DECONSTRUCTION AND THERAPY REVISITED:
INCLUDING THE EXCLUDED
by
ALAN PARRY, PhD.
FAMILY THERAPY PROGRAM
THE UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY
CALGARY, ALBERTA
‘T2N 4N1
CANADA
PRESENTED
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION
ANNUAL CONVENTION
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS
AUGUST 20-24, 1999
RUNNING HEAD:
DECONSTRUCTION ... REVISITEDDeconstruction and Therapy Revisited
Abstract
Jacques Derrida’s term deconstruction has achieved
widespread usage amongst psychotherapists. Much of this
derives from the influence of Michael White who has
interpreted it in a Foucauldian way consistent with his
practice of externalization. Problems are seen as
oppressors to be excluded. A return to a Derridean
understanding, buttressed by attention to the work of
Foucault, Lacan and Kristeva, is proposed in which
narratives embraced by families to the exclusion of others
return as symptoms which eventually hijack the
prevailing family story. Therapy consists in giving
excluded stories a voice through encouraging the
acknowledgement of the abjection all share so that
the”marginalized other” in all its forms may be included
once again.DECONSTRUCTION AND THERAPY REVISITED:
INCLUDING THE EXCLUDED
by
Alan Parry, PhD.
“When | use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said
in rather a scornful tone,
It means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.”
“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can
make words mean different things.”
“The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty,
“which is to be master-—that’s all.”
Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass
Man's desire is the desire of the Other.
Hegel, Phenomenology of the Spirit
Prologue
In 1982 Jacques Derrida wrote an important essay entitled Of an Apocalyptic
Tone Recently Adopted in Philosophy. His essay harked back to a famous essay by
Immanuel Kant entitled Of a Newly Raised Superior Tone in Philosophy (1796).
Kant’s essay had a satiric edge to it while Derrida’s was a call to the other to “Come!”
In that the very word evokes the closing words of the Apocalypse of John of Patmos,
“Come, Lord Jesus!” Derrida dares us to be open to a revelation. It is a strange sort of
revelation, however, one that reveals nothing because it is a call to welcome
everything that is nothing because it is excluded. This constitutes a revelation,