Professional Documents
Culture Documents
• I prefer to view
"Alternative
Medicine" as
Traditional
Western Medicine
and Modern
Western Medicine
as "Experimental
Medicine".
Alternative Medicine
• What is Alternative Medicine?
• How can there be an
alternative to medicine?
• Is there alternative
chemistry, alternative
physics, biology?
Alternative Medicine
Defined
• Alternative has two possible meanings. Correctly
employed, it refers to methods that have equal
value for a particular purpose. (An example would
be two antibiotics capable of killing a particular
organism.) When applied to unproven methods,
however, the term can be misleading because
methods that are unsafe or ineffective are not
reasonable alternatives to proven treatment.
Twenty-Five Ways to Spot
Quacks
1. When Talking about Nutrients, They Tell Only Part of the Story.
.
Twenty-Five Ways to Spot
Quacks
8. They Claim That Soil Depletion and the Use of Pesticides and
"Chemical" Fertilizers Result in Food That Is Less Safe and Less
Nourishing.
• Immortality Device
• Stops aging permanently!!
http://www.alexchiu.com/
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
Misconception #1: Quackery is easy to spot.
Quackery is far more difficult to spot than most
people realize. Modern promoters use scientific
jargon that can fool people not familiar with the
concepts being discussed. Even health
professionals can have difficulty in separating fact
from fiction in fields unrelated to their expertise.
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #2: Personal experience is the best
way to tell whether something works. When you feel
better after having used a product or procedure, it is natural
to give credit to whatever you have done. This can be
misleading, however, because most ailments resolve
themselves and those that don't can have variable
symptoms. Even serious conditions can have sufficient day-
to-day variation to enable quack methods to gain large
followings. In addition, taking action often produces
temporary relief of symptoms (a placebo effect). For these
reasons, controlled scientific studies are usually necessary
to establish whether health methods actually work.
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #3: Most victims of quackery are
easy to fool. Individuals who buy one diet book or "magic" diet pill
after another are indeed gullible. And so are many people who follow
whatever fads are in vogue. But the majority of quackery's victims are
merely unsuspecting. People tend to believe what they hear the most. And
quack ideas -- particularly about nutrition -- are everywhere. Another
large group of quackery's victims is composed of individuals who have
serious or chronic diseases that make them feel desperate enough to try
anything that offers hope. Alienated people -- many of whom are paranoid
-- form another victim group. These people tend to believe that our food
supply is unsafe; that drugs do more harm than good; and that doctors,
drug companies, large food companies, and government agencies are not
interested in protecting the public. Such beliefs make them vulnerable to
those who offer foods and healing approaches alleged to be "natural."
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #4: Quackery's victims deserve
what they get. This is based on the idea that people who
are gullible should "know better" and therefore deserve
whatever they get. This feeling is a major reason why
journalists, enforcement officials, judges, and legislators
seldom give priority to combating quackery. As noted
above, however, most victims are not gullible. Nor do
people deserve to suffer or die because of ignorance or
desperation.
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #5: All quacks are frauds and
crooks. Quackery is often discussed as though all of its
promoters are engaged in deliberate deception. This is
untrue. Promoters of mail-order quackery are almost
always hit-and-run artists who know their products are
fakes but hope to profit before the Postal Service shuts
them down. But most other promoters of quackery seem to
be true believers, zealots, and devotees whose problem is
lack of criticism -- a failure to apply skepticism to the
favored therapy, very much like a religious person who
blindly accepts "the faith."
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #6: Most quackery is dangerous.
Quackery can seriously harm or kill people by inducing them to
abandon or delay effective treatment for serious conditions. It can also
wreck the life of people who are so thoroughly misled that they devote
themselves to promoting the methods and welfare of the quack.
Although the number of people harmed in these ways cannot be
determined, it is not large enough or obvious enough to arouse a
general public outcry. Most victims of quackery are harmed
economically rather than physically. Moreover, many people believe
that an unscientific method has helped them. In most cases, they have
confused cause-and-effect and coincidence. But sometimes an
unproven approach actually relieves emotionally related symptoms by
lowering the person's tension level.
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #7: "Minor" forms of quackery are
harmless. Quackery involving small sums of money and no physical
harm is often viewed as harmless. Examples are "nutrition insurance"
with vitamin pills and wearing a copper bracelet for arthritis. But their
use indicates confusion on the part of the user and vulnerability to more
serious forms of quackery. There is also harm to society. Money wasted
on quackery would be better spent for research, but much of it goes into
the pockets of people (such as vitamin pushers) who are spreading
misinformation and trying to weaken consumer protection laws.
• Misconception #8: Government protects us. Although
various government agencies are involved in fighting quackery, most
don't give it sufficient priority to be effective. Moreover, the agencies
involved lack a coordinated plan to maximize their effectiveness.
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #9: Quackery's success represents
medicine's failure. It is often suggested that people turn to
quacks when doctors are brusque with them, and that if doctors were
more attentive, their patients would not turn to quacks. It is true that
this sometimes happens, but most quackery does not involve medical
care. Doctors should pay attention to the emotions of their patients and
make a special effort to explain things to them. But blaming medicine
for quackery is like considering the success of astrology the fault of
astronomy. Some people's needs exceed what ethical, scientific health
care can provide. The main reason for quackery's success is its ability
to seduce unsuspecting people. Several years ago a survey done in New
Zealand found that most cancer patients who used "alternative"
therapies were satisfied with their medical care and regarded
"alternative" care only as a supplement.
Common Misconceptions About
Quackery
• Misconception #10: "Alternative" methods have
moved toward the scientific mainstream. In 1991,
Congress passed a law ordering the National Institutes of Health
(NIH) to establish an office (now called the National Center for
Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) to foster
research into unconventional practices. It remains to be seen whether
any useful research will be done as a result. Meanwhile, of course,
"alternative" proponents have been labeling the very establishment of
the NIH office as "scientific acceptance" -- and media outlets have
been repeating this claim without bothering to investigate whether it is
true.
Why Bogus Therapies Often Seem to
Work
1.The disease may have run its natural course.
• Many diseases are self-limiting. If the condition is not chronic or fatal, the body's own recuperative
processes usually restore the sufferer to health. Thus, to demonstrate that a therapy is effective, its
proponents must show that the number of patients listed as improved exceeds the number expected
to recover without any treatment at all (or that they recover reliably faster than if left untreated).
Without detailed records of successes and failures for a large enough number of patients with the
same complaint, someone cannot legitimately claim to have exceeded the published norms for
unaided recovery.
• Many diseases are cyclical.
2.
• Such conditions as arthritis, multiple sclerosis, allergies, and gastrointestinal problems normally
have "ups and downs." Naturally, sufferers tend to seek therapy during the downturn of any given
cycle. In this way, a bogus treatment will have repeated opportunities to coincide with upturns that
would have happened anyway.
• The placebo effect may be responsible.
3.
• Through suggestion, belief, expectancy, cognitive reinterpretation, and diversion of attention,
patients given biologically useless treatments often experience measurable relief. Some placebo
responses produce actual changes in the physical condition; others are subjective changes that make
patients feel better even though there has been no objective change in the underlying pathology.
•
Why Bogus Therapies Often Seem to
Work
• 4. People who hedge their bets credit the wrong
thing.
• If improvement occurs after someone has had both "alternative" and science-
based treatment, the fringe practice often gets a disproportionate share of the
credit.
• 5. Theoriginal diagnosis or prognosis may have
been incorrect.
• Scientifically trained physicians are not infallible. A mistaken diagnosis, followed
by a trip to a shrine or an "alternative" healer, can lead to a glowing testimonial
for curing a condition that would have resolved by itself. In other cases, the
diagnosis may be correct but the time frame, which is inherently difficult to
predict, might prove inaccurate.
• 6. Temporary mood improvement can be
confused with cure.
• Alternative healers often have forceful, charismatic personalities. To the extent
that patients are swept up by the messianic aspects of "alternative medicine,"
psychological uplift may ensue.
•
Why Bogus Therapies Often Seem to
Work
• 7. Psychological
needs can distort what people
perceive and do.
• Even when no objective improvement occurs, people with a strong
psychological investment in "alternative medicine" can convince themselves
they have been helped. According to cognitive dissonance theory, when
experiences contradict existing attitudes, feelings, or knowledge, mental
distress is produced. People tend to alleviate this discord by reinterpreting
(distorting) the offending information. If no relief occurs after committing
time, money, and "face" to an alternate course of treatment (and perhaps to the
worldview of which it is a part), internal disharmony can result. Rather than
admit to themselves or to others that their efforts have been a waste, many
people find some redeeming value in the treatment.
Ten Ways to Avoid Being Quacked
• These claims are bunkum. The FDA has concluded that there is no evidence
that spirulina (or phenylalanine) is effective as an appetite suppressant. The
FDA has also noted that the "65% protein" claim is meaningless because,
taken according to their label, spirulina products provide only negligible
amounts of protein.
Dietary Supplements
Blue-Green Algae
• At the trial on January 9, 1986, the government introduced additional
evidence of the widespread use of blue-green algae Manna products,
and of the therapeutic claims that were made for these products. Victor
Kollman denied that he had made therapeutic claims. . . . Nevertheless
he continued to claim his product has a beneficial effect on the human
body . . . as a food, and not a drug. The government showed that taken
at the recommended dosage of 1.5 grams, its value as a nutrient is
negligible. Further, the cost of the defendant's products, which exceeds
$300 per pound, is so high as compared to other sources of the same
nutrients that it is apparent that these products are not intended to be
used as a food.
Spirulina
Blue-Green Algae
Claims to Cures All
•
•
Diseases
Spirulina / Blue Green Algae
The Spirulina is Earth's oldest living plant (3.6 billion years ago) and first photosynthetic
life form that created our oxygen atmosphere so all life could evolve. Spirulina is the
most nutritious, concentrated food known to man containing antioxidants, phytonutrients,
probiotics, and nutraceuticals. Spirulina is the best whole food source of protein,
betacarotene, GLA, B Vitamins, minerals, chlorophill, sulfolipids, glyco-lipids, super
oxide dimustase, phycocyanin, enzymes, RNA, DNA, and supplies many nutrients that
are lacking in most people's diets.
:
• Aging Alcoholism Allergies Anemia Anti-aging Arthritis Breast
cancer Cancer Cardiovascular diseaseDepression Diets Drug abuse Eczema Energy Eye
problems Food supplement General nutrition Goiter Gout Mercury poisoning Heavy
metal poisoning Hypoglycemia Immune problemsLiver disease Mononucleosis
• Nutrition Obesity Ovarian cancer Pancreatitis Senility Skin careSkin
problems Stress Ulcers Weighloss
• Youthfulness
Spirulina: Health Food or
Fraud?
• Low protein source
• For instance, it’s claimed that spirulina is a rich source of protein. True, the plant
contains 62 - 68% protein but you’ll spend less by eating white fish which has 97%
protein, chicken (80%) or white lean beef (79%). Moreover, the US Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) said most spirulina products provide only negligible amounts of
protein when taken as directed by their labels. Some products advertised as spirulina
have no spirulina at all.
• Another sales pitch is that spirulina is packed with vitamins. But nutritionists say you’ll
get more vitamins from broccoli and other green vegetables.
• Dieters may be enticed by ads which say spirulina only has 3.9 calories per gram. They
may be surprised to know that sugar contains 4 calories to the gram while bread has only
2 calories per gram. Both are cheaper than spirulina.
Spirulina: Health Food or
Fraud
• Contaminated
• In Health Schemes, Scams and Frauds, Dr. Stephen Barrett, a psychiatrist and board
member of the National Council Against Health Fraud, Inc. said an FDA analysis of one
popular product called Blue Green Manna contained "15 whole or equivalent adult flies,
164 adult fly fragments, 41 whole or equivalent maggots, 59 maggot fragments, one ant,
five ant fragments, one adult cicada, one cicada pupa, 763 insect fragments, nine ticks,
four mites, 1,000 ostracods, two rat or mouse hairs, four bird feathers, six bird-feather
barbules, and 10,500 water fleas." Some strains of spirulina also have toxins that can
cause nausea, diarrhea and throat infections.
Toxic Algae Causes Tumors,
• "In test animals injection of the toxic algae causes tumors, and larger
doses can cause death within minutes. Batches of contaminated
spirulina have been seized by the FDA. Since the toxins are not
routinely tested for by all manufacturers, it would seem that using the
algae is like playing Russian roulette," according to nutritionist Kurt
Butler in A Consumer’s Guide to Alternative Medicine.
Board of Advisors
• C. Norman Shealy, M.D., Ph.D. Founder and President, American Holistic Medical
Association
• Richard Kunin M.D. ,Founder The Orthomolecular Medical Society Society
• Leonard Horowitz, Ph.D. Author: Emerging Viruses: AIDS & Ebola - Nature, Accident, or
Intentional?
• Mohammed Ali Al-Bayati Ph.D Author: HIV Does Not Cause AIDS
• Jonathan Collins, M.D., Editor, Townsend Newsletter for Doctors
• Elson Haas, M.D. , Author
• Richard Shames M.D., Author
• Ann Spencer, Ph.D., President , International Medical Hypnotherapy Association
• Stephen Levine, Ph.D. Director of Research Nutricology, Inc.
• John Downing, Ph.D., O.D.
• Michael P. Joseph, D.C.
• Raphael Rettner D.C.
• William Lavelle O.M.D. L.A.c.
• William Cunningham B.A. C.BT. Director: White Dove Healing Clinic
• Mark Becker, Publisher New Life Magazine
The San Francisco Medical Research Foundation
Board of Advisors
• Scott Minor, Editor Well Being Journal
• Bernice Strock, Editor Publisher ìTo Your Health Magazineí
• Paul English, Publisher Free Spirit Magazine
• Iasos, Artist Musician
• Ivan Dryer, President Laser Images Inc.
• Michael Hutchinson Author, ìMegaBrainî
• Patricia Kramer, Director World School of Massage and Advanced
Healing Techniques
• Ursala Hanrahan, Spiritual Healer
• Rev. Harpreet Sandhu, M.S., CHT,
• President, Inner Revelations Inc.
• Mark Johnson, C.E.O. Trinity Water
Marks of Pseudoscience
or Bogus Science
1. A lack of well-controlled, reproducible
experimental support.
(by definition)
5. Argument by analogy.
Argument by spurious similarity.
Marks of Pseudoscience
or Bogus Science
• Faddism is a generic term used to describe nutrition nonsense. Food faddists are
characterized by exaggerated beliefs in the role of diet and nutrition in health and
disease.
• Unproven has fewer negative connotations than most of the other terms. It correctly
implies that, under the rules of science, proponents have the burden of proving that
their methods work. Unproven methods that appear logical and consistent with
established knowledge carry no connotation of quackery. However, methods that
appear illogical and in conflict with established knowledge should be regarded with
great suspicion and labeled more harshly.