1
Table of ContentsExecutive Summary..................................................................................................................................3
Background...................................................................................................................................3
Methodology.................................................................................................................................4
National Operation and Oversight of Detention Centers..........................................................4
International Human Rights Law.................................................................................................5
Applicable Domestic Law............................................................................................................5
The Northwest Detention Center................................................................................................5
Report Findings............................................................................................................................6
Conclusions and Recommendations..........................................................................................9
I. Introduction...........................................................................................................................................11
II. Methodology........................................................................................................................................12
III. Background of Immigrant Detention in the United States.............................................................14
A. Shift in Immigration Policy Led to Dramatic Increases in Detention................................14
B. Operation of and National Standards for Detention Centers.............................................16
C. Investigations Repeatedly Find Inhumane Conditions andAbuse in Detention Centers..................................................................................................17
1. ABA and UNHCR Note Major Deficiencies.................................................................17
2. NGO Reports Also Note Serious Problems................................................................17
3. U.S. Government Identified Similar Deficiencies........................................................18
4. Poor Detention Conditions in the International Spotlight.............................................19
5. All Reports Consistently Recommend Binding National Detention Standards............19
IV. International Human Rights Law......................................................................................................21
A. Treaties...................................................................................................................................21
B. Customary International Law................................................................................................22
C. Specific Rights under International Human Rights Law....................................................22
1.
Right to Liberty: Freedom from Arbitrary Detention.....................................................22
2.
Prohibition on Torture and Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment...........................23
3.
Right to Legal Access and Due Process......................................................................24
4.
Right to Food and Medical Care..................................................................................25
5.
Right to Family Unity....................................................................................................25
6.
The Rights of Refugees under International Law.........................................................26
a. The Convention on Refugees Prohibits Most Detentions of Refugees..........27
b.
Treatment of Refugees in Detention............................................................28
V.
Applicable Domestic Law...................................................................................................................30
A.
Federal Law and Regulations Governing Conditions of Detention..................................30
B.
Constitutional Rights of Immigrant Detainees....................................................................31
1.
Prohibition Against Cruel and Inhuman Treatment......................................................31
2.
Rights to Family Unity..................................................................................................32
VI. Conditions at the Northwest Detention Center (NWDC)................................................................34
A. Background............................................................................................................................34