You are on page 1of 13

January 2010

L a n e F i n a n c i a l M a n ag e m e n t
Stock Market Commentary .. by Ed Lane

Happy New Year


Wow! Not many of us have witnessed a with virtually
year like 2009 before — not so much be- no net growth
cause of market performance (see below for in either index
the S&P 500 (black, left axis) and NASDAQ in over 10
Special points of interest: (red, right axis) indexes in 1997, 1999, and years, we can
2003 for other examples of rapid price ap- take these
 Positive market mo-
preciation), but for the economic conditions lessons to inform our investment strategy
mentum continued in
and global government response to it. for the coming year (and beyond).
December
Now that the year is over, I can say I learned For my part, as you will see in my 2010
 The economy shows
two important lessons: One, in the face of forecast on the following pages, I will try
signs of slow but steady
impending economic disaster, do not under- not to let my current opinions about the
improvement
estimate the willingness of global govern- challenges facing the economy overly in-
 Interest rates may be ments to do whatever it takes to try to fluence my thinking about investment op-
increasing in anticipa- lessen the pain and restore growth. portunities, but rather give greater cre-
tion of Fed exit strate- dence to what the market itself is telling
The other lesson, even more valuable from
gies; the market may us through technical analysis. While fun-
an investor’s standpoint, is that the momen-
not be ready damental and technical analysis both rely
tum of a market is a more reliable predictor
 2010 Fearless Forecast on extrapolation of historical behavior,
of market performance than the opinions of
starts on page 3 technical analysis boils that behavior
market strategists.
down in a way that fundamental analysis
As we enter the final year of the decade cannot do.

Inside this issue:

Happy New Year 1

At-a-Glance 2
2010 Fearless Forecast 3-5

Economic Recap 6

Market Recap 7-8

Momentum Watch 9-11

My Bottom Line 12

Disclosures 13
Page 2
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
At-a-Glance
Here is a quick summary of this month’s  Asia/Pacific (ex. Japan) gave back some
market commentary: of its earlier gains but still had a strong
year
The Economy
 High yield bonds ended the year
Economic signals were generally positive for
strongly as credit spreads tightened.
the month:
The chart below shows 2009 returns for
 Initial claims for unemployment insurance
selected market sectors (detail on page 7).
continued to decline. The unemploy-
ment rate is inching downward as non- The Current Opportunities
The future ain’t what it farm payrolls declined only slightly in No-
Longer term, the best opportunities are
used to be. vember
Asia/Pacific (ex. Japan), Emerging Markets,
— Yogi Berra  The Index of Leading indicators contin- basic materials and technology.
ued its uptrend while Consumer Senti-
2010 Forecast
ment has retraced its decline back to
year-ago levels. The market will continue to do well, though
at a reduced pace, as long as government
Ironically, as the economy improves, recent
stimulus continues to flow.
Fed discussions about strategies to exit
stimulus programs sent negative shocks to My Bottom Line

the markets. I continue to be concerned about the pros-


The Market pects for the U.S. economy over the next
several years absent sustainable new em-
For the most part, momentum remained
ployment opportunities. The securities
positive in December:
market, on the other hand, will continue to
 Both the S&P 500 and Emerging Markets provide opportunities for gain.
performed strongly in December
Page 3
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
2010 Fearless Forecast — On the One Hand, On the Other
Before I offer my forecast for stock market foreign-earned profits will push the S&P
performance and the economy in 2010, 500 higher, perhaps even higher than
here’s what others are saying: conventional wisdom, to a range of
1200-1300.
 In a recent Bloomberg survey of leading
strategists from ten of the largest bro-  On the other hand, the brakes will
kerages, the S&P 500 will advance an av- come on when deficit reduction plans
erage of 9.8% for 2010. A Barron’s sur- and activities become more clear and
vey of twelve strategists predicted 12%. imminent.

 Mohamed El-Erian of PIMCO has pre-  The saving grace for the market in 2009
dicted a10% decline for the year (notable was massive global intervention. Since
since this is something few asset manager over half of already approved U.S.
There's no trick to be- market strategists ever do). stimulus remains to be distributed in the
ing a humorist when first half of 2010 and more may come,
 Economists Nouriel Roubini of NYU, Joe
you have the whole the stimulus will have its desired effect
Stiglitz of Columbia and Paul Krugman of
government working on consumption and will boost market
Princeton (the latter two being Nobel
for you. performance.
laureates) have all indicated a ―significant‖
— Will Rogers chance of economic decline in 2010,  Sooner or later, as recovery appears to
most likely to occur in the second half of be more imminent (or deficits too large
the year, absent additional government to ignore), the Fed will begin to with-
stimulus. draw liquidity from the system or, at
least, signal that that moment is nigh.
Many forecasters indicate that the S&P will
Ironically, when this happens, it’s likely
cool in the second half of the year as stimulus
to place a strain on the market as inter-
funds are expended (again, absent additional
est rates increase and credit conditions
stimulus).
tighten. That said, I don’t expect this
As an actuary, I should know not to make will occur much sooner than late 2010.
predictions as the one thing we know for
 Domestically, technology, large cap,
sure about forecasts and assumptions of the
consumer discretionary, basic materials
future is that they will be wrong. That said,
and medical devices are likely to be
I’m inclined to go along with the majority
among the best performers.
opinion of the market strategists, namely,
that the U.S. market will be positive for the  From a regional standpoint, Emerging
year with the best part of the performance Markets and Asia/Pacific (excluding Ja-
occurring in the first half of the year. pan, ―AxJ‖), though more volatile, are
likely to outperform the S&P 500 and
My 2010 forecast reflects the ying and yang
other developed markets for the fore-
of the U.S. market in 2010 as I see it.
seeable future.
 On the one hand, stimulus payments and
Page 4
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
2010 Fearless Forecast (cont.)
 I’m ambivalent about the dollar. Weak- will be watching carefully:
ness is in U.S. interests in that it stimu-
Employment is the ―sine qua non‖ to con-
lates exports and fattens foreign-earned
sumer spending and there are several meas-
profits. On the other hand, as the Fed
ures to keep in mind, including new unem-
unwinds stimulus and deficit hawks gain
ployment insurance claims, the unemploy-
the upper hand, rising interest rates will
ment rate, and hours worked. As the graph
strengthen the dollar. Bottom line, I see
below shows, the employment picture is
the dollar strengthening by the end of
indeed improving, but still has a long way to
the year.
go. I expect new unemployment insurance
Any man who afflicts  I have become less enthusiastic about claims to continue to decrease and the num-
the human race with gold. With ―push me, pull you‖ influ- ber of new jobs created to steadily increase,
ideas must be prepared ences and interest rate risk to the upside, though not enough to bring the unemploy-
to see them misunder- gold’s expected performance is too un- ment rate below 9% by year-end.
stood. predictable to continue my previous bull-
 H.L. Mencken ish stance.

 Quality and high yield income securities


of short and intermediate duration
(conventional and convertible bonds and
preferred stocks) will provide reasonable
returns with limited volatility. That said,
the prospect of increasing interest rates,
could put these funds (especially invest-
Consumer spending derives not only from
ment grade) under price pressure.
improvement in disposable income, but also
Despite stimulus, difficulties will remain in from access to, and use of, credit. There-
the domestic economy. Ultimately, the fore, interest rates and credit conditions will
economy can’t fully recover until final de- be important factors to watch. While posi-
mand is restored (consumer spending ac- tive in some respects, the charts on the
counts for about 65% of GDP). Stimulus next page are troubling to the markets in
spending will support demand for a period of that interest rates are increasing and con-
time, but no one believes that can continue sumer credit is continuing to unwind. I be-
indefinitely. The hope, I suspect, is that the lieve the 10-year Treasury bond rate will
stimulus will provide a catalyst for a more continue to climb, perhaps to 4.5%, while
self-sustaining economy. We’ll see. consumer credit continues to contract, both

While I will lean heavily on technical momen- unfavorable to the economy and the market

tum indicators to help identify investment in the short run, at least.

opportunities, here are some of the eco- Finally, I will be listening to the ―buzz‖ —
nomic indicators affecting final demand that I interviews with (admittedly selected) econo-
Page 5
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
2010 Fearless Forecast (cont.)
for any large institution that moves.

Francine McKenna (Re: The Auditors):


there is no need for me to be afraid but every
reason to be wary.

Trader Mark (Fund My Mutual Fund): Ben


Bernanke can remain irrational far longer than I
can remain solvent.

Karen Glassman (Tirschwell & Loewy):


Gordon Gekko has the same initials as Greed is
When the facts change, Good, Government and Goldman … how ironic.
I change my mind.
Stuart Varney (Fox Business Network): it
What do you do, sir?
is possible to borrow a trillion dollars, print a
— John Maynard trillion dollars and nationalize a big chunk of the
mists and money managers who go beyond a American economy, and still see the biggest nine
Keynes
superficial discussion of ―green shoots.‖ month stock market rally in three generations!
Without going into detail, I would say the
OneTwo (1-2 Knockout): no one ever went
economic outlook from these sources today broke underestimating the stupidity of govern-
is cautious if not decidedly negative. ment.
I close out 2009 and ring in 2010 with a little Patty Edwards (CNBC Fast Money): money
investment wisdom (edited for space), cour- covers a multitude of sins, usually those of politi-
tesy http://www.investmentpostcards.com/: cians and bureaucrats.

The Reformed Broker: If it’s true that we Tadas Viskanta (Abnormal Returns): Too
learn new things with every passing year then the big to fail = Too big to exist…also, it’s Gold-
year 2009 was like a crash course in fringe eco- man’s world, we are just living in it.
nomics, lunatic civics and paranormal market ac- Michael Panzner (Financial Armageddon):
tivity all rolled up in one. only three words matter when it comes to in-
TPC (The Pragmatic Capitalist): Wall Street- vesting in today’s markets: ignorance is bliss.
ers are like gold fish - they have very short The Analyst (The Atlantic): despite 10% (or
memories, are practically useless and require a 18%) unemployment, it totally makes sense that
great deal of help from outside resources to sur- retail and consumer discretionary stocks are
vive. back up to 2007 levels.
Lawrence McDonald (Author, A Colossal Wade Slome (Sidoxia Capital): $14 trillion
Failure of Common Sense): $10 trillion will al- in debt, 10% unemployment, and approval of
ways buy you 4000 DOW points. socialized healthcare can lead to an +80% move
Noah Rosenblatt (UrbanDigs): the fed can in the NASDAQ Composite over a 10 month
really buy their way out of a depression. period.

Eric Jackson (Ironfire Capital): it’s always


darkest before the Fed jumps in with backstops
Page 6
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Economic Recap
We ended November with the shock of Du- real consumer spending.
bai requesting extension on their massive
 The Conference Board's Index of Lead-
debt repayment. The result was a one day
ing Economic Indicators continued its
loss of nearly 2% in the S&P 500 and a nearly
uptrend in November giving a strong
4% drop in the Morgan Stanley Emerging
signal that the recent recession has
Market index. In both cases, the indexes
ended. The 0.9% rise was the eighth
bounced back the very next day suggesting,
consecutive monthly increase. More-
perhaps, an over-reaction to the news of po-
over, the 10.2% (centered) rate of in-
tential default. Since then, we’ve learned that
crease during the last six months was
Abu Dhabi seems to have come to Dubai’s
nearly the strongest since early-1983.
rescue with a $10 billion debt guarantee.
 The Institute for Supply Management
Other developments during the month, as
reported at the end of December that
reported by Haver Analytics and Bloomberg
An economist is an ex- its barometer rose to 60, exceeding the
were:
pert who will know to- most optimistic estimate of economists
morrow why things he  The pace of the economic recovery surveyed by Bloomberg News and the
predicted yesterday did- lagged as the strength of inventory re- highest level since January 2006.

n’t happen today. building disappointed in November. The


Then, there was this opening line to close
degree of inventory liquidation and re-
— Laurence J. Peter out the month and the year...
build has a significant influence on GDP.
“Dec. 30 (Bloomberg) -- Most U.S. stocks re-
 The labor market improved during No-
treated as investors speculated the Federal Re-
vember with the Bureau of Labor Statis-
serve will withdraw stimulus measures amid
tics reporting that nonfarm payrolls fell
growing evidence the economy is improving.”
by ―only‖ 11,000. (Payrolls need to grow
by around 200,000 jobs just to stay even ...suggesting the irony that an improving
with population growth.) The payroll em- economy will not be good for the stock
ployment decline was the shallowest market, at least in the short run.

since the recession began. Initial jobless As indicated in my 2010 forecast, a


claims fell by 22,000 in the week ended strengthening economy expected to lead to
Dec. 26, the lowest level since July 2008. a deleveraging of government debt and in-
 Consumer sentiment began December creasing interest rates might be good news
by retracing the declines of October and for deficit hawks and long term economic
November. The rise in sentiment was health, but will put a damper on the stock
near the highest since January of last market and threaten the pace of recovery.

year. According to Haver Analytics, dur- It seems investors are just not comfortable
ing the last ten years there has been a yet that the market is ready to fly on its
two-thirds correlation between the level own.

of sentiment and the three-month change


Page 7
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt

Market Recap

In the chart below, we see the twelve- then but trailing off considerably on Decem-
month performance of several exchange- ber 31st. Results for December were
traded and closed-end funds representing strongest for the S&P 500 and Emerging Mar-
selected investment sectors. kets, subpar for Europe and Asia/Pacific (ex.
Japan). Meanwhile, investment grade bonds
As I have reported in the past, in June, Au-
lost value while high yield bonds were very
gust and again in October, there were rela-
strong, reflecting rising investment grade
tively short-lived corrections on the contin-
yields and a tightening of the credit spread.
ued advance upward. Since I admit to my
reservations about the substance and poten-
In spite of the cost of
tial extent of the economic recovery in the
living, it’s still popular.
U.S., I see these minor corrections as warn-
— Laurence J. Peter ing signals of a fragile market.

In November, upward momentum contin-


ued until the Dubai announcement the day
after Thanksgiving. Following an immediate
correction to the shock of the announce-
ment, the equity markets basically drifted in
the first half of December, improving since

A prospectus for the above funds can be obtained through this website:
http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/research/etfs.aspx
Page 8
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Market Recap (cont.)
Looking at selected bellwethers represented ury bond rates brought about by the Fed’s
by ETFs in the annual chart below, basic ma- discussion of stimulus exit strategies which,
terials, technology and consumer discretion- in turn, signaled dollar strengthening. The
ary substantially outperformed the S&P 500 graph below shows a highly (though hardly
for the year while financials lagged. perfect) negative correlation between
movements in the 10-year Treasury bond
In this monthly chart, we see real estate
rate and the gold ETF over the last three
years (past relationships cannot be de-
pended upon to continue).
Get your facts first, and
then you can distort
them as much as you
please.

— Mark Twain
(largely commercial), technology and basic
materials all have the strongest month.
Gold, on the other hand, reversed some 7%
for the month. This was attributable, in my
view, to the increase in the 10-year Treas-

A prospectus for the above funds can be obtained through this website:
http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/research/etfs.aspx
Page 9
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Momentum Watch

mation for the MSCI Emerging Markets in-


This section highlights various technical
dex.
measures of momentum. These measures
are not unique and vary depending on the  The 75– and 150-day EMAs remain posi-
subject and time period. Caution on reli- tive, though not as aggressively so as the
ance is advised in the same way that caution S&P 500.
would be advised for fundamental analysis.  The MACD turned bearish around the
That said, I use momentum indicators to beginning of November and continues
inform trading decisions and fundamental to have that tilt, though not excessively
―Fundamental analysis economic analysis to inform longer term or so.
explains currency move- secular views.
ment in terms of macro- On the top of page 11, another chart shows
On the chart of the S&P 500 index on the a nearly 30-year weekly value of the S&P
economic variables such
top of the next page: 500 index along with a 50- and 75-week
as growth, inflation,
monetary policy, etc.  Momentum, as measured by 75- and EMA and the MACD (with different parame-
One of the weaknesses 150-day exponential moving averages ters than on the previous page). Notice
of fundamental analysis is (EMA), remains positive. The weaken- how well future price direction is
that it says very little ing momentum that appeared in No- ―predicted‖ by crossovers of the price and
about the timing of vember gave way to continued improve- the EMA line once the slope of the EMA
moves and risk manage- ment in the second half of December on changes.
ment. a spike in volume. While it’s true that a substantial portion of
Timing is an important  The spread between the daily price and the advance since last March would have
part of risk management. the 75-day EMA widened in a bullish been missed had one followed this indicator,
Even rudimentary techni- move. it is also true the decline from the beginning
cal analysis can help in- of 2008 would have been avoided for more
 The MACD (another indicator used to
vestors fine-tune their than a net positive result. Following the
measure direction and strength of mo-
entrance into an invest- MACD at extremes would have also given a
mentum) began to change course at the
ment and help quantify very favorable result, although there was
beginning of October and appears to be
the risk. Monitoring the greater potential for false starts.
weakening once again.
price action itself will At the bottom of page 11 we see a compa-
 The resistance line at 1000 has been
likely reveal a higher rable chart with a faster moving average to
handily exceeded and now forms a sup-
probability of successful indicate momentum over a shorter period.
port to a potential correction. I’ve
opportunities….‖ Here we also see positive momentum, but
placed my next resistance line at 1200,
— Journal of Indexes perhaps with less conviction as the slope of
near the bottom end of the range of my
the EMA, though still positive, is not as
year-end prediction of 1200-1300.
strong as on the longer timeframe chart.
The second chart shows comparable infor-
Page 10
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Technical Analysis (cont.)

I have left orders to


be awakened at any
time in case of na-
tional emergency,
even if I’m in a cabi-
net meeting.

— Ronald Reagan

The S&P 500 and the MSCI Emerging Markets indexes are unmanaged indexes which cannot be invested into
directly. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Page 11
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Technical Analysis (cont.)

The secret to creativ-


ity is knowing how to
hide your sources.

— Albert Einstein

The S&P 500 is an unmanaged index which cannot be invested into directly. Past performance is no guarantee of
future results.
Page 12
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt

My Bottom Line
2009 was a teachable moment, and I expect  By the fourth quarter of 2010, there will
2010 will be, as well. In 2009, we learned be enough ―green shoots‖ and/or the
that governments around the world will in- pressure from deficit hawks will be so
tervene aggressively to stave off, or repair strong that the Fed will begin gradual
from, a deep recession. And we learned tightening, hoping to avoid a shock to
that it worked (so far). the system as a result of tighter credit

In 2010 (or 2011), we will learn whether the  But a shock will occur since the false
global stimulus was enough to rekindle nature of the economic and market
economies (some will surely benefit more gains in the years leading up to October
Frankly, I am suspicious
than others) for sustainable growth. And, 2007 (based as they were on extremely
of anyone who has a
we will learn how governments will deal lax credit standards and profits in the
strong opinion on a com-
with the humongous deficits created to pro- financial sector derived from discredited
plicated issue.
vide the stimulus and the impact of these products) cannot be papered over; new
— Scott Adams (Dilbert actions on securities markets. industries will need to be created and
cartoonist) nurtured
I’ll continue my 2010 forecast with these
thoughts. With regard to the U.S. economy  The U.S. stock markets will seek a new,
and stock market, my suspicion is that the lower trend line as the ―new normal’
following will occur: predicted by Mohamed El-Erian of
PIMCO comes into focus.
 The impact of already committed stimu-
lus payments will keep the ―green Meanwhile, while I suspect a comparable
shoots‖ coming through the first half of result will occur in other developed econo-
the year and maybe through the third mies (especially in Western Europe), emerg-
quarter, as well ing and developed economies in Asia/Pacific
(excluding Japan) and Latin America will gen-
 Congress will pass a ―jobs‖ bill in early
erate the greatest share of global growth
2010 that will add more fuel to the
because:
economy
 A global economic rebalancing will be
 Remaining and new stimulus programs
driven by greater self-reliance and trad-
will put more money in the hands of
ing within their own sphere and
consumers than did earlier stimulus
(that largely went to large financial insti-  Their political systems are less ham-
tutions only to stay there), boosting strung than those of the West and,
consumer spending therefore, can address local problems
more quickly.
 The S&P 500 as well as small and mid-
cap stocks will do reasonably well ** *** **
through the first 3 quarters of the year,
Best wishes for a healthy, happy and pros-
especially technology and basic materials
perous New Year.
Page 13
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Disclosures
Lane Financial Management is a Registered Investment Adviser with the States of NY, CT
and NJ. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where Lane
Financial Management and its representatives are properly licensed or exempted.

No advice may be rendered by Lane Financial Management unless a client service agree-
ment is in place.

Stock investing involves risk including loss of principal. Investing in international and
Emerging Markets may entail additional risks such as currency fluctuation and political in-
stability. Investing in small-cap stocks includes specific risks such as greater volatility and
potentially less liquidity. Small-cap stocks may be subject to higher degree of risk than
more established companies’ securities. The illiquidity of the small-cap market may ad-
versely affect the value of these investments.
In the eyes of public
opinion, the contrarian Investors should consider the investment objectives, risks, and charges and expenses of
investor faces a lose- mutual funds and exchange-traded funds carefully for a full background on the possibility
lose proposition. When that a more suitable securities transaction may exist. The prospectus contains this and
contrarian approaches other information. A prospectus for all funds is available from Lane Financial Management
fail to keep pace with or your financial advisor and should be read carefully before investing.
the current market
darling, more- Note that indexes cannot be invested in directly and their performance may or may not
fashionable players correspond to securities intended to represent these sectors.
mock the out-of-step
thinker. When con- Investors should carefully review their financial situation, making sure their cash flow needs
trarian approaches sur- for the next 3-5 years are secure with a margin for error. Beyond that, the degree of risk
pass the alternatives, taken in a portfolio should be commensurate with one’s overall risk tolerance and financial
consensus-oriented objectives.
players decry the irre-
sponsibility of the un- Periodically, I will prepare a Commentary focusing on a specific investment issue. Please
conventional inves- let me know if there is one of interest to you. As always, I appreciate your feedback and
tor. look forward to addressing any questions you may have. You can find me at::
www.LaneFinancialManagement.com
— David Swenson,
Yale University Endow- Edward.Lane@LaneFinancialManagement.com
ment Fund Portfolio
Manager Edward Lane
Lane Financial Management
P.O. Box 666
Stone Ridge, NY 12484
917-575-0299

Reprints and quotations are encouraged with attribution.

You might also like