Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In this issue:
1) What is Inflation?
2) An Introduction to Inflation
3) What Causes Inflation?
4) Synthesis
This is the second essay in the "economic fundamentals" series and tackles
inflation. The greatest economists disagree about the nature of inflation. I will
not attempt to settle the debate here, but rather to explore the dominant
perspectives. My premise is that most of the perspectives on inflation are not
mutually exclusive, but rather represent different interpretations of a chaotic
reality. By applying many different lenses to the current economic climate we
will gain a more thorough understanding than with any single lens. A big part of
our job as investors is to find the intellectual tool that best fits the job. To that
end, I’ve structured this essay as a debate with many voices. Most of the ideas
here come from the great economists Hayek, Keynes, and Friedman, but I am
also indebted to the more modern economists John Hussman and Paul
Krugman. Those of you with a strong background in economics might want to
skip to section #3.
What is inflation?
Inflation is a persistent and widespread increase in prices. If a currency is
suddenly devalued causing all prices to double, this is not inflation. Inflation
requires a dynamic of persistent price increases over time. Once inflation takes
hold, it is naturally self-sustaining. If consumers expect that prices will continue
rising, they will make their purchases as soon as possible to avoid the higher
future prices; this causes the velocity of money to rise and increases the
immediate demand for goods, fulfilling the prophecy of higher prices. The
additional demand causes corporate revenues to rise and workers demand
raises; the higher wages similarly lead to higher demand and higher prices and
further wage hikes.
An Introduction to Inflation
At its core, inflation is simply a question of supply and demand. Prices of
goods are set where supply meets demand. If demand for goods increases
faster than supply, prices will rise. One trigger for inflation is a supply shock.
For example, in the Gulf War, the world’s oil supply was decreased while
demand was unchanged. This caused oil prices to rise until demand was
reduced to meet the new lower supply. The rise in oil prices led to higher prices
for all the many products that are directly and indirectly made from oil including
fertilizer, gasoline, and steel. Supply shock inflation is less frequent and
generally less lasting than demand driven inflation.
For much of human history, the money supply increased when new precious
metals were mined. More recently, central banks introduced fiat money (i.e.
paper currency) and controlled its supply. Friedman argued that modern
inflation was usually caused when the central bank increased the money supply
too quickly. This can happen with the literal printing of money, with open market
operations whereby the Federal Reserve purchases government debt from
banks, or from a reduction in reserve ratios or interest rates. Complicating this
view are the numerous examples of money printing that did not result in inflation
(i.e. Japan), how to measure the money supply, and savings versus investment,
and productive versus unproductive spending. I’ll revisit all of these issues.
Hussman concludes that we should focus on demand, not the money supply.
Government borrowing may increase aggregate demand and money printing
may not. This is a complex framework since it matters greatly who buys the
government debt and under what circumstances. In my example, citizens
purchased the debt with cash that was otherwise hidden under a mattress. If
instead it was banks purchasing the government debt under normal economic
conditions, the government debt would likely displace private borrowing and
would not increase aggregate demand.
What about the relationship between inflation and unemployment? One of the
biggest misconceptions in modern economics is based on the Phillips Curve.
The mistaken view is that the there is a direct trade off between inflation and
unemployment, and that by increasing inflation we decrease unemployment.
The flip side of this is the argument that as long as unemployment is high we
are unlikely to get inflation. First of all, the historical data does not support
either claim. While there is certainly a relationship, it is not at all direct. Rather,
the Phillips Curve shows the relationship between the employment level, and
real wage increases. When unemployment is low, wages will increase faster
than the general price level. If most prices are falling by 5%, wages may only
fall 2%. Wages are a key component in the general inflation level, but there are
many other factors to consider.
Hayek explained that it’s not inflation that causes unemployment to decrease,
but rather the unexpected increase in inflation. This is because an unexpected
increase in inflation causes revenues to increase unexpectedly and produces
greater profits. Over the long run, these profits are not real because they must
be spent on more expensive capital and material inputs. In the short run
however, they lead to an increase in aggregate demand and thus make
businesses and consumers feel wealthier. As soon as inflation expectations
match inflation, the higher interest rates eliminate the excess profits.
Synthesis
We’re faced with a handful of very different sources of inflation. To summarize:
Inflation may be caused by…
an increase in the base money supply
an increase in total money (taking into account the velocity of
money)
an increase in total money + debt (taking into account leverage)
an increase in aggregate demand
an increase in unproductive demand for goods
an increase in inflation expectations
a decrease in economic slack (e.g. unemployment)
None of these are mutually exclusive, but by emphasizing one element over
another, we may come to a very different conclusion about the current risk of
inflation. In the last few years, the base money supply has more than doubled
and government debt and spending have dramatically increased, but other
sectors of the economy have been deleveraging and the velocity of money has
collapsed. Inflation expectations remain moderate, and there is plenty of slack
in the form of unemployment and excess manufacturing capacity.
Risk over Reward: A conversation about intelligent investing – we discuss the nature of risk
and uncertainty, macroeconomics, security valuation, and how to think about markets and
invest profitably - http://www.riskoverreward.com/