanarrestedforthreateningtokillsheriffarpaio)

SeveralthousandprotestArpaio'sTentCity
(http://www.wdtimes.com/news/national/image_bbafe0067d575dbba3f1b72da23b5c7b.html)

EmailAddress
TheMorningEmail

Signmeup!

LatinoVoices

Gettopstoriesandblogpostsemailedtomeeachday..

HuffingtonPostSearch
Advertise(Http://Advertising.Aol.Com/Brands/HuffingtonPost)
LogIn(/Users/Login/)
RSS(/Syndication)

MakeHuffPostYourHomePage(/Makehome/)
Careers(/Jobs/)

UserAgreement(/Terms.Html)

FAQ(/Faq/)

Privacy(Http://Privacy.Aol.Com/)

CommentPolicy(/Comment/Policy/)

AboutUs(/P/HuffingtonPost.Html)

AboutOurAds(Http://Adinfo.Aol.Com/AboutOurAds/)
Copyright2014TheHuffingtonPost.com,Inc.

ContactUs(/Contact/)

"TheHuffingtonPost"isaregisteredtrademarkofTheHuffingtonPost.com,Inc.Allrightsreserved.

PartofHuffPostLatino

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-2 Filed 12/17/14 Page 4 of 4

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 1 of 11

Exhibit 3

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 2 of 11

(/INSTABLOG/ALL)
POLITICS(2548)(/INSTABLOG/POLITICS)

5377

253

(http://www.addthis.com/bookmark.php?v=300&winname=addthis&pub=ra536db77a775cf072&source=t
/54923c5e08d49cdf/2&frommenu=1&uid=54923c5e84c29898&ct=0&pre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.c

SEND A TIP

(/System/Breitbart%20Send%20A%20Tip?
page=%2fInstaBlog%2f2013%2f05%2f30%2fRecall
EffortAgainstSheriffJoeArpaioFails)

BREITBART VIDEO PICKS

U.S.senatorpledgestoblockeffortsto
normalizeCubarelations
Reuters

RecallEffortAgainstSheriffJoeArpaioFails

byDEBRAHEINE(/COLUMNISTS/DEBRAHEINE) 30May2013
392
POSTACOMMENT(/INSTABLOG/2013/05/30/RECALLEFFORTAGAINSTSHERIFFJOEARPAIO
FAILS#COMMENTS)

Morevideos:

Aliberalgroup,"RespectArizona"failedinitseffort
(http://www.latimes.com/news/nation/nationnow/la
nannffarpaiorecallfails
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER
20130530,0,7548060.story)torecallpopularArizona
emailaddress
SUBSCRIBE
SheriffJoeArpaio,Thursday,butavotergrouprepresented
byLarryKlayman,isstillsuingRespectArizonabecausehe
saystherecalleffortwasillegalunderArizonalawtobegin
with.
Here(https://docs.google.com/file/d/1mjmwcVaTkeJmqBld4eLiT1Kk
ubRmrajtxRq_AWdfOz6VYBw_Ki6xRnXV8h1/edit?usp=sharing)isthe
pressreleasefromKlayman'sgroup,CitizenstoProtectFairElectionResults:

Today,predictably,theattemptedrecallofSheriffJoeArpaiobyagroup
Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14
whichironicallycallsitselfRespectArizona,failedinitsbidtobeginarecall
ofthisrespectedlawenforcementofficial,whohasjustbeenreelectedto
officeforasixthterm.Whileadmittingthattheydidnotgettherequired
numberofsignaturestobeginarecall,obviouslybecausethepeopleof
MaricopaCountyarehappytohaveSheriffArpaioremaininoffice,the
RespectArizonaspokesmenfailedtomentionthattheirattemptedrecallwas
illegalinanyevent,asnotproscribedbytheArizonaConstitutionatArticle
8,part1,section5,whichprohibitsarecallwithinsixmonthsafteranelected
officialisswornin.Inthisregard,thelawsuitfiledbyattorneyLarry
KlaymanonbehalfofthevotersofMaricopaCounty,throughhisclient,the
CitizenstoProtectFairElectionResults,issetforhearingonJune25,2013
at1:30pmbeforeJudgeMichaelHerrod.
DespiteRespectArizonasmiserablefailuretogettherequisitenumberof
signaturesneededtoconductanillegalrecall,prohibitedbytheArizona
Constitution,wemaintainthatthecasemuststillbedecidedonthemerits,
asthisabuseofprocessiscapableofrepetitiveactsthatisotherelected
officials,includingjudges,couldbesubjecttosimilarimproperschemesto
thwartthewillofthevotingpublicandnullifytheirvotes.Moreover,theuse
ofaprematureandillegalrecallefforttoraisefundsforanorganizationsuch
asRespectArizona,defraudsdonorstotherecalleffortandwastesvaluable
countyandstateresources.ItisthusnowonderthatRespectArizonahas
refusedtomakepublicthesignatureswhichitclaimstohavecollected,as
theywereprocuredunderfalsepretenses,statedKlayman.
"ThecaseagainstRespectArizonaandthecountyagencieswhichallowed
thisillegalattemptedrecalltogoforwardisthusproceedingincourt,asthis
illegalconductcannotbeallowedtohappeninthefuture.Weneedaruling
bythecourtupholdingtheArizonaConstitution,toprotectthevotersofthis
greatstateandelectedofficialsandjudgeswhowontheirelectionsfairand
square,"addedKlayman.

392Comments

BreitbartNewsNetwork

Login

Share Favorite

SortbyOldest

Jointhediscussion
zmrcleanz 2yearsago

America"ssheriff
307

Reply Share

batcountry>zmrcleanz 2yearsago

WeneedSheriffJoeinD.C.

Page 3 of 11

280

Reply Share
1:14-cv-01966-BAH
Case
Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 4 of 11
WolfMoon>batcountry 2yearsago

ItwouldbefittingforhimtoarrestObamaandEricHolder.Veryfitting.
290

Reply Share

Teachem>WolfMoon 2yearsago

Illegals,HolderandtheHusseinOslamaAdministrationhavea
stackoflawsuitsagainstJoeastheirdefense.Anotherprime
exampleofexactlyhowdivisive,andgivingreasonfortheUS
CitizentodeclarewaragainstitsGovt.
104

Reply Share

Konservative_Punk>Teachem 2yearsago

Ineverynookandcrannyofthisadministration,youwillfind
corruptionandabuseofgovernmentpowerforpoliticalends.These
illegalattemptstoblockthewillofthepeoplewilltarnishObama's
legacyforever.
94

Reply Share

BenjaminDover>Konservative_Punk 2yearsago

HusseinObamaisadelusionalmarxist.
58

Reply Share

MichaelShreve>BenjaminDover 2yearsago

No,aMarxistmegalomaniac.
3

Reply Share

BenjaminDover>MichaelShreve 2yearsago

They'renotexclusivethings.Theguy'scertainlyadelusional
marxistmegalomaniac.
1

Reply Share

Bryan>BenjaminDover 2yearsago

Ifyoudontlikeit,leavethecountry.

Reply Share

BrandyBaron>Bryan ayearago

Bryan,judgingbythereplieshereI'dsaythatyou'retheminorityso
youcanleave.We'llstayandworkonfixingourgovernment.

Reply Share

georgewashlincoln>Konservative_Punk 2yearsago

dependsonwhoiswritingthehistorybooks
9

Reply Share

coolerking>Teachem 2yearsago

Rightlyso,astheUSGovernmenthasalreadydeclaredwaronits
owncitizens.
72

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>Teachem ayearago

There'snowar!Justsubstantiatedinformation.Getyourfacts
straight.WhitepeopleshouldbethemostpissedoffatHitler
Arpaio.PeoplemovetoAZbythetruckloadsfromalloverevery
day.Mostthesepeopleareretired,poor,disabled,andgeton
welfare(EBTCashassistance,AHCCCS)becauserentisstill
supercheapeverywhere.JanBrewercan'taffordtosupportthe
majorityofthestatebecausetheymismanagedfundsforyears.
ThewholeAndrewThomasscandalcostustaxpayersMILLIONS
ANDMILLIONSofdollars.SupportedbyJoeScumpaio.Youthink
thisistheonlytime?I'manativeandIdon'tfeelsafewithhimas
sheriff.Hesthenumber1inciterofviolencehere.Heyhowabout
theroadshere.MorelikelytodieonthestreetsofPhoenixthan

givebirthtotwins.
Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH
Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 5 of 11

Reply Share

djslogg>WolfMoon 2yearsago

That'swhyneitherwillgotoSheriffJoe'scounty.BothObamaand
Holderwouldlookmuchmoregirlyinpinkprisongarb.
86

Reply Share

jackcandobutwont>djslogg 2yearsago

Iwouldpaymoneytoseethat...thebamsterandholdersharingin
pinkundiessharingtimewhileoutonthechaingang!!
39

Reply Share

chekme2>djslogg 2yearsago

YOUGOSHERIFFARPAIO.WELOVEYOU.Don'tworryabout
thoseAholes.KEEPITUP.
49

Reply Share

blebs>djslogg 2yearsago

Ohplease,Ibegofyou.Betheretotakepicturesandpostthemall
overtheinternet.I'dliketoseethewholeadministrationliving
SheriffJoestentcity.
3

Reply Share

BrandyBaron>djslogg ayearago

I'msureObamawouldbeverycomfortableingirlypinkprison
garb...andwithaboyfriendnamedBubbavisitinghiscellLOL

Reply Share

BeautifulAmerica>WolfMoon 2yearsago

Thatwouldbeperfect!
30

Reply Share

blebs>WolfMoon 2yearsago

OhhowI'dlovetoseeithappen.Tasehimfirst,clubhimnext,
brutallyhandcuffhimandlegshackletheSOB,throwhimonthe
hoodofthecruiserfortheridetojail.
13

Reply Share

AllenKincade>blebs 2yearsago

Waterboard
14

Reply Share

joesmartpaio>blebs ayearago

AreyoutalkingaboutthePres?SecretServiceiscominforyour
sorryass...

Reply Share

georgewashlincoln>WolfMoon 2yearsago

idpaymoneytoseethat!
11

Reply Share

rm56>WolfMoon 2yearsago

OMG!Thatwouldbesocool.TohaveSheriffJoemarchinwithhis
deputiesandslapironsonthemandmarchthemofftojailwhere
theybelong.OnthatdayIwouldbeproudofAmerica.Thesedays
notsomuch.
9

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>rm56 ayearago

LOLsucharacistbigothypocrite...commentslikeyoursmakeit
hardtobeawhiteguy

Reply Share

ballpark1981>WolfMoon 2yearsago
Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH
Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 6 of 11

killedwillbeingarrestedworks,also

Reply Share

blebs>ballpark1981 2yearsago

No.Noeasyoutsforthesepeople.Deathwouldbetookind.They
needlifewithBubba.
1

Reply Share

disqus_8DcPHcJNZ3>WolfMoon 2yearsago

Watchforit.

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>WolfMoon ayearago

ItwouldbefittingforsomeonetoXXX...SheriffJoe

Reply Share

NovelConcepts>batcountry 2yearsago

IfSheriffJoewasinD.C...Hewouldruneachandeveryoneofourcorrupt
andselfservingpoliticiansrightoutoftown...orbetteryet,straighttojail.
Therewouldonlybeahandfulofstaffersleftintown.
99

Reply Share

brucelorraine>NovelConcepts 2yearsago

IfsheriffJoewasinDCtheLiberals,flamingtourchesinhand,
wouldstormthecastle&burnthemonsterout.
IwishwehadJoeinOakland.
35

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>brucelorraine ayearago

LOLnoyoudon't.You'dhaveariotwithinhoursofhiselection

Reply Share

opa>NovelConcepts 2yearsago

Troubleis,theentrenchedstaffersareabigpartoftheproblem.
Theyrighttheregulationsbasedonthelaws.
21

Reply Share

parabellum>NovelConcepts 2yearsago

StartingwiththecorruptpowerhungrypsychopathpimpcalledV.
AliattheDMV.
2

Reply Share

blueangel69>NovelConcepts 2yearsago

Garsh,IthinkIjusthadanepiphany.Theconnectionbetween
HollyweirdandDC?They'rebothpartsofLaLaLand.
10

Reply Share

disqus_8DcPHcJNZ3>NovelConcepts 2yearsago

Won'thappen.WeneedhiminArizonaaslongashechoosesto
run.
2

Reply Share

joereg4>batcountry 2yearsago

HeusedtobeinDC.Hekickedbuttinanagencythateventuallybecame
theDEA.
17

Reply Share

chekme2>batcountry 2yearsago

Heck,weneedSheriffJoe,EVERY
WEHRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
28

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>batcountry ayearago

haha,thenhewouldpickonblackpeople
Case
1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 7 of 11

Reply Share

ChrisDennis>zmrcleanz 2yearsago

America'sSheriff!!!Neededexclamationmarksbehindthatstatement!
96

Reply Share

Guest>zmrcleanz 2yearsago

IthinkthewholeideaofarecallwastotryandsmearsheriffJoeandmakeitlook
likehedidnothavetheconfidenceofthevoters.liberalsocialistswilltryacreate
aproblemwherenonereallyexistsinordertodestroysomeonewhodisagrees
withthem.
88

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>Guest ayearago

UHHHHNOwrongagain!therecallwasbecausethepublicissickofhis
antics,andstaiddemeanoraboutwaistingmillionsofourtaxdollarson
tryingtoindictjudgesbasedonfalseevidence.Alotofppldontknowhe
hasadaughterwhoisadrugaddictthatgetsspecialtreatment,hisother
daughterrunsthefoodprogramforallthejails,andalothesaysisalie,
He'sachickenandwon'tcommentonhisbuddyAndrewThomas

Reply Share

Guest>MistrSlapjaw ayearago

youhavejoinedtheranksoftheterminallystupid.Isincerelyhope
youlivelongenoughtoseetheerrorofyourways.
1

Reply Share

Guest>Guest ayearago

whyisdisqussendingnotificationsthataremonthsold????Ido
notreplytoeveryidiotwhorespondstothatwhichIpost.slapjaw,
whyareyoubotheringtoposttosomethingthisold?evenmyold
brainsaysenoughtimehaspassed.
1

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>Guest ayearago

Heyoldwhiteguy,Ithinkyourconfusingthetermterminallystupid
fromterminallyillwhichiswhatyour"oldbrain"is.Pleasehurryup
anddiesothatyourabilitytovoteiscoveredin6feetofdirt.Sheriff
Joeisan"oldwhiteidiot"likeyouare.Iamanative"whiteman"who
canseethroughtheBSbigotrykindoflikesomeonewhohasa
name"oldwhiteguy"Hopefullyyourabilitytoseewilldiminishand
maybesomedayyouwillactuallyseethe"light"andstopsticking
upforaJAlikeSheriffJoe.SunCityisnottheonlytownin
AZ...Closedmindsshouldkeepclosedmouthes.

Reply Share

BrandyBaron>MistrSlapjaw ayearago

Andhowdidthatrecallend????Therewasn'tevenenough"public
issickofhisantics"togetenoughsignaturestoputarecallonthe
ballot!LMAO!!!

Reply Share

roccity>zmrcleanz 2yearsago

Isaywetakeallthatammothatbigsishasbeenstoringuptouseagainst
americansandgiveitalltoJoe..That'saMANIcanstandbehind.Thatspineless
patheticwormfoodOsamabinBarackObamacouldpickupapointerortwofrom
him.
14

Reply Share

MistrSlapjaw>zmrcleanz ayearago

JoeArpaioisapoopface

Reply Share

deportillegals 2yearsago

deportillegals 2yearsago

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 8 of 11

SheriffJoerocks!
127

Reply Share

SoWhatBubb 2yearsago

Waytogo,Joe.
Iwishyouweremysheriff.
105

Reply Share

Loadmorecomments

WHAT'STHIS?

ALSOONBREITBARTNEWSNETWORK

MichelleObama'sExampleofRacismat
TargetProbablyWasn'tRacism

SonyCancels'TheInterview'Theatrical
Release

225comments6hoursago

652comments4hoursago

Redleg7I'mtall.Fromayoungagemy

KevSandersTheywantedtorelease

Momhasaskedmetohelpgetthings
fromthetopcabinets.Igoto

obama'scollegerecords.Theycouldn't
findany.

IsCyberattackonSonyDisruptive
EnoughtoConstituteanActofWar

ChamberofCommerce'Welcomes'
ObamaCubaAnnouncement

205comments4hoursago

95comments6hoursago

nopc4meNo,justtheirblatant

KJinAZAnybusinessthatdisplaysa

HYPOCRISY.

ChamberofCommercesignwillnolonger
getmybusiness.Theonlyway

Subscribe

AddDisqustoyoursite

Privacy

FROM OUR PARTNERS

FoxNewsPolitics

FoxNewsNational

FoxNewsSports

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document

9 of 11
Email 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page
SUBSCRIBE

SUBSCRIBE TO

'S NEWS ALERTS

WND

EFFORT TO OUST SHERIFF JOE FAILS

'Aftermonthsofnamecalling,disparagingeffigiesandtheatrics'
Published:05/30/2013at8:44PM

TheefforttorecallAmericastoughestsheriff,MaricopaCounty,
ArizonasJoeArpaio,fellshortofthe355,000votersignaturesneededby
yesterdayafternoon.
Arpaioreactedtotheoutcomeinastatement.
Aftermonthsofnamecalling,afterthedisparagingeffigiesandtheatrics
thislatestrecallefforthasfailed,thesheriffsaid.Thiseffortfailed
becausethegoodpeopleofMaricopaCounty,whomImhonoredto
serve,rejectedthewrongheadedideaofoverturninganelection.

(http://www.wnd.com/2013/05/do
sheriff
joes
enemies
have
enough
signatures
tooust
him/print/) SheriffJoeArpaio

TherecallcampaignwaslaunchedbyRespectArizona(https://www.recallarpaio.com/)andCitizensforaBetter
Arizona,whichprotestedthesheriffsaggressiveapproachtostoppingillegalimmigration,charginghisofficetargets
peopleonthebasisofrace,inviolationoftheConstitution.
RespectArizonasaiditbelievesourchildrendeserveasheriffthatrespectsfamilies,respectsimmigrantsandrespects
Latinos.
RandyParraz,presidentofCitizensforBetterArizona,toldtheLosAngelesTimesthetwogroupshadnearly300,000
signaturesbythe5p.m.deadlineThursday.HesaidthesetbackwontslowdownArpaioscritics,vowingthisfightis
notover.
InsupportofArpaio,whosebackersareaspassionateashisenemies,agroupcalledCitizenstoProtectFairElection
Results(http://www.cpfer.com/)wasformed.
ThegroupsattorneyLarryKlayman(http://www.larryklayman.com),founderofJudicialWatchandFreedomWatch,
saiddangerous,subversivelikeactivitiesofRespectArizonahavethepotentialtolaunchthiscountyandpossiblythe
entirestateinwhatcanonlybecalledanElectoralCivilWarthatcouldcostthecitizensofArizonamillionsoftaxpayer
dollars.
KlaymanchargedtheallegationsagainstArpaioarenotonlyfalseontheirface,but,inaddition,alsofraudulentsince
RespectArizonaobviouslydoesnotrepresentthemajorityofvotersofMaricopaCounty,Arizona,whojustreelected
SheriffArpaioafewmonthsago.
Arpaiosopponentscontendhemustbedismissedbecausehisofficehasfailedtoadequatelyinvestigatemorethan
400sexcrimescasesandhascostthecounty$25millioninlegalsettlementsovertreatmentincountyjails.
Inaddition,inacomplaintbroughtbyLatinos,afederaljudgeruledlastFridaythatArpaioandhisdeputies
unconstitutionallytargetpeoplebecauseofrace.
TherulingbyU.S.DistrictCourtJudgeMurraySnowcameinresponsetoaclassactionlawsuitbroughtbyHispanic
drivers.Atissuewaswhetherpolicecantargetillegalimmigrantswithoutraciallyprofilinginnocentcitizensandlegal
residentsofHispanicorigin.
TherulingchargestheagencystoppedcarsbecausetheyhaddarkskinnedpeopleinthemandarrestedLatinosfor
suspectedimmigrationviolationswithoutproperauthority.
Thesheriffstronglyinsiststherehasbeennoracialprofiling,andheplanstoappealthedecision.

AlreadySubscribed?

Lastsummer,theObamaJusticeDepartmentclosedacriminalprobeintoArpaioandhisdeputiesthatalsocharged
Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 10
racialprofilingofLatinosandunlawfularrest.Theinvestigationbeganin2008.

of 11

TheJusticeDepartmentalsosuedArizonaforitslawallowingstatelawenforcementofficerstoenforcefederal
immigrationlaws.
AsWNDreported(http://wnd.com/?p=215895),ArpaiohaschargedObamaiswagingwaronArizonaoverillegal
immigration.
Arpaiossupportershavearguedthesheriffwonreelectionfairlyandthatrecallorganizersshouldntbeallowedto
contesttheelectionbecausetheydidntliketheoutcome.
Arpaiohassaidhisofficeaddressedtheproblemswiththesexcrimesinvestigationsandhasmadechangestoprevent
arepeat.
InJanuary,theU.S.SupremeCourtruledregardingstateSenateBill1070thatArizonahastherighttoaskwhether
suspectsareintheU.S.legallybutcannotpunishanyoneforit.
Inresponsetotheruling,HomelandSecuritySecretaryJanetNapolitanossuspendedthe287(g)program,which
allowedtheDHStodeputizelocal,countyandstatelawenforcementofficerstoassistintheenforcementoffederal
immigrationlaws.
EvidentlyObamadidntgeteverythingtheywantedfromtheSupremeCourt,sotheydecidedtoretaliateagainst
Arizona,Arpaiosaidatthetime.
WhattheObamaadministrationwantsisamnesty,Arpaiosaid.DHShasmadeitclearthegoalistoallowpeople
hereillegallytohitthestreets.
ArpaiosColdCasePosseteamofvolunteerinvestigatorscontinuestoprobePresidentObamaseligibilityforoffice
(http://www.wnd.com/2013/05/sheriffjoetocongressinvestigateobamaseligibility/),focusingonthebirthcertificate
madepublicbytheWhiteHouse.Arpaioandthepossehaveconcludedthebirthcertificateisafraudandareurging
Congresstoinvestigate.
InApril,asuspiciouspackageaddressedtoArpaiocontainedabombthatwaspowerfulenoughtomaimorevenkill
him,hisofficesaid.

(http://www.wnd.com/2013/05/do
sheriff
joes
enemies
Note:Readourdiscussionguidelines(/discussionguidelines/)beforecommenting.

have
enough
signatures
tooust

SECTIONS

FEATURES

RESOURCES

WNDWEEKLY
him/print/)
(HTTP://SUPERSTORE.WND.COM/WORLDNETWEEKLY)CONTACT WND

WNDTV
CARTOONS
ABOUTWND(/ABOUT
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/WND
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/OPINION/CARTOONS/)
WND/)
WHOREADSUS
TV/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/WHO
REVIEWS
ADVERTISING
READSUS/)
COMMENTARY
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/DIVERSIONS/REVIEWS/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/ADVERTISE
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/OPINION/COMMENTARY/)
WITHWND/)
WHO'SWHOATWND
DAILYBLESSING
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/WHOS
POLITICS
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/AUTHOR/DAILYBLESSING/)
COMMENTATORLINEUP
WHOATWND/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/FRONT
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/COMMENTATORS/)
PAGE/POLITICS/)
EMAILTOTHEEDITOR
WNDHISTORY(/ON
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/OPINION/EMAILS
DONATETOWND
THISDAYINWND
U.S.
TOTHEEDITOR/)
(HTTP://SUPERSTORE.WND.COM/SPECIALTY
HISTORY/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/FRONT
ITEMS/CONTRIBUTIONS)
PAGE/US/)
FORUMS
WNDSCOOPS
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/OPINION/FORUMS/)
NEWSALERTS
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/WND
WORLD
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/SIGN
SCOOPSYOUREADIT
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/FRONT
PETITIONS
UPFORWNDSFREE
HEREFIRST/)
PAGE/WORLD/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/OPINION/PETITIONS/)
EMAILALERTS/)
MOBILEWND
FAITH
JOKEOFTHEDAY
G2BULLETIN
(HTTP://MOBILE.WND.COM/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/FRONT
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/DIVERSIONS/JOKE/)
(HTTP://G2BULLETIN.WND.COM/)
PAGE/FAITH/)
REDALERT
HEALTH
(HTTP://REDALERT.WND.COM/)
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/FRONT
PAGE/HEALTH/)
WNDSUPERSTORE
(HTTP://SUPERSTORE.WND.COM/)

AdvertisingInquiries
(/contactwnd/?
subject=advertising)
Corrections(/contact
wnd/?
subject=corrections)
EmailtotheEditor
(/contactwnd/?
subject=email)
NewsTips(/contact
wnd/?subject=tips)
Testimonials(/contact
wnd/?
subject=testimonial)

EDUCATION
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/FRONT
PAGE/EDUCATION/)

WNDBOOKS

Case 1:14-cv-01966-BAH
Document 17-3 Filed 12/17/14 Page 11 ofQuestions(/contact
11
(HTTP://WNDBOOKS.WND.COM/)

MONEY
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/MONEY/)

WHISTLEBLOWER
(HTTP://SUPERSTORE.WND.COM/WHISTLEBLOWER)

wnd/?
subject=questions)

DIVERSIONS
(HTTP://WWW.WND.COM/CATEGORY/DIVERSIONS/)

Copyright19972014.AllRightsReserved.WND.com.

(/privacypolicy/)

TermsofUse(/termsofuse/)

PrivacyPolicy(/privacypolicy/)