You are on page 1of 10

December 2009

L a n e F i n a n c i a l M a n ag e m e n t
Stock Market Commentary by Ed Lane

The Trend Is Your Friend


Perhaps you’ve heard this the concept of technical
investing expression before. momentum and relate that
In layman’s terms, it means to the market during No-
“go with the flow” and old vember.
Special points of interest: hands will remember the
Momentum has meaning to
 The market continued meaning behind “don’t fight
those (like myself) who use
its upward trajectory in the tape.”
technical analysis to inform
November following In essence, the implication is sively oversold, exception-
investment decisions by
October’s breather to ignore the “facts” (in ally low interest rates, in-
measuring the rate of
 The economic mes- quotes since my facts may vestors jumping on the
change in closing prices to
sages are generally not be your facts) and in- bandwagon, geopolitical
detect trend strength and
positive, but major long vest in the direction of ex- events, etc., etc.
potential reversal points (it
-term issues remain isting momentum — the must be the actuary in me). Taking all that into account,
unresolved theory being that over a my momentum indicators
Leaving aside for the time
given period of time, secu- remained positive in No-
 Investing opportunities being how momentum is
rity prices continue in a sin- vember and so went the
are limited. Caution is expressed and measured
gle direction until the market (even taking into
advised. (there are many ways), the
weight of forces driving the account the Dubai-related
rationale (at least my ration-
market changes sufficiently market shock that occurred
ale) for using it to assist in
and the direction reverses. at the end of the month).
Inside this issue: making investment decisions
There may be no better is that it strips away the Now, be careful. While the
The Trend Is Your 1 proof that this investment causes of market movement trend in the market contin-
Friend concept holds water today and leaves behind a pictorial ues to be positive, there are
At-a-Glance than what has happened in representation of the net many indications that equi-
2
the markets since the reces- effect of all forces working ties are reaching an over-
Economic Recap 3 sion began (or longer, if you bought condition (yes, I
together. I find that particu-
care to look). larly apropos today as there know I’ve said that before)
Market Recap 4-5
But I get ahead of myself. are so many competing and some of these will be
Technical Analysis 6-8 I’ll explore this topic more theories about what is driv- discussed in the pages that
on page 6 and even more in ing the market: excess li- follow. As much as ever,
My Bottom Line 9
a special Focus to be distrib- quidity (one of my favor- investment posture should
uted separately. ites), corporate earnings, be guided by one’s risk tol-
Disclosures 10
unemployment, inflation, erance and investment time-
Here, I’ll briefly remark on
recovery from being exces- frame.
Page 2
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
At-a-Glance
Here is a one page summary of this month’s  The reaction to Dubai’s plan to delay
market commentary: debt repayment shook the market at
the end of November illustrating, I be-
The Economy
lieve, the knife’s edge on which the eq-
The economy has had its ups and downs: uity markets rest
 The unemployment rate rose to 10.2%  Emerging market equities reacted even
while new initial claims for jobless insur- more negatively to the Dubai announce-
ance continued to decline ment than did developed markets
 Consumer confidence, which is strongly (following an correspondingly sharper
Nothing succeeds like
correlated with consumer spending, has rise in preceding months)
the appearance of suc-
moved sideways since Spring and remains  Gold, other precious metals, and do-
cess.
well below pre-recession levels mestic and foreign fixed income funds
— Christopher Lasch,
 The Federal Reserve indicated it would continue to show strength, possibly as
author
hold interest rates low with no foresee- safe havens for those looking to protect
able plans for an increase while the 3rd 2009 equity gains.
quarter GDP was restated downwards The Current Opportunities
from 3.5% to 2.8% (recall even that gain
 Opportunities depend on risk tolerance
was largely a result of stimulus payments
and investment horizon
of one kind or another in the first place)
 Over the next year, income-producing
 The Conference Board’s Index of Leading
investments appear most secure
Indicators continues to show improve-
ment with a strong showing from the  Longer term, best bets are Asia (ex Ja-
stock market and money supply compo- pan), emerging markets, building materi-
nents (the former is fragile and depend- als and technology.
ent on the latter, which itself may lack
My Bottom Line
sustainability given that a primary source
is government stimulus). I remain concerned about the prospects for
the U.S. economy over the next several
The Market
years but cautiously optimistic about the
Here the news is mostly positive, if shaky: market as long as positive momentum holds.
That said, there seems to be a growing con-
 After October’s pause, November con-
sensus that the market has gotten ahead of
tinued the upward trajectory begun last
itself. The sharp impact of Dubai’s recent
March
announcement illustrates the market’s fragil-
 While technical momentum indicators ity — whether or not it portends more
are still positive, they also give the ap- negative surprises to come.
pearance of running out of steam
Page 3
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Economic Recap
In general, the economic news for the month early-September of last year and are
was positive, but the end of the month down sharply from the peak reached in
brought a shocker. March.

The good news:

 The recession in U.S. factory sector ac-


tivity is over (at least for now), according
to the data from the National Associa-
tion of Purchasing Management which
rose to 55.7, its highest level since April
2006.

 The Chicago Purchasing Managers' Asso-


ciation reported that its November Busi-
Statistics: The only sci- ness Barometer improved to the highest ...and the not so good:
ence that enables dif- level since August of last year. According
ferent experts using the  The second estimate of 3Q U.S. eco-
to Haver Analytics, during the last ten
same figures to draw nomic growth was lowered from the
years there has been a 72% correlation
different conclusions. advance report due to slower growth in
between the Business Barometer and the
domestic demand and greater deteriora-
— Evan Esar, three-month change in factory sector
tion in the foreign trade deficit.
American Humorist industrial production.
 Consumer sentiment declined again in
 The gain in U.S. labor productivity im-
early November, falling from October's
provement in the 3rd quarter was its
70.6 to 66.0, measured by the Reuters/
strongest showing in six years.
University of Michigan Index of Con-
 According to the Organization of Eco- sumer Sentiment.
nomic Cooperation and Development
 The November event with the greatest
(OECD), composite leading indicators
potential impact on markets was Dubai’s
for September 2009 point strongly to
announcement of its plan to request a
growth in Italy, France, United Kingdom
standstill in its debt repayment. The
and China, while tentative signals of ex-
action called into question not only the
pansion have emerged in Canada and
financial stability of Dubai, but of emerg-
Germany. A recovery is clearly visible in
ing markets generally (a reaction that I
the United States, Japan and all other
believe is overblown in most, but not
OECD economies and major non-OECD
necessarily all, cases). What’s not clear
economies.
is whether this is the proverbial “canary
 The Labor Department reported during in the coal mine,” or no more than an
the month that claims for unemployment isolated and temporary shock as it ap-
insurance fell to their lowest level since pears to be as we enter December.
Page 4
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt

Market Recap

In the chart below, we see the year-to-date more to profit-taking than as an indication of
performance of several exchange-traded and fundamental weakness in these markets.
closed-end funds representing selected in- Notice also, the essential lack of reaction to
vestment sectors. the Dubai Announcement in the fixed income
In June, August and again in October, there space — corporate and high-yield bonds —
were relatively short-lived corrections on where there is some evidence of a flight to
the continued advance upward. Since I ad- safety. In fact, I would not be surprised to
mit to my reservations about the substance see this transition continue through the bal-
and potential extent of the economic recov- ance of the year as 2009 gains are locked in
Be thankful we're not
ery in the U.S., I see these minor correc- by investors and fund managers.
getting all the govern-
tions as warning signals of a fragile market. Though it is too early to see hard evidence of
ment we're paying for.
In November, upward momentum contin- this in the equity performance below, David
— Will Rogers
ued until the Dubai announcement the day Rosenberg of Gluskin Scheff reports that
after Thanksgiving. Notice the sharper de- “over the past six months, U.S. investors
cline in Asia (ex Japan) and Emerging Mar- have put a net $26 billion into equity funds
kets compared to the developed markets in while plowing $254 billion into bond/hybrid
the U.S. and Europe which I believe is due funds.”

A prospectus for the above funds can be obtained through this website:
http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/research/etfs.aspx
Page 5
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Market Recap (cont.)

Looking at selected bellwethers in the chart  The Consumer Discretionary sector is


below: showing surprising (at first blush) steady
upward momentum. A look behind the
 Gold, global building materials and tech-
scenes, however, shows that companies
nology continue to demonstrate strong
the likes of McDonald’s, Walt Disney,
momentum and, at least so far, are unaf-
Comcast, Amazon and Target are
fected by the Dubai announcement
among the top holdings — not really
 Financials and real estate seem the most high-priced product companies — mak-
precarious where both have trended ing the sector’s performance more un-
I think we agree, the sideways for the last four months derstandable.
past is over.

— George W. Bush

A prospectus for the above funds can be obtained through this website:
http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/research/etfs.aspx
Page 6
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Technical Analysis

the beginnings of a market reversal but


Quoting from the Journal of Indexes regard-
turned back north in July. At the begin-
ing investment in currencies but applicable
ning of October, the indicator began to
to other investments: “Fundamental analysis
change course and appears to be weak-
explains currency movement in terms of
ening once again.
macroeconomic variables such as growth,
inflation, monetary policy, etc. One of the  The resistance line at 1000 has been
weaknesses of fundamental analysis is that it handily exceeded and now forms a sup-
says very little about the timing of moves port to a potential correction.
and risk management. The second chart shows comparable infor-
Timing is an important part of risk manage- mation for the MSCI Emerging Markets in-
ment. Even rudimentary technical analysis dex. Notice the even more positive indica-
can help investors fine-tune their entrance tions of the EMAs on this chart. The resis-
into an investment and help quantify the tance line at 950 was broken twice in No-
Experience is a hard
risk. Monitoring the price action itself will vember as the index struggles to get by.
teacher because she
likely reveal a higher probability of success- On the top of page 8, another chart shows a
gives the test first, the
ful opportunities….” nearly 30-year weekly measure of the per-
lesson afterwards.
I agree. Here is a brief technical analysis for centage change in the S&P 500 index along
— Vernon Sanders
December: with a 45-week EMA. Notice how well the
Law, retired Major
percentage change continues its progress in
League Baseball pitcher On the chart of the S&P 500 index on the
a given direction as long as the slope of the
top of the next page:
EMA does not change. While past perform-
 Momentum, as measured by 75- and ance is not a guarantee of future results,
150-day exponential moving averages buying and selling at the inflection points
(EMA), remains positive. would have produced returns much better
 The spread between the daily price and than a buy-and-hold.
the 75-day EMA is narrowing such that a On page 8, we have a chart illustrating the
relatively small correction would begin performance of the S&P 500 index (in black)
to violate that indicator. This would not compared to the percentage of stocks
be too difficult a feat and the narrow within the index that are above their 150-
spread begins to raise a warning flag. day moving average (in red). Being above
 The MACD (another indicator used to 90% has been a warning signal of potential
measure direction and strength of mo- correction. This past month, the percent-
mentum) accurately showed an extreme age has dropped to about 85%, letting some
oversold situation last November and steam off. If past is prologue, and it is not
again in March. In June, MACD showed necessarily so, we can expect a further de-
cline in the not-too-distant future.
Page 7
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Technical Analysis (cont.)

The secret to creativ-


ity is knowing how to
hide your sources.

— Albert Einstein

The S&P 500 and the MSCI Emerging Markets indexes are unmanaged indexes which cannot be invested into
directly. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Page 8
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Technical Analysis (cont.)

Don't gamble; take all


your savings and buy
some good stock and
hold it till it goes up,
then sell it. If it don't
go up, don't buy it.

— Will Rogers

The S&P 500 is an unmanaged index which cannot be invested into directly. Past performance is no guarantee of
future results.
Page 9
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt

My Bottom Line
I remain concerned about the U.S. economy (FOMC) minutes and see the wide di-
and cautiously optimistic about the market. vergence of views over the macro out-
Here’s why I’m concerned about the econ- look, and this is coming from 17 of the
nation’s top policymakers who also os-
omy:
tensibly keep in touch with each other.
 The employment situation remains bleak The range on 2010 GDP estimates is:
and there does not appear to be forth- 2.0% to 4.0%; for 2011, 2.5% to 4.6%,
coming the structural industrial changes and 2.8% to 5.0% for 2012. These two
percentage points are huge…”.
needed to absorb the unemployment
overhang on a long term basis. Current And here’s why I’m cautiously optimistic
My dog is worried about
government stimulus, and fiscal and about the market:
the economy because
monetary policies generally, while help-
Alpo is up to 99 cents a  The stock market is much broader than
ful to many, will not cause the “escape
can. That's almost $7.00 the U.S. economy and there are many
velocity” for sustained economic
in dog money. opportunities for diversification.
growth. In other words, domestic
— Joe Weinstein, author growth seems to be built on a combina-  Continuing dollar weakness enhances
tion of government stimulus, a weak certain international markets as well as
dollar, and cost cutting, none of which reportable profits for U.S. companies
are sustainable over the long term. with overseas operations.

 While the period since March was char-  The flood of cash from stimulus pro-
acterized as a return to risk as a flood grams worldwide not only stimulates
of cash flowed into equities and lower economic activity, but demonstrates the
grade fixed income securities, that pat- commitment that exists to avoid further
tern may now be reversing (for exam- catastrophe.
ple, PIMCO increased holdings of gov-  Emerging economies are beginning to
ernment bonds in its very successful reduce dependencies on export led
Total Return Fund to 63%, its highest growth.
proportion since mid-2004).
Conservative investors and that portion of
 Technical indicators, still showing posi- portfolios that represents shorter-term in-
tive momentum, seem to be running out vestment should consider higher grade do-
of steam. Admittedly, we have seen this mestic and foreign income producing secu-
pattern several times since March. rities. While a longer term or more risky
 The Fed’s recent announcement to keep focus might look to emerging markets, tech-
interest rates low for the foreseeable nology, and infrastructure/building materials,
future suggests a low opinion of self- immediate caution is advised as these mar-
sustaining economic growth. In fact, as kets may be in the process of “catching their
reported by the investment manage- breath.”
ment firm Gluskin Sheff, “just go to the
Federal Open Market Committee
Page 10
L an e F in anc i a l M ana ge me nt
Disclosures
Lane Financial Management is a Registered Investment Adviser with the States of NY, CT
and NJ. Advisory services are only offered to clients or prospective clients where Lane
Financial Management and its representatives are properly licensed or exempted.

No advice may be rendered by Lane Financial Management unless a client service agree-
ment is in place.

Stock investing involves risk including loss of principal. Investing in international and
emerging markets may entail additional risks such as currency fluctuation and political in-
stability. Investing in small-cap stocks includes specific risks such as greater volatility and
potentially less liquidity. Small-cap stocks may be subject to higher degree of risk than
more established companies’ securities. The illiquidity of the small-cap market may ad-
versely affect the value of these investments.
In the eyes of public
opinion, the contrarian Investors should consider the investment objectives, risks, and charges and expenses of
investor faces a lose- mutual funds and exchange-traded funds carefully for a full background on the possibility
lose proposition. When that a more suitable securities transaction may exist. The prospectus contains this and
contrarian approaches other information. A prospectus for all funds is available from Lane Financial Management
fail to keep pace with or your financial advisor and should be read carefully before investing.
the current market
darling, more- Note that indexes cannot be invested in directly and their performance may or may not
fashionable players correspond to securities intended to represent these sectors.
mock the out-of-step
thinker. When con- Investors should carefully review their financial situation, making sure their cash flow needs
trarian approaches sur- for the next 3-5 years are secure with a margin for error. Beyond that, the degree of risk
pass the alternatives, taken in a portfolio should be commensurate with one’s overall risk tolerance and financial
consensus-oriented objectives.
players decry the irre-
sponsibility of the un-
conventional inves- Periodically, I will prepare a Commentary focusing on a specific investment issue. Please
tor.
let me know if there is one of interest to you. As always, I appreciate your feedback and
— David Swenson, look forward to addressing any questions you may have. You can find me at::
Yale University Endow- www.LaneFinancialManagement.com
ment Fund Portfolio Edward.Lane@LaneFinancialManagement.com
Manager

Lane Financial Management


P.O. Box 666
Stone Ridge, NY 12484
917-575-0299

Reprints and quotations are encouraged with attribution.

You might also like